Bell v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bell v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 1042 

Citation: Bell v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 1042
Appeal from: Christopher Bell v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] AATA 45
Parties: CHRISTOPHER BELL v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
File number: VID 151 of 2012
Judge: GORDON J
Date of judgment: 19 September 2012
Catchwords: INCOME TAX – capital gains tax – small business concessions – maximum net asset value test – meaning of “entity” – meaning of “liabilities of the entity that are related to the assets” – whether question of fact or question of law – Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth), Div 152
Legislation: A New Business Tax System (Capital Gains Tax) Bill 1999 (Cth)
A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (Cth)
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth)
Tax Laws Amendment (Simplified Superannuation) Act 2007 (Cth)
Tax Laws Amendment (2006 Measures No 7) Act 2007 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321
Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424
Bruce v Cole (1998) 45 NSWLR 163
Collector of Customs v Agfa-Gavaert Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 389
Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic Enterprises Pty Ltd (1993) 43 FCR 280
Comcare v Broadhurst (2011) 120 ALD 228
Commissioner of Taxation v Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd (2011) 191 FCR 561
Commissioner of Taxation v Traviati [2012] FCA 546
Condell v Commissioner of Taxation (2007) 66 ATR 100
Coulton v Holcombe (1986) 162 CLR 1
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Trail Brothers Steel & Plastics Pty Ltd (2010) 186 FCR 410
Industry Research and Development Board v Bridgestone Australia Ltd (2001) 109 FCR 564
Kowalski v Repatriation Commission [2011] FCAFC 43
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Application S20/2002 (2003) 198 ALR 59
Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115; 49 ER 282
Secretary, Department of Family & Community Services v Edwards (2000) 105 FCR 220
Travelex Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2010) 241 CLR 510
VWBF v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 154 FCR 302
Waterford v The Commonwealth of Australia (1987) 163 CLR 54
White v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 109
Zizza v Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 41 ATR 96

Heydon JD and Leeming MJ, Jacobs’ Law of Trusts in Australia (7th ed, Butterworths, 2006)

Date of hearing: 12 September 2012
Date of last submissions: 13 September 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 114
Counsel for the Applicant: Dr B Orow
Solicitor for the Applicant: WMB Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Dr P Bender
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Taxation Office, Legal Services Branch

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 1042
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bell v Commissioner of Taxation, the applicant, Bell, challenged the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s (AAT) decision regarding the calculation of the maximum net asset value (MNAV) under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth). The central issue was whether the AAT correctly identified and included certain assets and liabilities in the MNAV calculation. The applicant argued that the AAT erred in excluding certain debts and incorrectly treating separate bank accounts as a single account. Additionally, the applicant contested the AAT’s imposition of an administrative penalty.

The court examined whether the AAT erred in law by not considering certain debts as related to the assets of the small business entities. It also considered whether the AAT’s decision was irrational, manifestly unreasonable, or unsupported by evidence. The court held that the AAT’s findings on the bank accounts and the exclusion of certain debts were consistent with the evidence presented. The court found that the AAT correctly exercised its discretion in determining the MNAV and did not err in imposing an administrative penalty for the applicant's failure to take reasonable care.

