Ahamod v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

Ahamod and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 7 (8 January 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2017/7601

Re:Saly Ahamod

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member B J Illingworth

Date:8 January 2019

Place:Adelaide

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

............................[Sgd]........................................

Senior Member B J Illingworth

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – application for citizenship by conferral – application for citizenship refused – whether Tribunal satisfied as to identity – inconsistency in evidence – credibility - threshold requirement not met – decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007, s 24(3)

CASES

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Pochi v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 33
Sullivan v Civil Aviation Safety Authority (2014) 141 ALD 540; [2014] FCAFC 93
Re Be Beyan v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 256
Re Confidential v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] AATA 144
Re Dhayakpa v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 310
Re CDNB and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 757

Re ZVNT, GNGJ, SWQL and MFYW and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 3045

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Immigration and Border Protection, Australian Citizenship Policy, at 1 June 2016, Chapter 13

Explanatory Memorandum, Australian Citizenship Bill 2015 (Cth)
Attorney-General’s Department, National Identity Proofing Guidelines 2016
Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Country Information Report, Myanmar, 10 January 2017

Rohingyas - Insecurity and Citizenship in Myanmar, T. Gibson et al (eds.), 1 August 2016

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member B J Illingworth

8 January 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Saly Ahamod (“the Applicant”) has applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to review a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (“the Respondent”) dated 1 December 2017, refusing the Applicant’s application for conferral of Australian Citizenship in accordance with the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (“the Act”).

  2. The reasons for the refusal of conferral of Australian Citizenship were that:

    (a)the Applicant did not satisfy s 21(2)(h) of the Act, namely, he did not meet the good character test; and

    (b)the Applicant did not satisfy s 24(3) of the Act, namely, he did not satisfy the delegate of his identity.

  3. The Respondent subsequently decided that the Applicant satisfied s 21(2)(h) and was a person of good character. Hence the only issue before the Tribunal was whether the Applicant could satisfy s 24(3) of the Act, namely his identity.

  4. The Applicant was represented by Migration Agent Mr Mason and was assisted by an interpreter via telephone. The Respondent was represented by Mr Evans, Australian Government Solicitors Office.

  5. The Tribunal received into evidence:

    (a)Exhibit 1 – T documents;

    (b)Exhibit 2 – Supplementary T documents (“STD”);

    (c)Exhibit 3 – Further Supplementary T documents (“FSTD”) pages 360 – 364;

    (d)Exhibit 4 – Statutory Declaration dated 27 June 2018;

    (e)Exhibit 5 -  Copy of the Applicant’s single entry visa 2012;

    (f)Exhibit 6 - Extracts of Facebook profiles, 9 pages; and

    (g)Exhibit…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ahamod v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) considered the application of Mr. Saley Ahamod (the Applicant) for Australian citizenship by conferral. The Minister for Immigration and Border Protection had refused the application, and the Applicant sought review of this decision. The central dispute concerned whether the Applicant had satisfied the threshold requirement of proving his identity to the satisfaction of the Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it was satisfied as to the Applicant's identity, as required by section 24(3) of the *Australian Citizenship Act 2007* (Cth). This involved determining whether the Applicant had provided sufficient credible evidence to establish his identity, particularly in light of inconsistencies and a lack of documentary proof, and whether he had provided an acceptable explanation for this deficiency.

The Tribunal reasoned that the grant of Australian citizenship is a matter of significant consequence and should not be undertaken lightly. It noted that while the *Briginshaw* standard was not a strict rule for the AAT, it provided guidance on the level of proof required given the seriousness of the decision. The Tribunal found that the Applicant's provided documents were minimal, unreliable, or potentially fabricated. Crucially, the Tribunal found that the Applicant had not provided an acceptable or credible explanation for the absence of identity documents, nor had he demonstrated that he had exhausted all reasonably available avenues to obtain such evidence. The Tribunal referred to previous AAT decisions which highlighted the importance of documentary evidence or, in its absence, a compelling explanation for its unavailability, particularly when an applicant has been advised of the need for such evidence.

Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that it was not satisfied of the Applicant's identity for the purposes of section 24(3) of the Act. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, meaning the refusal of the citizenship application stood.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal received into evidence:(a)Exhibit 1 – T documents;(b)Exhibit 2 – Supplementary T documents (“STD”);(c)Exhibit 3 – Further Supplementary T documents (“FSTD”) pages 360 – 364;(d)Exhibit 4 – Statutory Declaration dated 27 June 2018;(e)Exhibit 5 - Copy of the Applicant’s single entry visa 2012;(f)Exhibit 6 - Extracts of Facebook profiles, 9 pages; and(g)Exhibit 7 – Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade Country Information Report Country Information Report (“DFAT Report”) Myanmar (10 January 2017).BACKGROUND The Applicant arrived in Australia as an unauthorised maritime arrival on 9 December 2009. He gave a Biodata Interview[1] that day in which he said, through an interpreter, that:[1] Exhibit 3, FSTD pp 360 – 364.(a)his name was Saley Ahamod ( which has a different spelling of his first name);(b)his date of birth was 1 September 1985;(c)his place of birth was Pawaichaung Village, Maungdaw in Myanmar (Burma) where he lived until October 2001;(d)his religion was Islam and his ethnic group Rohinya;(e)he attended the following schools:(i)Pawaichaung Primary School 1990 – 1995 , being up to grade 4, and (ii)Nganchaung Midle School 1995 – 1997, being up to grade 6;(f)after completing his schooling, from 1997 to 2001 he worked on his parent’s farm;(g)he had no identity documents;(h)between 10 April 2001 and 7 November 2001 he lived in Chitagong, Bangladesh. From 7 November 2001 to 14 November 2001 he lived in Guluk, Thailand. From November 2001 to November 2009 he lived in Penang, Malaysia;(i)he married his wife, Noor Wati, in 2007. She was an Indonesian citizen. There is one son to the marriage, Omar Farook born in 2008, who was residing in Malaysia with his mother; and(j)his father Nir Ahmed, was born in 1965 and was deceased. His mother Shava Khata, was born in 1961 and lived in Pawaichuang, Maungdaw, Myamar, as did his seven brothers and sisters, all of whom have now fled to Bangladesh. On 28 December 2009, the Applicant gave an Immigration – In – Confidence Interview (“Entry Interview”)[2] in which the information contained in the Biodata Interview was mostly repeated and further information was given namely: (a)that he was not legally permitted to live in Malaysia; (b)in 2002 he was detained for two months by Malaysian authorities. Police then deported him to the Thai - Malaysian border; (c)in 2003 he was detained by the Malaysian Police for one month and again deported to the Thai – Malaysian border; (d)in March 2009 he was detained for 12 days by the Malaysian police whom he bribed and he was subsequently released from custody;(e)he had been issued with a United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (“UNHCR”) card in Kuala Lumpur in 2002 which had been lost in Malaysia; document number 51204 C2973 2/3;[3] (f)he stated his wife “Noor Wati” was born in 1990, and his son “Omar Farook” was born in 2008;[4] and(g)he made a number of protection claims relating to discrimination faced by the Rohingya population from military forces in Myanmar; that he had been required to undertake forced labour; all his farmland had been seized by the military and given to Buddhist people[5] and that he had also lived in Bangladesh and Malaysia unlawfully.[6] [2] Exhibit 2, STD 1 p 86.[3] Exhibit 2, STD 1 p 90.[4] Exhibit 2, STD1, p 91.[5] Exhibit 2, STD 1 p 96.[6] Exhibit 2, STD 1 p 94.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A certificate of Australian Citizenship is a legal document of considerable significance.[30] Although the Tribunal is not bound to apply Briginshaw, it does provide guidance as to the requisite proof required, having regard to the seriousness of the consequences of the matter under consideration, and the consequences that follow from that decision. It is not a hard and fast rule. Nonetheless it is very clear that the grant of Australian Citizenship by conferral is a matter in respect of which the Australian Community expects the decision maker, and here the Tribunal, will approve only if the pre-requisite conditions are satisfied. The grant of such citizenship brings with it a high level of responsibility and consequential entitlements. It is not to be granted lightly. [30] ReBeyan and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2015] AATA 256.APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE The Applicant said that his date of birth of 12 January 1985 is the date that he chose for the purpose of the IAAAS Interview. He thereafter committed that date to memory and consistently referred to that date. The Applicant said when he was born in Myanmar (Burma) in a small rural village. There was no registration of birth and no one in his community would be able to provide an accurate date of birth for the Applicant or any