Barling and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

Barling and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 4358 (24 November 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/6948

Re:Gary Barling

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member I Thompson

Date:24 November 2021

Place:Adelaide

The reviewable decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency on 30 October 2020 is varied as follows:

(i)Mr Barling is to receive funding to purchase a new Volkswagen Caravelle.

(ii)Mr Barling is to receive funding for the modification of the Volkswagen Caravelle for front passenger conversion for wheelchair accessibility.

..............................[Sgnd]..........................................

Member I Thompson

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – review of statement of participant supports – reasonable and necessary supports – applicant sought review of statement of participant supports to allow for funding for a vehicle and modifications – decision under review varied 

Legislation

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Cases

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) ALD 634.

National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79.

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 309.

Masson v Parsons (2019) CLR 554, 572.

Ewin and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 4303.

McPherson and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 4303.

Certain Lloyd’s Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00AAQS v Cross [2012] 248 CLR 378, 390.

McKenzie v National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 3275.

Gelzinnis v National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 3970.

Secondary Materials

National Disability Insurance Scheme Operational Guideline, “Including Specific Types of Supports in Plans Operational Guideline – Vehicle modifications

Planning Operational Guideline, Appendix 1-Table of guidance on whether a support is most appropriately funded by the NDIS

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member I Thompson

24 November 2021

  1. The Applicant, Gary Barling, became a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) in 2016.  He is 48 years old and has Friedreich ataxia, a neurological degenerative condition, together with other complications. Mr Barling resides alone in a rental property in regional Victoria. In his words: “Independence through living by myself is the most important thing in my life.”[1]

    [1] Exhibit 7, para 3.

  2. In his application to the Tribunal, Mr Barling sought funding in his NDIS plan for the provision of a vehicle together with a front row passenger wheelchair conversion. In that way, he would have adequate transport to enable him to access health care, family and the community.

  3. The Respondent, the National Disability Insurance Agency, (the Agency) contends that the legislation does not permit the funding of the purchase of a vehicle as a reasonable and necessary support. Mr Barling submits that the Agency does have this statutory power. The Agency accepts that it has the authority under legislation to fund modifications to a private vehicle and, if Mr Barling had his own vehicle, it would fund such modifications.

  4. Mr Barling uses a wheelchair for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barling and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 4358
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Gary Barling against a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse funding for a modified vehicle. Mr Barling’s NDIS plan included goals related to community access and increased independence. The NDIA had previously refused funding for a vehicle with modifications, citing rules that generally preclude funding for motor vehicles as they are considered day-to-day living costs not directly attributable to a participant's disability support needs.

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine whether the provision of a vehicle and its modifications constituted a reasonable and necessary support under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether such a support would assist Mr Barling to pursue his stated goals and aspirations, and whether it would facilitate his social and economic participation.

The Tribunal considered evidence detailing Mr Barling's significant physical and communication impairments, his profound social isolation, and the stress and exhaustion associated with current transport methods. It noted that an occupational therapist's report indicated that a modified vehicle would empower Mr Barling, enabling him to attend appointments with certainty and providing immeasurable psychosocial benefits by breaking his isolation. The Tribunal was satisfied that the provision of a vehicle and its modifications would directly assist Mr Barling in achieving his goals of community access and participation, and would significantly improve his mental and physical well-being by alleviating isolation.

