BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v Pt Bayan Resources Tbk [No 5]

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   BCBC SINGAPORE PTE LTD -v- PT BAYAN RESOURCES TBK [No 5] [2023] WASC 116

CORAM:   ARCHER J

HEARD:   ON THE PAPERS

PUBLISHED           :   12 APRIL 2023

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1562 of 2012

BETWEEN:   BCBC SINGAPORE PTE LTD

Plaintiff

AND

PT BAYAN RESOURCES TBK

First Defendant

KANGAROO RESOURCES LTD

Second Defendant


Catchwords:

Special costs application - Complexity and importance - Turns on its own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Special costs orders made

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : No appearance (on the papers)
First Defendant : No appearance (on the papers)
Second Defendant : No appearance (on the papers)

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Herbert Smith Freehills
First Defendant : Clayton Utz
Second Defendant : Not applicable

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [2012] WASC 170

BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [2023] SGCA(I)

BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [No 3] [2013] WASC 239

BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [No 4] [2018] WASC 338 (S)

BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [No 4] [2018] WASC 338; (2018) 134 ACSR 1

Heartlink Ltd v Jones as Liquidator of HL Diagnostics Pty Ltd (in liq) [2007] WASC 254 (S)

Sino Iron Pty Ltd v Mineralogy Pty Ltd [No 2] [2017] WASCA 76 (S)

ARCHER J:

Introduction

  1. The first defendant (Bayan) seeks special costs orders.  Bayan seeks that its costs be taxed without regard to the limits imposed by the relevant costs determinations and without regard to the hourly rates and daily rates provided for legal representatives. 

  2. The plaintiff (BCBCS) opposes this.

  3. Special costs orders may be made if a court or judicial officer is of the opinion that the amount of costs allowable in respect of a matter under a costs determination is inadequate because of the unusual difficulty, complexity or importance of the matter.

  4. The primary dispute between the parties is whether the proceedings were unusually difficult, complex or important.  In short, BCBCS contends that Bayan is relying on aspects of other proceedings, heard with these proceedings, to justify its claim that the proceedings were unusually difficult, complex or important.  For this reason, it is necessary to detail the content and the history of both proceedings, as well as related proceedings in Singapore.

Relevant background

  1. The history of the various proceedings between the parties are tortuous.[1] 

    [1] The relevant chronology up to March 2022 was helpfully set out in an affidavit filed by Bayan, affirmed by Oliver Kar Heng Khaw on 9 March 2022.  Mr Khaw is the Head of Legal and Senior Foreign Counsel at Bayan.  Further events were set out in an affidavit filed by BCBCS, of Mark Dunlea Smyth affirmed on 27 February 2023.  Mr Smyth is a partner of the law firm acting for BCBCS.  Much of what follows in this section reproduces or draws from those affidavits, and from decisions of Le Miere…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v Pt Bayan Resources Tbk [No 5] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASC 116
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves an appeal by BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd against the costs decision of the Singapore International Commercial Court (SICC) in a complex commercial dispute with PT Bayan Resources Tbk. The dispute centres on the construction of an agreement and the application for special costs by Bayan. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, with Justice Edelman presiding over the proceedings. The primary legal issue was whether the Federal Court should grant special costs to Bayan for the proceedings, considering the complexity and importance of the case, and whether the delay in determining the construction dispute would cause any prejudice to Bayan. Additionally, the court had to consider the impact of the SICC's costs decision on the proceedings.

The court held that the determination of the construction dispute should be postponed until after the SICC delivered its costs decision in the Singapore Proceedings. This decision was made on case management grounds, as a short delay could potentially avoid the need for the construction dispute to be determined, saving costs and resources. The court found that there was no evidence that a delay would cause any prejudice to Bayan. Furthermore, if the estimated delivery of the SICC's Costs Decision proved inaccurate, Bayan could renew its application on an urgent basis. The court made programming orders based on the then unknown date of delivery of the SICC's Costs Decision. The SICC's Costs Decision was eventually delivered, awarding costs in favour of Bayan. BCBCS appealed against the SICC's Costs Decision but accepted that, unless the SICC's Costs Decision was overturned, Bayan was entitled to its costs, and there was no need to determine the construction dispute.

