ZNDV and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

[2014] AATA 921 

Division NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number

2014/2438

Re

ZNDV

APPLICANT

And

National Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President K Bean
Mr I Thompson, Member

Date 25 November 2014
Date of written reasons 11 December 2014
Place Adelaide

The decision under review is varied so as to incorporate the terms of a further plan (numbered 2 – X2ZHFT – V 4.2) printed by the respondent on 12 November 2014, with a review date of 6 February 2015, and which is annexed to this Decision.

..............................................................

Deputy President K Bean

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – Early intervention requirements – Asperger’s disorder – Reasonable and necessary supports – Occupational therapy room and equipment in applicant’s home – Whether support represents value for money – Support not reasonable, relative to likely benefits – Decision under review varied to incorporate terms of further plan agreed to by parties.

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013, ss 3(d), 5(f), 6, 21(1), 22, 23, 25, 34, 117, 209

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Facilitating the Preparation of Participants' Plan-South Australia) Rules 2013
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2013
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, subs 35(2)

SECONDARY MATERIALS

American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th ed, Text Revision, Washington DC, 2000)

American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed, Washington DC, 2013)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President K Bean
Mr I Thompson, Member

11 December 2014

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made on 16 April 2014 by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) in relation to a Support Plan for the applicant, which commenced on 4 December 2013.

  2. The applicant is now five years old, he has one brother and both boys live with their parents. His requests to the NDIA, and his requests for review of the relevant decisions, including his application to this Tribunal, have been made by his mother on his behalf.

  3. The NDIA granted the applicant access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) in accordance with the early intervention requirements in s 25 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013. The NDIA accepted that the applicant is a child with Asperger’s syndrome and he experiences developmental delay in areas of social interaction.[1]

    [1]  T6/61.

  4. We should also explain that, because the applicant is a child, at an early stage of the proceedings, the Tribunal made a confidentiality order under subs 35(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act). By that order, the Tribunal directed that the hearing take place in private, gave directions as to persons who could be present at the hearing, and prohibited disclosure of information that may identify the applicant.

  5. Following the hearing on 18 November 2014, our Decision and Reasons were delivered orally on 25 November 2014. This written version of our Reasons has been prepared at the request of the NDIA.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ZNDV and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 921
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of ZNDV and the National Disability Insurance Agency, the applicant sought funding for an occupational therapy room and equipment to be installed in their home for their child, who has been diagnosed with Asperger's disorder. The dispute was brought before the tribunal to determine whether the requested support was reasonable and necessary under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013. The tribunal was tasked with considering whether the proposed equipment met the criteria for being a reasonable and necessary support, particularly focusing on whether it represented value for money relative to the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative supports.

The key legal issue before the tribunal was whether the proposed occupational therapy room and equipment represented value for money, as required by subsection 34(1)(c) of the Act. The tribunal had to evaluate the costs and benefits of the proposed support, taking into account the evidence presented, including expert opinions and the potential long-term benefits of the equipment. The tribunal also considered whether there were alternative supports that could achieve similar outcomes at a lower cost. The decision hinged on whether the benefits of the proposed equipment were substantial and long-term, and if it would reduce the overall cost of supporting the participant in the future.

After reviewing the evidence, the tribunal determined that while the applicant's parents and some therapists believed the occupational therapy room would be beneficial, it did not meet the criteria for being a reasonable and necessary support under the Act. The tribunal found that there was insufficient evidence to conclude that the equipment would substantially improve the child's life stage outcomes or be of long-term benefit. Additionally, the tribunal noted that there were alternative supports that could be explored, which might achieve similar outcomes at a lower cost. Consequently, the tribunal varied the decision under review to incorporate the terms of a further plan agreed upon by the parties, which did not include funding for the occupational therapy room and equipment.

