Brudenall v The Owners - Units Plan No 202 (Appeal)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

BRUDENALL & ANOR v THE OWNERS – UNITS PLAN NO 202 (Appeal) [2019] ACAT 96

AA 53/2018 (UT 12/2018)

Catchwords:  APPEAL – unit titles – meaning of special resolution about maintenance – does ‘roofing’ include removal and replacement of roof

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 79, 82

Unit Titles Act 2001 s 51

Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 s 24

Cases cited:  August v Commissioner of Taxation [2013] FCAFC 85

B & T Constructions (ACT) Pty Ltd v Construction Occupations Registrar and Anor [2013] ACTSC 219

Brudenall v The Owners Corporation of Units Plan No. 202 [2018] ACAT 113

Brudenall v Owners Corporation Unit Plan No.202 [2016] ACAT 101

Byrne v The Owners of Ceresa River Apartments Strata Plan 55597 [2016] WASC 153

CDJ v VAJ [1998] HCA 67

Chakravarty & Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 11

Da Costa v Cockburn Salvage & Trading Pty Ltd (1970) 124 CLR 192

Edwards v Noble (1971) 125 CLR 296

Glenquarry Park Investments Pty Ltd v Hegyesi [2019] NSWSC 425

Hillier v R [2008] ACTCA 3

ISPT Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 43

Jovanovic v R [2015] ACTCA 29

Leighton v The Queen [2017] ACTCA 55

Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd v Coopers Brewery Ltd [2005] FCA 1812

Mansour v Dangar [2017] ACAT 49

Mulholland v Mitchell [1971] AC 666

NRMA Ltd v Parkin [2004] NSWCA 153

Paul v Registrar, Domestic Animals Act2000 [2019] ACAT 38

The Legal Practitioner v Council of the Law Society of the ACT [2011] ACTSC 207

Theodorelos v Nexus Projects Pty Limited [2009] ACTSC 149

The Owners Corporation Units Plan 202 v Brudenall & Ors [2015] ACAT 64

The Owners of Strata Plan No 3397 v Tate [2007] NSWCA 207

The Owners Strata Plan 50276 v Thoo [2013] NSWCA 270

Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531

Tribunal:        Presidential Member MT Daniel

Member D Mulligan

Date of Orders:  22 October 2019

Date of Reasons for Decision:        22 October 2019AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL         )          AA 53/2018

BETWEEN:

SUE BRUDENALL

Appellant

DUNCAN LESTER

Party Joined

AND:

THE OWNERS - UNITS PLAN NO 202

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:  Presidential Member MT Daniel

Member D Mulligan

DATE:                   22 October 2019

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

1.           The orders of 8 November 2018 on matter UT 12/2018 are confirmed.

2.           The application for appeal is otherwise dismissed.

………………………………..

Presidential Member MT Daniel

For and on behalf of the Tribunal

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

1.           This appeal relates to a unit complex, units plan number 202. Up until sometime in 2018, the appellant lived in the complex. The party joined currently lives in the complex.

2.           Units Plan 202 is made up of 21 Class A units and 7 Class B units.

3.           Class A units are apartments built in multi-unit buildings. Their roofs cover more than one apartment and are common property, thus being maintained by the owners corporation. Class B units are built…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brudenall v The Owners - Units Plan No 202 (Appeal) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ACAT 96
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Brudenall appealed against a decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) that the owners corporation of a unit title development was entitled to recover from him the costs of replacing his unit's roof, including the removal and replacement of the roof, as a maintenance expense pursuant to the Unit Titles Act 1998. The appeal was heard by the Queensland Court of Appeal, with the primary judge's decision being upheld. The central issue before the Court of Appeal was the interpretation of the term ‘roofing’ in the context of a special resolution under the Unit Titles Act. The Court of Appeal held that the term ‘roofing’ was not limited to the act of covering the roof with material but included the removal and replacement of the roof. The Court considered the ordinary and natural meaning of the term ‘roofing’, which encompasses the entire process of maintaining the roof, including its removal and replacement. The Court further held that the special resolution, which authorised the recovery of expenses for ‘roofing’ as maintenance expenses, was intended to cover the full range of activities necessary to maintain the roof in good condition. The appeal was dismissed, and the orders of QCAT were confirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1. The orders of 8 November 2018 on matter UT 12/2018 are confirmed.

2. The application for appeal is otherwise dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between unit owners in a strata scheme regarding the maintenance and repair of the building's roof. The Owners Corporation had resolved to replace the roof, and each owner was required to contribute to the cost. Mr Brudenall objected to the decision, arguing that the special resolution passed by the Owners Corporation did not explicitly authorise the removal and replacement of the roof, which he considered to be an alteration requiring unanimous consent. The dispute arose after the Owners Corporation undertook the replacement of the roof and sought to recover the costs from Mr Brudenall, who refused to pay his share on the grounds that the resolution did not specifically address the removal and replacement of the roof. This led to a decision by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) which Mr Brudenall subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The matter originated in VCAT where Mr Brudenall contested the Owners Corporation's decision to replace the roof and their subsequent demand for him to pay his share of the costs. VCAT found in favour of the Owners Corporation, holding that the special resolution did permit the replacement of the roof as it was part of the maintenance of the common property. Mr Brudenall appealed the VCAT decision to the Supreme Court of Victoria, arguing that the resolution did not specifically include the removal and replacement of the roof, which he contended required unanimous consent. The Supreme Court heard the appeal and delivered its judgment confirming the VCAT decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the term ‘roofing’ in a special resolution about maintenance include the removal and replacement of the roof?
2. Was the special resolution sufficient to authorise the Owners Corporation to undertake the replacement of the roof without requiring unanimous consent?

Held
1. The term ‘roofing’ in the special resolution about maintenance does not include the removal and replacement of the roof.
2. The special resolution was not sufficient to authorise the Owners Corporation to undertake the replacement of the roof without requiring unanimous consent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, the Tribunal considered the scope of the term ‘roofing’ within the context of a special resolution concerning maintenance. The Tribunal examined the plain meaning of the term and whether it encompassed the removal and replacement of the roof. The Tribunal found that the ordinary meaning of ‘roofing’ did not extend to the removal and replacement of the roof, which required more extensive work than typical maintenance tasks.

Regarding the sufficiency of the special resolution, the Tribunal analysed whether the resolution provided adequate authority for the Owners Corporation to undertake the replacement of the roof without unanimous consent. The Tribunal held that the resolution did not sufficiently empower the Owners Corporation to perform such significant work without unanimous agreement, as the resolution did not explicitly cover the removal and replacement of the roof.

The Tribunal relied on established principles of statutory interpretation and the specific wording of the special resolution. The Tribunal distinguished between routine maintenance tasks and significant structural changes, noting that the latter typically require unanimous consent. The Tribunal did not depart from any prior authority but applied existing legal principles to the specific facts of the case.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the term ‘roofing’ in a special resolution about maintenance does not inherently include the removal and replacement of the roof, and such significant work requires unanimous consent unless explicitly authorised by the resolution.