Bazzo and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

Bazzo and Commissioner of Taxation [2017] AATA 1592 (29 September 2017)

Division:TAXATION & COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/2809 – 11

Re:Tina Bazzo

APPLICANT

AndCommissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President S Boyle

Date:29 September 2017

Place:Perth

The hearing of the substantive application be adjourned and the dates listed for hearing, 9 and 10 October 2017, be vacated.

...........[sgd]........................................................

Deputy President S Boyle

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for adjournment of substantive application hearing – application granted

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – ss 2A, 37(1), 39(1), 40(1)

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) – ss 14ZZK, 284-75

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) – ss 166, 167

CASES

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175

Cement Australia Pty Ltd and Others v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2010] FCAFC 101

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Dalco (1990) 168 CLR 614

Fiorentino v Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board [2014] FCA 641

Gashi v FCT (2013) 209 FCA 3011

GH1 Pty Ltd, in Liquidation and Commissioner of Taxation [2017] AATA 1063

Graham Docker & Associates Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2005] ATC 2404

Haset Sali v SPC Ltd [1993] HCA 47;(1993) 116 ALR;(1993) ALJR 841

Holloway v McFeeters (1956) 94 CLR 470

Ma v Commissioner of Taxation (1992) 37 FCR 225

McCormack v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1979) 143 CLR 284

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li & Anor (2013) 249 CLR 332

Re Kalafatis and Commissioner of Taxation [2012] AATA 150

Rigoli v FCT [2014] FCAFC 29

SBLF v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 1219

Sullivan v Department of Transport (1978) 20 ALR 323

Trautwein v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1936) 56 CLR 63

Vadesz v Commissioner of Taxation [2006] AATA 683

Vu v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2006] FCA 889

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Tax Laws Amendment (2010 Measures No. 1) Act 2010

General Practice Direction, Direction given under section 18B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S Boyle

29 September 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application by the applicant for the adjournment of the hearing of the substantive application listed for hearing on 9 and 10 October 2017. The application for the adjournment is made pursuant to s 40(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act1975 (Cth) (AAT Act).

    BACKGROUND

  2. The substantive application by which this matter was commenced was lodged on 27 May 2016 (T1). It is an application for review of a decision (the decision) of the respondent to disallow an objection lodged by the applicant against Income Tax Assessments and Penalty Assessments issued by the respondent (T1). The decision was issued on 4 April 2016 (received by the applicant on 7 April 2016) (T2).

  3. The objections made by the applicant which were the subject of the decision related to the respondent’s amended assessments of the applicant’s taxable income and liability for payment of income tax for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bazzo and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1592
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for an adjournment of a substantive hearing before Deputy President Boyle of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The applicant, Ms Bazzo, sought to adjourn the hearing of her review of the Commissioner of Taxation's decision to disallow parts of her objection against income tax and penalty assessments for the financial years 2009, 2010, and 2011. The substantive application had been lodged in May 2016, and a considerable amount of procedural history and directions had occurred since then, including multiple extensions for filing evidence and submissions.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant the applicant's request for an adjournment of the hearing, which was scheduled for October 2017. This required the Tribunal to consider the principles governing the exercise of discretion to grant adjournments, particularly in light of the extensive history of the proceedings and the applicant's conduct. The Tribunal was also required to balance the applicant's right to present her case with the need for efficient case management and the proper use of public resources.

In determining the application, Deputy President Boyle considered the principles derived from High Court decisions such as *Haset Sali v SPC Ltd*. The Deputy President noted that while adjournments are generally granted in extraordinary circumstances, the specific facts of each case are paramount. The Tribunal identified several factors weighing against granting the adjournment, including the applicant's unsatisfactory explanation for the belated realisation of evidentiary needs, the respondent's consistent advice regarding the applicant's burden of proof over nearly three years, the applicant's representation by a firm with purported tax expertise, her own extensive involvement in tax matters and other proceedings, the fact that the jurisdiction is a no-cost jurisdiction, and the public interest in efficient case management.

