Syddall and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

Syddall and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 3738 (8 November 2022)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/7320

Re:Eric Syddall

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:The Hon. Justice F Meagher

Date:8 November 2022

Place:Brisbane

Pursuant to subparagraph 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Respondent for reconsideration with a direction that Respondent approve a new statement of participant supports for the Applicant, containing the following:

(a)funding for the Applicant to undertake travel to his General Practitioner as necessary, to his other medical appointments (consistent with their written advice as to their necessity and frequency), to engage in recreational and other activities in accordance with paragraphs 52 – 54 of the Applicant’s Statement dated 14 May 2020 and with an additional allowance of funding to undertake various trips in accordance with paragraph 55 of the Applicant’s Statement dated 14 May 2020; and

(b)specify the review date by the Respondent must review the plan to be six (6) months after the day on which the new statement of participant supports is approved.

……………[SGD]…………..
The Hon. Justice F Meagher

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – review of supports in plan – whether funding for a modified Toyota Commuter, including the associated travel costs, and a trailer is reasonable and necessary pursuant to section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) – consideration of National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth) – funding for vehicle precluded by Rules – funding for various other transport supports is reasonable and necessary - decision under review remitted with direction.

Legislation
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

Cases

Azizi and Minister for Home Affairs [2018] AATA 2561

Barling and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 4358

Beezley v Repatriation Commission [2015] FCAFC 165

Castledine and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 4240

Commonwealth v Esher (1991) FCR 324

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethic Affairs [1979] AATA 179

Ewin and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 4726

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308

McLaughlin and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 496

National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79

Re Costello and Department of Transport (1979) 2 ALD 834

Stoddart v Repatriation Commission (2003) 74 ALD 335; [2003] FCA 334

WRMF and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 1771

Secondary Materials
Macquarie Dictionary Online (Web Page, 8 November 2022)

‘Vehicle modifications and driving supports - Operational Guidelines’, National Disability Insurance Agency (Web Page, 8 November 2022) < FOR DECISION

The Hon. Justice F Meagher
8 November 2022

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Eric Syddall (the Applicant) has made an application to the Tribunal for review of a decision dated 15 August 2019 made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Respondent) which approved a Statement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Syddall and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 3738
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Syddall against a decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding funding for supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). Mr Syddall sought funding for a modified Toyota Commuter vehicle, associated travel costs, and a trailer. The NDIA proposed funding for taxi or taxi-like services as an alternative. The case was heard by Justice F Meagher.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the proposed funding for a modified vehicle, including associated travel costs and a trailer, constituted "reasonable and necessary" supports under section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). This involved considering the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth) and the NDIA's Operational Guidelines, particularly concerning the funding of vehicles and safety requirements for modifications.

