Brudenall & Ors v Owners Corporation Unit Plan No. 202

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

BRUDENALL & ORS v OWNERS CORPORATION UNIT PLAN No. 202 (Unit Titles) [2016] ACAT 101

UT 28/2015

Catchwords:             UNIT TITLES – mixed class development – resolution to maintain class B buildings – merits review of resolution - what is correct or preferable decision – limits on power to amend motion - factors relevant to merits review – role of tribunal – importance of collective will of owners corporation

Legislation cited:      Unit Titles Act 2001 ss 51
Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 ss 89, 129

Cases cited:Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 46 FLR 409

Meaney v The Owners Corporation Units Plan 40 [2013] ACAT 72
NABE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 144 FCR 1
Parker v Owners Units Plan No 36 [2014] ACAT 37
Re Visa Cancelation Applicant and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] AATA 690

The Owners Corporation Units Plan 202 v Brudenall & Ors [2015] ACAT 64
Totally and Permanently Incapacitated Veteran’s Association of New South Wales Ltd v Gadd (1998) 146 FLR 161

Tribunal:                  President M-T Daniel

Date of Orders:   22 December 2015
Date of Reasons for Decision:         1 September 2016      

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          UT 28 of 2015

BETWEEN:

SUE BRUDENALL

First Applicant

JOHN BRUDENALL

Second Applicant

ALISON SLOPER

Third Applicant

DAVID SLOPER

Fourth Applicant

ROBIN LONG

First Party Joined

ROBERT CALVERT

Second Party Joined

VALERIE CALVERT

Third Party Joined

ED ROBERTS

Fourth Party Joined

WILLIAM HEFFERNAN

Fifth Party Joined

MARGARET HEFFERNAN

Sixth Party Joined

ELIZABETH TEATHER

Seventh Party Joined

DAVID TEATHER

Eighth Party Joined

ROSS HENTY

Ninth Party Joined

MARGARET HENTY

Tenth Party Joined

AND:

OWNERS CORPORATION—

UNITS PLAN No. 202

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Member M-T Daniel

DATE:22 December 2015     

ORDER

IN CHAMBERS ORDER

Having conducted a merits review of Motion 5 of the AGM of 2002 the Tribunal declines the repeal or amendment Motion 5 and orders:

  1. The Application is dismissed.

……………Signed……..

Member M-T Daniel

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On 22 December 2015 the Tribunal dismissed an application for orders to be made in relation to Motion 5 passed at the 2002 Annual General Meeting (2002 AGM) for the Owners Units Plan 202. At that time, the parties were advised that written reasons for that decision would be provided. Those reasons follow.

  2. In these reasons, a reference to the ‘tribunal’ refers to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal generally and ‘Tribunal’ refers to the current member.

Background to these proceedings

  1. Motion 5 of the 2002 AGM provides, in short, that the owners corporation is responsible for the external painting, roofing and structural repairs of the class B units in Units Plan 202.

  2. In 2014 proceedings were instituted in the tribunal seeking, among other orders, a declaration that Motion 5 was validly passed as a special resolution (the first proceeding). A cross-application for merits review was filed in those proceedings, however at an early stage of case management it was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brudenall & Ors v Owners Corporation Unit Plan No. 202 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACAT 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The decision involved Brudenall and others versus Owners Corporation Unit Plan No. 202, concerning an appeal to the Owners Corporation Strata Schemes Tribunal. The dispute arose from an annual general meeting held in 2002, where a motion was proposed and passed to repeal or amend Motion 5. The applicants sought to overturn this decision, arguing it was made improperly. The Tribunal was tasked with reviewing the merits of the appeal and deciding whether the original decision should be upheld or set aside.

The central legal issues addressed by the Tribunal included whether the motion to repeal or amend Motion 5 was validly passed, and if the decision-making process followed the required statutory procedures. The applicants argued that the meeting lacked proper notice, and the motion was not adequately considered. The Tribunal had to examine the evidence and procedural fairness of the meeting to determine the validity of the applicants' claims.

After reviewing the evidence, the Tribunal found that the annual general meeting was conducted in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions. The notice provided met the legal requirements, and the meeting was held as scheduled. Furthermore, the motion to repeal or amend Motion 5 was properly presented and debated, with a valid majority vote in favour of the motion. The Tribunal concluded that the decision to repeal or amend Motion 5 was legitimate and dismissed the application. The applicants' appeal was thus unsuccessful.

The Tribunal's final order was that the application to overturn the decision to repeal or amend Motion 5 be dismissed. The original decision of the annual general meeting was upheld, and no further action was required regarding the repeal or amendment of Motion 5.

Orders

Orders of the court

IN CHAMBERS ORDER

Having conducted a merits review of Motion 5 of the AGM of 2002 the Tribunal declines the repeal or amendment Motion 5 and orders:

1.

The Application is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between the applicants, Brudenall and others, and the Owners Corporation Unit Plan No. 202. The applicants own units within a strata titled unit plan and are contesting a decision made by the Owners Corporation regarding the management and operation of common property. The dispute specifically concerns Motion 5 of the Annual General Meeting (AGM) held in 2002, which the applicants seek to repeal or amend. Motion 5 pertains to certain rules and regulations governing the common property, and the applicants argue that the current provisions are not in line with the Strata Schemes Management Act. The applicants claim that the Owners Corporation has acted contrary to the Act by implementing these provisions without proper consultation or adherence to legislative requirements.

The matter has come before the court following a decision by the tribunal, which conducted a merits review of Motion 5. The tribunal's review was prompted by an application filed by the applicants seeking to challenge the validity of Motion 5. The applicants argued that the motion was improperly passed and that it contravenes the Strata Schemes Management Act. The tribunal considered the submissions from both parties and, after reviewing the relevant legal framework and evidence, declined the applicants' request to repeal or amend Motion 5. The tribunal's decision is now subject to judicial review by the court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Motion 5 of the AGM of 2002 was properly passed and whether it complies with the requirements of the Strata Schemes Management Act.
2. Whether the Owners Corporation acted contrary to the Strata Schemes Management Act by implementing provisions of Motion 5 without adequate consultation or adherence to legislative mandates.
3. Whether the tribunal's decision to decline the repeal or amendment of Motion 5 is legally sound and supported by the evidence presented.

Held
1. The court concluded that Motion 5 of the AGM of 2002 was properly passed and complies with the requirements of the Strata Schemes Management Act.
2. The Owners Corporation did not act contrary to the Strata Schemes Management Act by implementing provisions of Motion 5 without adequate consultation or adherence to legislative mandates.
3. The tribunal's decision to decline the repeal or amendment of Motion 5 is legally sound and supported by the evidence presented.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the procedural and substantive aspects of Motion 5 as per the Strata Schemes Management Act. The tribunal's decision was upheld as the motion adhered to the statutory requirements for notice and voting, ensuring that the owners had proper opportunity to participate. The court noted that the Owners Corporation's actions in implementing the motion were consistent with legislative provisions, thereby not constituting a breach of any statutory duty to consult or adhere to legislative mandates. Furthermore, the tribunal's decision to decline the repeal or amendment of Motion 5 was found to be reasonable, as the evidence supported the conclusion that the motion was validly passed and in compliance with the Act. The court did not identify any legal errors in the tribunal's assessment and thus confirmed its decision.