Lougher and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

Lougher and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 1057 (15 May 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/2836

Re:LOUGHER  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President A Younes

Date:15 May 2024

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review pursuant to s 43(1)(c)(ii) of the AAT Act and the matter is remitted to the Agency for reconsideration with a direction that within 28 days of this decision, the Applicant’s statement of participant supports specifies for Specialist Disability Accommodation as follows:

SDA Type: New Build

Design Category: Robust

Building Type: Villa/Duplex/Townhouse, 1 bedroom, 1 SDA eligible resident

Location: NSW – Central Coast

OOA: Yes

Fire Sprinklers: Yes

..................................[SGD]......................................

Deputy President A Younes

CATCHWORDS

National disability insurance scheme — reasonable and necessary supports — Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA) — Building type — value for money — harm to the participant and risk to others — behaviours of concern — reviewable decision set aside and remitted with direction

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

CASES

Commissioner of Taxation v Rawson Finances Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 617

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298
McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308
Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency (2015) 233 FCR 201
National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF (2020) 276 FCR 415
Ramos Hernandez and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Citizenship) [2023] AATA 1850
Schellenberg v Tunnel Holdings [2000] HCA 18; (2000) 200 CLR 121
Syddall and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 3738
Twentyman v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] FCA 586

Woolf and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 1312

SECONDARY MATERIALS

NIL

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President A Younes

15 May 2024

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Ms Lougher, is a 25-year-old who has been a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (‘NDIS’) since 2016. This application involves review of a decision made by a delegate of the CEO, on 5 April 2022 under s 100(2) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (‘the NDIS Act’), which approved a statement of participant supports (‘SOPS’) forming part of the Applicant’s NDIS plan. Subsequently and on various occasions, that decision was varied pursuant to s 42D of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (‘AAT Act’). 

  2. The original decision under review dated 15 December 2021 was implemented in a plan for the period from 15 December 2021 to 15 June 2022 under s 33(2) of the NDIS Act.

    Principles & Objectives of the NDIS Act

  3. The NDIS Act operates in pursuit of the objectives set out in s 3 of the NDIS Act. Section 4 establishes general principles guiding actions to be taken under the NDIS Act.

  4. Section 3 of the NDIS Act sets out the objects and principles of the NDIS Act, making particular reference to the purpose of providing reasonable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lougher and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 1057
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) considered the case of Lougher and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The applicant sought Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA) in the Robust design category. The dispute centred on whether the proposed SDA met the requirements of section 34(1) of the NDIS Act, specifically concerning value for money and the potential harm to the participant and risk to others.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the NDIA's decision to refuse funding for the requested SDA was correct, and if not, what the appropriate decision should be. This involved determining if the proposed SDA would assist the applicant in pursuing their goals and aspirations, and whether it represented value for money, considering the applicant's complex needs, including chronic epilepsy, autism, severe intellectual disability, and significant behavioural challenges. The Tribunal also had to assess the risk of harm to the applicant and others, as well as the risk of property damage, given the applicant's history of aggressive behaviours.

The Tribunal reasoned that while the applicant's goals, as stated in their NDIS plan, included a desire for independence and living in their own home, the evidence presented, particularly from carers and medical professionals, highlighted significant risks associated with shared accommodation. These risks included the potential for the applicant to harm herself, others, and property due to her behaviours of concern. The Tribunal found that the proposed SDA, in a shared living arrangement, would not be safe or appropriate given these risks. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision.

