Johnson v The Owners Units Plan No 4373 (Appeal)

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

JOHNSON & ANOR v THE OWNERS – UNITS PLAN NO 4373 (Appeal) [2021] ACAT 54

AA 5/2021 (UT 32/2019)

Catchwords:               APPEAL – unit titles – whether a communal dining room may be used for a home business – decision of Executive Committee to refuse that use – Original Tribunal dismissed the application under the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 section 129 – internal appeal – role of Appeal Tribunal – merits review of Executive Committee’s resolution – resolution set aside and replaced

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 79, 82

Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 ss 2, 3, 22, 35, 125, 127, 128 129, Sch 2 s 2.4, Sch 4 s 3.6

Subordinate

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Procedures Rules 2020 r 91

Cases cited:Cooper v The Owners-Strata Plan 58068 [2020] NSWCA 250

Fox v Percy[2003] HCA 22
House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499
I.C. Formwork Services Pty Limited v Moir (No 2) [2020] ACTCA 44
In the matter of AB [2018] ACAT 18
Johnson & Anor v The Owners – Units Plan 4373 [2020] ACAT 114

Meaney v The Owners Corporation Units Plan 40[2013] ACAT 72
Parker v Owners Units Plan No 36 [2014] ACAT 37

Tribunal:  President G Neate AM

Senior Member B Meagher SC

Date of Orders:  24 June 2021

Date of Reasons for Decision:         24 June 2021

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AA 5/2021

BETWEEN:

MARK JOHNSON

First Appellant

JANET JOHNSON

Second Appellant

AND:

THE OWNERS – UNITS PLAN NO 4373

Respondent

APPEAL TRIBUNAL:       President G Neate AM

Senior Member B Meagher SC

DATE:24 June 2021

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

1.The appeal is allowed.

2.The decision of the Executive Committee of the respondent to refuse to allow the request by the appellants to use the Dining Room for drawing classes is set aside.

3.The request by the appellants to use the Dining Room is allowed on the following conditions:

(a)Janet Johnson may use the Dining Room for drawing classes conducted by her.

(b)Mark and Janet Johnson must hold adequate public liability insurance in respect of that use of the Dining Room.

(c)Each such use will be for a period no longer than approximately 2.5 hours.

(d)The size of each class (usually about three or four people) will not exceed 10 people.

(e)The use will be occasional only and not unduly frequent.

(f)The availability of the Dining Room for that use is subject to the Dining Room booking system now in place.

(g)Mark and Janet Johnson are responsible for ensuring that the persons attending each class are quiet and respectful of residents and that the Dining Room is left clean and tidy after each class.

4.The parties have liberty to make submissions about the form of Order 3 within 14 days of these orders being made, and that Order will not come into force until:

(a)if no submissions are received within that time, 9 July 2021;…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Johnson v The Owners Units Plan No 4373 (Appeal) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] ACAT 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Johnson and his wife appealed against the decision of the Australian Capital Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) which dismissed their application under the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011. The Johnsons sought to use the communal dining room of their unit plan for drawing classes. The Executive Committee of the respondent, The Owners Units Plan No 4373, refused the request. The ACAT dismissed the appeal. The Johnsons appealed to the Appeal Tribunal, which reviewed the merits of the decision of the Executive Committee. The Appeal Tribunal set aside the decision of the Executive Committee and allowed the appeal. The Tribunal found that the decision of the Executive Committee to refuse permission was not the preferable one and that the Johnsons' request should be granted subject to conditions. These conditions included that the drawing classes were for a period no longer than approximately 2.5 hours, the size of each class would not exceed 10 people, and the use of the Dining Room was occasional only and not unduly frequent. The Johnsons were also required to hold adequate public liability insurance and to ensure that the Dining Room was left clean and tidy after each class. The parties had liberty to make submissions about the form of the approval within 14 days of the orders being made. If no submissions were received within that time, the orders would come into force on 9 July 2021. If submissions were received, the orders would come into force on a date to be notified to the parties.

The appeal was allowed, and the decision of the Executive Committee of the respondent to refuse to allow the request by the appellants to use the Dining Room for drawing classes was set aside. The request by the appellants to use the Dining Room was allowed subject to conditions. The conditions included that Janet Johnson could use the Dining Room for drawing classes conducted by her, Mark and Janet Johnson must hold adequate public liability insurance in respect of that use of the Dining Room, each such use will be for a period no longer than approximately 2.5 hours, the size of each class (usually about three or four people) will not exceed 10 people, the use will be occasional only and not unduly frequent, the availability of the Dining Room for that use is subject to the Dining Room booking system now in place, and Mark and Janet Johnson are responsible for ensuring that the persons attending each class are quiet and respectful of residents and that the Dining Room is left clean and tidy after each class. The parties have liberty to make submissions about the form of Order 3 within 14 days of these orders being made, and that Order will not come into force until if no submissions are received within that time, 9 July 2021; or if submissions are received, on a date to be notified to the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The decision of the Executive Committee of the respondent to refuse to allow the request by the appellants to use the Dining Room for drawing classes is set aside.