The Deputy President ultimately granted the application for an adjournment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The substantive application by which this matter was commenced was lodged on 27 May 2016 (T1). It is an application for review of a decision (the decision) of the respondent to disallow an objection lodged by the applicant against Income Tax Assessments and Penalty Assessments issued by the respondent (T1). The decision was issued on 4 April 2016 (received by the applicant on 7 April 2016) (T2). The objections made by the applicant which were the subject of the decision related to the respondent’s amended assessments of the applicant’s taxable income and liability for payment of income tax for the financial years ending June 2009, 2010 and 2011 following an audit of the applicant’s income tax returns for the relevant years (T45). Penalties pursuant to s 284-75(1)[1] of the Taxation Administration Act1953 (Cth) (TAA) were also imposed by the respondent as were interest charges on the assessed tax shortfalls. [1] This section was repealed by Tax Laws Amendment (2010 Measures No. 1) Act 2010. The decision allowed some of the objections that had been raised by the applicant and disallowed others. The end result of the decision was: The decision also reduced penalties and interest payable in respect of the tax shortfalls that had been imposed by the respondent commensurately with the reductions in the assessed taxable incomes. The relevant history of the matter after the lodgement of the application in the Tribunal on 27 May 2016 is:(a)14 June 2016, directions made by Senior Member Walsh that on or before 26 August 2016 the applicant file and serve her statement of issues, facts and contentions and any evidence on which she intends to rely on at the hearing of the matter and that the respondent do likewise by 7 October 2016;(b)14 June 2016, Senior Member Walsh, on the application of the respondent, orders that the time for filing of the documents required by s 37(1) of the AAT Act be extended to 15 July 2016;(c)18 July 2016, by consent, it is ordered that the time for lodgement of the documents required by s 37(1) of the AAT Act be extended to 12 August 2016, the time for the applicant to file her Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and any evidence upon which she seeks to rely at the hearing be extended to 23 September 2016 and the time for the respondent to file his Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and any evidence be extended to 4 November 2016;(d)16 August 2016, Senior Member Walsh, on the application of the respondent, orders that the time for filing the documents required by s 37(1) of the AAT Act be extended to 26 August 2016;(e)16 August 2016, Senior Member Walsh directs that the time for the applicant to file her Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and any evidence she intends to rely on at the hearing be extended to 7 October 2016 and that the time for the respondent to file his Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and any evidence be extended to 18 November 2016;(f)26 August 2016, the respondent files the documents required by s 37(1) of the AAT Act;(g)10 October 2016, Senior Member Walsh directs that the directions made on 16 August 2016 be revoked and that the applicant file her Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and any evidence by 21 October 2016 and that the respondent file his Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and any evidence by 2 December 2016;(h)21 October 2016, the applicant files her Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions;(i)24 October 2016, Senior Member Walsh directs that the directions made on 10 October 2016 be revoked and that the applicant file her Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions on or before 21 October 2016 and any evidence upon which she will seek to rely at the hearing on or before 4 November 2016 and that the respondent file his Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and any evidence by 16 December 2016;(j)11 November 2016, the applicant files witness statement of Tina Michelle Bazzo signed 11 November 2016;(k)16 December 2016, the respondent files his Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions;(l)16 February 2017, Conference Registrar Hodgson directs that on or before 28 April 2016 the applicant file and serve all evidence upon which the applicant intends to rely at the hearing including further witness statements and any amended Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and that by 8 May 2017 the parties file and exchange hearing certificates addressing any unsuitable dates for a hearing in August, September and October 2017 and that by 23 June 2017 the respondent file any amended Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and any evidence upon which he will seek to rely at the hearing;(m)17 February 2017, the applicant through her solicitors Zafra Legal, applies for the issue of a summons to produce documents addressed to National Australia Bank. Covering letter to the Tribunal states that the documents sought in the summons go “to proof of the matters contained at [39]-[41] of the Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions”;(n)17 March 2017, documents the subject of the summons are produced to the Tribunal and orders are made on that date by Deputy President Dr Kendal that the applicant inspect the documents produced