HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
KIEFEL CJ,
GAGELER, GORDON, EDELMAN AND GLEESON JJBERNADETTE BOSANAC APPELLANT
AND
COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION & ANOR RESPONDENTS
Bosanac v Commissioner of Taxation
[2022] HCA 34
Date of Hearing: 16 August 2022
Date of Judgment: 12 October 2022P9/2022
ORDER
1. Leave to amend the Notice of Contention refused.
2. Appeal allowed.
3. Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 31 August 2021 and 31 January 2022 and, in their place, order that:
(a) the appeal be dismissed; and
(b)the appellant pay the second respondent's costs.
On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia
Representation
N C Hutley SC with J E Hynes and T L Bagley for the appellant (instructed by Pier Paolo Parisi)
J O Hmelnitsky SC with D P Hume and J S Slack-Smith for the first respondent (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)
R A Blow for the second respondent (instructed by Cove Legal) – submitting appearance
Notice: This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.
KIEFEL CJ AND GLEESON J. This appeal concerns the purchase by Ms Bosanac of a residential property in Perth ("the Dalkeith property") in 2006. She and Mr Bosanac married in 1998. They separated in 2012 or 2013 but continued to reside together at the Dalkeith property until September 2015, when Mr Bosanac moved to a new residential address.
Ms Bosanac appears to have instigated the purchase of the Dalkeith property. In April 2006 she offered to purchase it for $4,500,000 subject to her obtaining approval for a loan of $3,000,000 from a bank. The offer was accepted in May 2006. The contract for sale required Ms Bosanac to pay a deposit of $250,000 within 30 days. The deposit was provided from an existing joint loan account in the names of Ms and Mr Bosanac.
In October 2006, Ms and Mr Bosanac applied for two loans in the sums of $1,000,000 and $3,500,000. The balance of the purchase price was paid from two loan accounts in their joint names, and after settlement the surplus funds in these accounts were paid into the joint loan account from which the deposit had been drawn. The Dalkeith property was registered in Ms Bosanac's name alone. Mr Bosanac has never claimed an interest in the property.
The securities required by the bank for the loans were mortgages over the Dalkeith property and three other properties – units at Mount Street and a property at Hardy Street. The unit at 10/41-43 Mount Street was owned by Mr Bosanac. Ms Bosanac owned the Hardy Street property. The Dalkeith and Hardy Street properties were used as securities again almost a year later when the loans were refinanced.
The primary judge in the Federal Court, McKerracher J, found that during the marriage Ms and Mr Bosanac shared some bank accounts, but had substantial assets which they held in their separate names. Mr Bosanac…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bosanac v Commissioner of Taxation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] HCA 34
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether a presumption of a resulting trust arose in favour of Mr Bosanac regarding a half-share of the Dalkeith property. This required the Court to determine the objective intention of Ms and Mr Bosanac at the time of the property's acquisition, considering their conduct and the surrounding circumstances, and to assess whether the presumption of advancement, which traditionally applies in husband and wife scenarios, remained part of Australian law and if it was displaced by the facts.
The High Court reasoned that the objective facts surrounding the acquisition of the Dalkeith property demonstrated that the parties' intention was inconsistent with the creation of a trust in favour of Mr Bosanac. While joint loans were obtained and the property became their matrimonial home, the Court found that Ms Bosanac contracted for the purchase in her own name, the property was registered in her name, and there was a history of separate asset ownership between the couple. The Court concluded that Mr Bosanac's involvement in the loans was primarily to facilitate Ms Bosanac's acquisition of the property, given the disparity in their financial positions and the need for joint liability to secure the finance. Consequently, the presumption of a resulting trust did not arise, and no equitable interest was created in Mr Bosanac's favour.
The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The Court ordered that the appeal to the Full Court be dismissed and that Ms Bosanac pay the second respondent's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Leave to amend the Notice of Contention refused.
2. Appeal allowed.
3. Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 31 August 2021 and 31 January 2022 and, in their place, order that:
(a) the appeal be dismissed; and
(b) the appellant pay the second respondent's costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: KIEFEL CJ, GLEESON J, GAGELER J, GORDON AND EDELMAN JJ
Finally, and of primary significance, the two cases cited by Professor Scott in support of his second statement quoted in Cummins concerned a statutory discretion under s 17 of the Married Women's Property Act 1882 (45 & 46 Vict c 75), which provided that in any question between husband and wife as to the title or possession of property, the court was to decide the matter as it thought fit[165]. In short, under that Act, "the question of contract, gift, or trust" was put to one side[166]. The second quoted statement from Professor Scott does not concern equity more generally or any equitable presumption. [165]Rimmer v Rimmer [1953] 1 QB 63 at 70-71, 73, 76; Fribance v Fribance [No 2] [1957] 1 WLR 384 at 387; [1957] 1 All ER 357 at 359. See also Cobb v Cobb [1955] 1 WLR 731; [1955] 2 All ER 696; Silver v Silver [1958] 1 WLR 259 at 262-263; [1958] 1 All ER 523 at 525-526.[166]Fribance [1957] 1 WLR 384 at 387; [1957] 1 All ER 357 at 359.Objective intention inconsistent with declaration of trust The objective facts arising from the Commissioner's affidavit evidence – the parties' conduct at the time of the purchase of the Dalkeith property – do not permit an inference consistent with a declaration of trust. To the contrary, the inference to be drawn from the objective facts is that the parties' objective intention was inconsistent with a declaration of trust in favour of Mr Bosanac as to 50 per cent of Ms Bosanac's interest in the Dalkeith property. Accordingly, the presumption of resulting trust does not arise[167]. No equitable interest in favour of Mr Bosanac was created.[167]Pettitt [1970] AC 777 at 815, 823; Calverley (1984) 155 CLR 242 at 267; Muschinski (1985) 160 CLR 583 at 612; Goodman [1986] Fam 106 at 110-111. Ms and Mr Bosanac made the financial arrangements they did for the acquisition of the Dalkeith property recognising, intending and understanding that the Dalkeith property was Ms Bosanac's – not only was it acquired in her name and registered in her name, but it was her property. Recognition, intention and understanding are different words for expressing the inference that is to be drawn from all of the parties' conduct at the time the Dalkeith property was acquired – the objective facts – including the way in which they had arranged their overall financial affairs in the past. In particular, Ms and Mr Bosanac held their substantial assets separately. Ms Bosanac contracted to purchase the Dalkeith property alone and the purchase contract required Ms Bosanac to acquire finance. Although there was no evidence that Westpac required the loans to be put in both names[168], the disparity in wealth and employment makes it unlikely that Ms Bosanac could have obtained or serviced the loans on her own. In that circumstance, and against the history of Ms and Mr Bosanac holding their substantial assets separately, the clear inference is that the parties' objective intention was that Mr Bosanac was doing no more than facilitating Ms Bosanac's acquisition of the Dalkeith property by assisting in paying the deposit and entering into the joint loans for the purpose of funding the purchase. [168]cf Calverley (1984) 155 CLR 242 at 251.