C & F Nominees Mortgage Securities Ltd v Karbotli

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCI 2020 0094

C & F NOMINEES MORTGAGE SECURITIES LTD (ACN 089 819 803) Applicant
v
HEND KARBOTLI (also known as HIND ISSA) First Respondent
and
REGISTRAR OF TITLES Second Respondent

---

JUDGES: KYROU, McLEISH and SIFRIS JJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 11 March 2021
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 14 May 2021
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2021] VSCA 134
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2020] VCC 987 (Judge Macnamara)

---

ENFORCEMENT OF MORTGAGE – Forged mortgage registered under Transfer of Land Act 1958 – Whether judge erred in finding mortgagee did not take reasonable steps to verify authority and identity of mortgagor pursuant to s 87A of Act – Reliance by mortgagee on deficient solicitor’s certificate and 100 point identification check documentation – Reasonable steps not taken ­– Mortgage void – Transfer of Land Act 1958 s 87A.

ENFORCEMENT OF MORTGAGE – Covenant in registered mortgage by mortgagor to pay principal sum in manner and times specified –­ Memorandum of Common Provisions incorporated – Whether judge erred in holding mortgage secured nothing because no funds advanced to mortgagor – Reasonable businessperson approach – Covenant to pay principal sum whether advanced to mortgagor or not – Winau Aust Pty Ltd v LCC Property Development Pty Ltd (2020) 19 BPR 40; [2020] NSWSC 434, distinguished.

ENTITLEMENT TO INDEMNITY – Whether judge erred in holding mortgagee not entitled to indemnity from Registrar of Titles pursuant to s 110 of Transfer of Land Act 1958 ­– No indemnity available as mortgagee in breach of statutory duty and relevantly neglectful – Registrar of Titles v Fairless [1997] 1 VR 404, distinguished – Transfer of Land Act 1958 s 110.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel

Solicitors
For the Applicant Mr S Senathirajah QC with Mr R Moore Wotton + Kearney
For the First Respondent Mr J A F Twigg QC with Ms E R Tadros Marino Law
For the Second Respondent Ms G Costello QC with Mr J McKay Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning

KYROU JA
McLEISH JA
SIFRIS JA:

Introduction

  1. The first respondent, Hend Karbotli, also known as Hind Issa (‘Ms Issa’), is the registered proprietor of the property situated at 42 Barak Street, Bulleen in the State of Victoria (‘Property’).  The applicant, C & F Nominees Mortgage Securities Limited (‘C & F Nominees’) holds a registered mortgage over the Property (‘C & F Mortgage’).  The signature of Ms Issa on the C & F Mortgage is a forgery.

  1. As the holder of a registered instrument and not being a party to the forgery or fraud, as was conceded, C & F Nominees asserted that it had an indefeasible right to enforce the C & F Mortgage. This was the legal position prior to the introduction of s 87A of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (‘TLA’) in 2014.[1]  The section, in its original form, was in the following terms:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C & F Nominees Mortgage Securities Ltd v Karbotli and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] VSCA 134
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved C & F Nominees Mortgage Securities Ltd, the mortgagee, seeking to enforce a registered mortgage against Karbotli, the mortgagor. The dispute centred around the validity of the mortgage, the enforceability of a payment covenant within the mortgage, and the mortgagee's entitlement to indemnity from the Registrar of Titles. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether the mortgagee took reasonable steps to verify the authority and identity of the mortgagor, and if the mortgage was valid and enforceable. Specifically, the court needed to determine if the mortgagee's reliance on a deficient solicitor’s certificate and an incomplete 100 point identification check amounted to reasonable steps under section 87A of the Transfer of Land Act 1958. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the mortgage was enforceable despite no funds being advanced to the mortgagor and whether the mortgagee was entitled to indemnity from the Registrar of Titles under section 110 of the Act.

The court found that the mortgagee did not take reasonable steps to verify the mortgagor's authority and identity, rendering the mortgage void. The court concluded that the mortgagee's reliance on an incomplete identification check and a deficient solicitor’s certificate was insufficient. Furthermore, the court held that the covenant to pay the principal sum was enforceable irrespective of whether funds were advanced to the mortgagor. The court distinguished the current case from Winau Aust Pty Ltd v LCC Property Development Pty Ltd, finding that the mortgage was not void due to the absence of funds. Lastly, the court held that the mortgagee was not entitled to indemnity from the Registrar of Titles because it was in breach of its statutory duty and neglectful.