3. The request by the appellants to use the Dining Room is allowed on the following conditions:

(a) Janet Johnson may use the Dining Room for drawing classes conducted by her.

(b) Mark and Janet Johnson must hold adequate public liability insurance in respect of that use of the Dining Room.

(c) Each such use will be for a period no longer than approximately 2.5 hours.

(d) The size of each class (usually about three or four people) will not exceed 10 people.

(e) The use will be occasional only and not unduly frequent.

(f) The availability of the Dining Room for that use is subject to the Dining Room booking system now in place.

(g) Mark and Janet Johnson are responsible for ensuring that the persons attending each class are quiet and respectful of residents and that the Dining Room is left clean and tidy after each class.

4. The parties have liberty to make submissions about the form of Order 3 within 14 days of these orders being made, and that Order will not come into force until:

(a) if no submissions are received within that time, 9 July 2021; or

(b) if submissions are received, on a date to be notified to the parties.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appellants’ reasons for appealing against the decision of the Original Tribunal were, in summary, as follows.:(a)The Original Tribunal’s findings that the proposed use is for unfettered access and impacts other owners, and that the appellants made a block booking, are errors of fact.(b)It is wrong to say the Johnsons’ proposed use of the Dining Room is commercial and they are a commercial cohort.(c)The asserted lack of procedural fairness was not considered.(d)The decision that the Original Tribunal could not just make findings is an error of law and involved failure to consider a recent judgment in Cooper v The Owners-Strata Plan 58068 [2020] NSWCA 250.(e)The decision not to allow commercial use created a de facto rule and the Original Tribunal was in error in not so concluding.(f)The Original Tribunal did not consider that the decision might be void for irregularity despite evidence that showed it was.(g)The Original Tribunal relied on the survey without considering the inappropriate content of the survey. (h)The Original Tribunal did not consider a course of action was available that preserves the appellants’ rights and those of other residents and was preferable to a decision that eliminates such rights.(i)The decision endorses the subjective decision-making and bias shown by the Executive Committee which is inconsistent with the requirements of procedural fairness imposed by the UTM Act.66.The appellants’ arguments or submissions were listed by reference to the list of errors. The list above was taken from the initial appeal application and was revised. We were told that we should read both together,[64] so what follows endeavours to compress the two and make the essential points. As will be seen, it is not necessary to deal with every point separately to decide the appeal.[64] Transcript of appeal proceedings 7 April 2021 page 367.The appellants’ documents set out specific findings and point to various pieces of evidence that, they contended, establish what was overlooked and is inconsistent with the Original Tribunal’s findings. We will not set them all out here, but we have read them carefully and will advert to them in our consideration.68.An example is a challenge to a finding by the Original Tribunal (at [59]) that the appellants’ proposed use unreasonably interferes with use of the Dining Room by other owners. The evidence relied on by the appellants includes the limited use sought in their first email,[65] the appellants’ explanation that the use was only as an adjunct as they had secured other premises,[66] their assurances to the Committee that they were sensitive of the needs of others and would cooperate in ensuring fair use,[67] referring to their notes of the meeting of 21 October 2019,[68] their email on 3 September 2019,[69] and evidence of the low use of the room.[70] In another document provided to the Original Tribunal, in which the appellants critiqued aspects of Mr Hall’s witness statement, they stated that they had told the previous Chair of the Executive Committee that the proposed frequency of use would be within a range of five to 15, and that the lower figure had proved to be the reality.[71][65] Original application appendix A1[66] Original application appendix A9[67] Original application appendix A1, A15 [68] Original application attachment M&J 002 – reasons for our application page 4[69] Original application appendix A20[70] Original application appendix D3[71] Appellants reply to additional response of respondent of 22 April 2020, dated 5 May 2020 at AB2; request for subpoena, dated 5 May 2019, pages 10, 1169.As we have come to a decision that favours one side or other on each argument, we will state what our conclusion is and, in doing so, explain the argument to the contrary. We will not say more about what the successful party has said on the topic.ConsiderationShould the findings sought be made?70.We agree with the Original Tribunal that it is orders that the Tribunal makes, not findings or opinions about the conduct of people – as explained by the Court of Appeal in I.C. Formwork Services Pty Limited v Moir (No 2).