SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Callide Power Management Pty Ltd & Ors v Callide Coalfields (Sales) Pty Ltd & Ors; CS Energy Ltd v Callide Coalfields (Sales) Pty Ltd & Ors (No 5) [2016] QSC 199
PARTIES:
CALLIDE POWER MANAGEMENT PTY LTD
ACN 082 468 700
(first applicant)
CALLIDE ENERGY PTY LIMITED
ACN 082 468 746
(second applicant)
IG POWER CALLIDE LTD (FORMERLY SHELL COAL POWER CALLIDE LTD)
ACN 082 413 885(third applicant)
v
CALLIDE COALFIELDS (SALES) PTY LTD
ACN 082 543 986
(first respondent)
ANGLO COAL (CALLIDE) PTY LTD
ACN 081 022 228
(second respondent)
ANGLO COAL (CALLIDE) NO. 2 PTY LTD
ACN 004 784 454(third respondent)
CS ENERGY LIMITED
ABN 54 078 848 745(applicant)
v
CALLIDE COALFIELDS (SALES) PTY LTD
ACN 082 543 986
(first respondent)
ANGLO COAL (CALLIDE) PTY LTD
ACN 081 022 228
(second respondent)
ANGLO COAL (CALLIDE) NO. 2 PTY LTD
ACN 004 784 454
(third respondent)FILE NO/S:
SC No 12122 of 2013
SC No 12138 of 2013
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Trial
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
31 August 2016
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
18 – 20 July 2016
JUDGE:
Flanagan J
ORDERS:
The separate questions in SC No 12138 of 2013 are answered in the terms of Annexure A to these Reasons.
The separate questions in SC No 12122 of 2013 are answered in the terms of Annexure B to these Reasons.
I will hear the parties as to costs.
CATCHWORDS:
CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – where the respondents and the applicants are parties to Coal Supply Agreements – where the Coal Supply Agreements include a mechanism for review where a Change Event is notified – where a Change Event is a change in circumstances which has, or will have, a material effect on the competitiveness of either party in relation to the industry in which it operates – where the respondents issued notice of a Change Event to the applicants on 12 November 2013 – where the applicants dispute the validity of the 12 November 2013 notice issued by the respondents – where the parties agreed a list of separate questions for determination – whether the 12 November 2013 notice issued by the respondents to the applicants was valid under the terms of the Coal Supply Agreements – whether the alleged facts pleaded by the respondents are true – whether the alleged facts pleaded by the respondents give rise to the objective commercial purpose pleaded by the respondents – whether the 12 November 2013 notice issued by the respondents to the applicants was valid on its face – whether a mere increase in costs is capable of being a Change Event for the purposes of the Coal Supply Agreements – whether a change in a party’s expectation of benefitting under the Coal Supply Agreement is capable of being a Change Event for the purposes of the Coal Supply Agreements – whether the time requirements in clauses 12.3(b)(i)…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Callide Power Management Pty Ltd v Callide Coalfields (Sales... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] QSC 199
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered several legal issues, including whether the Change Event notice issued by the respondents was valid, whether the alleged facts pleaded by the respondents were true, and whether the alleged facts gave rise to the objective commercial purpose as pleaded. Additionally, the court examined whether a mere increase in costs or a change in a party's expectation of benefiting under the agreement could constitute a Change Event. Another issue was whether the time requirements in certain clauses of the agreements were essential and whether the notice accurately described the Change Event, its impacts, options, and alternatives. The court's analysis focused on the interpretation of the Coal Supply Agreements and the specific provisions related to the review mechanism and Change Events.
The court concluded that the alleged fact in paragraph 1(d) was true, and the review mechanism under the Coal Supply Agreement CS93 was limited as it was only triggered by major changes to prescribed working conditions within the coal mining industry. The court held that the review under clause 17.6 was further constrained to the suitability of certain indexes. Consequently, the Change Event notice issued by the respondents was deemed valid on its face. The court also determined that the time requirements in clauses 12.3(b)(i) and 12.3(b)(ii) were not essential, and the notice sufficiently described the Change Event and its impacts. Therefore, the Change Event notice issued by the respondents was found to be valid under the terms of the Coal Supply Agreements.
The court answered the separate questions in the two proceedings, SC No 12138 of 2013 and SC No 12122 of 2013, as outlined in the annexures to the reasons for judgment. The court further indicated that it would hear the parties on the issue of costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
The separate questions in SC No 12138 of 2013 are answered in the terms of Annexure A to these Reasons.
The separate questions in SC No 12122 of 2013 are answered in the terms of Annexure B to these Reasons.
I will hear the parties as to costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The relevant background fact is that clauses 9.1.3 and 17.6 of CS93 contain a limited review mechanism in the event of any major change to prescribed working conditions within the coal mining industry (as alleged in paragraph 4A(e)(iii) of the Sixth Further Amended Defence). The question posed by 1(a) is simply whether the fact is true. Clause 9.1.3 of CS93 provided:“9.1.3The parties confirm that the proposed changes in Contract Price are not intended to reflect changes in either productivity in the coal mining industry or costs specific to coal mining and that the parties agree that the price should remain linked to generalised indices of the Australian economy as a whole. In the event of any major change to prescribed working conditions within the coal mining industry, the Agreement shall be reviewed in accordance with Clause 17.6. Arbitration relating to the Contract Price will be limited to the consideration of the suitability of the indexes selected to reflect the real purchasing power of the Australian dollar within the Australian economy.”[39]Clause 17.6 of CS93 provided:“17.6 Mutual CollaborationThe Commission and the Sellers recognize that circumstances may arise which could not have been reasonably foreseen at the time the Agreement was entered into. The parties agree that they will use their best efforts to resolve any problems due to any such unforeseeable circumstances including continuation of any force majeure condition in the spirit of mutual understanding and collaboration.”[40][39] Ex “TJH-1”, Affidavit of Hulme, 24-25.[40] Ex “TJH-1”, Affidavit of Hulme, 42. The question in terms does not call for a comparison of the review mechanism in clause 12.3 of the Coal Supply Agreement with that in CS93. Under CS93 the review is only triggered by any major change to prescribed working conditions within the coal mining industry. Further, the review under clause 17.6 dealing with arbitration, is limited to the consideration of the suitability of certain indexes. A review under clause 17.6 is in relation to circumstances which could not have been reasonably foreseen at the time CS93 was entered into. It may therefore be accepted that the review mechanism under CS93 was more limited than the review mechanism under clause 12.3 of the Coal Supply Agreement. The applicants submit that whilst the arbitration referred to in clause 9.1.3 was limited, the review was not. The review was at large.[41] Whilst the review of the terms of CS93 was at large any arbitration relating to the Contract Price was constrained to a consideration of the suitability of certain indexes selected to reflect the real purchasing power of the Australian dollar within the Australian economy. Therefore, even without comparing the review mechanisms under CS93 with clause 12.3 of the Coal Supply Agreement, the review mechanism under CS93 was limited in the ways I have identified. The alleged fact set out in paragraph 1(d) is true and the question should be answered “yes”. It was also a fact known to the parties. Question 1(b) in respect of fact 1(d) should also be answered “yes”. It is unnecessary to answer question 1(c).[41] CS Energy’s Written Submissions, [8] and CPM’s Written Submissions, [59].