Trautwein v FCT

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read
56 CLR 63

taxing master's authority to disallow any costs which he may think H. C. OF unnecessary.

The appeal will be dismissed with costs.

McTIERNAN J. I agree.

Appeal dismissed with costs. Solicitors for the appellant, Bergin Papi &Finn. Solicitors for the respondent, C. R. Ellison &Co. falco v FCT

OF AUSTRALIA.] TRAUTWEIN

THE FEDERAL COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION RESPONDENT.

THE FEDERAL COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

Ex PARTE TRAUTWEIN. Income Tax (Cth.)-Assessment-Amended assessment-Alterations or additions-

<< Imposing any fresh liability, or increasing any existing liability"-Right of taxpayer to object-Un maccounted-for accretion of assets over period of years-Alloca- tion by commissioner-Equal proportion to each year within that period-Validity -Burden of proof-Objections by taxpayer-Duty of commissioner-Income May 13, 14, Tax Assessment Act 1922-1934 (No. 37 of 1922-No. 18 of 1934), secs. 36, 37, 39, 50, 51A.

A taxpayer, who had not kept proper records or books of account, objected to assessments for Federal income tax made in respect of his income during each of seven consecutive years. His liability to tax was reviewed by the and

56 CLR 64

commissioner in the light of a report by the taxpayer's accountants, which showed that as between the beginning and the end of the seven years period there had been a large unaccounted-for accretion of assets, which the commis- sioner regarded as of an income and not of a capital nature. The commis- sioner added a seventh part of the amount of this accretion to the assessable income of each of the seven years. The assessments were then amended. In six of the assessments the amount of assessable income was increased, and in one reduced. Three days later the commissioner notified the taxpayer that his objections to the previous assessments had been allowed to the extent shown in the amended assessments, and his attention was directed to his right of appeal. The taxpayer did not request that his objections be treated as appeals, but lodged objections against the amended assessments. Upon the disallowance of these objections he requested that they be treated as appeals. The taxpayer was unable to prove during what year or years the accretion was earned, or the precise amount of assessable income in each year, but it could not have been the case that in fact the annual increment in his wealth was throughout the seven years always equal in amount.

(1) The addition, in equal proportions, to the assessable income of each year within a period of years of income derived during that period but which could not be accurately apportioned did not render the assessments invalid.

(2) The burden was upon the taxpayer of establishing that the amount or some other particulars of each separate assessment were incorrect and that that incoreretness operated to his prejudice.

(3) A re-arrangement of an assessment as a whole upon an entirely new basis constitutes an alteration in or addition to the assessment as a whole, imposing a new or fresh liability within the meaning of the proviso to sec. 37 (1) of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trautwein v FCT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1936] HCA 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Trautwein v Federal Commissioner of Taxation* concerned appeals by Theodore Charles Trautwein against Federal income tax assessments for several years. The dispute arose because the Commissioner of Taxation, after discovering a significant unaccounted-for accretion of assets over a seven-year period, allocated one-seventh of this accretion to each year and amended the assessments accordingly. Trautwein, who had not maintained adequate records, objected to these amended assessments. The matter was brought before the High Court of Australia, which was asked to determine several questions regarding the validity of the assessments and the scope of Trautwein's right to appeal.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Commissioner's method of allocating an unexplained accretion of assets equally across several years rendered the assessments invalid, and what the extent of the taxpayer's right of appeal was in relation to amended assessments. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the appeal was limited to the increase in taxable income from a previous assessment or extended to the entire amount of the amended assessment. Furthermore, the court was required to determine if the taxpayer had a right of appeal for a particular year where the amended assessment had resulted in a reduced taxable income.

The court reasoned that the Commissioner's method of allocating the unaccounted-for accretion of assets equally across the seven years, despite it not being earned equally in each year, did not invalidate the assessments. It was held that the burden of proof lay with the taxpayer to demonstrate that the assessments were incorrect and prejudicial to him, and Trautwein had failed to prove the precise amount of income earned in each specific year. The court also determined that a re-arrangement of an assessment as a whole, constituting a new liability, allowed for an appeal against the entire amended assessment, not just the increase from a prior assessment. The court found that the taxpayer did have a right to appeal in respect of the year where the amended assessment resulted in a reduced taxable income, as the objection was still lodged against an assessment.

The appeals were dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.