Clixby and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Clixby and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 2669 (30 July 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/10466

Re:Jessica Clixby

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:                  The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

Date:30 July 2024

Place:Sydney

Pursuant to section 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

................[SGD]........................................................

The Hon. Pru Goward, Senior Member

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABLITY INSURANCE SCHEME – review of supports in plan – epilepsy – Supported Disability Accommodation (SDA) – nursing care – probative evidence – prescription medication – reasonable and necessary support – medical advice – veracity of evidence – midazolam – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Specialist Disability Accommodation) Rules 2020

Cases

Lougher and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 1057

Woolf and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 1312
ZNDV and National Disability Insurance Agency [2014] AATA 921

Secondary Materials
Operational Guidelines National Disability Insurance Scheme (Web Page, 30 October 2023) <

REASONS FOR DECISION

THE HONOURABLE PRU GOWARD AO, SENIOR MEMBER

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Jessica Clixby, is a thirty five year old woman with cerebral palsy, visual impairments, hemiplegia, an intellectual disability, Williams syndrome, hydrocephalus and epilepsy. On the basis of these conditions and Kabuki syndrome, the Applicant became a participant of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the Scheme) on 8 September 2016.

  2. The Applicant sought review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of a decision of a delegate of the CEO of the Respondent of 2 December 2022 (the decision under review). This had affirmed an earlier decision in relation to the Applicant’s Statement of Participant Supports (SOPS), included in her plan of 7 October 2022.

    That plan included a SOPS made pursuant to section 33(2) of the National Disability Insurance SchemeAct 2013 (Cth) (the Act), and provided total funded supports of $368,432.23 comprised of:

    (a)Core supports of $281,043.13;

    (b)Transport funding of $1,784.00;

    (c)Improved Life Choices (CB Choice and Control) supports of $1,485.75;

    (d)Improved Daily Living (CB Daily Activity) supports of $13,935.62 (including 35 hours for occupational therapist, including assessment for assistive technology, 11 hours for speech pathology (for review of mealtime management plan), 22 hours for physiotherapy and six hours for a continence assessment);

    (e)Improved Relationships (CB Relationships) supports of $9,842.44 (including 40 hours of specialist behaviour intervention support and 20 hours of behaviour management plan and training in behaviour management strategies);

    (f)Support Coordination of $23,059.60;

    (g)Assistive Technology of $18,000.00 (rental cost for a power chair whilst waiting for new equipment and funding for electric bed and recliner pending trail and completion of assessment and quote, as well as repairs and maintenance of existing equipment); and

    (h)Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA) up to $51,651.47 per year (high physical support, apartment, two bedrooms, two residents, NSW – Sydney, Blacktown).

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clixby and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2669
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered an application for review by the Applicant of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) delegate. The NDIA's decision affirmed an earlier decision regarding the Applicant's Statement of Participant Supports (SOPS) within her National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) plan. The Applicant's plan included significant funding for core supports, transport, improved life choices, daily living, relationships, support coordination, assistive technology, and Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA). The NDIA had determined that certain requested supports, specifically funding for SDA single occupancy, self-management of plan management, and increased daily activity supports with 24-hour support worker assistance, were not reasonable and necessary.

The legal issues before the Tribunal included whether the Applicant's requested supports for SDA single occupancy, self-management of plan management, and 24-hour support worker assistance were reasonable and necessary under section 34(1) of the NDIS Act 2013 (Cth) and the relevant Rules. The Tribunal also had to consider the probative value of the evidence presented, particularly in light of the Applicant's behaviour during hearings and the inability to verify certain medical documentation and witness testimony. The NDIA also sought an interlocutory dismissal of the application, arguing that the Applicant's conduct impeded the Tribunal's ability to review the request and progress the matter.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the evidence presented and its reliability. While the Applicant's Statement of Lived Experience indicated a need for nursing care, she later referred to general care or support workers. The Tribunal accepted she sought additional support workers at a 1:1 ratio, but this request was withdrawn, rendering the specific nature of the care immaterial. Crucially, the Tribunal found that evidence from certain medical practitioners and a former support person could not be verified due to their unavailability or the inability to confirm the contents of their documentation. The Tribunal noted that the Applicant's behaviour during the hearing significantly undermined her position.

The Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision. The Applicant's requests for SDA single occupancy, self-management of plan management, and increased daily activity supports with 24-hour assistance were found not to be reasonable and necessary, primarily due to insufficient probative evidence to support these specific needs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Respondent has developed operational guidelines to regulate its application of the Act and the Rules. The operational guideline generally relevant to the planning process is the Planning Operational Guideline.Background The Applicant currently lives alone in a two-person apartment on the first floor of an apartment block in the western suburbs of Sydney and has no family or other informal support. The Applicant is wheelchair bound and significantly sight-impaired. She is highly dependent on assistance for many activities of daily living but nevertheless, is a bright and engaged young woman of strong opinions and personality. Considering her complex array of impairments, it was not always clear whether the Applicant’s at times dysregulated behaviour, both during and outside hearings, was the consequence of those impairments or of personal choices. Suffice it to say, the Applicant’s actions significantly undermined her position and required, eventually, that she be removed from the hearing room. The Applicant has been under the auspices of the NSW Public Guardian since 2010 with several guardianship orders over that time. Most recently, on 1 November 2023, the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal, NCAT, ordered that the Applicant be subject to a guardianship order for a period of twelve months from that date. Despite the guardianship order, counsel assisting the Applicant advised the Tribunal that she was capable of providing instructions and proceeded to represent her on that basis. The Hearing was held in person on both days to accommodate the needs of the Applicant. The Applicant was represented and after her evidence had been given, was expected to remain silent, relying upon her counsel to represent her. Issues The Respondent sought an interlocutory hearing for dismissal of the application on the grounds of impedance to the Tribunal’s objective of reviewing the Applicant’s request and the Applicant’s failure to progress the matter. On the final day of the hearing the Applicant submitted that there was insufficient evidence of probative value to support the requested supports of (a) and (c) but submitted there was sufficient evidence to demonstrate the need for sole occupancy SDA, high physical support, (b). For completion, the Tribunal notes the following additional supports were originally sought by the Applicant:(a)24/7 support delivered at a 1:1 ratio of care; (b)sole occupancy SDA, high physical support; and (c)the management of her SOPS to be self-managed. Regarding the request for additional care, the Tribunal notes that although the Applicant’s Statement of Lived Experience identified the need for nursing care, at other times the Applicant referred only to care, or to support workers. The Tribunal accepts that the Applicant was seeking additional support workers at a 1:1 ratio of care, but since the Applicant withdrew this request, considers that the nature of the care is immaterial.Evidence Relied upon In making the determination, the Tribunal relied on evidence provided by the parties at the hearing, The substantiative evidence provided in the T-Documents were as follows:(i)Report of Sadiq Rehmani, Occupational Therapist dated 24 December 2021 (ii)Certificate of Management by the NSW Trustee and Guardian dated 8 July 2010; (iii)Letter from Jane Burford, Epilepsy Nurse Specialist at Epilepsy Action Australia dated 26 May 2021 (iv)Letter from Debasis Karanjai of Myhealth Blacktown Medical Centre dated 3 June 2021 (v)Letter from Dr Kyle Lloyd, Resident Medical Officer, Neurology dated 9 May 2022 (vi)Adapt Housing, Specialist Disability Accommodation Quote dated 2 August 2022(vii)NSW Trustee & Guardian, Notice Pursuant to s122(2) of the NSW Trustee and Guardian Act 2009 dated 16 November 2022

