Callide Power Management Pty Ltd v Callide Coalfields (Sales) Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Callide Power Management Pty Ltd & Ors v Callide Coalfields (Sales) Pty Ltd & Ors; CS Energy Ltd v Callide Coalfields (Sales) Pty Ltd & Ors (No 3) [2015] QSC 295

PARTIES:

CALLIDE POWER MANAGEMENT PTY LTD
ACN 082 468 700
(first applicant)
CALLIDE ENERGY PTY LIMITED
ACN 082 468 746
(second applicant)
IG POWER CALLIDE LTD (FORMERLY SHELL COAL POWER CALLIDE LTD)
ACN 082 413 885

(third applicant)

v
CALLIDE COALFIELDS (SALES) PTY LTD
ACN 082 543 986
(first respondent)
ANGLO COAL (CALLIDE) PTY LTD
ACN 081 022 228
(second respondent)
ANGLO COAL (CALLIDE) NO. 2 PTY LTD
ACN 004 784 454

(third respondent)

CS ENERGY LIMITED
ACN 078 848 745

(applicant)

v
CALLIDE COALFIELDS (SALES) PTY LTD
ACN 082 543 986
(first respondent)
ANGLO COAL (CALLIDE) PTY LTD
ACN 081 022 228
(second respondent)
ANGLO COAL (CALLIDE) NO. 2 PTY LTD
ACN 004 784 454
(third respondent)

FILE NOS:

SC No 12122 of 2013

SC No 12138 of 2013

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

28 October 2015

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

13 April; 5 May; 15 May; and 15 July 2015

Supplementary submissions received 7 September 2015 (applicants) and 14 September 2015 (respondents)

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDER:

It is determined that this is an appropriate case for the ordering of the hearing and determination of separate questions.

I will hear from the parties as to the precise formulation and wording of the proposed separate questions and as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – MISCELLANEOUS PROCEDURAL MATTERS – CROSS-CLAIMS: SET-OFF AND COUNTERCLAIM – COUNTERCLAIM – OTHER MATTERS – where the applicants in two separate but related proceedings applied for the respondents’ counterclaims to be excluded from the proceedings pursuant to r 182 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) – where the exclusion of the counterclaims was sought on the basis that the hearing of the counterclaims might cause an undue delay in the trial of the action – where the hearing of the counterclaim will involve extensive evidence and many months of hearing time – whether there is any overlap between the applicants’ proceedings and the respondents’ counterclaims – whether there is any utility in excluding the counterclaims from the present proceedings

PROCEDURE – SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – PROCEDURE UNDER UNIFORM CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES AND PREDECESSORS – OTHER MATTERS – where the applicants in two separate but related proceedings applied for the determination of separate questions pursuant to r 483 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) – where the proposed separate questions involve the construction of a contract and the validity or invalidity of a notice delivered pursuant to that contract – where the trial of separate questions would take a substantially shorter amount of time than the trial of the balance of the issues – where the applicants’ submit that the separate questions are distinct, of short compass and involve limited factual disputes – where the respondents’ submit that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Callide Power Management Pty Ltd v Callide Coalfields (Sales... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QSC 295
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Callide Power Management Pty Ltd v Callide Coalfields (Sales) Pty Ltd (No 3), the applicants, who are owners of power stations, sought orders in relation to counterclaims and the determination of separate questions in two related proceedings. The respondents, who supply coal for the operation of these power stations, had filed counterclaims and opposed the determination of separate questions. The legal issues before the court were whether the respondents' counterclaims should be excluded from the proceedings due to potential undue delay and whether there was any utility in doing so. Additionally, the court had to decide whether there was any overlap between the applicants' proceedings and the respondents' counterclaims. Another issue was whether there was utility and economy in the determination of separate questions, and whether such determination would delay the resolution of the whole dispute.

The court considered the utility and economy of the proceedings, case management, and the interests of justice. It found that the determination of separate questions would be of greater utility and economy, as it would allow for a quicker resolution of distinct issues with limited factual disputes. The court also noted that there would be substantial overlap in evidence and witnesses between a trial on separate questions and a trial on the whole of the dispute. However, the court determined that the determination of separate questions would not delay the resolution of the whole dispute and would serve the interests of justice.

In conclusion, the court ordered that separate questions should be determined in the proceedings, and it invited the parties to propose the precise formulation and wording of the proposed separate questions, as well as to address the issue of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

It is determined that this is an appropriate case for the ordering of the hearing and determination of separate questions.

I will hear from the parties as to the precise formulation and wording of the proposed separate questions and as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

