Castledine and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

Castledine and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 4240 (16 October 2019)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:           2017/3459

Re:Jake Castledine

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member K. Parker

Date:16 October 2019

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision made on 27 April 2017 by a National Disability Insurance Agency reviewer to approve a statement of participant supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) forming part of the Applicant’s NDIS plan that commenced on 27 April 2017.

In substitution and with effect from 27 April 2017, the Tribunal decides to approve a new statement of participant supports for the Applicant that includes the following supports:

1.143 hours of therapeutic intervention per annum to be provided by a speech therapist and/or occupational therapist in accordance with the directions of the Applicant’s clinical practice leader;

2.160.5 hours of practice coaching per annum to be provided to the Applicant’s support staff by a registered psychologist in accordance with the directions of the Applicant’s clinical practice leader;

3.110 hours of “behavioural support planning, support, monitoring and reporting” per annum to be provided by a positive behaviour support practitioner who is a registered psychologist in accordance with the directions of the Applicant’s clinical practice leader;

4.transport costs for the actual kilometres travelled by Mr Castledine by private vehicle for all journeys to and from Ms Castledine’s residence to the unit provided to Mr Castledine by the Victorian Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS Unit) or to or from the DHHS Unit to places in the community, on any day of the week, to be calculated on the basis of the rate per kilometre prescribed by the Australian Taxation Office from time to time for the purpose of calculating an individual’s tax deductions relating to travel in a private vehicle;

5.all of the supports listed in the statement of participant supports forming part of the Applicant’s current NDIS plan that commenced on 23 June 2019, to the extent that those supports have not already been provided for by the approval of the supports referred to in paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 4 above; and

6.the review date of the statement of participant supports is extended to 22 June 2020.

..........................[sgd]..............................................

Member K. Parker

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – review of statement of participant supports – participant with multiple serious and permanent medical conditions – participant has intense and complex support needs – multidisciplinary therapy – practice coaching for support staff – concerns raised about self-management of plan and direct employment of support staff - dispute about the number of hours of speech therapy, occupational therapy and practice coaching required – provision of therapy assistants as an alternative support – method of calculation of transport supports – treatment of successive NDIS plans – decision under review set aside and substituted with decision to approve a new statement of participant supports – extension of review date in statement of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Castledine and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 4240
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an internal review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding the statement of participant supports for Mr Castledine, who has multiple serious and permanent medical conditions requiring intense and complex support needs. The review was undertaken by a reviewer appointed under section 100(5)(a) of the NDIS Act, following a deemed decision by the CEO not to review Mr Castledine's plan. An internal review meeting took place on 14 February 2017, and the reviewer's decision was recorded in a letter dated 9 May 2017.

The legal issues before the court involved the determination of the appropriate level of supports for Mr Castledine, specifically concerning the number of hours of speech therapy, occupational therapy, and practice coaching required. The dispute also extended to the provision of therapy assistants as an alternative support, the method for calculating transport supports, and the treatment of successive NDIS plans. The reviewer's decision, made on 27 April 2017, addressed changes to previous plan decisions, including increases to consumables funding and capacity building supports for daily activities and relationships, while declining to change decisions regarding short-term accommodation, respite, an intensive multidisciplinary team, a dietitian, and vehicle provision.

The reviewer's reasoning involved an assessment of Mr Castledine's support needs, leading to an increase in funding for a continence package and capacity building supports. This included a specific adjustment for a practice coach, previously charged at a therapy assistant rate, and the inclusion of hours for a continence nurse assessment. Additionally, support for capacity building in relationships was increased to address behaviours of concern and facilitate the development of a behaviour support plan. The reviewer also determined that no separate decision was required for program management and administration costs, as these were already incorporated into the pricing unit costs. The outcome of the internal review was the substitution of the previous decision with a new statement of participant supports, including an extension of the review date.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Ms Castledine’s case, a delegate of the NDIA proceeded to undertake an internal review of the deemed decision by the CEO not to review Mr Castledine’s plan. This review was undertaken under s 100(5)(a) of the NDIS Act by a “reviewer” as defined in that provision. Specifically, an “internal review meeting” took place on 14 February 2017. This meeting resulted in the following decision being made by the reviewer. Internal review decision On 27 April 2017 the reviewer made a decision that was recorded in a letter dated 9 May 2017.[5] The Tribunal notes that in the first paragraph of this letter the reviewer appears to have mischaracterised the request that was made by Ms Castledine. The reviewer stated that Ms Castledine (and Mr Castledine) had requested a review of the NDIA’s decision on 28 September 2016. This is incorrect. While the end result is closely linked, the proper characterisation of the request that had been made by Ms Castledine was for a review to be undertaken of Mr Castledine’s plan under s 48 of the NDIA Act, as addressed above in paragraphs [12] to [16]. [5] Refer to T-Documents T2. Despite that initial mischaracterisation, the reviewer then referred (in her letter dated 9 May 2017), to the provisions under s 48 and acknowledged that the CEO was taken to have decided not to review Mr Castledine’s plan, which lead to the internal review meeting on 14 February 2017. The reviewer stated in her letter dated 9 May 2017 as follows:[6]Following an internal review meeting at [address] on the 14th February 2017 where Jake’s support coordinator was present, I have made an internal review decision on the 27th April 2017 resulting in the current 6 month plan being approved on that date.[6] Ibid at page 12. The reviewer described the “outcome” of her decision as:[7](a)having “changed decisions made in the previous plan related to the areas” which included an “increase” to “consumables funding”, “support for capacity building – daily activities” and “supports for capacity building – relationships” (as detailed in paragraph [20]);(b)deciding “not to change the following decisions made on the previous plan” in relation to “short term accommodation and in-home respite”; capacity building supports – the requests for an intensive multidisciplinary team and a dietitian; and the provision of a “vehicle” and ongoing maintenance costs; and(c)determining that “no decision about additional funding for program management and administration (such as business operating costs) was required” (on the basis that those costs were already included in the plan as they formed part of the pricing unit costs.[7] Ibid at pages 12 and 13. In relation to paragraph [19(a)], the reviewer described the changes she had decided to make as follows:[8] (a)increasing the level of funding for a continence package from $1,200 per 12 months to $4,720 per six months;(b)increasing support for capacity building (daily activities), inclusive of:(i)a “therapy line item for a practice coach (previously charged at the therapy assistant rate)”; and (ii)four hours for a continence nurse to undertake an assessment;(c)increasing support for capacity building (relationships), inclusive of “specialist behavioural intervention and behavioural management training (stated support/agency managed) to address behaviours of concerns and to develop and implement a behaviour support plan (BSP)”.[8] Ibid at page 12.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established