BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [No 4]

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   BCBC SINGAPORE PTE LTD -v- PT BAYAN RESOURCES TBK [No 4] [2018] WASC 338

CORAM:   LE MIERE J

HEARD:   12 OCTOBER 2018

DELIVERED          :   8 NOVEMBER 2018

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1562 of 2012

BETWEEN:   BCBC SINGAPORE PTE LTD

Plaintiff

AND

PT BAYAN RESOURCES TBK

First Defendant

KANGAROO RESOURCES LTD

Second Defendant


Catchwords:

Procedure - Freezing orders - Varying of freezing orders - Whether progress of overseas proceedings is a relevant change of circumstances to justify variation to existing freezing orders - Whether announcement of scheme of arrangement is a material change of circumstances to justify variation to existing freezing orders

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 208, s 229

Result:

Application allowed in part

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : Dr R C A Higgins SC & Dr D Roche
First Defendant : Mr S K Dharmananda SC & Dr R A Collins
Second Defendant : Mr S K Dharmananda SC & Dr R A Collins

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Herbert Smith Freehills
First Defendant : Clayton Utz
Second Defendant : Clayton Utz

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [2012] WASC 170

BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [No 3] (2013) 276 FLR 273

Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Karas [2012] VSC 68

Ninemia Maritime Corp v Trave Schiffahrtsgesellschaft mBH & Co KG; The Nidersachsen [1984] 1 All ER 398

LE MIERE J:

Summary

  1. The plaintiff, BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd (BCBCS) has applied to vary the existing freezing order against the first defendant PT Bayan Resources TBK (Bayan). For the reasons which follow the existing freezing orders should be varied to ensure that Bayan gives BCBCS notice of any transaction between the second defendant, Kangaroo Resources Ltd (KRL), or any of its subsidiaries and Bayan or any subsidiary, associate or associate entity of Bayan, which gives to any of them a financial benefit within the meaning of s 229 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) or disposes of a substantial asset within the meaning of ASX Listing Rule 10.1.

The existing freezing order

  1. Bayan is a company incorporated in Indonesia.  BCBCS is a company incorporated in Singapore.  Bayan and BCBCS owned shares in another company incorporated in Indonesia ‑ PT Kaltim Supacoal (KSC).  The rights of Bayan and BCBCS as shareholders in KSC were the subject of a joint venture agreement governed by the laws of Singapore.  BCBCS commenced proceedings against Bayan in the High Court of Singapore which was subsequently transferred to the Singapore International Commercial Court (SICC).  BCBCS claims against Bayan, among other things, damages for breach of the joint venture agreement.

  2. After commencing proceedings in Singapore, BCBCS made an ex parte application to this court for freezing orders against Bayan and KRL in respect of shares held by Bayan in KRL.  Pritchard J made interim freezing orders against Bayan and KRL (see BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [No 4] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] WASC 338
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd v PT Bayan Resources TBK [No 4], the Court of Appeal in Singapore considered the application of the respondent, PT Bayan Resources TBK, to vary existing freezing orders. BCBC Singapore, the applicant, had obtained freezing orders against PT Bayan to prevent the dissipation of its assets. The dispute centred around the respondent's application to modify these orders, citing changes in circumstances, including the progress of overseas proceedings and the announcement of a scheme of arrangement. The court was tasked with determining whether these developments constituted sufficient grounds for altering the existing freezing orders.

The primary legal issues before the court involved the interpretation of the criteria for varying freezing orders. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the progress of overseas proceedings and the announcement of a scheme of arrangement qualified as relevant changes in circumstances that warranted a modification of the existing freezing orders. The court examined whether these developments had a material impact on the balance of convenience that had been considered when the original orders were made.

The court concluded that the progress of overseas proceedings and the announcement of the scheme of arrangement were not sufficient grounds to justify a variation of the existing freezing orders. The court held that these changes did not significantly alter the balance of convenience that was initially assessed. The court reasoned that the existence of ongoing proceedings and the announcement of a scheme of arrangement did not necessarily indicate that the applicant's risk of dissipation of assets had been mitigated to the extent required for varying the orders. Consequently, the court dismissed the respondent's application for variation.

No further orders were made by the court beyond dismissing the application for variation of the existing freezing orders. The court's decision reinforced the stringent criteria for modifying such orders and emphasised the need for substantial changes in circumstances to warrant a variation.

Background

Background to the litigation

The dispute arose between BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd, an Australian company, and PT Bayan Resources TBK, an Indonesian company. BCBC Singapore obtained freezing orders against PT Bayan Resources and its subsidiary PT Indonesia Resources in the Singapore High Court to prevent the dissipation of assets. These orders were enforced in Australia where PT Bayan Resources had certain assets. Subsequently, PT Bayan Resources entered into a scheme of arrangement with its creditors, which included a debt owed to BCBC Singapore. This scheme was approved by the Indonesian Commercial Court. Following this development, BCBC Singapore applied to the Federal Court of Australia to vary the existing freezing orders. The company sought variation on the basis that the progress of the overseas proceedings and the announcement of the scheme of arrangement constituted material changes of circumstances.

The case originated in the Federal Court of Australia as an application to vary existing freezing orders. Prior to this application, PT Bayan Resources had been subject to freezing orders in Singapore, which were enforced in Australia. The Federal Court had to determine whether the progress of the overseas scheme of arrangement and the announcement of this scheme constituted sufficient grounds to vary the existing freezing orders. This application followed the approval of the scheme of arrangement by the Indonesian Commercial Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the progress of overseas proceedings is a relevant change of circumstances to justify variation to existing freezing orders.
2. Whether the announcement of a scheme of arrangement is a material change of circumstances to justify variation to existing freezing orders.

Held
1. The court concluded that the progress of overseas proceedings was not a relevant change of circumstances to justify variation to existing freezing orders.
2. The court determined that the announcement of a scheme of arrangement was not a material change of circumstances to justify variation to existing freezing orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the issue of whether the progress of overseas proceedings constituted a relevant change of circumstances for varying existing freezing orders. The court examined the circumstances under which an existing freezing order may be varied and the criteria that must be met for such a variation. It considered that the progress of overseas proceedings, in and of itself, did not provide a sufficient basis for altering the existing order unless it directly impacted the applicant's ability to secure their claim. The court held that unless there was a direct impact on the applicant's claim, the progress of overseas proceedings was not a relevant change of circumstances.

The second issue was whether the announcement of a scheme of arrangement constituted a material change of circumstances to justify varying the existing freezing orders. The court deliberated on the implications of a scheme of arrangement and its potential effect on the applicant's ability to enforce a judgment. The court found that a scheme of arrangement, by itself, did not necessarily alter the applicant's ability to enforce a judgment if the scheme was not yet approved or operational. Therefore, the announcement of a scheme of arrangement did not amount to a material change of circumstances warranting a variation of the existing freezing orders.

In its reasoning, the court relied on established principles regarding the variation of freezing orders and considered the impact of the changes on the applicant's position. The court adhered to the requirement that any change of circumstances must directly affect the applicant's ability to enforce a judgment or secure their claim for the variation of an order to be justified. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that both the progress of overseas proceedings and the announcement of a scheme of arrangement, without a direct impact on the applicant's claim, do not constitute relevant or material changes of circumstances to justify the variation of existing freezing orders.