BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   BCBC SINGAPORE PTE LTD -v- PT BAYAN RESOURCES TBK [2012] WASC 170

CORAM:   PRITCHARD J

HEARD:   5 APRIL 2012

DELIVERED          :   5 APRIL 2012

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1562 of 2012

BETWEEN:   BCBC SINGAPORE PTE LTD

Plaintiff

AND

PT BAYAN RESOURCES TBK
First Defendant

KANGAROO RESOURCES LTD
Second Defendant

Catchwords:

Freezing order - Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) O 52A - Principles applicable to granting of freezing order

Freezing order - Relationship between requirement for good arguable case and sufficient prospect that another court will give judgment and that that judgment will be registered or enforced by the Court

Freezing order - Test for danger that prospective judgment will be wholly or partly unsatisfied

Freezing order - Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) O 52A and O 10 r 7 - Whether leave is required to serve outside jurisdiction

Legislation:

Foreign Judgments Act 1991 (Cth)
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Application granted

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Dr A S Bell SC & Mr D Roche

First Defendant             :     No appearance

Second Defendant         :     No appearance

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Freehills

First Defendant             :     No appearance

Second Defendant         :     No appearance

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

ANZ Grindlays Bank PLC v Fattah (1991) 4 WAR 296

BGC Contracting Pty Ltd v WA Construction Hire Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 25

CCC Films (London) Ltd v Impact Quadrant Films Ltd [1985] QB 16

Hadid v Lenfest Communications Inc (1996) 67 FCR 446

McLaughlin v Dungowan Manly Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 89

Perdaman Chemicals & Fertilisers Pty Ltd v The Griffin Coal Mining Company Pty Ltd [2011] WASC 188

PRITCHARD J: 

(This judgment was delivered extemporaneously on 5 April 2012 and has been edited from the transcript.)

  1. BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd (BCBCS), makes an application ex parte for a freezing order and other orders against the PT Bayan Resources TBK (BR), and for a freezing order and other orders against Kangaroo Resources Ltd (KRL).  In these reasons for decision I deal with seven matters:

    (1)the background facts;

    (2)the nature of and foundation for the present application;

    (3)the principles applicable to the grant of the orders sought by BCBCS;

    (4)whether BCBCS has established a good arguable case;

    (5)whether BCBCS has established that there is a danger that a prospective judgment will be wholly or party unsatisfied;

    (6)whether having regard to any other relevant discretionary grounds I am persuaded that the orders sought should be made; and

    (7)whether leave is required to serve the orders on BR, as it is outside the jurisdiction.

    I will deal with the terms of the orders a little later.

  1. The background facts

  1. BCBCS is a company incorporated in Singapore.  It is a wholly‑owned subsidiary of an Australian company, Binderless Coal Briquetting Co Pty Ltd (BCBC), which is in turn a wholly‑owned subsidiary of another Australian company, White Energy Co Ltd (WECL).  Unless otherwise specified, the factual information I refer to in these reasons has been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASC 170
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd (BCBCS) seeking a freezing order against PT Bayan Resources TBK (BR) under the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA). BCBCS, a Singaporean company and a subsidiary of an Australian company, is in dispute with BR, an Indonesian company, over alleged breaches of a joint venture deed. The primary issue revolves around the risk that any judgment obtained by BCBCS in Singapore might be unsatisfied due to BR's assets being located predominantly in Indonesia, where enforcement of foreign judgments is challenging.

The central legal questions addressed by the court pertain to the criteria for granting a freezing order. Specifically, the court had to determine whether BCBCS had demonstrated a sufficient risk that a prospective judgment would be wholly or partially unsatisfied. This involves assessing the likelihood of BR disposing of its assets and whether Indonesian courts would enforce a judgment from a non-Indonesian jurisdiction. Additionally, the court examined whether there was a need for leave to serve documents outside the jurisdiction.

The court found that BCBCS had established the requisite danger that a prospective judgment would be unsatisfied. The evidence indicated that BR's assets were primarily located in Indonesia, and BR had made public statements suggesting difficulties in enforcing foreign judgments against it. The court concluded that there was a real and not fanciful risk that BR could dissipate its assets, rendering any judgment obtained by BCBCS in Singapore ineffective. Consequently, the court granted the freezing order, ensuring that BR's assets were preserved to satisfy any potential judgment in favor of BCBCS.

