W D & H O Wills (Australia) Ltd v Rothmans Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read
94 CLR 18294 CLR 183

[ ] W. D. &H. O. WILLS (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED

RESPONDENT,

ROTHMANS LIMITED

RESPONDENT. APPLICANT Trade Mark-Removal from register-Absence of bona fide user for requisite period-

Proprietor not manufacturing or selling trade marked goods-Manufacture by American corporation of trade marked goods-Private persons in Australia MELBOURNE,

ordering direct from American corporation-Payment in America by person Feb. 17, 20;

ordering-Goods sent direct by American corporation to person ordering- SYDNEY,

Periodic accounting by American corporation to proprietor in respect of share April 13.

of profit on such sales-Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 (No. 20 of 1905-No. 76 of 1948), 8. 72.

Section 72 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 provides that (1) The court may, on the application of any person aggrieved, if it is shown that there has been no bona fide user of a trade mark for a consecutive period of three years since the date of the last registration thereof, order its removal from the register, unless it was at the date of the application in bona fide use and had been so for a period of six months immediately prior to the date of the appli- cation. (2) For the purpose of this section bona fide user or use means user or use of a trade mark in respect of the goods in respect of which it is registered for the purposes of trade by the proprietor or registered user of the trade mark or a predecessor in title.

W. was registered proprietor of a trade mark in respect of " tobacco manu- factured or unmanufactured" consisting simply of the words Pall Mall' From 1918 to 1932 it manufactured cigarettes which it sold to retailers in Australia in small numbers under such trade mark. In 1932 such sales ceased. In 1937 it imported 2,000 cigarettes into Australia which it sold under the trade mark, and in 1941 it manufactured and sold under the trade mark in Australia a further 5,000 cigarettes. After 1946 small parcels of American cigarettes were imported into Australia mainly, if not exclusively, for the use of personnel employed in Australia by American corporations or in business activities in which such corporations were interested. These were purchased from British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd. in the United States and payment was made direct to that company by the person giving the order. Some of

94 CLR 184

these cigarettes bore the trade mark " Pall Mall' W. was in no way con- cerned in these importations and, although under an arrangement which it had with the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd. it was entitled to receive a commission on all Australian sales made by that company whether it had any part in effecting those sales or not, it neither claimed nor received any com- mission. In July 1952 W. arranged with the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd. that the latter would account to it for any profit made on orders for such cigarettes in excess of five per cent on factory cost. The arrangement was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read W D & H O Wills (Australia) Ltd v Rothmans Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1956] HCA 15
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

W. D. & H. O. Wills (Australia) Ltd. (the appellant) appealed to the Full Court of the High Court of Australia from an order of Fullagar J. that its trade mark "Pall Mall" be removed from the Register of Trade Marks. The application for removal was made by Rothmans Ltd. (the respondent), a United Kingdom company that had been unable to register its own "Pall Mall" trade mark in Australia due to the appellant's existing registration. The dispute centred on whether the appellant had made bona fide use of its "Pall Mall" trade mark in Australia for the requisite periods under section 72 of the *Trade Marks Act 1905-1948* (Cth).

The court was required to determine whether the appellant had made bona fide use of the "Pall Mall" trade mark in Australia for the six months preceding 15 September 1954, the date of the respondent's application for removal. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the importation and distribution of "Pall Mall" cigarettes from the United States to Australia, under arrangements involving the appellant and the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd., constituted a "bona fide user" of the trade mark in Australia for the purposes of trade by the appellant, as defined by the Act.

The court reasoned that for a trade mark to be in bona fide use, it must be used in relation to goods for the purposes of trade, indicating a connection in the course of trade between the goods and the proprietor. The evidence showed that while "Pall Mall" cigarettes were imported into Australia, the entire trading in these cigarettes, including the offer, sale, payment, and delivery, took place in the United States. The cigarettes were purchased and paid for in the US by individuals or American corporations operating in Australia, and were then consigned to them. The court concluded that once the goods left the United States, they were no longer in the course of trade, and the trading in them had concluded with their acquisition by the consumer. The stickers affixed to the packets, stating they were "Made in U.S.A. for the proprietors in Australia, W. D. & H. O. Wills (Australia) Ltd.", were not considered sufficient to establish use of the trade mark in Australia for the purposes of trade by the appellant.

