Meaney v The Owners Corporation Units Plan 40

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

MEANEY V THE OWNERS CORPORATION UNITS PLAN 40  
(Unit Titles) [2013] ACAT 72

UT 13/5 and UT 12/25

Catchwords:             UNIT TITLES – works for which approval was refused by owners corporation: modification of carport gate and installation of air conditioning units with associated structures – unsuccessful motion at the meeting of owners corporation – two stage process in making a tribunal order under section 129 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011: merits review of unsuccessful motion and deciding whether opposition to the motion was unreasonable – merits review is to make a correct or preferable decision – characteristics of “unreasonableness” – consideration against opposition to motion: medical condition of applicant, absence of noise impact on neighbours, and less obtrusive nature of structures – costs power of the tribunal: consideration of section 48 of the ACAT Act and section 129 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011

Legislation:ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, s.48

Unit Titles Act 2001, s.125

Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011, ss. 129

Tribunal:                  Ms. M-T. Daniel  –  Member

Date of Orders:  9 September 2013
Date of Order in relation to Costs:  22 October 2013        
Date of Reasons for Decision:         22 October 2013

ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL                 UT 13/5

BETWEEN:

MARY MEANEY

Applicant

AND:

THE OWNERS CORPORATION UNITS PLAN 40

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Ms. M-T. Daniel - Member

DATE:22 October 2013

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

1.    Application for costs is dismissed.

………………………………..

Ms. M-T. Daniel  –  Member

ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL                 UT 13/5

BETWEEN:

MARY MEANEY

Applicant

AND:

THE OWNERS CORPORATION UNITS PLAN 40

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Ms. M-T. Daniel - Member

DATE:9 September 2013

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

  1. The ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal, having conducted a merits review of the unsuccessful motion 1 for owners corporation consent for the installation of 4 air-conditioning units and associated conduits/pipework at Lot 9 and being satisfied that opposition to the motion was unreasonable, orders that motion 1 be given effect.

  2. The ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal, having conducted a merits review of the unsuccessful motion 4 for owners corporation consent for alteration of the carport gates, orders that motion 4, as amended to specify that the carport gates will be double-hinged, not affixed to common property, and painted to match the existing gate, be given effect.

Signed

Ms. Mary-Therese Daniel

Member

ACT Civil & Administrative Tribunal

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL  UT 12/25

THE OWNERS CORPORATION UNITS PLAN 40
Applicant
MARY MEANEY
Respondent

Tribunal:          Ms. Mary-Therese Daniel, Member

Date:          9 September 2013

ORDER

  1. Application for an order for removal of structure is dismissed.

Signed

Ms. Mary-Therese Daniel

Member

ACT Civil & Administrative Tribunal

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. These proceedings were commenced on 8 February 2013 by the Owners Corporation Units Plan 40 (TOCUP 40) filing an application (UT 12/25) seeking orders requiring Ms Meaney to remove unapproved structures and erections to lots 9 and 10 of Units Plan 40.  Ms Meaney opposed that application, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Meaney v The Owners Corporation Units Plan 40 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ACAT 72
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The decision in Meaney v The Owners Corporation Units Plan 40 involved a dispute between Meaney and the Owners Corporation Units Plan 40, relating to an application for costs. The case was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The primary issue before the court was the meaning of "unreasonable" in the context of the Urban and Regional Planning Act (UTM Act) and whether the tribunal must give effect to a motion if the opposition to it is found to be unreasonable. The court also had to determine the discretionary nature of the tribunal's power to make an order in such circumstances.

The court found that the term "unreasonable" is not defined in the UTM Act and referred to its ordinary English meaning as outlined in the Macquarie Dictionary. The court examined the extensive body of case law concerning when administrative decisions are considered unreasonable, such as when they are capricious, irrational, illogical, inconsistent, lacking in evidentiary basis, or based on fundamental error of fact. The court also noted that a defect in the process leading to the administrative decision could render it unreasonable, such as a lack of natural justice. However, the court clarified that even if the opposition to the motion is found to be unreasonable, the tribunal is not obligated to give effect to the motion. Instead, the tribunal must make the correct or preferable decision, which may not necessarily be approval of the unsuccessful motion.

The court further held that the tribunal's power to make an order is discretionary, as evidenced by the use of the word "may" in the relevant section of the UTM Act. This means that the tribunal may decline to approve the unsuccessful motion despite finding that the opposition to the motion was unreasonable.

The tribunal dismissed the application for costs, indicating that the tribunal found the opposition to the motion was not unreasonable, or that the tribunal decided not to give effect to the motion despite finding the opposition unreasonable.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Orders that:

1. Application for costs is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Thirdly, when conducting merits review there is no threshold question of reasonableness or unreasonableness of the original decision to be determined before the Tribunal may proceed to make an order. What does it mean for a decision to be “unreasonable”? Section 129(1)(g) places a significant limitation upon the merits review process, by requiring that the ACAT must be satisfied that opposition to the motion was unreasonable before an order giving effect to the motion may be made. The word ‘unreasonable’ is not defined in the UTM Act. Its ordinary English meaning, according to the Macquarie Dictionary, is:Unreasonable: adjective 1. not reasonable, not endowed with reason. 2. not guided by reason or good sense. 3. not agreeable to or willing to listen to reason. 4. not based on or in accordance with reason or sound judgement. 5. exceeding the bounds of reason; immoderate; exorbitant. There is an extensive body of authority outlining when administrative decisions are, or are not, considered to be ‘unreasonable’ and therefore liable to be set aside. An administrative decision may be ‘unreasonable’ where it is capricious or irrational, is illogical or perverse, is inconsistent with other decisions on like facts, has simply no evidentiary basis or is based on an error of fact which is fundamental to the decision. In some cases, a defect in the process leading to the making of the administrative decision will render the decision ‘unreasonable’. For example, where the process leading to the making of the decision lacked natural justice, this may lead to the decision itself being considered ‘unreasonable’. Given that the Tribunal is tasked with conducting merits review of the motion, a process usually made available in relation to decisions of an administrative character, it is appropriate to draw on this body of law as providing some guidance as to whether ‘opposition to the motion was unreasonable’.If ACAT is satisfied opposition to the motion is unreasonable, is it required to give effect to the motion? The use of the word ‘may’ in the prefatory words of subsection 129(1) makes it clear that the power provided to the tribunal by paragraph 129(1)(g) is discretionary. In other words, even if the ACAT is satisfied that opposition to a motion was unreasonable, it is not obliged to make an order giving effect to the motion. It is at this point that merits review would require that the tribunal make the correct or preferable decision, whether to give effect to the unsuccessful motion (either as originally proposed or as amended) or not. It is hard, but not impossible, to conceive of a case in which, opposition to the motion being unreasonable, approval of the motion would not be the correct or preferable decision. Certainly, if the ‘unreasonableness’ is due to a defect in the process, approval of the unsuccessful motion would not always follow. In such matters, the tribunal might decline to approve the unsuccessful motion notwithstanding that the opposition to the motion was found to be unreasonable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.