The tribunal's decision underscores the importance of a thorough evaluation of proposed supports under the NDIS, ensuring that any funding decisions are based on evidence of long-term benefits and value for money. The final orders of the tribunal reflected the agreement between the parties on the revised support plan, excluding the contested occupational therapy room and equipment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

We will next outline what we consider to be the most salient aspects of the documentary evidence, before turning to the oral evidence given at the hearing.The Documentary EvidenceReports of Mr Dino Mennillo – Director, Occupational Therapy for Children Mr Mennillo is an occupational therapist who has been involved in providing occupational therapy to the applicant through the business Occupational Therapy for Children (OTFC) since March 2013. We understand that whilst the applicant’s treating occupational therapist at OTFC is Mr Klaassen-Smith (whose reports will be discussed below), Mr Mennillo has supervised the therapy provided by Mr Klaassen-Smith and also undertaken some assessments of the applicant. The material before us includes a number of reports from Mr Mennillo, which we will discuss in date order. The first report from Mr Mennillo that we have is a report to the applicant’s treating general practitioner, on 4 March 2013[10]. In that report Mr Mennillo indicated that the applicant was progressing well and did not have a high need for ongoing occupational therapy: This evaluation did not indicate any processing deficits. [The applicant] is an exceptional young boy and I feel that it is his IQ rather than his actual Asperger’s Syndrome that sets him apart from other children his age.…There was some modulation difficulties with ‘filtering in’ and ‘filtering out’ amounts of sensory input that impact on [the applicant’s] tolerance to noise, touch, clothing textures etc. However, these are not of significant concern and are quite consistent for children his age.…I indicated to [the applicant’s mother] that she will also potentially need to use her FaHCSIA funding for the provision of equipment or other items as I do not feel that [the applicant] has a high degree of need for ongoing OT, speech or any other type of therapy.[11]We also note that in an assessment conducted in March 2013, Mr Mennillo found that the applicant was average or above average in all areas, apart from “sensory identification of fingers” and “draw a person” where he was below average. His overall total score was in the 83rd percentile.[12][10] T19/126.[11] T19/127.[12] T19/128 – 129. However it appears that subsequent to Mr Mennillo’s report of March 2013, the possibility of an occupational therapy or “sensory room” was raised with Mr Mennillo. In a report dated 9 October 2013[13], Mr Mennillo stated as follows:[The applicant] has been a client of OTFC since April 2013. His diagnosis of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is compounded by presenting sensory issues, most notably difficulty modulating Sensory input. The visible component of this for a young boy with ASD includes difficulty regulating arousal level throughout the day, difficulty calming when anxious and over reactions to seemingly innocuous input i.e. sounds. A significant part of therapy for [the applicant] has focused on sensory modulation and teaching [the applicant] how to regulate himself, with the assistance of his parents and carers. Commonly, this is referred to as a “Sensory diet” and for many children is included as part of the ‘alert program’ for sensory regulation.In discussion with [the applicant’s] treating therapist and in consultation with his parents, … it is felt that [the applicant] will continue to benefit from a sensory diet for many years to come. With this in mind [the applicant’s] parents have begun the process of converting a garage at their home into a ‘Sensory room’ to provided [sic] [the applicant] with regular opportunities to engage in self-regulatory activities. This is a commendable commitment and one that is fully supported by this practice. Funding a Sensory room is expensive, items need to be chosen carefully and a child requires supervision at all times. [The applicant’s mother] has received ongoing education regarding the use and timing of such equipment and I support her request for assistance without reservation or hesitation.[14][13] T27/244.[14] T27/244.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In deciding what are reasonable and necessary supports, the Tribunal must also take into account the requirements of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013. In particular, Part 3 of the Rules provides context for the meaning of “value for money” (Rule 3.1), “Effective and beneficial and current good practice” (Rule 3.2 and Rule 3.3), “Reasonable family, carer and other support” (Rule 3.4), and “Supports appropriately funded or provided through the NDIS” (Rule 3.5, Rule 3.6 and Rule 3.7).THE APPLICANT’S PLAN AND THE DECISION UNDER REVIEW As we have already mentioned, in November 2013, the CEO of the NDIA approved a plan for the applicant to commence on 4 December 2013 with a review scheduled for 3 June 2014. The plan included funding for an early intervention program totalling 48 hours of therapeutic supports over 24 weeks (including speech therapy and occupational therapy), group work with a psychologist, and expenses