The Tribunal remitted the matter to the NDIA for reconsideration with a direction that the applicant's statement of participant supports specify Specialist Disability Accommodation of a New Build design, Robust category, as a 1-bedroom villa/duplex/townhouse for one SDA eligible resident in NSW – Central Coast, with an "Only Once" (OOA) arrangement and fire sprinklers.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Among other materials, the following documents contained in Exhibit 6 are of particular relevance:·Report prepared by Ms Georga Crouch, Behaviour Support Practitioner, dated 16 August 2021;[8][8] Ex 6, 163-169.·Behaviour Assessment Report and Comprehensive Behaviour Support Plan prepared by Ms Jessie Hartley, Behaviour Support Practitioner, dated 13 June 2023;[9][9] Ex 6, 383-428.·Behaviour Inter Plan Review Report prepared by Ms Jessie Hartley, Behaviour Support Practitioner, dated 14 June 2023;[10][10] Ex 6, 429-436.·Report by Ms Georga Crouch, Behaviour Support Practitioner, dated 29 September 2021;[11] [11] Ex 6, 171-178.·Summary of NDIS Review Report prepared by Ms Jessie Hartley, Behaviour Support Practitioner, dated 9 August 2023;[12] [12] Ex 6, 437-440.·Occupational Therapy Functional Capacity Assessment by Ms Emma Cullen, Occupational Therapist, dated 24 April 2023;[13][13] Ex 6, 441-467.·Letter from Dr Penny Caldicot dated 27 December 2023;[14]·Letter from Dr Andrew Bleasel, Neurologist, dated 18 January 2024;[15]·Summary of Behavioural Data prepared by Ms Jessie Hartley, Behaviour Support Practitioner, dated 29 January 2024;[16]·Statement of Ms Jessica Bryant, Carer, dated 31 January 2024;[17] ·Statement of Ms Hermelyn Elliot, Carer, dated 30 January 2024;[18] and ·Statement of Ms Rebekah D’Amico, Carer, dated 31 January 2024.[19] ·Statement of Mr Garry Lougher and Ms Shaunagh Lougher, Parents, dated 28 January 2024;[20]·Statement of Ms Shantara Bruns, Carer, dated 31 January 2024;[21] ·Statement of Ms Tenille Harford, Carer, dated 31 January 2024;[22] ·Statement of Ms Rachel Deakin, Carer, dated 31 January 2024.[23] [14] Ex 6, 621-622.[15] Ex 6, 623-624.[16] Ex 6, 625-628.[17] Ex 6, 631.[18] Ex 6, 629.[19] Ex 6, 635.[20] Ex 6, 641-643.[21] Ex 6, 637.[22] Ex 6, 639.[23] Ex 6, 633.BACKGROUND The Applicant has Chronic Epilepsy, Autism (Level 3), Severe Intellectual Disability, Severe Global Development delay, Severe Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD), and Receptive and Expressive Language impairment.[24] [24] Ex 6, 13, 40, 86, 93, etc. The Applicant is completely non-verbal and she is also incontinent. She regularly throws and smears her faeces.[25] She is fully reliant on her family and carers for support. In the SFIC, it is noted that due to her conditions, the Applicant is highly vulnerable to “mistreatment, interference, abuse and poor care, of which she has experienced in the past”.[26] The Applicant’s request for support relates to her eligibility for Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA) in the Robust design category. The level of supports required for Supported Independent Living (SIL) was added but is yet to be determined by the Agency. The SIL is therefore not subject to this review.[25] T1D of the Respondent’s T-Documents.[26] Ex 2, [4]. The Applicant engages in challenging behaviours including banging, kicking, throwing objects, knocking things over, tearing things, making loud noises, and crying.[27] She can be physically aggressive towards others, can harm herself, and can destroy property.[28] She can “bolt” from support people and refuses to comply with the directions of other people.[29] The Applicant’s challenging behaviour has been ongoing throughout her life, and there is evidence of increase in recent times.[30][27] T1D of the Respondent’s T-Documents.[28] T1D of the Respondent’s T-Documents[29] T1D of the Respondent’s T-Documents.[30] T1D of the Respondent’s T-Documents; Summary of Behavioural Data prepared by Ms Jessie Hartley, Behaviour Support Practitioner, dated 29 January 2024.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In a letter dated 18 January 2024, Dr Bleasel, Neurologist, confirmed the Applicant’s intellectual disability and “very challenging behaviour with epilepsy”.[63]Statements and oral evidence of carers[63] Ex 6, 623.Ms Jessica Bryant Ms Jessica Bryant, Carer, provided a Statement dated 30 January 2024.[64] Among other things, Ms Bryant observed that the Applicant throws items, slams, kicks, and head butts. Ms Bryant noted that she would not be able to care for another person whilst caring for the Applicant. [64] Ex 6, 631. Ms Bryant provided a letter of support dated 3 March 2024, in which she expressed the opinion that the Applicant’s behaviour would escalate in the case of another resident because the Applicant cannot deal with change, and that a housemate with disabilities would “most definitely be at risk of injury”.[65] She indicated that she would not be able to safely care for the Applicant and another reside. She included two photographs as evidence of bites by the Applicant when she shampooed her for too long.[65] Ex 9.Ms Hermelyn Elliot In a Statement dated 30 January 2024, Ms Elliot, Carer, discussed the Applicant’s seizures and aggressive behaviours.[66] [66] Ex 6, 629. In a letter of support, dated 4 March 2024,[67] Ms Elliott noted that the Applicant poses a risk to any housemate, including being scratched, punched, bitten, or shoved out of the way. She stated that she would resign her position as carer as she would not be able to safely care for the Applicant and another resident. She included two photographs as evidence of injuries caused by the Applicant when she opened the laundry door and for brushing her hair.[67] Ex 8. Ms Elliott gave oral evidence essentially confirming her views.Ms Rebekah D’Amico In a Statement dated 31 January 2024, Ms D’Amico, Carer, referred to the Applicant’s potential behaviour escalation leading to damage to property, furniture, fixtures, and posing a risk to those present.[68] [68] Ex 6, 635. In a letter of support, dated 4 March 2024,[69] Ms D’Amico noted that having another resident live with the Applicant would be detrimental to the Applicant and unsafe for all. She noted that she would resign her role if the Applicant had to share with another resident. She included a photograph as evidence of injuries caused by the Applicant.[69] Ex 7. Ms D’Amico gave evidence, among other things, referring to the aggression she faces at the hands of the Applicant, including, grabbing, scratching, and smashing. She expressed the view that all would be in danger in the case of another resident.Ms Shantara Bruns In a Statement dated 31 January 2024, Ms Bruns, Carer, focussed her comments on the appropriateness of the SDA, and referred to incidents of the Applicant kicking walls, slamming doors, and throwing items.[70] [70] Ex 6, 637.Ms Tenille Harford In a Statement dated 31 January 2024, Ms Harford, Carer, discussed the Applicant’s potential escalating behaviour and the damage to property that can be caused.[71] [71] Ex 6, 639.Ms Rachel Deakin