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Regarding the request for additional care, the Tribunal notes that although the Applicant’s Statement of Lived Experience identified the need for nursing care, at other times the Applicant referred only to care, or to support workers. The Tribunal accepts that the Applicant was seeking additional support workers at a 1:1 ratio of care, but since the Applicant withdrew this request, considers that the nature of the care is immaterial.Evidence Relied upon In making the determination, the Tribunal relied on evidence provided by the parties at the hearing, The substantiative evidence provided in the T-Documents were as follows:(i)Report of Sadiq Rehmani, Occupational Therapist dated 24 December 2021 (ii)Certificate of Management by the NSW Trustee and Guardian dated 8 July 2010; (iii)Letter from Jane Burford, Epilepsy Nurse Specialist at Epilepsy Action Australia dated 26 May 2021 (iv)Letter from Debasis Karanjai of Myhealth Blacktown Medical Centre dated 3 June 2021 (v)Letter from Dr Kyle Lloyd, Resident Medical Officer, Neurology dated 9 May 2022 (vi)Adapt Housing, Specialist Disability Accommodation Quote dated 2 August 2022(vii)NSW Trustee & Guardian, Notice Pursuant to s122(2) of the NSW Trustee and Guardian Act 2009 dated 16 November 2022 In addition to the documents provided to assist the Tribunal, the Applicant also submitted a number of photographs of her living arrangements, notes from medical practitioners and prescriptions for Midazolam and Clobazam (the contents of which were unable to be verified) and various screenshots of equipment such as an oxygen cylinder. Additionally, in making her case, the Applicant placed reliance on various witnesses. These included:(a)Ms Jane Burford (A Registered Nurse at Epilepsy Action Australia)(b)Ms Huda Ibrheem (Applicant’s Support Provider)(c)Ms Robyn Goodman (The Applicant’ Former Support Person)(d)Dr A. Zaki At the final day of hearing the last two abovementioned witnesses (Ms Goodman and Dr Zaki) were due to give evidence. The Applicant’s Representative informed the Tribunal that Dr Zaki would make himself available at the hearing to clarify the medical evidence, but they did not intend to call him as a witness. The Respondent instead attempted to locate Dr Zaki and confirm his availability to give evidence. However, this attempt failed and accordingly, the medical note and prescription for Clobazam allegedly provided by him could not be verified. In respect of Ms Goodman, the Tribunal was open to hearing evidence from her given her position as the Applicant’s former support person. She had also provided a short letter to the Tribunal in support of the Applicant. Her contact number and availability were provided to the Tribunal ahead of time and in order to accommodate her, the final day of hearing commenced in the late afternoon. Numerous attempts were made to contact Ms Goodman at that time, but all attempts failed. Accordingly, the Tribunal could not clarify or confirm the contents of that letter.Contentions(a) Dismissal of the Application