[72][72] [2020] ACTCA 44 at [15]-[19]71.The underlying object of section 129 of the UTM Act is to resolve disputes, not to create an environment that will perpetuate them. We think the orders we will make should achieve that purpose.Was the refusal due to procedural unfairness including bias?72.Mr Hall in his statement set out at length the approach of the Executive Committee and himself. He asserted that the guiding principles that he followed were to do the right thing by all owners and to treat all fairly. His considered statement about his approach to the matter reveals a conscientious and thorough examination of the matters involved. He stated that, in his observation, other Committee members have behaved similarly. We are impressed by the statement. In any event he was not cross-examined due to the nature of the hearing before the Original Tribunal and, even if we might be of a mind to doubt this, it is not open to us to do so.73.In expressing that view, we acknowledge that the appellants provided the Original Tribunal with a detailed written critique of aspects of Mr Hall’s witness statement,[73] and they advised us at the hearing of that critique.[74] While some of the criticisms made by the appellants inform other aspects of our decision on the main issue in this appeal, the critique confirms that the appellants were given opportunities to present their case to the Executive Committee on various occasions, although they disagree with the Committee’s characterisation of their enterprise.[73] Appellants’ reply to additional response of respondent of 22 April 2020, dated 5 May 2020 at AB2; request for subpoena, dated 5 May 2019, pages 9-13[74] Transcript of appeal proceedings 7 April 2021 pages 48-5074.Mr Amentas, who appeared for the respondent, reminded us that the Executive Committee is made up of volunteers who give up their time for what can be a burdensome and often thankless task.[75][75] Transcript of appeal proceedings 7 April 2021 page 2775.As the chronology of emails and other communications between the Johnsons and the Executive Committee demonstrates, they were given (and they accepted or precipitated) a series of opportunities to put arguments orally and in writing in support of their application to the Executive Committee. In that sense, they were afforded procedural fairness.76.We well understand why the appellants see the matter as personal, but objectively, we are not persuaded to that conclusion. It is to be expected that where decisions are to be made by fellow owners that impact on one owner, personal sensitivities can be affected. The very nature of a strata plan is such that the decisions to be reached by the Executive Committee or at the AGM will be by people who know each other and who might from time to time get cross with each other. Bias in this context cannot be as clear as in the conduct of a court case, for example, where the decision-maker is unknown to the parties and has no interest in common with them. It is presumably for this reason that the Tribunal has the power to repeal or amend a resolution of the Executive Committee on the merits (section 129(1)(f)), and any injustice real or perceived may be remedied by doing so.Special privilege or rule change – General Meeting77.As noted earlier, a suggestion has been made that the Johnsons seek a ‘special privilege’ in relation to the proposed use of the Dining Room. The Dictionary to the UTM Act provides that ‘special privilege’ means: a right, other than a sublease, granted to a person to use the common property of a units plan in a manner that is additional to, or restrictive of, the rights of other people (who are not granted the special privilege) to use the common property. 78.Section 22(1) of the UTM Act provides:22 Special privileges relating to common property(1) An owners corporation for a units plan may, if authorised by a special resolution, grant a special privilege for a period of less than 3 months to—(a) a unit owner; or(b) someone else with an interest in a unit.Examplea right to the exclusive use of a pool area for a private partyNote A special privilege that is granted for a period of 3 months or more must be granted by a special privilege rule (see s 112A).This requires a special resolution that needs 75% of a vote at a General Meeting.[76] [76] Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 Schedule 3, section 3.1679.What the appellants seek is the use of the Dining Room within the current booking system that envisages use to the exclusion of others for short periods that are a minor use. This is not a ‘special privilege’ and they do not want to change the rules. The suggestion that this request should be the subject of a resolution by a General Meeting is therefore not applicable.80.We have also considered whether the matter generally should be referred to a General Meeting. Any resolution of such a meeting may well be challenged in the Tribunal, just as the Executive Committee’s decision is, and there is no practical benefit in doing so where, as here, we consider that the decision might be reviewed on the merits.A review on the merits81.As we have set out in the discussion of the relevant legislation, the Original Tribunal should have considered whether, standing in the shoes of the Executive Committee, she regarded it as unreasonable to refuse the Johnsons’ request. She did not do this but assumed that it was for the Committee and not her to make the call and she should only interfere if it was subjectively unreasonable.[77] In taking this approach she fell into error.[77] Johnson & Anor v The Owners Corporation – Units Plan 4373 [2020] ACAT 114 at [62], [63]82.As the Original Tribunal stated, Schedule 2, section 2.4 of the UTM Act provides that the Executive Committee may approve an application by a member of the corporation to use the common property if:(a)the use applied for is “minor”; and(b)the use will not unreasonably interfere with the reasonable use and enjoyment of the common property by other members of the corporation. 