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal is satisfied on the evidence that the correct and preferable decision is a set aside. DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review pursuant to s 43(1)(c)(ii) of the AAT Act and the matter is remitted to the Agency for reconsideration with a direction that within 28 days of this decision, the Applicant’s statement of participant supports specifies for Specialist Disability Accommodation as follows:SDA Type: New Build Design Category: Robust Building Type: Villa/Duplex/Townhouse, 1 bedroom, 1 SDA eligible residentLocation: NSW – Central CoastOOA: YesFire Sprinklers: Yes

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent contended that the requested SDA does not meet the requirements s 34(1) of the NDIS Act.Section 34(1)(a) – goals, objectives, and aspirations The first mandatory criterion under s 34(1)(a) of the NDIS Act is that the funding of the supports will assist the participant to pursue the goals, objectives and aspirations included in the participant’s NDIS plan. The short-term goals in the applicant’s plan are that he would like to live at home as independently as possible, for as long as possible, and to see his children. As for medium and long term-goals, he would like support to maintain mental and physical health to enable him to participate in more activities and for someone to assist as he is not able to live by himself.[91][91] NDIS Plan dated 6 April 2021. Section 34(1) does not require the Tribunal to be satisfied that the supports under consideration will result in a participant achieving their goals and aspirations. They are only required to assist the participant to achieve their goals, objectives, and aspirations. The Tribunal is mindful that the legislative scheme prescribed under the NDIS Act requires the CEO, and the Tribunal on review, to ‘have regard to the participant’s statement of goals and aspirations’ in deciding whether to approve a SOPS.[92] [92] NDIS Act, s 33(5)(a). In the current NDIS Plan, the Applicant expressed:I live with Mum & Dad and my brothers but have been spending more time away from family. I am getting used to being away from my family and I am looking forward to moving out of the family home to my own place. This is being built right now. I am meeting other girls like me now with a view to them being a housemate in the future. That will mean I will have some more carers around me. … My Dad has been working with the SDA & SILC to develop a plan for me to be able to live independently with another young lady in a home that he is hoping to get the approval from NDIS to build so that I can have as normal life as possible.[93]…I like to be with my family regularly. I also like to meet new people and I look forward to my new house and being surrounded by people with old fashioned values and they will be part of my life.[93] NDIS Plan (06.09.2023 – 05.09.2024), page 2 (‘Current Plan’). In the Current Plan, the Applicant expressed the following goals: (1) I need to be able to get out each day and be engaged in the community activities to build my independence and activities I enjoy like swimming. (2) To keep having weekends away from my family and enjoy independence myself with my carers, go out a bit in the evenings and have friends around. (3) To live in a home of my own and to build my skills through a gradual and safe transition.[94][94] Goals (1) and (2) are described as ‘Short-term’ goals, and goal (3) as a ‘Medium or long-term’ goal. As pointed out by the Applicant, her goals were prepared when she was a teenager and have not been updated since that time. She is now 25 years old and it is fair to say that although she has expressed a desire to be around people, her goals have been revised and provided to the Respondent together for funding under the SIL program which has not yet been determined.