beginning 17 March 2017 and the respondent inspect the documents produced commencing 24 March 2017;(o)3 May 2017, the applicant files witness statement of Tina Michelle Bazzo signed 2 May 2017;(p)8 May 2017, the respondent files hearing certificate advising unavailable dates for the hearing and advising no witnesses to be called;(q)11 May 2017, the applicant files hearing certificate advising of unavailable dates for the hearing and advising of one witness to be called, namely the applicant;(r)11 May 2017, the Tribunal advises the parties of the listing of the matter for hearing on 9 and 10 October 2017;(s)22 August 2017, the applicant through her lawyers Zafra Legal, makes application by letter to the Tribunal for an adjournment of the hearing of the matter. Witness statement of Daniel Steven Romano signed 22 August 2017 filed in support of the application for adjournment;(t)19 September 2017, Deputy President Boyle directs respondent to file and serve submissions and any evidence in support of the application for adjournment by 1:00 PM 21 September 2017 and for the respondent to file and serve submissions and any evidence by 4:00 PM on 22 September 2017;(u)21 September 2017, the applicant files outline of submissions in support of application for adjournment of the hearing and witness statement of Daniel Steven Romano signed 21 September 2017;(v)22 September 2017, the respondent files submissions in opposition to application for adjournment and affidavit of Cong Thanh Nguyen sworn 22 September 2017;(w)26 September 2017, the applicant files witness statement of Daniel Steven Romano signed 26 September 2017; and(x)26 September 2017, the application for adjournment of hearing heard by Deputy President Boyle.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Deputy President goes on to note at paragraphs [44]-[46] in relation to the High Court’s decision in Haset Sali v SPC Ltd [1993] HCA 47;(1993) 116 ALR;(1993) ALJR 841 that:44.It is clear from the following passage from the judgment of the majority that the particular circumstances of the case, rather than case management principles and the system of case management used in the court, were the determining factors:“19. Having regard to the findings of the Full Court, the appellant suffered no injustice when the Court refused to adjourn the hearing for two weeks. It is true that it is only in extraordinary circumstances that the interests of justice will be served by a refusal of an adjournment in a case such as the present where the practical effect of the refusal is to terminate the proceedings. The members of the Full Court were, however, conscious of that fact. Thus, Tadgell J commented that it was, in his experience, ‘unique’ that the Full Court had had to refuse ‘an application for an adjournment of this kind’. Clearly, their Honours considered that the circumstances before them were both extraordinary and extreme. On the findings which they made, they were fully entitled to be of that view. On those findings, the appellant was the author of his own misfortune.”45.The principle that underlies both Haset Sali and Aon is that issues relating to case management are not deciding factors in any particular case. They are, instead, relevant factors and the weight they are accorded can only be determined when regard is had to all of the factors that are relevant. Those objectives are not to be attained at the expense of giving the parties the proper opportunity to present their case but what amounts to a proper opportunity is determined by reference to, among other relevant matters, the speedy and efficient disposition of the matter.46.The principle that, consistently with Eshetu, underlies both Haset Sali and Aon is that objectives of the sort set out in s 2A of the AAT Act, and that are applicable in a case management system, must be understood and applied in a particular case in light of the particular circumstances of that case and in light of the Tribunal’s functions and its duties i.e. its duties to act with procedural fairness and to reach the correct or preferable decision.CONSIDERATION In the present case there are significant factors that would work against the Tribunal exercising the discretion to allow an adjournment of the hearing. They include:·the unsatisfactory explanation of the reason for the belated realisation of the inadequacy of the state of the applicant’s evidence;·the fact that the respondent has repeatedly over a period approaching three years (at least) set out in detail the requirements of the legislation, in particular that the applicant has the burden of proof and what the applicant must establish;·the fact that the applicant has throughout her dealings with the Commissioner and in these proceedings been represented by a firm that purports to have expertise in taxation law;·the fact that the applicant is not an unsophisticated individual and has extensive other involvement in matters of tax including multiple other proceedings in this Tribunal;·that the respondent cannot be compensated for costs thrown away by an adjournment because this is a no-cost jurisdiction;·the terms of General Practice Direction 4.38 – 4.43;·the need for this Tribunal’s time to be used efficiently;·the applicant may have grounds for recourse against those who have been advising her in the substantive application; and·the public interest in case management and the efficient utilisation of public resources and money.