Catholic Healthcare Limited v Rhyder

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read
WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Catholic Healthcare Limited v Rhyder [2016] NSWWCCPD 60
APPELLANT: Catholic Healthcare Limited
RESPONDENT: Fardiani Rhyder
INSURER: Catholic Church Insurance Limited
FILE NUMBER: A1-2835/16
ARBITRATOR: Mr G Capel
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 26 August 2016
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 8 December 2016
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Section 352(6) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (the 1998 Act) – admission of fresh evidence, application of CHEP Australia Ltd v Strickland [2013] NSWCA 351; 12 DDCR 501; operation of
s 354 of the 1998 Act and procedural fairness; alleged errors in fact finding; weight of medical evidence – application of Hancock v East Coast Timber Products Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 11; 80 NSWLR 43; 8 DDCR 399, Paric v John Holland Constructions Pty Ltd [1984] 2 NSWLR 505, Hevi Lift (PNG) Ltd v Etherington [2005] NSWCA 42; 2 DDCR 271; argument not raised at first instance – application of Metwally v University of Wollongong [1985] HCA 28; 60 ALR 68; 59 ALJR 481
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Deputy President Michael Snell
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Astridge & Murray
Respondent: Garling & Co
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1. The respondent’s application for leave to rely on fresh evidence pursuant to s 352(6) of the 1998 Act is refused.

2.   The Arbitrator’s determination dated
 26 August 2016 is confirmed.

INTRODUCTION

  1. This appeal concerns a challenge to findings by an Arbitrator that, due to a conceded injury to the dominant left shoulder, Fardiani Rhyder (the respondent) developed a consequential condition of the right shoulder, and that surgery to the right shoulder is reasonably necessary as a result. For reasons that follow, the appeal does not succeed.

BACKGROUND

  1. The respondent was employed full-time by Catholic Healthcare Limited (the appellant) as a community care worker. Dr Bodel’s history recorded that, at the time she sustained injury, she worked 48 hours per fortnight, performing respite and domestic activities for clients of the appellant. She suffered employment injury to her dominant left shoulder on 9 April 2013, while vacuuming a thick carpet at a client’s house. The appellant accepted liability to pay compensation in respect of the left shoulder injury.

  2. The respondent came under the care of Dr Piper, an orthopaedic surgeon. She underwent surgery to the left shoulder at the hands of Dr Piper on 14 August 2013, involving arthroscopic rotator cuff repair, biceps tenodesis and acromioplasty. She subsequently resumed restricted duties with the appellant, for hours and periods which varied from time to time.

  3. The respondent’s statement dated 30 March 2016 indicated that she commenced suffering from symptoms in the right shoulder, from about early 2015. Dr Piper, in his report dated
     27 August 2015, referred to an MRI of the right shoulder dated 20 August 2015, and said it showed “a large rotator cuff tear with severe subacromial bursitis and a large subacromial spur, similar to the findings on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Catholic Healthcare Limited v Rhyder and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWWCCPD 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Catholic Healthcare Limited v Rhyder, the primary dispute revolves around the admission of fresh evidence under Section 352(6) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. The respondent, Rhyder, sought to introduce new evidence that was not presented during the original arbitration proceedings, which had resulted in an unfavorable outcome. The respondent's application for leave to rely on this fresh evidence was challenged by Catholic Healthcare Limited, who argued against the admissibility of the new evidence on the grounds that it was not sufficiently compelling or necessary to alter the outcome of the arbitration.

The court was tasked with determining whether the fresh evidence introduced by Rhyder could be admitted under the specific provisions of Section 352(6) of the 1998 Act. This involved assessing whether the evidence was not available at the time of the arbitration due to reasonable diligence and whether its exclusion would cause substantial injustice. Additionally, the court had to consider the principles of procedural fairness and the appropriate weight to be given to the new evidence in the context of the existing medical evidence presented in the case. The court also examined whether the arguments regarding the fresh evidence had been adequately raised during the original arbitration, referencing relevant case law.

The court found that the new evidence presented by Rhyder did not meet the threshold requirements for admission under Section 352(6) of the 1998 Act. It was determined that the evidence could have been obtained with reasonable diligence and that its exclusion would not cause substantial injustice. Furthermore, the court held that the principles of procedural fairness were not compromised, and the weight of the new evidence did not warrant altering the original arbitration decision. The court also noted that certain arguments regarding the new evidence had not been raised at the first instance, impacting the respondent's ability to rely on them.

The court's decision resulted in the refusal of the respondent's application for leave to rely on fresh evidence. Consequently, the Arbitrator's determination dated 26 August 2016 was confirmed, maintaining the original outcome of the arbitration proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondent’s application for leave to rely on fresh evidence pursuant to s 352(6) of the 1998 Act is refused.

2. The Arbitrator’s determination dated

26 August 2016 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Practice Direction No 6 sets out the process for seeking leave of the Commission to give ‘new evidence’ on appeal. It provides as follows:“FRESH EVIDENCE AND/OR ADDITIONAL EVIDENCEEach application to introduce fresh evidence or additional evidence on appeal will be considered on its own facts and circumstances and in the context of the Commission’s obligation to act according to equity, good conscience and the substantial merits of the case without regard to technicalities or legal forms (see s 354 of the 1998 Act).In the exercise of its discretion to admit fresh evidence or further evidence on appeal the Commission will have regard to, and the parties should make submissions on, whether:·it can be demonstrated that the evidence could not with reasonable diligence have been obtained by the party and tendered in proceedings before the Arbitrator;·the evidence is credible;·there is a high degree of probability that there would have been a different decision if the evidence had been admitted at the arbitration, and/or·it is just to admit the evidence in all the circumstances of the individual case.Parties should be aware that a review under s 352 of the 1998 Act is not a rehearing or hearing de novo. The original arbitration should not be treated as a preliminary hearing and all relevant evidence should be called at that time.” Practice Direction No 6 also provides that, if fresh evidence or evidence in addition to or in substitution for the evidence received in relation to the decision appealed against is relied upon, parties must include:· a schedule of the fresh or additional evidence;· a copy of the fresh or additional evidence;· a brief outline of the fresh or additional evidence and the reasons why it was not given in proceedings before the Arbitrator, and· submissions on why the fresh or additional evidence should be admitted, or rejected as the case may be. In CHEP Australia Ltd v Strickland [2013] NSWCA 351; 12 DDCR 501 (Strickland) Barrett JA (Macfarlan JA agreeing) dealt with the application of s 352(6) of the 1998 Act. His Honour at [27] and [31] said:“27. In the s 352(6) context, there are two threshold questions. They arise as alternatives and are set out in the second sentence of the provision. The first goes to the issue of availability in advance of the proceedings. The second entails an assessment of whether continued unavailability of the evidence ‘would cause substantial injustice in the case’. The discretion to admit becomes available to be exercised only if the Commission is satisfied as to one of the threshold matters.”“31. … The part of s 352(6) concerning ‘substantial injustice’ does not direct attention to possibilities or potential outcomes. The task is to decide whether absence of the evidence ‘would cause’ substantial injustice in the case. There must therefore be a decision as to the result that ‘would’ emerge if the evidence were taken into account and the result that ‘would’ emerge if it were not. If the result would be the same on each hypothesis, the ends of justice cannot be said to have been defeated by exclusion.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established