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicant sought review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of a decision of a delegate of the CEO of the Respondent of 2 December 2022 (the decision under review). This had affirmed an earlier decision in relation to the Applicant’s Statement of Participant Supports (SOPS), included in her plan of 7 October 2022.That plan included a SOPS made pursuant to section 33(2) of the National Disability Insurance SchemeAct 2013 (Cth) (the Act), and provided total funded supports of $368,432.23 comprised of: (a)Core supports of $281,043.13; (b)Transport funding of $1,784.00; (c)Improved Life Choices (CB Choice and Control) supports of $1,485.75; (d)Improved Daily Living (CB Daily Activity) supports of $13,935.62 (including 35 hours for occupational therapist, including assessment for assistive technology, 11 hours for speech pathology (for review of mealtime management plan), 22 hours for physiotherapy and six hours for a continence assessment); (e)Improved Relationships (CB Relationships) supports of $9,842.44 (including 40 hours of specialist behaviour intervention support and 20 hours of behaviour management plan and training in behaviour management strategies); (f)Support Coordination of $23,059.60; (g)Assistive Technology of $18,000.00 (rental cost for a power chair whilst waiting for new equipment and funding for electric bed and recliner pending trail and completion of assessment and quote, as well as repairs and maintenance of existing equipment); and (h)Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA) up to $51,651.47 per year (high physical support, apartment, two bedrooms, two residents, NSW – Sydney, Blacktown). On 7 October 2022, the Applicant requested an internal review of her SOPS pursuant to s100 of the Act. On 2 December 2022, a delegate of the CEO of the Respondent made a decision confirming the original decision pursuant to s100(6)(a) of the Act. Particularly, the following requested supports were found to be not reasonable and necessary having regard to s34(1) of the Act and the Rules: (a)funding for SDA single occupancy; (b)to change plan management with all products changed to self-managed within the plan budget; and (c)increased funding for daily activity supports with 24-hour support worker assistance. On 20 December 2022, the Applicant lodged an application for review of the decision with the Tribunal. On 10 February 2023, the Respondent filed a request to issue summons to: (a)NSW Trustee and Guardian; (b)Epilepsy Action Australia; (c)Inspire Health Care; and (d)Myhealth Blacktown. On 1 March 2023, the Tribunal made an order pursuant to s40B (1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act), giving the parties leave to inspect summonsed material produced from the parties as identified at paragraph 6 (a) to (c) outlined above. On 15 March 2023, the Tribunal made a further order pursuant to s40B (1) of the AAT Act, giving the parties leave to inspect summonsed material at paragraph 6 (d). The Applicant objected to the Respondent inspecting the summonsed material.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Part 2 of the SDA Rules sets out the matters to be determined by the CEO in respect of each eligible participant, including the building type, design category and location of the SDA. Operational Guidelines The Respondent has developed operational guidelines to regulate its application of the Act and the Rules. The operational guideline generally relevant to the planning process is the Planning Operational Guideline.Background The Applicant currently lives alone in a two-person apartment on the first floor of an apartment block in the western suburbs of Sydney and has no family or other informal support. The Applicant is wheelchair bound and significantly sight-impaired. She is highly dependent on assistance for many activities of daily living but nevertheless, is a bright and engaged young woman of strong opinions and personality. Considering her complex array of impairments, it was not always clear whether the Applicant’s at times dysregulated behaviour, both during and outside hearings, was the consequence of those impairments or of personal choices. Suffice it to say, the Applicant’s actions significantly undermined her position and required, eventually, that she be removed from the hearing room. The Applicant has been under the auspices of the NSW Public Guardian since 2010 with several guardianship orders over that time. Most recently, on 1 November 2023, the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal, NCAT, ordered that the Applicant be subject to a guardianship order for a period of twelve months from that date. Despite the guardianship order, counsel assisting the Applicant advised the Tribunal that she was capable of providing instructions and proceeded to represent her on that basis. The Hearing was held in person on both days to accommodate the needs of the Applicant. The Applicant was represented and after her evidence had been given, was expected to remain silent, relying upon her counsel to represent her. Issues The Respondent sought an interlocutory hearing for dismissal of the application on the grounds of impedance to the Tribunal’s objective of reviewing the Applicant’s request and the Applicant’s failure to progress the matter. On the final day of the hearing the Applicant submitted that there was insufficient evidence of probative value to support the requested supports of (a) and (c) but submitted there was sufficient evidence to demonstrate the need for sole occupancy SDA, high physical support, (b). For completion, the Tribunal notes the following additional supports were originally sought by the Applicant:(a)24/7 support delivered at a 1:1 ratio of care; (b)sole occupancy SDA, high physical support; and (c)the management of her SOPS to be self-managed. Regarding the request for additional care, the Tribunal notes that although the Applicant’s Statement of Lived Experience identified the need for nursing care, at other times the Applicant referred only to care, or to support workers. The Tribunal accepts that the Applicant was seeking additional support workers at a 1:1 ratio of care, but since the Applicant withdrew this request, considers that the nature of the care is immaterial.Evidence Relied upon