Moriarty-Baes v Office Works Superstores Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read
WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Moriarty-Baes v Office Works Superstores Pty Ltd [2015] NSWWCCPD 28
APPELLANT: Kim Moriarty-Baes
RESPONDENT: Office Works Superstores Pty Ltd
INSURER: Wesfarmers Group Team Cover
FILE NUMBER: A1-2916/14
ARBITRATOR: Mr P Sweeney
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 19 December 2014
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 4 May 2015
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Claim for cost of hospital and medical expenses for consequential right shoulder condition alleged to have resulted from accepted injury to the left wrist; assessment of lay and expert evidence; alleged finding against the weight of evidence; alleged failure to conduct proceedings “in equity, good conscience and on the substantial merits of the case”; consequence of respondent’s failure to comply with cl 46 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2010; application of principles in Hancock v East Coast Timber Products Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 11; 80 NSWLR 43; alleged error in applying the “best evidence rule” when the Commission is not bound by the rules of evidence; s 354(2) and (3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998; conduct of proceedings in the Commission generally
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Deputy President Bill Roche
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Nikolovski Lawyers
Respondent: Kaden Boriss
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

The Arbitrator’s determination of 19 December 2014 is confirmed.

INTRODUCTION

  1. This appeal involves a challenge to the Arbitrator’s finding that he was not persuaded that the worker’s right shoulder condition was caused by her employment or resulted from favouring her left arm after suffering an accepted work injury to her left wrist. For the reasons explained below, the challenge is unsuccessful and the Arbitrator’s determination is confirmed. To fully understand the Arbitrator’s decision, and the nature of the challenges to it, it is necessary to set out the background in some detail.

BACKGROUND

  1. The appellant worker, Kim Moriarty-Baes, worked part time for the respondent employer, Office Works Superstores Pty Ltd, as a customer service assistant, starting there in about 2007. On 11 April 2009, she injured her left wrist when she attempted to stop a box from falling. After a period away from work, she returned on 13 May 2009 with a certificate from her general practitioner, Dr Gordon Mill, in which she was certified fit for suitable duties, but avoiding heavy lifting and pushing loads.

  2. Investigations revealed a triangular fibro-cartilage tear in Ms Moriarty-Baes’ left wrist. Dr Mill referred Ms Moriarty-Baes to Dr Stuart Jansen, orthopaedic surgeon, and she had a left wrist cortisone injection on 28 July 2009. On 7 September 2009, Dr Jansen recorded that, because of her symptoms in her left wrist, Ms Moriarty-Baes had trouble “lifting up coffee cups”. Dr Jansen referred her to Dr Scougall, a hand and wrist surgeon, for an opinion on surgery to her wrist.

  3. On 19 October 2009, Dr Mill recorded, among other things, that Ms Moriarty-Baes had a “sore (R) shoulder [indecipherable] → shifting load to other side; not well tolerated”. On 9…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moriarty-Baes v Office Works Superstores Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWWCCPD 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Moriarty-Baes v Office Works Superstores Pty Ltd involved a claim for costs related to hospital and medical expenses for a consequential right shoulder condition, which the claimant alleged resulted from an accepted injury to the left wrist. The dispute was heard by the Workers Compensation Regulator of New South Wales. The central legal issues before the court involved the assessment of lay and expert evidence, whether the Arbitrator made findings against the weight of the evidence, and if the proceedings were conducted in equity, good conscience, and on the substantial merits of the case.

The court examined whether the Arbitrator correctly assessed the evidence, particularly focusing on the nature of the claimant’s pre-injury duties as outlined in the medical evidence. The Arbitrator considered Dr. Ho’s report, which detailed the claimant’s duties as involving check-out tasks typical of a customer assistance operative, and found this to be the best evidence on the subject. The court found that the Arbitrator was entitled to rely on this evidence and that there was no better evidence available to him on the issue of the claimant’s pre-injury duties. The court also noted that the claimant’s evidence of developing shoulder symptoms post-injury did not establish an injury to the right shoulder that could be linked to her pre-existing condition.

In its reasoning, the court confirmed that the Arbitrator’s determination of 19 December 2014 was correct. The Arbitrator had appropriately considered the available evidence, including the claimant’s medical history and Dr. Ho’s report, and had made findings consistent with the evidence presented. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in his assessment of the evidence or in conducting the proceedings. The Arbitrator’s findings were in line with the principles set out in Hancock v East Coast Timber Products Pty Ltd and the relevant statutory provisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Arbitrator’s determination of 19 December 2014 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In light of the above exchanges, Mr Moffet’s submissions on appeal were surprising, to say the least. The Arbitrator considered and assessed the evidence tendered. As noted earlier in this decision (see [93] above), Ms Moriarty-Baes’ statement of 11 December 2014 said nothing relevant about the nature of her pre-injury duties. This meant that, as often occurs in cases in the Commission, though it is completely unsatisfactory, the Arbitrator was forced to extract, as best he could, the evidence of those duties from other sources. He said, starting at T3.32:“[Ms Moriarty-Baes’] normal hours of work were somewhat less than 20 hours a week as I understand the evidence. Unfortunately in [Ms Moriarty-Baes’] signed statement in this matter, there is no unequivocal description of the nature of her work and her job description, to use a colloquial expression, has to be gleaned from the medical evidence and other material before the Commission. Dr Ho, in his report, records that [Ms Moriarty-Baes’] work involved the ordinary check-out duties that one might associate with a customer assistance operative at the respondent or any other large store. He says this:‘Her normal duty of work certainly included taking phone calls, serving customers, scanning all the products and also putting the products into the shopping containers and handing them to customers.’That being the best evidence on the subject I intend to accept that evidence as indicative of the nature of [Ms Moriarty-Baes’] work. It is important probably from the perspective of Dr Ho that it did not involve over head or above shoulder work.” (emphasis added) Evidence in a medical history is evidence of the fact (Guthrie v Spence [2009] NSWCA 369; 78 NSWLR 225 at [75]). It has not been submitted on appeal that, on the issue of Ms Moriarty-Baes’ pre-injury duties, there was better evidence available to the Arbitrator, on which he should have relied, instead of Dr Ho’s history. It is therefore unclear what evidence the Arbitrator should have had regard to on this issue, if he erred in having regard to Dr Ho’s history. The Arbitrator was aware of, and referred to, Ms Moriarty-Baes’ evidence of developing shoulder symptoms in 2010, “probably when operating a newly installed touch screen register over four days using her right arm” (T8.10). However, as noted above, this occurred after the left wrist injury. Moreover, it was not evidence of “overhead work” and was not sufficient to establish a s 4 injury to the right shoulder, if that was Mr Moffet’s point. The Arbitrator was entitled to have regard to Dr Ho’s history, it being the best evidence on the subject. Naturally, it would have been preferable if Ms Moriarty-Baes had given evidence in her statement of her pre-injury duties. That she did not was unsatisfactory and unhelpful. It left the Arbitrator to do the best he could with the evidence tendered. That evidence included the history recorded by Dr Ho, an independent AMS appointed by the Commission.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.