The court dismissed Bell’s appeal, confirming the AAT’s findings and the MNAV calculation. The court found that the AAT appropriately applied the relevant statutory provisions and that the applicant's grounds of appeal were either factual disagreements or misconceived legal complaints. Consequently, the AAT’s decision was upheld, and the applicant’s appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties are to bring in orders to give effect to these reasons for decision by 4.00pm on 2 October 2012.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There are a number of answers to that concern. First, there must still be a relationship of a kind which satisfies s 152-20. Second, the steps taken by a trustee of a trust may well be different in nature and legal effect than the steps taken by non-trustee companies and other entities. And third, if there is a concern that the steps taken by a taxpayer are a scheme to “frustrate” the proper operation of the MNAV test, then the appropriate course is to seek to apply Pt IVA of the 1936 Act. There was no suggestion that Pt IVA applied here.(f) Irrational, manifestly unreasonable or no evidence The Applicant submitted that the AAT’s conclusion that there was no relationship between the $2,018,000 debt and the Units was irrational and manifestly unreasonably and/or was unsupported by evidence (Ground 2). Given the view I have formed about Ground 1, it is unnecessary to address Ground 2.(2) The Adelaide Bank accounts (Grounds 5, 6 and 7)(a) Introduction The AAT found that:1.there were two bank accounts in the name of Ms Cotterill, one with a credit balance of $1,252,112 (Offset Account) and one with a debit balance of $1,085,824 (Loan Account), not one bank account with a balance which was $166,288 in credit: AAT Decision at [32];2.the Loan Account reflected borrowings which had been used to purchase a home (owned by the Applicant’s spouse): AAT Decision at [33]; and3.the Offset Account and the Loan Account were linked, by the Bank, to enable interest earned on the Offset Account to be offset against interest owing on the Loan Account: AAT Decision at [32]. Indeed, the Adelaide Bank records disclosed two separate account numbers with two separate account balances – the Offset Account and the Loan Account: AAT Decision at [32]. The records also disclosed transfers between the Loan account and the Offset account and recorded the interest that would have accrued but was saved by reason of the Offset: AAT Decision at [32]. It was common ground that the Applicant did not adduce any evidence before the AAT of the terms and conditions governing the two accounts. After the hearing, the Applicant sought to adduce evidence of the terms governing the Adelaide Bank accounts. The Court has a limited jurisdiction to receive further evidence (s 44(8) of the AAT Act) and to make further findings of fact (s 44(7) of the AAT Act). That jurisdiction ought not to be exercised in the present case. The Applicant is bound by the case he ran below: Coulton v Holcombe (1986) 162 CLR 1 at 7-8. In relation to the Loan Account, the AAT concluded it related to the purchase of a house held by the Applicant’s spouse, that that asset was not included in the MNAV calculation and, accordingly, the balance of the Loan Account was not included in the MNAV calculation: AAT Decision at [33]. In relation to the Offset Account, the AAT concluded the balance of the Offset Account was a cash asset that should be included in the MNAV calculation: AAT Decision at [34]. (b) Appeal grounds

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, the phrase “connected with another entity” was defined extensively in s 152-30. For present purposes, it is sufficient to note that an entity is connected with another entity if there is a relationship of control between the entities or through a third entity: s 152-30 of the 1997 Act. C AAT DECISION At the centre of the AAT Decision was a table entitled “Table of assets and liabilities of the Trust and its connected entities”. The table was set out at [4] of the AAT Decision as follows: The table listed individuals and trusts and, no less importantly, assets and liabilities of those individuals and trusts. What the table did not do was identify how or why the persons and trusts listed in bold were connected with the Trust or the small business affiliates of the Trust. Indeed, it may be the position that the 1300 Phonewords Australia Unit Trust should be listed separately and not simply as an asset of the Trust. That issue does not need to be resolved. The need to understand the basis on which they were listed in the table has been earlier explained: see [16] above. It affects the calculation of the net value of the CGT assets of that person or entity and, in particular, what can and cannot be considered. It will be necessary to return to this issue later in these reasons for judgment. The table also identified five disputed amounts the Applicant contended should have been included in calculating the MNAV:1.a debt of $2,018,000, claimed to be owed by the Trust to the BPHUT;2.a debt of $591,840 claimed to be owed to the BPHUT under a guarantee;3.an amount of $549,000 allegedly owed to the BPHUT by the Trust on account of advances on distributions; 4.part of a Swagman Motor Home hire purchase debt owed by the Trust; and5.the balance in an Adelaide Bank account (or accounts), being an account (or accounts) in the name of Ms Cotterill, the Applicant’s spouse.1.Those amounts are in italics in the table. In calculating the MNAV, the AAT excluded items 1 and 2, included item 3, included an amount of $370,000 in respect of item 4 and included $1,252,112 in respect of item 5. As a result, the AAT’s MNAV calculation was set out at [35] of the AAT Decision as follows: The AAT then set aside the Commissioner’s decision to impose a penalty on the recklessness scale of 50% and imposed a penalty of 25% on the basis that the Applicant failed to take reasonable care. D APPEAL GROUNDS The Applicant complained about the AAT’s treatment of three of the disputed amounts:1.the debt of $2,018,000 claimed to be owed by the Trust to the BPHUT (the $2,018,000 debt);2.a debt of $591,840 claimed to arise from guarantees given by the Trust and the Applicant to the BPHUT (the Guarantees); and3.the balance in an Adelaide Bank account (or accounts), being an account (or accounts) in the name of Ms Cotterill (the Adelaide Bank accounts). When the matter came on for hearing, the Applicant did not pursue his grounds of appeal in relation to the Guarantees. The remaining appeal grounds were as follows:1.$2,018,000 debt:1.1the AAT erred in law by not finding that the debt incurred by the Trust was a liability that related to the Units (Ground 1);1.2further or alternatively, the AAT’s decision was irrational and manifestly unreasonable (Ground 2),2.Adelaide Bank accounts:2.1the AAT erred in law by not finding that the debit balance of $1,085,824 in the Adelaide bank account related to the credit balance of $1,252,112 (Ground 5);2.2the AAT erred in law in not characterising the Adelaide bank account as a single account or as in substance a single account with a credit balance of $166,288 (Ground 6);2.3further or alternatively, the AAT’s decision was irrational and manifestly unreasonable (Ground 7),3.Imposition of administrative penalty (Ground 8):3.1the AAT erred in law by finding that the position taken by the Applicant was not reasonably arguable and that the Applicant was liable to penalty on that basis;3.2further or alternatively, the AAT’s decision was irrational and manifestly unreasonable.E ANALYSIS

