Laticrete International Inc. v Seal Hard Australia Pty. Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition to application made by Laticrete International Inc. under s.92 of the Act to remove trade mark no. 1238325 - S SEAL HARD PROTECTS CONCRETE WHERE IT COUNTS - in the name of Seal Hard Australia Pty. Ltd.

Delegate: M. Cooper
Representation: Opponent: Ben Gardiner
Applicant: No appearance

Decision:

[2019] ATMO 48
Trade Marks Act 1995 - opposition to application under s 92(4)(b) to remove trade mark from Register for non-use – use demonstrated for Goods - s 92(4)(b) grounds not established.

Background

  1. This matter concerns the opposition by Seal Hard Australia Pty. Ltd.  (“the Opponent”) to an application under s.92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”) by Laticrete International Inc (“the Applicant”), to remove its trade mark no. 1238325 from the Register for non-use.

  2. On 1 May 2008, the Opponent applied to register the trade mark below (allocated trade

    mark no. 1238325):

    (“the Trade Mark”)

  3. The goods for which the Trade Mark is registered are as follows:

    Class 3:

    Floor polishes; floor treatment chemicals and floor treatment compositions.

    (“the Goods”).

  4. This application for removal for non-use under s.92(4)(b) of the Act was made on 23 June 2017. It was made in relation to all the goods for which the Trade Mark is registered.

  5. A Notice of Intention to Oppose the removal application was filed by the Opponent on 6 September 2017. On 5 October 2017 it filed its Statement of Grounds and Particulars (“SGP”).

  6. A Notice of Intention to Defend was filed by the Applicant on 28 November 2017.

    Evidence

  7. The evidence filed in relation to this removal opposition comprises:

    ·     Evidence in Support

    Ø  Declaration of Tony James Maher, the Opponent’s Managing Director, dated 5 March 2018 with Annexures TM-01 to TM-20 (“the Maher Declaration”).

    ·     Evidence in Answer

    Ø  Declaration of Daniel C. Lu, the Applicant’s Senior Vice President, dated 14 June 2018 with Exhibits 1-8. (“the Lu Declaration”).

  8. No Evidence in Reply was filed. On 10 October 2018 the Opponent requested a hearing. The matter was heard before me, as delegate of the Registrar, in Canberra on 4 April 2019. Following directions, the Opponent filed written submissions and appeared at the hearing. There were no submissions filed by the Applicant, nor did it appear at the hearing.

    The Opponent’s Evidence

  9. In his declaration, Mr. Maher stated that the Opponent’s business supplies premium concrete treatment products to builders and contractors across Australia. He said it specialises in floor treatment chemicals and floor treatment compositions. He annexed various documents regarding the nature of the products supplied and described “the Seal Hard Product” as a floor treatment chemical composition that functions to polish, dustproof, waterproof, seal, densify and harden concrete floors.

  10. He claimed that the Trade Mark is the Opponent’s primary logo and has been continuously used in Australia in good faith in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Laticrete International Inc. v Seal Hard Australia Pty. Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ATMO 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Laticrete International Inc. (the Applicant) to remove the trade mark "SEAL HARD" from the Register under section 92(4)(b) of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth) for non-use. Seal Hard Australia Pty. Ltd (the Opponent) opposed this application. The Applicant alleged that the trade mark had remained registered for a continuous period of three years without use in Australia. The Opponent contended that it had continuously used the trade mark in good faith in relation to the registered goods since 1 May 2008, and specifically during the relevant period of 24 May 2014 to 23 May 2017.

The primary legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether the Applicant had established the grounds for removal of the trade mark due to non-use. This required determining if the Opponent had used the trade mark in Australia in good faith during the three-year period preceding the filing of the removal application. The Applicant’s evidence suggested that the Opponent had been a distributor for L&M Construction Chemicals Inc., from whom the Applicant claimed to have acquired intellectual property rights in the "Seal Hard" mark.