Justice Meagher reasoned that the support sought should be characterised as transport. While acknowledging that the NDIA's current Operational Guideline generally precludes funding for the purchase or lease of a vehicle, the court found this blanket prohibition to be inconsistent with the NDIS Act and the specific Rules, which do not contain such an explicit prohibition. The court also considered the safety requirements outlined in the Operational Guideline, concluding that while participants must demonstrate that supports meet statutory tests, this does not impose an undue onus of proof. The court determined that the decision under review should be remitted to the NDIA with directions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Therefore, the supports sought crystallised as a particular modified motor vehicle and associated travel costs, either purchased or leased, and a trailer.[16] The Respondent proposed an alternative to the purchase or lease of the vehicle – namely the funding of a taxi or taxi-like service.[17] [16] Respondent’s Closing Submission, [2]. [17] Respondent’s Closing Submission, [3]. Background Mr Syddall was born on 1 July 1956 and is currently 66 years old.[18] He lives at Tewantin with his wife, Susan, and his two sons.[19] Mr Syddall also has two adult daughters who live some distance away from him. Mr Syddall’s older son is a participant in the NDIS.[20][18] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions filed on 21 June 2021, [6]. [19] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions filed on 21 June 2021, [7]. [20] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions filed on 21 June 2021, [10]. Mr Syddall first started experiencing symptoms in November 2000 and was diagnosed with diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis (DISH), ankylosing spondylosis, nerve compression, diabetes mellitus type I and narcotic induced bowel bleeding in 2009.[21] DISH is a permanent and progressive condition.[22][21] Exhibit 1, A8, [7]. [22] Exhibit 1, A21, 221; Exhibit 1, R2, 332. Mr Syddall has three wheelchairs.[23] They include a manual wheelchair that has been prescribed with particular back and headrest supports, and in which he is unable to propel himself.[24] Secondly, he has a power wheelchair, a ‘Permobil’, which he uses most regularly.[25] Thirdly, Mr Syddall has a ‘Sahara’ wheelchair, with fat wheels, designed to be more effective on certain terrains, including roads.[26] However, it is too large for many interiors, such as his doctors surgery.[27] As well, the Sahara has not proved effective on roads,[28] including because Mr Syddall has nearly been hit by other vehicles when using it.[29] Therefore, Mr Syddall does not use the Sahara much and describes the Permobil as his ‘day to day wheelchair’.[30] [23] Transcript, P18, lines 3 – 7. [24] Transcript, P-18, lines 4 – 5 and 12. [25] Transcript, P-18, lines 4 – 6. [26] Transcript, P-18, line 6. [27] Transcript, P-18, line 8 – 9. [28] Transcript, P-18, lines 9 – 10. [29] Transcript, P-18, lines 24 – 26. [30] Transcript, P-18, lines 5 – 6. Mr Syddall and his wife own a 2012 Kia Grand Carnival (the Kia),[31] and Mr Syddall currently holds an unrestricted driver’s licence.[32][31] Exhibit 1, A8, [25]. [32] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions filed on 21 June 2021, [92(a)]. The purchase of the Kia was subsidised by Queensland Health, through the Vehicle Option Subsidy Scheme in 2015, partly to meet the needs of Mr Syddall, and partly to meet the needs of his older son, whose disabilities (namely Asperger’s and ADHD) mean he needs to be seated a certain distance from other people travelling in a vehicle, in order for him, other passengers, and the driver to travel safely.[33][33] Exhibit 1, A8, [29] – [30].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At the time of the hearing, the relevant Operational Guideline was entitled ‘Including Specific Types of Supports in Plans Operational Guideline – Vehicle Modifications’ and was current as of 3 October 2019 (the previous Operational Guideline).[69] It was upon this Operational Guideline that the parties based their submissions. [69] Exhibit 1, O4, 357 – 358. It came to my attention, without indication from the parties, that that Operational Guideline had been replaced on 10 February 2022 by an Operational Guideline entitled ‘Vehicle modifications and driving supports’ (the current Operational Guideline).[70] The current Operational Guideline is materially different from the former one. [70] ‘Vehicle modifications and driving supports - Operational Guidelines’, National Disability Insurance Agency (Web Page, 8 November 2022) < type="1">A telephone directions hearing was conducted on 19 May 2022 to bring to the parties’ attention the change in the Operational Guideline. I also raised with the parties, particularly the Applicant, concerns I had regarding the evidence with respect to Mr Syddall’s driving of the vehicle, and made directions timetabling submissions from the parties responsive to the matters raised. Accordingly, the parties also filed the following further submissions:·Applicant’s Further Submissions dated 16 June 2022 (the Applicant’s Operational Guideline Submissions); and·Respondent’s Further Submissions dated 20 June 2022 (the Respondent’s Operational Guideline Submissions). THE NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEMEThe NDIS is governed by the NDIS Act.