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The complaint is dismissed. The findings of fact made, and inferences drawn (if any) by the AAT are not open to challenge on the basis of “no evidence”. (e) Ground 6(b) - relevant and irrelevant considerations The Applicant relies on two “relevant” considerations said to have been ignored by the AAT:1.the Adelaide bank account was a single facility with an overall balance that “nets off the credit and debit balances”; and2.the debit balance of $1,085,825 “related to” the credit balance of $1,252,112.The first has been dealt with. It is contrary to the facts found. It does not arise. The second remains to be addressed. The AAT will only have fallen into error in failing to consider what has been identified as a relevant consideration, if it can be shown that the AAT was bound to consider the consideration and that the consideration was not so insignificant that a failure to consider it could not have materially affected the decision: Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24 at 39- 40. To establish an error of law based on taking into account an irrelevant consideration, the consideration must be one which the decision-maker was prohibited from considering. The considerations to be taken into account, and not to be taken into account, by a decision-maker are determined by reference to any consideration expressly referred to in the statute or, if none are stated, by implication from the subject-matter, scope and purpose of the statute: Peko-Wallsend at 39-42; Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510 at [195] and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323 at [74] The second so-called “relevant” consideration is misconceived. It is not a “consideration”. It is the application of the relevant statutory provisions to findings of fact. Taken at its highest, the Applicant merely seeks to challenge a finding which the Applicant contends that the AAT ought to have made. In that sense, of course, the AAT took it into account. By making findings contrary to the position contended for by the Applicant, the AAT has taken that finding into account. Indeed, the weight to be attached to evidence and whether incorrect conclusions were drawn from the evaluation of evidence are matters of fact, not law. The Applicant’s grounds of appeal are framed in terms of relevant and irrelevant considerations, but the substance of his position amounts to a disagreement with the factual and legal basis of the AAT’s decision: Commissioner of Taxation v Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd (2011) 191 FCR 561 at [42]; Zizza v Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 41 ATR 96 at [51] and [90] and Abebe at [194]-[195]. To the extent that it is a factual disagreement, that is not a matter reviewable by the Court. Simply framing the grounds in terms of relevant and irrelevant considerations cannot transform them into questions of law enlivening the Court’s jurisdiction. The complaint is dismissed. To the extent that it is a legal complaint, that will be addressed at [91]-[100] below.