The court concluded that the parties should be allowed to proceed with their agreed course of action, which involved BCBCS paying Bayan's costs of the Freezing Orders Proceedings, subject to the outcome of the Singaporean Court of Appeal's decision. The court also ordered that the matter would be dealt with on the papers, without the need for a hearing. The Singaporean Court of Appeal subsequently dismissed BCBCS' appeal against the SICC's Tranche 3 Judgment, affirming the SICC's decision. The Federal Court of Australia did not make any order or observations in respect of trial costs, as the costs of the trial had already been determined by the SICC.

The final orders of the court were that BCBCS was to pay Bayan's costs of the Freezing Orders Proceedings, subject to the outcome of the Singaporean Court of Appeal's decision, and that the matter would be dealt with on the papers. The court did not make any order or observations in respect of trial costs, as the costs of the trial had already been determined by the SICC.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd (BCBCS) and PT Bayan Resources Tbk (Bayan) regarding a coal supply agreement. The agreement was governed by a Joint Venture Deed, and the dispute centers around alleged breaches of the coal supply obligations by Bayan. BCBCS initiated proceedings in the Singapore International Commercial Court (SICC), where Bayan was eventually awarded costs. BCBCS appealed the SICC's decision on costs to the Singapore Court of Appeal, which dismissed the appeal but awarded BCBCS nominal damages for breaches of the coal supply obligations. Meanwhile, BCBCS also sought an order for special costs from the court in relation to the freezing orders proceedings. The court initially deferred determining the special costs application until after the outcome of the appeal against the SICC's costs decision. The SICC eventually delivered its costs decision in December 2022, awarding costs to Bayan. The appeal against this decision is still pending.