[71] Its objects are set out in section 3 of the NDIS Act. They should be used to assist in the construction of the NDIS Act, unless contrary to clear words elsewhere in the Act, notwithstanding they ‘may pull in different directions’ or be ‘aspirational’.[72] General principles guiding actions to be taken under the NDIS Act are set out in section 4. Such actions include ‘determining whether a statement of participant supports should be approved’.[73] [71] NDIS Act, s 3(1)(b). [72] National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79, [145] – [146]. [73] NDIS Act, s 33(2). Participant Plans are covered in Chapter 3 Part 2 of the NDIS Act. Section 31 of the NDIS Act deals with the preparation, review and replacement of a participant’s plan. Section 33 of the NDIS Act deals with matters which must be contained within a participant’s plan. They include a statement of goals, objectives and aspirations and the participant’s environmental and living context prepared by the participant.[74] They also include a SOPS prepared with the participant and approved by the CEO.[75] [74] NDIS Act, s 33(1). [75] NDIS Act, s 33(2). Subsection 33(5) of the NDIS Act specifies the matters which the CEO must have regard to when deciding whether or not to approve a SOPS, including: ·the participant’s statement of goals and aspirations; ·relevant assessments conducted in relation to the participant;·satisfaction that section 34 of the NDIS Act is met in relation to the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded and the general supports that will be provided;·application of the rules (if any) made for the purposes of section 35;·the principal that a participant should manage their plan to the extent they wish to do so; and·the operation and effectiveness of any previous plans of the participant. Section 35 of the NDIS Act provides for the making of rules including in relation to prescribing reasonable and necessary supports or general supports that will not be funded or provided under the NDIS.In McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308 (McGarrigle), Mortimer J stated, with respect to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth) (the Rules), that:43.The rules are legislative instruments to be made by the Minister: see s 209. Section 209, sub-paras (4) to (7) constrain the rule-making power to preserve the federal characteristics of the NDIS. The National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth) (the Rules) are an important element of the legislative scheme, introducing the ability to modify the operation of ss 33 and 34 by, for example, excluding certain kinds of supports from inclusion in participant plans. It is through the Rules that the executive is able to implement, within the federalism constraints imposed in s 209, some policy decision-making about the nature and extent of supports to be provided or funded under the NDIS.Subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act contains criteria in respect of which a decision maker must be satisfied. All the criteria must be met. The phrase ‘reasonable and necessary’ is not defined in the legislation. It is a composite phrase and should be considered as such. Section 99 of the NDIS Act contains a table enumerating reviewable decisions under the NDIS Act. They include, ‘[A] decision under subsection 33(2) to approve the statement of participant supports in the plan’. Section 100 of the NDIS Act provides for review of reviewable decisions within the NDIA. Pursuant to section 103 of the NDIS Act, an application may be made to the Tribunal in respect of any decision reviewed under section 100 of the NDIS Act. There are also Operational Guidelines which constitute government policy and should be considered if not inconsistent with the provisions or objects of the legislation. As set out above, the Operational Guidelines changed after the hearing and provision of submissions but before the decision had been made. Those changes were:·First, the previous Operational Guideline stated that the NDIS would generally not fund the purchase of a motor vehicle.[76] The current Operational Guideline provides that the NDIS will not provide funding to buy or lease a vehicle.[77] ·Secondly, the previous Operational Guideline did not address safety. The current Operational Guideline outlines further consideration and requirements regarding the necessary documentary evidence and/or assessments required to demonstrate that modifications to vehicles are safe.[78] The current Operational Guideline provides for further requirements if a participant is to drive a vehicle and references the national ‘Assessing Fitness to Drive’ medical standard.[79] [76] Exhibit 1, O4, 358. [77] ‘Vehicle modifications and driving supports - Operational Guidelines’, National Disability Insurance Agency (Web Page, 8 November 2022) 3, < ‘Vehicle modifications and driving supports - Operational Guidelines’, National Disability Insurance Agency (Web Page, 8 November 2022) 10 – 11, < ‘Vehicle modifications and driving supports - Operational Guidelines’, National Disability Insurance Agency (Web Page, 8 November 2022) 13, < As a decision by the Tribunal is to be treated as if it were that of the primary decision-maker, the Tribunal is required to apply the law as if it were the decision-maker. However, the decision in Re Costello and Department of Transport (1979) 2 ALD 834,[80] later endorsed by the Full Federal Court in Commonwealth v Esher (1991) FCR 324,[81] held that this approach is only required where the Tribunal is considering anterior entitlements, unless the amending legislation is expressed to have retrospective effect.