83.The Original Tribunal assumed (without proof and contrary to the assertions of the Johnsons, whose use was known to it) that the use would likely require some regular and frequent booking and would unreasonably interfere with the use of the Dining Room by other owners.[78] She did not consider whether the approval, if any, might limit the frequency and length of use which the Johnsons assert they would accept if it interfered with other owners. [78] Johnson & Anor v The Owners Corporation – Units Plan 4373 [2020] ACAT 114 at [59]84.The Original Tribunal drew comfort from the result of the survey. The survey was poorly drafted and likely to produce a negative response. It was only replied to by about one half of the owners, and the comments of some responses revealed a series of unmerited assumptions that might have been dispelled if the question had been put more clearly (by reference to the particular application being considered) or with a balanced explanation. Consequently, we regard the result of the survey as of little or no worth in guiding the decision of the Executive Committee in relation to the Johnsons’ application. The result should not have influenced the Executive Committee or the Original Tribunal. Even more significant is the opinion expressed by the Committee in its 13 June 2019 email that their concerns did not apply to the proposed use by the appellants. Mr Hall made a similar point at paragraph [46] of his statement. 85.What the negative responses to the survey[79] show is that the use of the word ‘commercial’ without explanation conjured up a series of consequences which would have prevented approval being given under the existing rule as they would amount to more than ‘minor’ use. The Executive Committee was sidetracked by its concern about setting a precedent and the ‘commercial’ quality of the proposed use of the Dining Room. The provision of the UTM Act that enables use of common property has the solution built in by the use of the word ‘minor’ and the requirement that the use will not unreasonably interfere with the reasonable use and enjoyment of the common property by other members of the corporation.[80][79] Original application appendix C3[80] UTM Act Schedule 2, section 2.486.As we have noted, Mr Hall in his statement (at paragraph [53]) identified a number of points that might affect whether permission should be given or continued. Similar considerations were mentioned in the email from the Secretary of 13 June 2019.[81] They are all sensible points and demonstrate the conscientious thought that was given to the issue. They would continue to be relevant in considering any requests. As the previous Committee and Mr Hall (in part at least) acknowledged, the Johnsons’ application met those concerns. [81] Original application appendix A1687.We have concluded that the Original Tribunal did not exercise the discretion available to it. Even assuming that discretion was exercised, it was attended with error such that we must exercise the discretion afresh. It follows that the discretion the Original Tribunal had miscarried, and it is for us to determine what is the preferable decision.88.In our view the Executive Committee’s decision to refuse permission is not the preferable one and the Johnsons’ request should be granted.Other issues89.The judgment in Cooper v The Owners-Strata Plan 58068[82] does not add to our understanding here. We do not agree with the appellants’ submission that a rule or by-law has been made. We accept that, in practice, whenever the undefined word ‘commercial’ might be attached to a proposed use, that use would probably not be allowed by the Executive Committee. But that does not elevate a decision-making practice into a rule or by-law.[82] [2020] NSWCA 25090.We have drafted an order that allows the Johnsons’ request subject to conditions. This draft differs from that proposed by the appellants, as we consider that their proposal does not go into enough detail. Because there might be some practical problems with our draft, we will give the parties liberty to make submissions about the form of the approval. If no submissions have been received from either party within 14 days of the date of our orders, the proposed Order 3 will become final.91.The Orders are:1.The appeal is allowed.2.The decision of the Executive Committee of the respondent to refuse to allow the request by the appellants to use the Dining Room for drawing classes is set aside.3.The request by the appellants to use the Dining Room is allowed on the following conditions:(a) Janet Johnson may use the Dining Room for drawing classes conducted by her.(b) Mark and Janet Johnson must hold adequate public liability insurance in respect of that use of the Dining Room.(c) Each such use will be for a period no longer than approximately 2.5 hours.(d) The size of each class (usually about three or four people) will not exceed 10 people.(e) The use will be occasional only and not unduly frequent.(f) The availability of the Dining Room for that use is subject to the Dining Room booking system now in place.(g) Mark and Janet Johnson are responsible for ensuring that the persons attending each class are quiet and respectful of residents and that the Dining Room is left clean and tidy after each class.4.The parties have liberty to make submissions about the form of Order 3 within 14 days of these orders being made, and that Order will not come into force until:(a) if no submissions are received within that time, 9 July 2021; or(b) if submissions are received, on a date to be notified to the parties.………………………………..President G Neate AMFor and on behalf of the Tribunal