The Hearing Officer considered evidence from both parties. The Opponent provided a declaration from its Managing Director, supported by various documents including Wayback machine archives of its website, invoices to Australian clients, a company vehicle displaying the mark, business cards, and screenshots showing the mark on product packaging and a commercial building. The Applicant’s evidence included a declaration from its Senior Vice President, asserting its global leadership and its acquisition of rights from L&M. However, the Opponent submitted that the Applicant's assertions were irrelevant to the question of the Opponent's use of the trade mark during the non-use period.

Ultimately, the Hearing Officer was satisfied that the Opponent had presented sufficient evidence to rebut the Applicant's allegations of non-use. The evidence demonstrated repeated and consistent use of the trade mark by the Opponent in relation to the registered goods throughout the relevant period. Consequently, the Hearing Officer determined that the grounds for removal had not been established, and the trade mark would remain on the Register. The Opponent was awarded costs against the Applicant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

He claimed that the Trade Mark is the Opponent’s primary logo and has been continuously used in Australia in good faith in relation to the Goods since 1 May 2008 and, in particular, during the period from 24 May 2014 to 23 May 2017. He provided several documents evidencing that use as follows: · Wayback machine archives of the Opponent’s website demonstrating use of the Trade Mark on selected dates from 21 June 2014 to 19 February 2017;· use of the Trade Mark on a company vehicle;· several invoices for Australian-based clients displaying the Trade Mark, including for the period between May 2014 and May 2017; · business card displaying the Trade Mark with a tax invoice from the printer;· screenshot dated December 2014 of use of the Trade Mark on a drum of floor polish;· screenshot dated September 2014 of use of the Trade Mark on a commercial building.The Applicant’s evidence As noted above, the Applicant sought that the Trade Mark be removed under s.92(4)(b) for non-use for all the goods for which it is registered. The period of non-use was not stated. According to the Lu declaration, the Applicant is “a global leader in the field of adhesives, grouts, surface finishes and protectants, and construction chemicals.” He said since 2008 the Opponent had been the Australian distributor of SEAL HARD products for L&M Construction Chemicals Inc (“L&M”). On 5 March 2014 he said that L&M had assigned all its intellectual property rights in the SEAL HARD mark to the Applicant. He exhibited the Trademark Assignment document and the USPTO and Brazilian registrations by L&M of the word trade mark “Seal Hard” in 1997 and 1999 respectively. He referred to the Opponent’s Wayback machine website extracts, noting those that also include references to L&M and its logo. He also exhibited an L&M Technical Data Sheet for the Seal Hard product which he claimed was available in Australia. Submissions As noted above, only the Opponent filed submissions. After noting the relevant legal tests, the Opponent submitted that the Maher declaration demonstrated “repeated and consistent use of the Trade Mark by the Opponent in relation to the Registered Goods throughout the Relevant Period”, which he identified as the period 24 May 2014 to 23 May 2017. Website screenshots, equipment, the Opponent’s vehicles, invoices, business cards, and brochures were all said to evidence that use. In relation to the Lu declaration, the Opponent submitted that the assertions made are irrelevant and appear to have no bearing on whether the Opponent has used the Trade Mark during the non-use period. He submitted that it follows that the application for removal should be dismissed. The Opponent sought costs.Legislation Section 92 of the Act relevantly provides as follows: 92 Application for removal of trade mark from Register etc.(1) Subject to subsection (3), a person may apply to the Registrar to have a trade mark that is or may be registered removed from the Register. (2) The application: (a) must be in accordance with the regulations; and (b) may be made in respect of any or all of the goods and/or services in respect of which the trade mark may be, or is, registered. (3) An application may not be made to the Registrar under subsection (1) if an action concerning the trade mark is pending in a prescribed court, but the person may apply to the court for an order directing the Registrar to remove the trade mark from the Register. Note: For prescribed court see section 190. (4) An application under subsection (1) or (3) (non-use application) may be made on either or both of the following grounds, and on no other grounds:[...](b) that the trade mark has remained registered for a continuous period of 3 years ending one month before the day on which the nonuse application is filed, and, at no time during that period, the person who was then the registered owner:(i) used the trade mark in Australia; or(ii) used the trade mark in good faith in Australia;in relation to the goods and/or services to which the application relates.Note 1: For file and month see section 6.Note 2: If non-use of a trade mark has been established in a particular place or export market, then instead of the trade mark being removed from the Register, conditions or limitations may be imposed under section 102 on the registration of the trade mark so that its registration does not extend to that place or export market.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am therefore satisfied that the Opponent has rebutted the Applicant’s allegations of non-use in the relevant period. Decision Section 101 of the Act relevantly provides:101 Determination of opposed application—general(1) Subject to subsection (3) and to section 102, if:(a) the proceedings relating to an opposed application have not been discontinued or dismissed; and(b) the Registrar is satisfied that the grounds on which the application was made have been established;the Registrar may decide to remove the trade mark from the Register in respect of any or all of the goods and/or services to which the application relates. It follows that I am not satisfied that the Applicant has established the grounds for removal of the Trade Mark. Accordingly, the Trade Mark will remain on the Register.Costs As the Opponent has been successful, I award costs against the Applicant under section 221 of the Act in the amounts set out in Schedule 8 of the Regulations.Mary-Ann CooperHearing OfficerTrade Marks and Designs Oppositions and Hearings3 April 2019