for travel for psychology sessions. Not all of the support requests were approved. In particular, the NDIA did not consider that funding for a “sensory room and the associated equipment” was a reasonable and necessary support under s 34 of the Act. The reason given to the applicant’s family was that a best practice review had concluded that there was no evidence that the provision of a sensory room and equipment would be effective or beneficial in assisting the applicant’s functional impairment, associated with Asperger’s syndrome. Other requested supports also were not approved. However, as we have already indicated, the issues arising out of that refusal have since been resolved by the parties. Before applying to the Tribunal, the applicant’s mother applied for an internal review of the original decision of the NDIA, in accordance with subs 99(d) and subs 100(2) of the Act. One of the outcomes she sought was funding for occupational therapy equipment for the applicant at home. In respect to that request, the NDIA made a determination to vary the original reviewable decision[4] and the effect of the variation was that the approved supports would be provided as a package of flexible therapeutic services through a transdisciplinary approach. However, the reviewer did not vary that part of the original decision which had denied the request for occupational therapy equipment.[4] Subsection 100(6)(b) of the Act. It appears that the main effect of the decision on review was to provide greater flexibility to the applicant’s parents to discuss the quantity of service provision with chosen service providers. In declining to agree to the request for support to install occupational therapy equipment at the applicant’s home, the NDIA stated that it did not “regard it as reasonable and necessary to fund any kind of therapy equipment in the home that is accessible through the community / therapy visits or with consideration expectation (sic) of what a parent would provide in terms of toys, sporting and hobby equipment that meet [the applicant’s] development needs and interests.”[5] The NDIA added that they recommended “… a discussion with the Occupational Therapist to identify appropriate options for a program of activities for [the applicant] to access within local community facilities to assist [the applicant] to achieve his goals and subsequently address some of the factors the family faces …”.[6][5] T2/25.[6] T2/25.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Ashburner also commented that therapies such as sensory integration therapy seemed to be based on an assumption that it was possible to retrain the brain or “fix” the impairments of people with ASD. However, in her opinion, it was more a question of managing these impairments or traits, rather than fixing or eliminating them. She also indicated that there were many ways of approaching issues such as turn-taking and sequencing, and the need to release emotion. She said it was not necessary to have particular equipment to address these issues. Dr Ashburner indicated she did not consider that an occupational therapy room would be of long-term benefit to the applicant.Consideration As we have indicated above, in considering whether the requested items of equipment are “reasonable and necessary supports”, we are required to have regard to the criteria in sub 34(1) of the Act, as further elaborated in the Rules. Importantly, the criteria set out in subs 34(1) are cumulative, so that if the equipment does not meet all of the criteria, it will not be a “reasonable and necessary” support for the purpose of s 34. It is in this context that we propose to first address criterion subs 34(1)(c): “the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support.”Value for money In addressing this criterion, we should first acknowledge that we accept that the applicant’s parents firmly believe that having occupational therapy equipment at home will be of significant benefit to him. We also accept that a number of the therapists involved with treating the applicant, including Mr Mennillo and Mr Klaassen-Smith, also consider that an occupational therapy room will be of benefit to the applicant, albeit that the idea to establish the room emanated from the applicant’s parents rather than from them. Ultimately, however, we consider that in applying the NDIS legislation, it is our role to evaluate the respective costs and benefits of a proposed support having regard to all of the evidence available to us. In determining whether the relevant equipment represents value for money within the meaning of subs 34(1)(c), we note that the Rules require us to have regard, amongst other things, to:…(a) whether there are comparable supports which would achieve the same outcome at a substantially lower cost;(b)whether there is evidence that the support will substantially improve the life stage outcomes for, and be of long-term benefit to, the participant;(c) whether funding or provision of the support is likely to reduce the cost of the funding of supports for the participant in the long term (for example, some early intervention supports may be value for money given their potential to avoid or delay reliance on more costly supports);…(f)whether the support will increase the participant’s independence and reduce the participant’s need for other kinds of supports (for example, some home modifications may reduce a participant’s need for home care).