other member of the community. He has never had a birth certificate. The Applicant was cross-examined on whether he was familiar with the “white card”. He said he had heard of such a card but did not know whether anyone in his family had one. The first time he received an identity document was in Malaysia, namely a UNHCR card. The Applicant was asked whether he needed any form of identification in order to enrol in primary school. The Applicant said his parents enrolled him and he did not know whether registration or identification was required. When asked if he needed documentation to enrol in middle school he said perhaps the record was transferred from primary school. He said his parents would have had those records however his village was burnt down in 2017 and his family fled to save their lives. He said the school also burned down so the records are most likely destroyed. He has made no inquiry about the existence of such records.The Household list The Applicant was referred to the Household list he provided in support of his citizenship application.[31] He said this was a form of identification document detailing those people living in a house. Within that document the Applicant is referred to by the name Saly Ahamod, registration number 158164. When questioned about that number, and that it suggested the Applicant was not stateless, he said that he did not know what the number referred to and his best guess was that it may have been a number given to him at middle school. He also said that this Household list was nothing more than a check undertaken by authorities from time to time to see who was living in a particular residence in a particular village.[31] Exhibit 1, T4 p 42 – 43.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, the Tribunal is not satisfied of the Applicant’s identity for the purposes of s 24(3) of the Act.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent reminded the Tribunal that s 24(3) of the Act says the Minister must not approve the person becoming an Australian citizen unless the Minister is satisfied of the identity of the person. Where identity documents have not been provided, an acceptable and credible explanation is required. The Respondent submitted that in the Applicant’s case, details of any significant attempts to obtain documentation are absent, with no acceptable or credible explanation. Hence having regard to the statutory provisions and authorities the Tribunal should find it is not satisfied of the identity of the Applicant to the requisite standard which is a higher level of balance of probabilities. CONSIDERATION What is required in this application is for the Tribunal to be satisfied of the Applicant’s identity. The level of satisfaction required has already been discussed. The documents provided by the Applicant in support of his identity are minimal, unreliable or bogus. Where there is minimal documentation, the Applicant must be able to explain why this is the case and provide evidence that all avenues reasonably available to him have been exhausted. The Tribunal notes the commentary in ReConfidential v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] AATA 144 at paragraph 34 and 35:I have concluded that the Minister has not been provided with any documentation to enable the Minister to form an opinion on the identity of the applicant. For this reason the application was, in my view, correctly rejected by the delegate.…In my opinion the application is deficient because there is no documentary evidence of any “links” between the birth name of the applicant and the current name of the applicant. The delegate had earlier advised Mr H that he required evidence of “changes of name” and such evidence has not been provided by the applicant. In my opinion the application is deficient because there is no birth certificate of the applicant or any documentary evidence of the change of name of the applicant. The Tribunal further notes Re Dhayakpa v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 310 at paragraph 117: Neither the Act nor the common law requires that identity can only be established by the production of documents appropriate to an established or undisturbed society. The decision in Confidential is not an authority that documentation is a requisite for the Minister to be satisfied as to identity. I accept the submission for the applicant that the case merely stands for the proposition that where an applicant has failed to avail himself of opportunities to secure evidence of identity which might reasonably be expected to exist and which he has been advised to secure, the application ought to be rejected. The question here is whether the identity can be established to the satisfaction of the Tribunal. It is notable that the Applicant obtained the Household List and the marriage contract after the grant of his Class XB visa. The Household list was obtained in support of the Applicant’s citizenship application, and the marriage contract was provided in support of his wife, son and nephew’s humanitarian visa application.