The appeal was dismissed, and the order for the removal of the trade mark from the register was affirmed. The court held that the whole trading in the cigarettes occurred in the United States, and it was only there that the trade mark was used for the purposes of trade.

Background

Background to the litigation

W D & H O Wills (Australia) Ltd, a company registered in the United Kingdom, was the registered proprietor of the trade mark "Pall Mall" for tobacco products in Australia. From 1918 to 1932, the company manufactured and sold cigarettes under this trade mark in small numbers in Australia. However, these sales ceased in 1932. After 1946, small quantities of American cigarettes bearing the "Pall Mall" trade mark were imported into Australia, mainly for the use of personnel employed in Australia by American corporations. These cigarettes were purchased from the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd. in the United States, with payment made directly to that company by the person giving the order. W D & H O Wills (Australia) Ltd received a commission on all Australian sales made by the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd., regardless of whether it had any involvement in effecting those sales.

In July 1952, W D & H O Wills (Australia) Ltd arranged with the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd. that the latter would account to it for any profit made on orders for such cigarettes in excess of five percent on factory cost. This arrangement was carried out, but W D & H O Wills (Australia) Ltd took no part in any of the transactions. The cigarettes were imported into Australia in red packets bearing the words "Pall Mall" and a sticker stating "Made in U.S.A. for the proprietors in Australia, W D & H O Wills (Australia) Ltd." Between July 1952 and September 1954, approximately 515,400 cigarettes were imported into Australia by eight or nine persons. The cigarettes were ordered by letter to the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd., accompanied by a cheque on an American bank in payment, and sent by parcel post to the person ordering.

The matter before the court is an appeal by W. D. & H. O. Wills (Australia) Ltd. against the decision of Fullagar J., who ordered the removal of trade mark No. 18437 from the Register of Trade Marks under section 72 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948. The appeal was brought before the Full Court following the decision of Fullagar J. reported as Rothmans Ltd. v. W. & H. O. Wills (Australia) Ltd. The primary issue is whether the trade mark was in bona fide use in Australia for the requisite period prior to the application for its removal from the register. The appellant argues that the trade mark was in use in Australia as it was affixed to cigarettes imported into Australia by the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd. on its behalf, with profits from sales being accounted to the appellant. The respondent contends that the trade mark was not in use by the appellant as the entire trading process occurred in the United States, with the appellant taking no part in the importation or sale of the cigarettes in Australia. This case involves an examination of the definition of "bona fide use" and the scope of "trade" as it applies to the use of a trade mark in Australia under the Trade Marks Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the use of a trade mark by a proprietor in another country, where the trade mark is applied to goods that are then imported into Australia, constitute bona fide use of the trade mark in Australia for the purposes of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948?

2. Was the trade mark "Pall Mall" used in respect of the goods in respect of which it is registered for the purposes of trade by the proprietor or registered user of the trade mark or a predecessor in title in Australia?

3. Did the trade mark "Pall Mall" indicate a connection in the course of trade between the goods and the proprietor of the trade mark in Australia?

4. Can the use of a sticker indicating the proprietor of the trade mark in Australia on goods imported into Australia constitute bona fide use of the trade mark in Australia?

5. Did the arrangement between W. D. & H. O. Wills (Australia) Ltd and the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd amount to a use of the trade mark "Pall Mall" for the purposes of trade by the proprietor in Australia?

6. Is the use of a trade mark in the course of trade limited to the sale of goods, or does it include other dealings with the goods in the process of manufacture or in the course of business before they are offered for sale to the public?

Held
1. Does the use of a trade mark by a proprietor in another country, where the trade mark is applied to goods that are then imported into Australia, constitute bona fide use of the trade mark in Australia for the purposes of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948?
The Court held that such use does not constitute bona fide use in Australia.

2. Was the trade mark "Pall Mall" used in respect of the goods in respect of which it is registered for the purposes of trade by the proprietor or registered user of the trade mark or a predecessor in title in Australia?
The Court held that there was no such use in Australia.

3. Did the trade mark "Pall Mall" indicate a connection in the course of trade between the goods and the proprietor of the trade mark in Australia?
The Court held that the trade mark did not indicate such a connection in Australia.