Consequently, the Tribunal varied the NDIA's decision, ordering that Mr Barling be provided with funding to purchase a new Volkswagen Caravelle and to fund the necessary modifications for wheelchair accessibility.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Barling’s NDIS plan includes funding for supports which include assistance with self-care and transport, allied health therapies, support coordination and assistive technology. The plan does not provide for a vehicle which is modified.BACKGROUND Mr Barling’s current NDIS plan was approved on 30 October 2020 with a review date due on 30 October 2021. Mr Barling’s NDIS plan specifies two short term goals as follows:“To have a vehicle to have the ability to access the community where possible and to be able to go for a drive”“To have sufficient supports for waking hours during the week (an additional 2 hours) and weekends (an additional 4 hours) and for more frequent sleepovers when needed.”[3] [3] Exhibit 56, T18, p 136. Mr Barling’s NDIS plan also includes medium and long term goals, to have safe, unassisted access to his back and front yards, to have access to regular therapy for pain relief and improved mobility, and to continue to receive support for continence supplies.[4] By consent of the parties, the plan review date was varied from 30 October 2021 to 30 December 2021.[5][4] Ibid, T18, pp 136 – 137.[5] Noted 3 November 2021 in accordance with s 26(1)(b) Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). The issue in this review arises out of the first short-term goal, to have a vehicle to enable Mr Barling to access the community. Both the short-term goals and medium-term goals in the current plan are identical to those in a preceding plan which commenced on 23 April 2020.[6] Mr Barling requested an un-scheduled review of that plan under section 48 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (the NDIS Act) and a plan was approved with a commencement date on 15 September 2020 and a review date on 15 September 2021. Mr Barling requested an internal review of that plan under section 100 of the NDIS Act on 17 September 2020.[7] The internal review was concerned with additional funding for assistance with self-care activities together with funding for a vehicle with modifications. Mr Barling’s request for funding for assistance with self-care activities was granted. However his request for funding for a vehicle with modifications was not granted. [6] Ibid, T17, p 119.[7] Ibid, T8, p 73. A delegate of the Agency’s Chief Executive Officer wrote to Mr Barling on 30 October 2020 with an explanation of the result of the internal review. In relation to the request for funding for a vehicle with modifications, the delegate explained that the support could not be provided because rule 5.1 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (the Support Rules) prevents the funding of such a support. The delegate referred to the National Disability Insurance Scheme Operational Guidelines (the Guidelines) which state that funding for the purchase of a motor vehicle is generally not provided by the NDIA.[8] The letter added: “In your review you requested funding for a motor vehicle and modifications to allow you to access the community with greater independence and freedom, and increase your participation in daily living tasks such as shopping. While it is acknowledged that access to a vehicle with modifications may be beneficial for the previously stated reasons, as outlined in the Operational Guidelines of the National Disability Insurance Agency funding for the purchase of a motor vehicle is generally not provided by the NDIA. This is because funding for the purchase of a motor vehicle relates to day-to-day living costs that are not attributable to a participant’s disability support needs under Part 5.1 (d) of the Supports for Participants Rules. Many individuals choose to purchase a motor vehicle for convenience of transport and these costs are the responsibility of each individual. As the cost of a motor vehicle is not an additional living cost incurred solely and directly as a result of your disability support needs, not an ancillary cost to another support, this support does not meet Part 5.2 of the Supports for Participants Rules and cannot be funded by the NDIS.As the request for costs associated with the purchase of a motor vehicle cannot be funded in your NDIS plan, the NDIA will not fund modifications until a suitable vehicle which can be modified has been identified.… You have the choice to use your flexible core funding in your NDIS plan to fund provider costs associated with transporting you to and from NDIS funded community-based activities of your choosing.”[9][8] Ibid, T1A, pp 7-13.[9] Ibid, T2, p 53.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Consideration of these issues involves an analysis of the evidence and the applicable provisions of the legislation.EVIDENCEGary Barling Mr Barling gave evidence by video link. He also provided a detailed affidavit which was admitted into evidence. His evidence is not contested. He has high levels of support throughout the day and evening for practically every activity of living. He has numerous appointments which he needs to keep to maintain his health. His enjoyment of life includes using a computer to keep up-to-date with current issues and historical matters, watching movies and documentaries, listening to music and to podcasts. He is unable to go outside without assistance, however if assistance is available he enjoys spending time in his backyard and he enjoys the company of his two cats. Travelling to appointments both locally and in Melbourne is stressful and exhausting. As a result of reaching an advanced stage of Friedreich ataxia, Mr Barling accepts the opinion of the medical specialists that a change in his functional status is not likely. He depends on a powered wheelchair for mobility and Mr Pickett is his primary support worker. Mr Barling’s cardiomyopathy causes him to experience weakness, light-headedness, nausea, loss of appetite, fatigue from simple daily activities and excessive fluid retention. He has profound impairments in hearing and speech. The sounds which he processes are distorted which makes it difficult for him to identify and translate speech. His own speech is weak and often unintelligible to others, particularly those who do not know him well. He has a Phonak Pen which is a 2 way device which acts as an amplifier and wireless microphone to assist with communication. It is effective in quiet environments and it is also expensive, with intricacies in setting up and putting it away. Mr Barling’s vestibular impairment causes nausea, disorientation and fatigue especially when travelling in wheelchair taxis and in trains. As a result of Friedreich ataxia, Mr Barling’s immune system is compromised which puts him at risk of life threatening conditions. It is difficult for him to clear fluid or mucus in his chest or throat. He suffers from urinary frequency and urinary tract infections. He has severe scoliosis as a result of his disability and despite surgery in 1994 this condition has worsened with adverse effects on his posture, comfort and upper torso mobility. He is prone to breathlessness and also swelling in his limbs if he cannot change his posture from time to time. Mr Barling expresses his appreciation for the support which he receives to enable him to remain comfortable at home. However he describes his isolation as oppressive and it has a significant impact on his mental health. He has consulted counsellors and psychologists and he understands that the issue of isolation must be addressed in order to enhance his mental well-being. His social isolation is a result of the severe impact on his mobility caused by Friedreich ataxia. He feels depressed and he suffers from insomnia, tearfulness and anhedonia. “The dark days are many, bereft of wonder, happiness, calm or simply a sense of hope that this imprisonment will break into a day of difference.”[53][53] Affidavit of Gary David Barling, para 117. Michael Pickett