The court ordered that the mortgage was void and unenforceable, and that the mortgagee was not entitled to indemnity from the Registrar of Titles.

Background

Background to the litigation

C & F Nominees Mortgage Securities Ltd (the mortgagee) sought to enforce a mortgage against Karbotli, who was the registered proprietor of a property. The mortgage was registered under the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic). The mortgagee argued that it had taken reasonable steps to verify the authority and identity of the mortgagor, relying on a solicitor's certificate and a 100-point identification check. However, it later emerged that the mortgage had been forged, and the mortgagor had no authority to enter into the mortgage agreement. The mortgagee also claimed that it was entitled to indemnity from the Registrar of Titles for any loss suffered due to the registration of the forged mortgage. The primary issue was whether the mortgagee had taken reasonable steps to verify the mortgagor's authority and identity and whether the mortgage was void. Another issue was whether the mortgage secured a debt, even though no funds had been advanced to the mortgagor. Finally, the mortgagee claimed entitlement to indemnity from the Registrar of Titles, arguing that the Registrar was negligent in registering the forged mortgage.

The case came before the Supreme Court of Victoria for a final hearing. Prior to this, the matter had been before the County Court of Victoria, where the judge found in favour of Karbotli and against the mortgagee on all counts. The mortgagee appealed the County Court's decision to the Supreme Court. The appeal was heard by a single judge, who upheld the County Court's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the judge erred in finding that the mortgagee did not take reasonable steps to verify the authority and identity of the mortgagor pursuant to s 87A of the Transfer of Land Act 1958.
2. Whether the judge erred in holding that the mortgage secured nothing because no funds were advanced to the mortgagor.
3. Whether the judge erred in holding that the mortgagee was not entitled to indemnity from the Registrar of Titles pursuant to s 110 of the Transfer of Land Act 1958.

Held
1. The court held that the judge did not err in finding that the mortgagee did not take reasonable steps to verify the authority and identity of the mortgagor pursuant to s 87A of the Transfer of Land Act 1958. The reliance on a deficient solicitor’s certificate and a 100 point identification check documentation did not amount to reasonable steps. Consequently, the mortgage was void.
2. The court held that the judge did not err in holding that the mortgage secured something despite no funds being advanced to the mortgagor. The court applied a reasonable businessperson approach and found the covenant to pay the principal sum was enforceable regardless of whether funds were advanced.
3. The court held that the judge did not err in holding that the mortgagee was not entitled to indemnity from the Registrar of Titles pursuant to s 110 of the Transfer of Land Act 1958. The mortgagee was in breach of their statutory duty and was neglectful, thus no indemnity was available.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the mortgagee's failure to take reasonable steps to verify the mortgagor's authority and identity as required by s 87A of the Transfer of Land Act 1958. The reliance on a deficient solicitor’s certificate and incomplete identification documentation was found insufficient to satisfy the statutory requirement. This reasoning aligns with the principle that a mortgagee must take reasonable steps to ensure the validity of the mortgage. The court distinguished the case from Winau Aust Pty Ltd v LCC Property Development Pty Ltd (2020) 19 BPR 40; [2020] NSWSC 434, which dealt with a different set of facts regarding mortgage security.

Regarding the mortgage's enforceability despite no funds being advanced, the court applied a reasonable businessperson approach and concluded that the covenant to pay the principal sum was enforceable irrespective of whether funds were advanced. This decision reinforces the enforceability of covenants in registered mortgages, regardless of the advancement of funds.

Lastly, the court addressed the mortgagee's entitlement to indemnity under s 110 of the Transfer of Land Act 1958. The court found the mortgagee was in breach of their statutory duty and was neglectful, thus not eligible for indemnity from the Registrar of Titles. This decision aligns with the principle that indemnity is not available to a party in breach of their statutory obligations, as seen in Registrar of Titles v Fairless [1997] 1 VR 404. The court's reasoning and decision establish that a mortgagee's neglect and breach of statutory duty can preclude entitlement to indemnity from the Registrar of Titles.