4. Can the use of a sticker indicating the proprietor of the trade mark in Australia on goods imported into Australia constitute bona fide use of the trade mark in Australia?
The Court held that it cannot.

5. Did the arrangement between W. D. & H. O. Wills (Australia) Ltd and the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd amount to a use of the trade mark "Pall Mall" for the purposes of trade by the proprietor in Australia?
The Court held that it did not.

6. Is the use of a trade mark in the course of trade limited to the sale of goods, or does it include other dealings with the goods in the process of manufacture or in the course of business before they are offered for sale to the public?
The Court held that the use of a trade mark for the purposes of trade must include at least a use of the mark to indicate the origin of the goods.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court in this case had to determine whether the trade mark "Pall Mall" was being used in Australia for the purposes of trade by the registered proprietor, W. D. & H. O. Wills (Australia) Ltd. The court was required to interpret the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 and determine the meaning of "bona fide use" of a trade mark. The central issue was whether the activities of the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd. in importing and selling Pall Mall cigarettes in Australia constituted bona fide use of the trade mark by the proprietor, W. D. & H. O. Wills (Australia) Ltd.

The court first addressed the issue of whether the use of a trade mark by a proprietor in another country, where the trade mark is applied to goods that are then imported into Australia, constituted bona fide use of the trade mark in Australia for the purposes of the Trade Marks Act. The court found that the trade mark "Pall Mall" was only used for the purposes of trade in the United States, and not in Australia. The trade mark was applied to the cigarettes in the United States and the trading in the cigarettes occurred there, not in Australia. The court concluded that the use of the trade mark in the United States did not amount to bona fide use in Australia because the trade mark was not used for the purposes of trade in Australia.

The court then considered whether the trade mark "Pall Mall" was used in respect of the goods in respect of which it is registered for the purposes of trade by the proprietor or registered user of the trade mark or a predecessor in title in Australia. The court found that the trade mark was not used in Australia by the proprietor or any other person for the purposes of trade. The proprietor did not manufacture, import, or sell the cigarettes in Australia. The British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd. was the entity that imported and sold the cigarettes in Australia, and it did not act as an agent for the proprietor.

The court also examined whether the trade mark "Pall Mall" indicated a connection in the course of trade between the goods and the proprietor of the trade mark in Australia. The court held that the trade mark did not indicate any connection in the course of trade between the goods and the proprietor in Australia. The trade mark was not used in the course of trade in Australia, and the only connection between the proprietor and the cigarettes was through the sticker that indicated the proprietor in Australia.

Further, the court considered whether the use of a sticker indicating the proprietor of the trade mark in Australia on goods imported into Australia constituted bona fide use of the trade mark in Australia. The court found that the sticker did not constitute bona fide use of the trade mark. The sticker did not indicate any connection in the course of trade between the goods and the proprietor in Australia, and it did not amount to a use of the trade mark for the purposes of trade.

The court also addressed the issue of whether the arrangement between W. D. & H. O. Wills (Australia) Ltd and the British-American Tobacco Co. Ltd amounted to a use of the trade mark "Pall Mall" for the purposes of trade by the proprietor in Australia. The court found that the arrangement did not amount to a use of the trade mark for the purposes of trade in Australia. The proprietor did not take part in any of the transactions and did not manufacture, import, or sell the cigarettes in Australia.

Finally, the court considered whether the use of a trade mark in the course of trade was limited to the sale of goods, or whether it included other dealings with the goods in the process of manufacture or in the course of business before they were offered for sale to the public. The court held that the use of a trade mark in the course of trade was not limited to the sale of goods, but also included other dealings with the goods before they were offered for sale to the public. However, in this case, the trade mark was not used in the course of trade in Australia, and therefore did not meet the requirements of the Trade Marks Act.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the use of a trade mark in another country, where the trade mark is applied to goods that are then imported into Australia, does not constitute bona fide use of the trade mark in Australia for the purposes of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948. Additionally, the use of a trade mark in the course of trade includes dealings with the goods before they are offered for sale to the public, but in this case, the trade mark was not used in the course of trade in Australia, and therefore did not meet the requirements of the Act. The court distinguished prior authority that had held that the use of a trade mark in another country could constitute bona fide use in Australia, and instead found that the use of the trade mark in this case did not meet the requirements of the Act.