Brother Industries Ltd v Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Brother Industries, Ltd v Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 1490

TRADE MARKS – infringement of registered trade marks – importing and selling goods packaged in counterfeit packaging constitutes ‘use’ of trade marks – construction of trade mark specifications – meaning of “consumables” – defence of consent – insufficient evidence to establish chain of supply started with manufacturer – consent of registered owner, not related entity in corporate group, must be acquired.

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct and false representations – importing and selling goods packaged in counterfeit packaging is misleading and deceptive – intention not relevant – importing and selling goods packaged in counterfeit packaging constitutes passing off.

TRADE PRACTICES – liability for sale of good not of merchantable quality – evidence of defectiveness required.

WORDS AND PHRASES – “consumable”

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), ss 7(4), 9, 17, 20, 120, 123
Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth), sch 1
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 52, 53, 74D, 74H

Angoves Pty Ltd v Johnson (1982) 43 ALR 349 cited
Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Ltd (2004) 218 CLR 592 cited
Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Limited (2000) 202 CLR 45 considered
Champagne Heidsieck et Cie Monopole Societe Anonyme v Buxton [1930] 1 Ch 330 cited
Coca-Cola Co v All-Fect Distributors Ltd (1999) 96 FCR 107 considered
Estex Clothing Manufacturers Pty Ltd v Ellis and Goldstein Ltd (1967) 116 CLR 254 considered
Given v CV Holland (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1977) 29 FLR 212 cited
Hornsby Building Information Centre Pty Ltd v Sydney Building Information Centre Ltd (1978) 140 CLR 216 cited
Leeks v FXC Corporation (2002) 118 FCR 299 cited
Mark Foys Pty Ltd v TVSN (Pacific) Ltd (2000) 104 FCR 61 considered
Nokia Corporation v Truong (2006) 66 IPR 511 cited
Pioneer v The Registrar of Trade Marks (1977) 137 CLR 670 considered
Playboy Enterprises International Inc v Hong (2004) 63 IPR 533 considered
R & A Bailey & Co Lt v Boccaccio Pty Ltd (1986) 4 NSWLR 701 considered
Revlon Inc v Cripps and Lee [1980] FSR 85 cited
Thunderbird Products Corp v Thunderbird Marine Product Pty Ltd (1974) 131 CLR 592 cited
Transport Tyres Pty Ltd v Montana Tyres Rims and Tubes Pty Ltd (1999) 93 FCR 421 considered
W.D. & H.O. Wills (Australia) Lrd v Rothmans Ltd (1956) 94 CLR 131 cited

Blanco White TA and Jacobs R, Kerly’s Law of Trade Marks and Trade Names (12th ed, Sweet & Maxwell, 1986)
Davison M, Johnston K and Kennedy P, Shanahan’s Australian Law of Trade Marks & Passing Off (3rd ed, Lawbook Co., 2003)

BROTHER INDUSTRIES, LTD AND BROTHER INTERNATIONAL (AUST) PTY LTD (ACN 001 393 835) v DYNAMIC SUPPLIES PTY LTD (ACN 064 793 862)
NSD 50 OF 2005

TAMBERLIN J
26 SEPTEMBER 2007
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 50 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