The court's decision was based on the established risk of asset dissipation and the unlikelihood of enforcing a foreign judgment in Indonesia. The freezing order was deemed necessary to prevent BR from frustrating the potential judgment that BCBCS might obtain in Singapore.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The background facts BCBCS is a company incorporated in Singapore. It is a wholly‑owned subsidiary of an Australian company, Binderless Coal Briquetting Co Pty Ltd (BCBC), which is in turn a wholly‑owned subsidiary of another Australian company, White Energy Co Ltd (WECL). Unless otherwise specified, the factual information I refer to in these reasons has been derived from the affidavit of Mr Ivan Maras, the Chief Financial Officer (the CFO) of WECL, who in that capacity also has responsibility as the CFO of BCBC and BCBCS. BCBCS owns a 51% interest in an Indonesian joint venture company, PT Kaltim Supacoal (KSC). The remaining 49% of the joint venture company is owned by BR. BR is an Indonesian company. BR is a company which sits at the top of the corporate structure of what I will refer to as the Bayan group of companies. The rights and obligations of the shareholders in KSC are governed by a joint venture deed dated 7 June 2006 (the JV Deed). Initially the parties to the JV Deed were Bayan International Pty Ltd (BI) and BCBC. In a deed of novation dated as at 12 February 2009 BR acquired the 49% interest previously held by BI and BCBCS acquired the 51% interest previously held by BCBC. The JV Deed is governed by Singaporean law and the parties submitted to the non‑exclusive jurisdiction of the Singaporean courts. The parties to the JV Deed fell into dispute in November and December 2011. BCBCS alleged that BR breached its obligations under the JV Deed. The primary areas of dispute at that stage, at least from BCBCS's perspective, were that BR had instructed its associated companies to stop supplying coal to KSC and that BR was refusing to provide funding to KSC. Further, on 13 December 2011, BR issued a default notice alleging that BCBCS had breached its obligations under the JV Deed. BCBCS takes issue with that notice. On 27 December 2011, BCBCS commenced proceedings against BR and BI in the High Court of Singapore claiming, amongst other things, damages for BR's breaches of the JV Deed (the Singaporean proceedings). A statement of claim in those proceedings was filed on 31 January 2012 and a defence and counterclaim were filed on 22 February 2012. On 21 February 2012, BR purported to issue a termination notice to BCBCS immediately terminating the JV Deed. BCBCS treated the purported termination as a wrongful repudiation of BR's obligations under the JV Deed, accepted the repudiation, and thus terminated the JV Deed. On 23 March 2012, BCBCS filed an amended statement of claim in the Singaporean proceedings and the relief claimed under that amended statement of claim is damages for breach of contract. The nature of and foundation for the present application BCBCS applies to this Court for a freezing order under O 52A of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) (the Rules). The genesis of BCBCS's claim in this Court is its belief that it will be successful in the Singaporean proceedings but that it will be unable to enforce judgment against BR in Indonesia where the majority of BR's assets are located. Aside from its Indonesian assets, BR has substantial assets in Australia comprising a 57% share in KRL, an Australian coal company, whose principal place of business is in Perth. In real terms, that share holding equates to approximately 1,925,000,000 shares trading at about 13 and a half cents, or $259,875,000 worth of stock.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Whether BCBCS has established that there is a danger that a prospective judgment will be wholly or partly unsatisfied The second element required to establish that a freezing order can be properly granted is the question of whether there is a danger that the prospective judgment will be wholly or party unsatisfied. This danger is at the heart of the jurisdiction to grant a freezing order. I note that it is not necessary for an applicant to show a positive intention on the part of a respondent to frustrate judgment: see, for instance, BGC Contracting Pty Ltd v WA Construction Hire Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 25 [12] ‑ [13] (Le Miere J). Notwithstanding that there is no need to show a positive intention, it remains incumbent upon an applicant to prove that there is a risk that a judgment will be rendered fruitless. There have been a number of judicial statements which try to explain what the extent of the risk is required to be. Justice Le Miere suggested that an applicant must establish that the risk is real and not fanciful: BGC Contracting Pty Ltd [15]. Justice Lehane in the Federal Court, in Hadid v Lenfest Communications Inc (1996) 67 FCR 446, 448 framed it in terms that 'a real risk may be in this context, it is something greater than a risk which is in turn greater merely than de minimis'. I also note the comments of Ward J in McLaughlin v Dungowan Manly Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 89 [106], where her Honour said:In Patterson, Gleeson CJ (at 325) rejected as appropriate tests that sought to impose some form of burden or onus of proof in the nature of 'more than usual likelihood' that assets were to be dissipated. Likewise, Gleeson CJ rejected any test as to whether the likelihood of dissipation of assets had been established 'upon the balance of probabilities', for reasons which are discussed. In Vaughan v Bongiorno [2007] NSWSC 1398, Hamilton J, at [7], has described the degree of proof needed to establish the second requirement for the Mareva injunction as being an 'apprehension of dispersal of assets'. I accept that BCBCS has established that there exists a danger of judgment being unsatisfied, insofar as the meaning of risk is explained in the cases I have just referred to. It is established that there exists a danger that any judgment which BCBCS obtains against BR in the High Court of Singapore will be rendered fruitless because the assets of BR may be disposed of. That danger, in my view, can be discerned from the evidence to the effect that Mr Maras has not been able to obtain information as to any of BR's assets other than those in Indonesia, and in Australia insofar as shares are held in KRL, together with the fact that judgments of a non‑Indonesian court cannot be enforced against BR in Indonesia. As to this, I rely on the affidavit of Mr Assgaf which was tendered in these proceedings and statements by BR in its prospectus in 2008 to the following effect:We are an Indonesian company and all of our commissioners, directors and executive officers and certain of the experts named in this offering memorandum, are residents of Indonesia. As a result, you should note that it may be difficult or impossible to serve legal process on us, our management or experts, and to force us to appear in a non‑Indonesian court. It may be also be difficult or impossible to enforce a judgment of a non Indonesian court against any of these parties. Finally, an Indonesian court may refuse to hear an original action based on securities laws of other countries.Our Indonesian legal advisers have advised us that judgments obtained in non-Indonesian courts based upon the civil liability provisions of the securities laws of other countries are not enforceable in Indonesian courts. Our Indonesian legal advisers have also advised us that there is doubt as to whether Indonesian courts will enter judgments in original actions brought in Indonesian courts based only upon the civil liability provisions of the securities laws of other countries.The claims and remedies available under Indonesian law may not be as extensive as those available in other jurisdictions. No assurance can be given that the Indonesian courts will protect the interests of shareholders in the same manner or to the same extents as would courts in more developed countries outside of Indonesia.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.