Bewley v The Owners Units Plan No. 596 (Unit Titles)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



BEWLEY v THE OWNERS UNITS PLAN No. 596 (Unit Titles) [2016] ACAT 142

UT 34/2015

Catchwords:              UNIT TITLES DISPUTE – amendment of owners corporation resolution – lighting in common property – merits review – regard for opinion of the unit holders

Legislation cited:      Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 s 129

Subordinate

Legislation cited:      Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design General Code

Cases cited:Brudenall & Ors v Owners Corporation Unit Plan No 202 [2016] ACAT 101

Meaney v The Owners Corporation Units Plan 40[2013] ACAT 72

Parker v Owners Units Plan No 36 [2014] ACAT 37

Tribunal:                   President L Crebbin

Date of Orders:  12 December 2016
Date of Reasons for Decision:         12 December 2016

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY 

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL           UT 34/2015

BETWEEN:

TERESA BEWLEY AND PHILIP BEWLEY

Applicants

AND:

THE OWNERS UNITS PLAN No 596

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             President L Crebbin

DATE:  12 December 2016

ORDER

  1. The Tribunal orders that the application is dismissed.

……………………………..

President L K Crebbin

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. The applicants, Teresa and Philip Bewley, are unit holders in Units Plan 596, which is a small development of four townhouse units on a corner block in Barton. The applicants seek an order section 129(1)(f) of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (the UTMA) amending a resolution of the executive committee of the respondent regarding outdoor lighting on the common property driveway.

  2. In particular, on 12 May 2015 the executive committee resolved:

    two common property lights be decommissioned. The associated electricity meter … be surrendered to ACTewAGL.

  3. The applicants seek an order that the resolution be amended to read as follows:

    two common property lights be maintained in situ with power supplied by ACTEWAGL, and be fitted with light-sensitive switching to facilitate their continuous operation during all hours of darkness to meet the standards required in the ACT Government’s protocol “Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design General Code” during all hours of darkness as they apply to “Multi Unit Housing” with “private open space” (page 3) to the standard set out under “Item 3.3 Lighting, Criterion C10”.

  4. The applicants seek the amendment to the resolution on the grounds that the two common property lights are necessary for the safety and security of owners, residents and visitors when walking on the common property driveway at night. In support of their claim regarding the required standard of lighting, the applicants rely upon the lighting requirements under Item 3.3 Lighting, criterion C10 within the Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design General Code (the Code), which is one of the design codes forming part of the ACT Territory Plan.

  5. The applicants contended that the three solar garden lights that have been installed as alternative lighting along the boundary fence are ineffective. They contended that the solar lights do not “actually illuminate the ground and we see [that] as being quite unsafe.”[1] The applicants said that after a series of dark cloudy days, the lights are “typically weak”[2] They acknowledge that sensor lights have…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bewley v The Owners Units Plan No. 596 (Unit Titles) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACAT 142
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bewley was involved in a legal dispute against The Owners Units Plan No. 596 (Unit Titles), with the matter being heard in the Australian Capital Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT). The central issue in the case was whether the lighting of the common property, particularly the driveway, complied with the Building Code of Australia. Bewley argued that the lighting did not meet the Code’s requirements, which are intended to achieve principles such as natural surveillance. Conversely, the respondent claimed that the lighting removal was lawful and that the Code does not apply retrospectively to previously approved developments.

The legal issues before the Tribunal centred on whether the Code should be applied to retrospectively affect the respondent's decision to remove the common property lighting. The Tribunal had to consider the legislative scheme governing the approval and maintenance of developments and whether the respondent acted lawfully in removing the lighting. The key consideration was whether the Code’s provisions applied retroactively or if they only applied prospectively to new developments.

The Tribunal concluded that once the development was approved 25 years ago, the construction could be maintained regardless of later requirements under the Territory Plan or the Code. The Tribunal also found that the Code does not apply with retrospective effect, meaning that the removal of the lighting by the respondent was lawful. The Tribunal emphasised the importance of adhering to community standards and values as encapsulated in legislation rather than allowing subjective views to guide the decision. The Tribunal’s responsibility to make the correct or preferable decision was balanced with the legislative scheme under which the resolution was made, leading to the conclusion that the application should be dismissed.

The Tribunal dismissed the application, upholding the respondent’s decision to remove the common property lighting. The Tribunal’s decision highlighted the importance of considering the legislative scheme and community standards in making decisions, rather than relying on subjective views or idiosyncratic ideas.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The Tribunal orders that the application is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal’s responsibility to make what it considers to be the correct or preferable decision nevertheless requires consideration of the legislative scheme within which the resolution was made. In Brudenall & Ors v Owners Corporation Unit Plan No 202[7] at paragraphs 44 – 47 the Tribunal said: 44. ... However, finding the ‘preferable’ decision is not as straightforward as simply substituting the individual view of the Tribunal member for that of the owners corporation. 45. In Re Visa Cancellation Applicant and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] AATA 690, the following statements were made about how a Tribunal makes ‘the preferable decision’. [62] ... The test, however, cannot be subjective. It cannot admit of idiosyncratic ideas. Evaluation in accordance with the decision-maker’s own personal standards or philosophy must not guide the determination.[64] It must be the case that the proper basis of evaluation, of reaching the preferable decision, in these cases, is reference to community standards or community values. It is not the decision-maker’s idiosyncratic view of what will adequately protect the public which is relevant, but what the decision- maker determines will achieve that result in accordance with community standards or values. 46. The reference to ‘community standards’ in the preceding excerpt is not a reference to the views expressed by the parties in a particular matter, it is a reference to ‘more permanent values’[referring to In Re Visa at paragraph 79] such as those encapsulated in legislation. 47. In this regard, the Tribunal notes the corporation’s legislated right to be self-determining, provided decisions and actions are lawful and there is no oppression of a minority. [7] [2016] ACAT 101 The question therefore is whether the Tribunal should amend the resolution in the way proposed by the applicants or in some other way, based on a merits review, having regard to the competing viewpoints of the parties and the legislative scheme under which the resolution was made. I refer first to the applicants’ claim that the lighting of the common property, and in particular the driveway, does not comply with the Code. I accept the applicants’ submission that the Code applies to multi-unit housing, as this is, per Table 1 to the Code. I accept too that the intent of the Code is to achieve key principles of natural surveillance, among other things, “through the establishment of clearly delineated and hierarchy of public open space, community open space (meaning shared areas) and private open space”. The Tribunal regards the common property of Units Plan 596 as community open space, being a shared area. It does not follow, however, that the respondent acted unlawfully by removing the common property lighting. The Territory Plan, and the Code forming part of the Territory Plan, establishes a legislative scheme for determining whether an application for a proposed development should be approved or not. Once a development is approved, as occurred in this case 25 years ago, construction pursuant to the approved development can be maintained regardless of later requirements under the Territory Plan or the Code. The Tribunal accepts the respondent’s submission that the Code does not apply with retrospective effect.