BROTHER INDUSTRIES, LTD
First Applicant/First Cross-Respondent

BROTHER INTERNATIONAL (AUST) PTY LTD
(ACN 001 393 835)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brother Industries Ltd v Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1490
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Brother Industries Ltd brought an action against Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd, alleging infringement of trade marks and misleading or deceptive conduct under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and the tort of passing off. Brother Industries, a Japanese company, is the owner of several trade marks relating to the word ‘BROTHER’ and manufactures a variety of products, including a printer drum unit known as the ‘Brother DR-200’. Dynamic Supplies, an Australian company, imports and distributes Brother products, as well as similar but unbranded products referred to as ‘original equipment manufacturer’ products. In 2003, Dynamic Supplies sourced three shipments of Brother products from a supplier in the United States, rather than from Brother Australia or its authorised distributors, and subsequently sold these products as ‘Brother’ branded products. Brother contends that the units sourced from the United States were not genuine Brother products, and that Dynamic Supplies’ conduct constituted an infringement of Brother’s trade marks, misleading or deceptive conduct and passing off. The central legal issues in this case were whether Dynamic Supplies had infringed Brother’s trade marks, engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, and committed the tort of passing off. The Court found that Dynamic Supplies had indeed infringed Brother’s trade marks by selling products that were not genuine Brother products. The evidence showed that the units sold by Dynamic Supplies were OEM products, not genuine Brother products, and were not branded with the ‘BROTHER’ trade mark. The Court also found that Dynamic Supplies had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and the tort of passing off by selling the unbranded products as ‘Brother’ branded products. The Court dismissed Dynamic Supplies’ cross-claim for declaratory relief and damages by way of indemnity under s 74H of the Trade Practices Act. The Court found that Dynamic Supplies was not entitled to relief under those provisions because it had failed to establish that it was an innocent infringer or that it had taken reasonable steps to prevent the infringement. The Court ordered that Brother Industries draft, file and provide to Dynamic Supplies Draft Short Minutes of Orders in respect of the precise form of the orders arising out of these reasons for judgment, costs and directions as to the future conduct of these proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants draft, file and provide to the respondent Draft Short Minutes of Orders in respect of the precise form of the orders arising out of these reasons for judgment, costs and directions as to the future conduct of these proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