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons which have been set out, the Tribunal finds that the provision of a new vehicle, namely a Volkswagen Caravelle at a cost of $58,990 is a reasonable and necessary support within the meaning of s 34(1) and related provisions of the NDIS Act. The Tribunal finds that the modification to the vehicle at a cost of $94,570 is a reasonable and necessary support within the meaning of s 34(1) and related provisions of the NDIS Act.DECISION The decision under review is varied as follows:(i)Mr Barling is to receive funding to purchase a new Volkswagen Caravelle. (ii)Mr Barling is to receive funding for the modification of the Volkswagen Caravelle for front passenger conversion for wheelchair accessibility.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Agency accepted that a front row conversion would be a reasonable and necessary support which is capable of being funded by the NDIS. That circumstance would only arise on the Agency’s submission if Mr Barling has a vehicle.[87] By approaching the case in this way it followed that the Agency had little to say or challenge in response to the questions which arise in consideration of the evidence relating to each subsection of s 34(1) of the NDIS Act. In that sense, the evidence in relation to those subsections was largely unchallenged.Whether the support will assist the participant to pursue the goals, objectives and aspirations in the participant’s statement of goals and aspirations: s 34(1)(a) of the NDIS Act[87] Respondent closing submissions, para 57. Mr Barling’s NDIS plan has two short term goals. The first one is to have a vehicle which would enable him to access the community where possible. In order to achieve the goal he set out his aspiration to work with therapists to explore options for a suitable vehicle and to undertake and complete assessments. He envisaged support from his support coordinator to link in with appropriate therapists.[88] [88] Exhibit 56, T18. In his NDIS plan Mr Barling noted that the progression of his disability has diminished his ability to work and to be involved in community activities. In the past he has participated in the community in various ways which included conducting his own radio program on a community network, participation on the management committee of an advocacy association, writing and tutoring. In a report provided to the Agency, occupational therapist Ms Russell acknowledged that the provision of the vehicle with appropriate modifications would assist Mr Barling to pursue the goals and aspirations in his NDIS plan. Ms Russell wrote: “The means of transportation for Gary is no small request as he has stated, however, this is a fraction of his supports in comparative [sic] with immeasurable benefits. Access to a controlled environment for transport will truly empower and enable Gary to reach his goals. Specialist appointments or massage for pain relief and mobility can be booked with assurance that transport will no longer be an issue, major disruption or stopper to any of Gary’s planning. This will further the maintenance required for Gary’s ongoing health and well-being. The psychosocial benefits are immeasurable, breaking from the confines of total isolation to simply view the ocean, visit friends or family, attend functions and actively participate in the community.”[89] [89] Ibid, T1B, p 26. The Tribunal is satisfied that the requirement in s 34(1)(a) is met both in relation to the funding for the vehicle and the funding for the modifications to that vehicle. Whether the support will assist the participant to undertake activities, to facilitate the participant’s social and economic participation: s 34(1)(b) of the NDIS Act Mr Barling’s GP, Dr Duffy, wrote in a letter dated 9 February 2021 that Mr Barling’s mental health:“… is impacted by his limited opportunities for mental stimulation resulting from his being unable to leave the house. It is my opinion that his physical and mental health would greatly benefit from being able to visit places that would lift his mood, without being reliant on a taxi to do so.” [90][90] Exhibit 13.