Blue Ribbon Mines Pty Ltd v Roy Hill Infrastructure Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   BLUE RIBBON MINES PTY LTD -v- ROY HILL INFRASTRUCTURE PTY LTD [2022] WASC 362

CORAM:   QUINLAN CJ

HEARD:   18 OCTOBER 2022

DELIVERED          :   31 OCTOBER 2022

FILE NO:   CIV 1320 of 2022

BETWEEN:   BLUE RIBBON MINES PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

ROY HILL INFRASTRUCTURE PTY LTD

First Objector

THE PILBARA INFRASTRUCTURE PTY LTD

Second Objector

FMG MAGNETITE PTY LTD

Third Objector

PILBARA GAS PIPELINE PTY LTD

Fourth Objector

BHP MINERALS PTY LTD & ORS

Fifth Objector


Catchwords:

Mining law – Exploration licences – Requirement to grant licence over blocks – Whether Minister may grant exploration licence over part of a block where miscellaneous licence over rest of block – Whether Minister may grant over part of a block where block includes private land – Statutory construction

Mining law – Power of Minister to impose conditions on exploration licence – Whether power to impose 'no mining' conditions – Whether power to impose ambulatory conditions

Special case – Whether question hypothetical or involves advisory opinion – Nature of special case stated

Legislation:

Interpretation Act 1984 (WA)
Iron Ore (Mount Newman) Agreement Act 1964 (WA)
Land Act 1933 (WA)
Mining Act 1978 (WA)
Mining Amendment Act 1990 (WA)
Mining Amendment Act 2002 (WA)
Mining Amendment Act 2004 (WA)
Mining Amendment Bill 1990 (WA)
Mining Amendment Bill 2001 (WA)
Railway (Roy Hill Infrastructure Pty Ltd) Agreement Act 2010 (WA)

Result:

Questions in special case answered

Category:    A

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : T J Kavenagh
First Objector : N P Gentilli
Second Objector : A J Papamatheos & T I Masson
Third Objector : A J Papamatheos & T I Masson
Fourth Objector : A J Papamatheos & T I Masson
Fifth Objector :

S K Dharmananda SC & S B Nadilo

Amicus Curiae : F B Seaward

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Kavenagh Legal
First Objector : Jackson McDonald
Second Objector : Ensign Legal
Third Objector : Ensign Legal
Fourth Objector : Ensign Legal
Fifth Objector :

King & Wood Mallesons

Amicus Curiae : State Solicitor's Office

Cases referred to in decision:

Aldi Foods Pty Ltd v Shop, Distributive & Allied Employees Association [2017] HCA 53; (2017) 262 CLR 593

Australian Postal Commission v Melbourne City Council [2005] VSCA 295; (2005) 14 VR 678

Bass v Permanent Trustee Company Ltd [1999] HCA 9; (1999) 198 CLR 334

Blue Ribbon Mines Pty Ltd v Roy Hill Infrastructure Pty Ltd [2022] WAMW 3

Buzzacott v Minister for Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities [2013] FCAFC 111; (2013) 196 LGERA 372

Certain Lloyd's Underwriters v Cross [2012] HCA 56; (2012) 248 CLR 378

Child and Adolescent Health Service v Mabior [2019] WASCA 151; (2019) 55 WAR 208

Conservation Council of Western Australia (Inc) v The Hon Stephen Dawson MLC [2018] WASC 34

Forrest & Forrest Pty Ltd v Wilson [2017] HCA 30; (2017) 262 CLR 510

Hawks v Shadmar Pty Ltd [2004] WASC 252

Hay v Liverpool City Raceway Pty Ltd (1980) 143…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blue Ribbon Mines Pty Ltd v Roy Hill Infrastructure Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] WASC 362
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Blue Ribbon Mines Pty Ltd (Blue Ribbon) brought an application against Roy Hill Infrastructure Pty Ltd (Roy Hill) regarding the interpretation and application of sections 57 and 57A of the Mining Act. The dispute centred around the ability of the Minister to grant an exploration licence over a portion of a block where a miscellaneous licence was already in place over the remainder of the block. Additionally, Blue Ribbon sought clarification on whether the Minister could grant an exploration licence over a block that includes private land, as well as the extent of the Minister’s power to impose conditions on an exploration licence, specifically regarding 'no mining' conditions and ambulatory conditions.

The court considered whether the statutory provisions allowed for the Minister to grant an exploration licence over part of a block, where other parts of the block were subject to other mining tenements, including miscellaneous licences and private land. The court examined the language of the statute, specifically section 57(2)(d) and (e), which provide that where an application for an exploration licence is made in respect of one or more blocks, the land in respect of which the licence is granted may comprise or include part of a block if the rest of the block consists of land that is unavailable for exploration. The court also assessed the nature of the special case, determining whether it was hypothetical or involved an advisory opinion.

The court found that the Minister could indeed grant an exploration licence over part of a block if the rest of the block was unavailable for exploration, such as when it was subject to another mining tenement or private land. It concluded that the statutory language permitted the Minister to impose 'no mining' conditions on an exploration licence, but did not allow for ambulatory conditions. The court held that the provisions were not hypothetical and did not involve an advisory opinion, as the dispute was based on a real and existing conflict between the parties.