For reasons which follow I have concluded that this is such a case primarily due to considerations of utility and economy, case management and the interests of justice.Background Some of the applicants are owners of power stations located in Central Queensland. The coal for the operation of these power stations is supplied by some of the respondents pursuant to Coal Supply Agreements entered into on or about 11 May 1998. Whilst there are two sets of proceedings, namely BS12138/13 and BS12122/13, the issues which arise are, for all practical purposes, the same. The Coal Supply Agreements are also substantially identical. For the purposes of determining these applications for separate determination I will refer to the pleadings and particulars in BS12138/13. CS Energy Limited is the named applicant in those proceedings. The Coal Supply Agreement was for an initial term of 10 years. The applicant, however, has four successive options to extend the term of the Coal Supply Agreement, each option being for a period of five years. In or about 2009, the first option was exercised. Clause 12 of the Coal Supply Agreement, entitled “Review of Agreement”, contains a procedure for the possible adjustment of the terms of the Coal Supply Agreement consequent upon the occurrence of a “Change Event”. It relevantly provides:“12.3 Change Events(a)A ‘Change Event’ is a change in circumstances which has, or will have, a material effect on the competitiveness of either the Coal Mine Owners or the Buyer (in the reasonable opinion of a Party) in relation to the industry in which it operates, and includes, without limitation:(i)the Commercial Load Date of Unit 2 occurring more than 18 months after the Effective Date;(ii)if the Buyer reasonably demonstrates, by the elimination of other relevant factors, that there is a change in coal prices being paid by other power stations. The Parties acknowledge that the Buyer must reasonably demonstrate, by the elimination of other relevant factors, that there is a material adverse change in the competitive position of the Power Station which is due to changes in coal prices being paid by other power stations, before the Parties will be obliged to review this Agreement against the principle set out in Clause 12.1(a)(iii).(iii)major changes to working conditions within the coal mining industry, including, without limitation, advances in technology which were not foreseen at the date of this Agreement;(iv)a demonstrated (by the Seller) increase in the long term (being at least five years) trend in electricity price occurring during the whole or any part of any period when an EMI is not operative; and(v)a change in governmental policy, or a change in a law or regulation, relating to environmental standards and compliance with those standards.(b)If at any time after the date of execution of this Agreement there occurs, or either Party considers there may occur, a Change Event, then:(i)a Party (the ‘Notifying Party’) may notify the other (the ‘Receiving Party’) in writing promptly when that Change Event becomes known to the Notifying Party that it is the Notifying Party’s intention to initiate a review of this Agreement which may lead to an Adjustment;(ii)if it wishes to proceed with a review of this Agreement, the Notifying Party must, as soon as practicable in all the circumstances, submit a formal notice of a Change Event (the ‘Change Event Notice’) to the Receiving Party, which will include:(A)all data which the Notifying Party holds which is relevant both to the Change Event including detailed information regarding the nature, extent and quantum of the cost and revenue impacts of the Change Event and to calculating those costs and revenue impacts as they relate to all of the options and alternatives identified by the Notifying Party available to accommodate or mitigate the Change Event; and(B)options and alternatives identified by the Notifying Party and the Notifying Party’s recommended option,and a Change Event will be deemed to have occurred;(iii)As soon as possible after a Notifying Party becomes aware that an estimate of the financial effect is likely to be incorrect, the Notifying Party must amend that estimate and give copies of the amended estimate and the estimate it amends to the Receiving Party;(iv)The onus is upon the Notifying Party to establish the impact of the Change Event;(v)The Parties must use their best endeavours to review and to attempt to agree an Adjustment generally in accordance with the principles set out in Clause 12.1.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The primary reason for the difference in the estimates of the length of the trial of any separate questions is the respondents’ desire to present extrinsic evidence as to the surrounding circumstances relevant to the construction of the Coal Supply Agreement. The respondents also anticipate that further evidence (both lay and expert) may need to be led in relation to whether a change in geological conditions experienced by the respondents while mining at the Callide Mine constitutes a “change of circumstances” for the purposes of the Coal Supply Agreement. This is relevant to issue 15(b) of the List of Issues. The respondents also point to the fact that the applicant alleges that the Change Event Notice does not include the quantum of cost and revenue impacts of the change event or the proposed options. The respondents therefore submit that in resolving these issues the court may need to form a view about the sufficiency of various financial information contained in spreadsheets forming part of the annexures to the Change Event Notice as well as other financial and quantities information included in the body of the Change Event Notice.[29] Ms Platford therefore anticipates that the volume of disclosure required in relation to the proposed separate issues is likely to be significant and that lay and expert evidence will need to be led.[30] The respondents therefore identify that the practical question on the present application is which of these two approaches represents the better course at this stage of the proceeding, with the applicants having the burden of demonstrating that the course that they propose is plainly of greater utility and economy.[31] To answer that question it is necessary to consider in more detail the issues raised by the parties. Those issues may be identified as follows:[29] Respondents’ outline of submissions dated 9 April 2015, [94].[30] Affidavit of Colleen Anne Platford sworn 27 March 2015, [41]-[45].[31] Respondents’ outline of submissions dated 9 April 2015, [43], citing Tepko Pty Ltd v Water Board (2001) 206 CLR 1, 55 [170]. (a)the nature and extent of extrinsic evidence as to the purpose of the Coal Supply Agreement;(b)evidence as to cost increases associated with geological conditions;(c)evidence as to whether the Change Event Notice permits identification of the quantum of the cost and revenue impacts;(d)whether there is an overlap of issues and evidence;(e)whether there is utility and economy in the determination of separate questions;(f)will the determination of separate questions delay the balance of the proceedings; and(g)the interests of justice.(a)The nature and extent of the extrinsic evidence as to the purpose of the contract At the time of the hearing of the application for separate questions before Jackson J the respondents had not identified any extrinsic facts which would inform their contentions as to the proper construction of the Coal Supply Agreement.[32] [32] Callide Power Management Pty Ltd & Ors v Callide Coalfields (Sales) Pty Ltd & Ors; CS Energy Ltd v Callide Coalfields (Sales) Pty Ltd & Ors [2014] QSC 216, [21].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established