In response to these allegations, Dynamic Supplies has filed a cross-claim seeking declaratory relief and damages by way of indemnity pursuant to s 74H of the TPA in respect of compensation which it paid to its customers who purchased defective goods manufactured by Brother.BACKGROUND For many years, Brother Japan has conducted an international business of producing, marketing and selling a variety of products, ranging from sewing machines to printers. Since the late 1970s, Brother Australia carried on the Australian arm of that business with the licence and authority of Brother Japan, and used several registered trade marks relating to the word ‘BROTHER’. One product produced by Brother Japan is a printer drum unit. These units are designed to incorporate toner cartridges within their structure and are then inserted into machines such as printers and facsimiles in which they enable the transfer of the ink in the toner cartridge onto paper fed through the machines. Each printer drum unit produced by Brother is designed to be used with a number of machines. The specific printer drum unit relevant in this case, and in respect of which Brother’s trade marks are registered, is called a ‘Brother DR-200’ unit. This unit is embossed with the ‘BROTHER’ brand. It receives a ‘Brother TN-200’ toner cartridge and is manufactured for use in conjunction with a wide range of Brother machines, including laser printers, facsimiles and multi-function devices. The Brother DR-200 is packaged in distinctive packaging, comprising a box made of cardboard which bears the ‘BROTHER’ trade mark. An unrelated Japanese company, Asano Danboru Kabushiki Kaisha (“Asano Danboru”), manufactures the Brother DR-200 packaging for all Brother DR-200 units produced in Japan. It does so according to very precise specifications. The evidence is that Asano Danboru has always performed this job exclusively for Brother Japan and has never outsourced manufacture of the Brother DR-200 packaging. This exclusivity of packaging supply has continued unbroken since the commencement of the relationship between Brother and Asano Danboru. Brother also makes a printer drum unit which is similar but not identical to a Brother DR-200 and is not embossed with the ‘BROTHER’ name. It is called an ‘original equipment manufacturer’ product (“OEM product”). These OEM products are not branded, and have never been branded, with the ‘BROTHER’ trade mark. All OEM products produced by Brother are sold exclusively to one purchasing company (“Company X”), the identity of which, in these proceedings, is the subject of a confidentiality order. Having purchased the OEM products, Company X then sells or distributes them under a brand name unrelated to Brother or with no brand name at all. The respondent, Dynamic Supplies, is an Australian company which imports and distributes or sells printer drum units which are made by Brother and contained in packaging bearing the ‘BROTHER’ trade mark. Until 2003, Dynamic Supplies sourced almost all of the Brother products it sold or distributed from Brother Australia or its authorised distributors. However, this arrangement changed in early 2003 when Dynamic Supplies sourced three shipments of units at a substantially lower price from another supplier in the United States of America, namely Discover Group Inc (“Discover Group”), which is an entity unrelated to the applicants.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Concerning Dynamic Supplies’ cross-claim, there is only one issue to be determined: (vii)Is Dynamic Supplies entitled to relief pursuant to ss 74D and 74H of the TPA?EVIDENCE for brother I turn now to the evidence relating to the above issues. A large body of affidavit evidence was adduced in these proceedings, some of which is claimed by Brother to be confidential and will be so treated. Several of the deponents were required for cross-examination, and their evidence is summarised below. Mr Suzuki is the manager of a development group in a division of Brother Japan. He commenced employment with Brother Japan in 1985 and has been responsible, inter alia, for designing and reviewing designs of components of various Brother products. In particular, Mr Suzuki has experience with the design of printer drum units and toner cartridges, including the Brother DR-200. He gave evidence that Brother Japan manufactures, distributes and sells the Brother DR-200, and that these units and their packaging bear the ‘BROTHER’ trade mark. Based on this familiarity, Mr Suzuki says that the Sample Units acquired by Brother from Dynamic Supplies in early 2004 were not Brother DR-200 units, a conclusion reached after considering the absence of the ‘BROTHER’ trade mark, the cleaning brush mechanism, the plastic paper guide and guide cover, the anti-static sheet and the transfer roller on each product. Mr Sonoda is the manger of a development department in a division of Brother Japan. He commenced employment with Brother Japan in 1986. Until late 1994, Mr Sonoda’s roles and responsibilities were similar to those of Mr Suzuki, involving the design and review of designs of Brother products. However, at that date, Mr Sonoda was appointed to a position relating to the design and supply of an OEM product to Company X. Although he has been promoted since, Mr Sonoda’s experience in the design and development of Brother products remains relevant to his current position. Mr Sonoda gave evidence of the path taken by Brother Japan to convert a Brother DR-200 into an OEM product suitable for use by Company X. He gave evidence that the trade mark ‘BROTHER’ is not and never has been applied to any OEM products. Based on this experience and knowledge, Mr Sonoda identified the Sample Units as OEM products produced by Brother Japan for sale to Company X. Three affidavits were filed by Mr Inagawa in these proceedings. He is an assistant manager of a production department in a division of Brother Japan, having joined the company in 1968. Since 1999, his role has been to supervise the production of printer drum units, including the production lines for Brother DR-200 units and the OEM products sold to Company X. Mr Inagawa gave evidence detailing the production process for Brother products. He states that a production order is created specifying the quantity of products required and the date of manufacture. Having received a copy of this production order, the relevant departments of Brother Japan and Asano Danboru fill the order with the appropriate number of printer drum units and packaging respectively. Serial codes are then attached to the printer drum units by stickers. During this process, there are five separate ways in which Brother Japan checks the number of printer drum units and packaging units match the production order. On the basis of his knowledge and experience of this process, Mr Inagawa states that it is not possible for the number of printer drum units produced to exceed the number or packaging units produced, or vice versa. The detail of the process is recorded in and confirmed by log books, which are kept for each separate production line. Mr Inagawa also deposes to the procedures that Brother Japan has in place for when a printer drum unit or packaging unit is defective or damaged. On the basis of his familiarity with Brother Japan’s production procedures and serial codes, Mr Inagawa highlighted a discrepancy in the serial codes applied to the Sample Units and the Sample Packaging which indicate that the Sample Units were purportedly packaged in the Sample Packaging significantly in advance of their date of production. He also concluded that the Warranty Units sent by Dynamic Supplies to Brother were not ‘BROTHER’ branded units but rather were OEM products produced for Company X.

Decision

Reasons for decision

TAMBERLIN J
For these reasons, the cross-claim should be dismissed.CONCLUSION I allow the applicants’ claim that the respondent has infringed the registered trade marks, and has engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct in contravention of ss 52 and 53 of the TPA and the tort of passing off. I dismiss the respondent’s cross-claim. I direct the applicants to draft, file and provide to the respondent Draft Short Minutes of Orders in respect of the precise form of the orders arising out of these reasons for judgment, costs and directions as to the future conduct of these proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: TAMBERLIN J

Full text does not contain this section.