The matter before the court involves a special costs application by BCBCS against Bayan, which was deferred pending the outcome of an appeal against the SICC's costs decision. On 27 May 2022, the court heard further submissions and decided to postpone the determination of the special costs application until after the SICC had delivered its costs decision. The SICC's costs decision was delivered on 19 December 2022, awarding costs to Bayan. BCBCS appealed this decision to the Singapore Court of Appeal, which dismissed the appeal on 10 February 2023. Following the delivery of the SICC's costs decision, the parties conferred on how to progress Bayan's application for special costs. The court made orders by consent on 2 February 2023, programming the filing of submissions and evidence, and reserving the question of whether a hearing would be required. After receiving the parties' submissions, the court was satisfied that a hearing was not necessary.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 27 May 2022, I heard further from the parties. I gave brief extempore reasons explaining why I had decided that the determination of the construction dispute should be postponed until after the SICC had delivered its costs decision in the Singapore Proceedings (SICC's Costs Decision). I explained that I had made this decision purely on case management grounds. I noted that a short delay could mean that there would be no need for the construction dispute to be determined, saving costs to the parties and the resources of the court. I found that there was no evidence that a delay would cause any prejudice to Bayan. I further said that, if the estimated delivery of the SICC's Costs Decision proved inaccurate, Bayan could renew its application on an urgent basis. I made programming orders by reference to the then unknown date of delivery of the SICC's Costs Decision.[16][16] ts 527 ‑ 529. The SICC's Costs Decision took longer than anticipated, and was not delivered until 19December 2022. On that date, the SICC awarded costs in favour of Bayan. BCBCS has appealed against the SICC's Costs Decision. However, it accepts that, unless the SICC's Costs Decision is overturned, Bayan is entitled to its costs, and there is no need to determine the construction dispute. Following the delivery of the SICC's Costs Decision, the parties conferred as to the manner in which Bayan's application for special costs should be progressed. On 2 February 2023, I made orders by consent (February Orders). By order 1 of those orders, BCBCS was to pay Bayan's costs of the Freezing Orders Proceedings. However, by order 2, BCBCS had liberty to apply to reopen that order in light of any orders made by the Singaporean Court of Appeal. Further orders were made programming the filing of submissions and any further evidence in relation to the appropriate measure of costs. Finally, an order was made that the Court would advise the parties as to whether it would deal with the matter on the papers or whether a hearing would be required. Later, after receiving the parties' submissions, I was satisfied that a hearing was not required. On 10 February 2023, the Singaporean Court of Appeal handed down its decision in relation to BCBCS' appeal against the SICC's Tranche 3 Judgment.[17] The Court said:[18]For these reasons, we dismiss the appeal. That said, we recognise that the appellants were successful, in the first and second tranches, in establishing that [Bayan] acted in breach of the coal supply obligations they owed under the [Joint Venture] Deed. Even though they were not able to prove that they suffered substantial damages as a consequence, that does not detract from their success in establishing [Bayan's] liability for breach of contract. We therefore award the appellants S$1,000 in nominal damages. As to the costs of the appeal, unless the parties are able to come to an agreement, we direct them to file written submissions, limited to ten pages each, setting out their positions on the appropriate costs orders we should make together with the supporting grounds. These are to be filed within three weeks of the date of this judgment. We note that the costs of the trial have been determined by the SICC: see BCBCS Singapore Pte Ltd and another v PT Bayan Resources TBK and another [2022] SGHC(I) 17 (the 'Costs Judgment'). As we have affirmed the Judgment, and as there is a pending application before us by which the appellants seek permission to appeal the SICC's Costs Judgment, we expressly make no order or observations in respect of trial costs. The usual consequential orders will apply.[17] BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [2023] SGCA(I) 1.[18] BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [2023] SGCA(I) 1 [66] ‑ [67].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by noting that it had previously decided to postpone the determination of the construction dispute until after the SICC had delivered its costs decision in the Singapore Proceedings (SICC's Costs Decision). This decision was made purely on case management grounds, with the aim of potentially saving costs to the parties and the resources of the court. The court found that there was no evidence that a delay would cause any prejudice to Bayan and that if the estimated delivery of the SICC's Costs Decision proved inaccurate, Bayan could renew its application on an urgent basis.

Upon the delivery of the SICC's Costs Decision, which awarded costs in favour of Bayan, the court proceeded to consider the application for special costs by BCBCS against Bayan. The court made orders by consent (February Orders) which provided that BCBCS would pay Bayan's costs of the Freezing Orders Proceedings, but also gave BCBCS the liberty to apply to reopen that order in light of any orders made by the Singaporean Court of Appeal. The court further programmed the filing of submissions and any further evidence in relation to the appropriate measure of costs and indicated that it would advise the parties as to whether it would deal with the matter on the papers or whether a hearing would be required. After receiving the parties' submissions, the court was satisfied that a hearing was not required.

The court then considered the decision of the Singaporean Court of Appeal in relation to BCBCS' appeal against the SICC's Tranche 3 Judgment. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal but awarded BCBCS S$1,000 in nominal damages for Bayan's breach of contract. The Court of Appeal also directed the parties to file written submissions on the appropriate costs orders for the appeal, limited to ten pages each, and supported by the relevant grounds. The court noted that the costs of the trial had been determined by the SICC and that it would make no order or observations in respect of trial costs, as there was a pending application by BCBCS to appeal the SICC's Costs Judgment.

The court concluded that the appropriate measure of costs to be awarded under the special costs application would be determined in accordance with the orders made by the Singaporean Court of Appeal and any written submissions filed by the parties on the costs of the appeal. This approach ensures that the costs are assessed in light of the latest developments in the case and the parties' submissions on the appropriate costs orders. The court's decision not to grant the application for special costs made by BCBCS against Bayan is based on the finding that Bayan was entitled to its costs awarded by the SICC and that there was no evidence that a delay would cause any prejudice to Bayan. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases where the costs have already been determined by another court, the court should not grant an application for special costs unless there are exceptional circumstances that warrant such an award.