[82] As the decision in this matter relates to Mr Syddall’s current entitlement to the supports in dispute, and there is no consideration of reimbursements or retrospective entitlements, I will apply the current Operational Guideline. [80] [939] – [945]. [81] 101 ALR 35. [82] Stoddart v Repatriation Commission (2003) 74 ALD 335; [2003] FCA 334. CONSIDERATIONAs alluded to above, the parties made lengthy detailed submissions. As will become clear from these reasons it neither necessary nor appropriate for me to deal with all of them. As decided in Azizi and Minister for Home Affairs [2018] AATA 2561, a decision of the Tribunal is normative in that its findings of fact should be followed if that factual issue is relevant to another decision.[83] In order to avoid inconsistent decision making, the Tribunal needs to be cautious in deciding more than what is necessary.[83] [6].However, one issue which has arisen in different contexts within the parties’ submissions is the characterisation of the support sought. I need to deal with this issue to consider the parties’ submissions relating to the use of taxi services. In relation to submissions with respect to rule 3.1 of the Rules (that is, submissions made before the changes to the Operational Guidelines and relevant to the value for money argument advanced by the Respondent regarding the use of taxis as an alternative), Mr Syddall submitted that what he was claiming is not “transport” generally, rather a vehicle that he can access and operate generally.[84] In reply the Respondent submitted that to make such a distinction took an unduly narrow and unrealistic approach.[85] I accept the Respondent’s submissions in that regard and accept that the support sought should be characterised as transport. Further, as others have concluded with respect to the previous Operational Guideline, there may be circumstances where the purchase of a motor vehicle would be undertaken by the Respondent, such as in the decision of Barling and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 4358, in respect of which no appeal was lodged by the Respondent. [84] Applicant’s Closing Submissions, [89].[85] Respondent’s Further Closing Submissions, [11].With respect to the current Operational Guideline, insofar as they state that the NDIS will not provide funding to buy or lease a vehicle[86] I consider them to go beyond the statutory scheme and thus to not apply. Rule 7.21 of the Rules sets out the transport supports for which the Respondent will be responsible, and rule 7.22 of the Rules sets out those for which it will not.[87] Nowhere within the Rules is there a prohibition on buying (or leasing) a motor vehicle. Furthermore, the current Operational Guideline makes no attempt to consider rule 7.21 and 7.22, and instead applies a blanket bar to the funding of the purchase or lease of a vehicle. To that extent, I find that the current Operational Guideline, with respect to not providing funding for leasing or purchasing a vehicle, undermines what the legislation provides and, for that reason, does not apply. [86] ‘Vehicle modifications and driving supports - Operational Guidelines’, National Disability Insurance Agency (Web Page, 8 November 2022) 3, < Barling and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 4358, [49]. With respect to the current Operational Guideline as it relates to safety, Mr Syddall submits that the requirements (which are in this case intended to amplify rule 5.1(a) of the Rules) are inconsistent with the Rules.[88] Rule 5.1(a) of the Rules states that a support will not be funded under the NDIS if it is likely to cause harm to the participant or pose a risk to others. Mr Syddall submits that in accordance with rule 5.1(a) of the Rules, the Tribunal must have evidence to satisfy itself that harm or risk is likely, whereas the current Operational Guideline appears to impose an obligation upon a participant to establish that a support is safe.[89] I consider that to be drawing too fine a distinction. There is a general consensus that there is no onus of proof in relation to matters before the Tribunal. In saying that, Mr Syddall needs to demonstrate that the evidence sustains his argument that the supports in dispute meet the relevant statutory tests. The Rules are subordinate legislation that comprise the statutory scheme that governs the NDIS. The Federal Court in Beezley v Repatriation Commission [2015] FCAFC 165 commented that:[90] …as a practical matter, it is not incorrect to say that a person “must satisfy” the requirements in the statute. To say that is not to impose an onus of proof on the applicant, but rather to recognise the operation of the legislative scheme under which the person seeks a benefit or interest…[88] Applicant’s Operational Guideline Submissions, [16]. [89] ‘Vehicle modifications and driving supports - Operational Guidelines’, National Disability Insurance Agency (Web Page, 8 November 2022) 10 – 11, < [68].