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The evidence filed in relation to this removal opposition comprises:· Evidence in Support Ø Declaration of Tony James Maher, the Opponent’s Managing Director, dated 5 March 2018 with Annexures TM-01 to TM-20 (“the Maher Declaration”).· Evidence in AnswerØ Declaration of Daniel C. Lu, the Applicant’s Senior Vice President, dated 14 June 2018 with Exhibits 1-8. (“the Lu Declaration”). No Evidence in Reply was filed. On 10 October 2018 the Opponent requested a hearing. The matter was heard before me, as delegate of the Registrar, in Canberra on 4 April 2019. Following directions, the Opponent filed written submissions and appeared at the hearing. There were no submissions filed by the Applicant, nor did it appear at the hearing. The Opponent’s Evidence In his declaration, Mr. Maher stated that the Opponent’s business supplies premium concrete treatment products to builders and contractors across Australia. He said it specialises in floor treatment chemicals and floor treatment compositions. He annexed various documents regarding the nature of the products supplied and described “the Seal Hard Product” as a floor treatment chemical composition that functions to polish, dustproof, waterproof, seal, densify and harden concrete floors. He claimed that the Trade Mark is the Opponent’s primary logo and has been continuously used in Australia in good faith in relation to the Goods since 1 May 2008 and, in particular, during the period from 24 May 2014 to 23 May 2017. He provided several documents evidencing that use as follows: · Wayback machine archives of the Opponent’s website demonstrating use of the Trade Mark on selected dates from 21 June 2014 to 19 February 2017;· use of the Trade Mark on a company vehicle;· several invoices for Australian-based clients displaying the Trade Mark, including for the period between May 2014 and May 2017; · business card displaying the Trade Mark with a tax invoice from the printer;· screenshot dated December 2014 of use of the Trade Mark on a drum of floor polish;· screenshot dated September 2014 of use of the Trade Mark on a commercial building.The Applicant’s evidence As noted above, the Applicant sought that the Trade Mark be removed under s.92(4)(b) for non-use for all the goods for which it is registered. The period of non-use was not stated. According to the Lu declaration, the Applicant is “a global leader in the field of adhesives, grouts, surface finishes and protectants, and construction chemicals.” He said since 2008 the Opponent had been the Australian distributor of SEAL HARD products for L&M Construction Chemicals Inc (“L&M”). On 5 March 2014 he said that L&M had assigned all its intellectual property rights in the SEAL HARD mark to the Applicant. He exhibited the Trademark Assignment document and the USPTO and Brazilian registrations by L&M of the word trade mark “Seal Hard” in 1997 and 1999 respectively. He referred to the Opponent’s Wayback machine website extracts, noting those that also include references to L&M and its logo. He also exhibited an L&M Technical Data Sheet for the Seal Hard product which he claimed was available in Australia. Submissions