In the Matter of AB

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

IN THE MATTER OF AB (Appeal) [2018] ACAT 18

AA 35/2017

Catchwords:             APPEAL – guardianship – appeal from decision reviewing and confirming the appointment of the Public Trustee and Guardian as guardian and manager for a protected person– hearing of appeal conducted as a review of all of the original decision – interim application to provide fresh evidence that post-dated the original hearing refused – appointment of Public Trustee and Guardian as guardian and manager for protected person confirmed – appeal dismissed

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 60, 79, 80, 82

Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991 ss 4, 5A, 6, 9, 10, 11, 19

Human Rights Act 2004 ss 11, 12, 30

Mental Health Act 2015

Subordinate

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Procedural Rules (2009) (No. 2) r 21

Cases cited:B&T Constructions (ACT) Pty Ltd v Construction Occupations

Registrar and the Owners – Units Plan 3324 [2013] ACTSC 219
Excel Intelligent Pty Ltd v Thomson [2018] ACAT 4
Felle & Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT [2012] ACAT 82

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118

Giusida Pty Limited v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2016] ACTSC 275

House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499

Hussain v Farhmand [2017] ACAT 107

Kostas v HIA Insurance Services Pty Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 390

Murray v Figge (1974) 4 ALR 612
Steed v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1981) 37 ALR 620

Paper cited:               “Roles in Protective Management of Person and Property”, Justice Geoff Lindsay, Probate and Protective List Judge, Equity Division of the NSW Supreme Court, 8 December 2017

Tribunal:                  Presidential Member E Symons
  Member Dr R Davies

Date of Orders:  28 February 2018                   

Date of reasons for decision:           28 February 2018

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY           )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AA 35/2017

IN THE MATTER OF AB

TRIBUNAL:Presidential Member E Symons

Member Dr R Davies

DATE:    28 February 2018

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The order made by the Tribunal on 6 September 2017 in GT 2/2017 confirming the appointment of the Public Trustee and Guardian as guardian and manager for the protected person is confirmed.

  2. The appeal is dismissed.

………………………………..

Presidential Member E Symons

Delivered for and on behalf of the Tribunal

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal (the appeal) from the decision of the Tribunal (GT 2/2017) (the Original Tribunal) made on 6 September 2017[1] after reviewing the orders made by the tribunal (the first Tribunal) on 18 April 2017 appointing the Public Trustee and Guardian (PTG) as guardian and manager for the protected person, AB (AB) pursuant to the Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991 (the GMP Act).  The Original Tribunal confirmed the orders made by the first Tribunal on 18 April 2017.

    [1] As set out in reasons for decision dated 6 September 2017

  2. The appeal was lodged by AC (the appellant or AC), the father of AB,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Matter of AB and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ACAT 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

AB, a 32-year-old individual receiving treatment for chronic schizophrenia at the Adult Mental Health Unit at the Canberra Hospital, was the subject of an appeal concerning the appointment of a guardian and manager under the Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991. The appeal was brought by AC, who had previously applied to be appointed as AB's guardian and manager but later withdrew that application. The Public Trustee and Guardian (PTG) had been appointed as AB's guardian and manager by the Tribunal on 18 April 2017, following an application by a social worker at the Adult Mental Health Unit. AC subsequently lodged an application for review of this decision, which was heard by a differently constituted Tribunal on 7 August 2017. The appeal tribunal was required to determine whether the appointment of the PTG as AB's guardian and manager should be revoked or varied.

In considering the appeal, the tribunal reviewed the evidence and submissions presented at the original hearing and the review hearing, including medical reports, statements from AB's family members, and input from the PTG. The tribunal found that the PTG was the most suitable candidate to act as AB's guardian and manager, given their expertise and experience in managing the affairs of individuals with impaired decision-making abilities. The tribunal also noted that AB's condition and the complexity of his care needs justified the appointment of a guardian and manager to facilitate his discharge from hospital and transition back into the community. Consequently, the tribunal confirmed the appointment of the PTG as AB's guardian and manager and dismissed the appeal.

The tribunal made the following orders: (1) confirming the appointment of the Public Trustee and Guardian as AB's guardian and manager, and (2) dismissing the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The order made by the Tribunal on 6 September 2017 in GT 2/2017 confirming the appointment of the Public Trustee and Guardian as guardian and manager for the protected person is confirmed.

2.

The appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The background to the Original Tribunal’s decision, which is the subject of this appeal, is set out in the Original Tribunal’s reasons for decision dated 6 September 2017. The Appeal Tribunal sets out, below, from the Original Tribunal’s reasons for decision, the background to the first decision dated 18 April 2017 and the background to the review of that decision:Background to the guardianship and management order dated 18 April 20173. The current order was made in unusual circumstances.4. AB was born in 1984. At the time of the review hearing he was 32 years old. Since May 2016, he has been receiving treatment at the Adult Mental Health Unit (AMHU) at the Canberra Hospital. In November 2016, the Tribunal made a Psychiatric Treatment Order (PTO) in relation to him for a period of six months.5. On 4 January 2017, AC lodged with the Tribunal Registry an application for an order under the Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991 (GMP Act) appointing him as the plenary guardian for AB. He subsequently advised the Tribunal Registry that he was withdrawing that application. 6. On 16 March 2017, AC lodged a new application seeking to be appointed as guardian and manager. Included in that application (and the previous application) was the following statement:Because [AB] does not have a guardianship,(sic) our involvement in [AB’s] treatment is seen by some treating psychiatrists as illegal, unwelcome and a breach of privacy.On many occasions, the treating doctors urge us to apply for a guardianship so that they can welcome us as a legal partners in pursuing of helping [AB] finding a lasting cure for his illness. (Errors in original)7. On 24 March 2017, a social worker at the AMHU lodged an application for appointment of the PTG as guardian and manager for AB. That application included the following statements:[AB] has a diagnosis of chronic schizophrenia and was assessed and found having impaired decision-making ability in respect of health, welfare and financial matters. He was supported by parents until now in these areas....[AB] has been in AMHU since May 2016, receiving treatment for his diagnosed mental condition. Treating team have organised an expert opinion on his case and would like to plan for discharge. [AB] doesn’t have capacity to make decision on matters related discharge destination, NDIS support, community supports, financial and welfare matters. Treating would like a guardian and financial manager appointed for [AB] to make decisions on these matters, to facilitate discharge planning and subsequently transition him back to community. (Errors in original)8. On 12 April 2017, one doctor signed a review report prepared by another treating doctor recommending to the Tribunal that an additional PTO be made.9. At the hearing on 18 April 2017, the original Tribunal had before it the recommendation for an additional PTO and the two applications for the appointment of a guardian and manager in relation to AB: one by AC, and the other by the social worker. AC provided the original Tribunal with a detailed written statement in relation to why (in his submission) AB needs a guardian and manager, and why AC is the most suitable person to be appointed as the guardian and manager. The original Tribunal heard from AC and AB’s mother, AB’s brother, two treating psychiatrists, the social worker, and the Public Advocate. The PTG was not represented at that hearing, which went for more than two hours.10. On that day, the original Tribunal made two types of orders in relation to AB:(a)a PTO for six months from that date; and(b)an order appointing the PTG as guardian and manager for AB to be reviewed not later than 18 April 2020.Background to the application for review of the orders dated 18 April 201711. On 11 May 2017, AC lodged an application for appeal against the guardianship and management order. He asked that the order appointing the PTG be set aside and that either AC or his wife be appointed as guardian and manager, or that they be appointed jointly as guardian and manager. He attached detailed typed documents in support of the application.12. Following the making of procedural orders on 31 May 2017, a differently constituted Tribunal (the appeal Tribunal[3]) presided at a hearing on 17 July 2017. AC and his wife were present. Their other son participated by telephone. The PTG was represented. The social worker who applied for the appointment of the PTG as guardian and manager was not present. The appeal Tribunal[4] did not proceed because of evidentiary issues and because the original applicant had not been advised of the hearing.13. After some discussion with the parties, the appeal Tribunal directed that:(a)the hearing of the appeal be adjourned to a date to be fixed and be subject to any further order of the Tribunal; and(b)there be a hearing in relation to whether the order appointing the PTG as the guardian and manager should be varied or should be revoked (the review hearing).As a consequence of this approach, other issues that would otherwise have been dealt with on appeal (e.g. in relation to the original Tribunal’s conduct of the hearing) no longer arise.14. Having decided that the matters in issue be dealt with by the review process rather than the appeal process, the appeal Tribunal made procedural directions for the review hearing to occur on 7 August 2017.[3] The 17 July 2017 appeal Tribunal[4] The 17 July 2017 appeal Tribunal

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.