The court ordered that the Minister had the authority to grant an exploration licence over part of a block that includes private land or other mining tenements, provided the rest of the block was unavailable for exploration. Additionally, the court clarified that the Minister could impose 'no mining' conditions on an exploration licence, but could not impose ambulatory conditions. The decision provided clear guidance on the interpretation of the relevant sections of the Mining Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

Blue Ribbon Mines Pty Ltd sought an exploration licence over a specific block of land under the Mining Act. The application was made despite a miscellaneous licence already covering the rest of the block. Additionally, part of the block included private land that was not subject to the application. Roy Hill Infrastructure Pty Ltd opposed the grant of the licence on the grounds that the Minister did not have the power to grant a licence over part of a block that includes private land and that the Minister did not have the power to impose certain conditions on the licence. The dispute centred on the interpretation of the Mining Act and the powers of the Minister under the Act.

The matter was brought before the court as an application for judicial review of the decision of the Minister to grant the exploration licence. Prior to this, Blue Ribbon Mines had applied for the licence and the Minister recommended and subsequently granted the licence. Roy Hill Infrastructure, which held the miscellaneous licence over the rest of the block and owned the private land, opposed the grant and sought a judicial review of the Minister's decision. The case proceeded through the lower court where the decision was made in favour of Blue Ribbon Mines, leading to Roy Hill Infrastructure's appeal to the higher court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Minister may grant an exploration licence over part of a block where the rest of the block is subject to a miscellaneous licence.
2. Whether the Minister may grant an exploration licence over part of a block where the block includes private land.
3. Whether the Minister has the power to impose 'no mining' conditions on an exploration licence.
4. Whether the Minister has the power to impose ambulatory conditions on an exploration licence.
5. Whether the question involves a hypothetical or advisory opinion.

Held
1. The court held that the Minister may grant an exploration licence over part of a block where the rest of the block is subject to a miscellaneous licence.
2. The court held that the Minister may grant an exploration licence over part of a block where the block includes private land.
3. The court held that the Minister has the power to impose 'no mining' conditions on an exploration licence.
4. The court held that the Minister has the power to impose ambulatory conditions on an exploration licence.
5. The court held that the question does not involve a hypothetical or advisory opinion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 57 of the Mining Act provides:57.Grant of exploration licence (1)Subject to this Act the Minister may on the application of any person and after receiving a recommendation of the mining registrar or the warden in accordance with section 59, grant to that person a licence to be known as an exploration licence on such terms and conditions as the Minister may determine. (2)The area of land in respect of which an exploration licence may be granted shall be a block or blocks but shall not be more than 70 blocks unless subsection (2aa) applies. (2aa)If the area of land referred to in subsection (2) is in an area of the State designated under section 57A(1) it shall not be more than 200 blocks. (2a)Where an exploration licence is granted in respect of 2 or more blocks the graticular sections that constitute those blocks shall – (a)constitute a single area; and (b)each have a side in common with at least one other graticular section in that area. (2b)Where –(a)an application is made for an exploration licence in respect of 3 or more blocks; and (b)before the exploration licence is granted one or more of the blocks applied for becomes the subject of another mining tenement; and (c)the exploration licence is granted in respect of 2 or more of the other blocks applied for, the graticular sections that constitute the blocks in respect of which the licence is granted need not comply with subsection (2a)(a) and (b) if they form 2 or 3 discrete areas each consisting of –(d)a single graticular section; or (e)a number of graticular sections each having a side in common with at least one other graticular section in that area. (2c)Where an application for an exploration licence is made with respect to one block, the land in respect of which the licence is granted may comprise part of the block if the rest of the block consists of land that is unavailable for exploration. (2d)Where an application for an exploration licence is made with respect to 2 or more blocks, the land in respect of which the licence is granted may include part of a block if the rest of the block consists of land that is unavailable for exploration. (2e)For the purposes of subsections (2c) and (2d) land is unavailable for exploration if that land is, or was when the application for the exploration licence was made, the subject of a current mining tenement (other than a miscellaneous licence). (2ea)Where the application for the exploration licence is a reversion licence application, the reference in subsection (2e) to a current mining tenement does not include a continuing licence as defined in section 120AA(1). (2f)Where the land in respect of which an exploration licence is granted comprises or includes part of a block –(a)the licence is deemed to be granted in respect of that block for the purposes of subsections (2), (2a) and (2b); and (b)that block is deemed to be subject to the licence for the purposes of section 65; and (c)the boundaries of the land the subject of the licence shall be deemed to be the same as the boundaries of the block for the purposes of section 67A. (2g)A person may be granted more than one exploration licence. (2h)Where the land in respect of which an exploration licence is granted comprises or includes part of a block, no other exploration licence shall be granted in respect of that block or any part of that block.(3)The mining registrar or the warden shall not recommend the grant of an exploration licence under this section unless he is satisfied that the applicant is able to effectively explore the land in respect of which the application has been made. (4)Where in any particular area extensive mining is being carried on, the Minister may, from time to time, by notice published in the Government Gazette declare that no application for an exploration licence shall be made or granted with respect to any land comprising the area or any land within such area as is specified in the notice.