McPherson and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

McPherson and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 4303 (20 November 2018)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:           2018/1251

Re:Mark McPherson

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr L Bygrave, Member

Date:20 November 2018

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

......................[sgd]..............................................

Dr L Bygrave, Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports – muscular dystrophy – anxiety/depression – whether NDIA should fund a private motor vehicle – applicant seeking to access community independently – difficult to use public transport or accessible taxis – no current driver’s licence – impact on financial sustainability of the NDIS – whether funding a private motor vehicle is consistent with the Supports for Participants Rules/Operational Guideline – whether a private motor vehicle is a reasonable and necessary support within the context of section 34(1) – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 3, 4, 34, 103, 209

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

CASES

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Operational Guideline – Including specific types of supports in plans

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr L Bygrave, Member

20 November 2018

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Mr Mark McPherson, is 27 years old and resides in the inner west area of Sydney. He has diagnoses of limb girdle muscular dystrophy and anxiety/depression, which affect his mobility and community access. His condition of muscular dystrophy causes weakness and wasting of the muscles in his arms and legs and, since suffering a leg fracture in 2013, he relies on an electric-powered wheelchair and requires a hoist for transfers.

  2. Mr McPherson became a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the NDIS or Scheme) on 19 April 2017 and subsequently requested funding for a private motor vehicle in his NDIS plan. His first NDIS plan commenced on 29 June 2017 but did not include funding for a private motor vehicle.

  3. Mr McPherson sought a review of this decision and, on 12 March 2018, an internal review by the National Disability Insurance Agency (the NDIA) affirmed the decision to not fund the cost of a private motor vehicle.

  4. On 14 March 2018, Mr McPherson applied to the NDIS Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) for review.

  5. Pursuant to section 103 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (the Act), the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the internal review decision made by the NDIA.

  6. The matter was heard in Sydney on 12 and 18 October 2018. Mr McPherson did not have legal representation; he attended the hearing on 12 October 2018 in person and gave oral evidence, and attended the hearing on 18 October 2018 by conference telephone.

    ISSUE

  7. The issue for determination by the Tribunal is whether providing funding for a private motor vehicle for Mr McPherson is a “reasonable and necessary support” as set…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McPherson and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 4303
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr McPherson to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) challenging a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). Mr McPherson sought funding for a private motor vehicle, modified to enable him to drive independently, to facilitate his access to the community. He argued that his muscular dystrophy and anxiety/depression made public transport and accessible taxis extremely difficult to use, and that a private vehicle was essential for his independence, allowing him to engage in social, educational, and employment activities. The NDIA had refused funding for the vehicle.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether funding a private motor vehicle for Mr McPherson constituted a "reasonable and necessary support" under section 34(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). This involved considering whether the proposed support was consistent with the Supports for Participants Rules and relevant Operational Guidelines, and whether it was appropriate in the context of the NDIS's financial sustainability and the potential for inequity among participants.

The Tribunal found that Mr McPherson's request for funding was speculative. While acknowledging his desire for independence and the difficulties he faced with existing transport options, the Tribunal noted that Mr McPherson did not currently hold a driver's licence. Crucially, there was no expert evidence from medical practitioners, an occupational therapist, or relevant government bodies regarding his potential to obtain a licence given his conditions. Furthermore, the Tribunal lacked clear, objective documentation detailing the specific vehicle modifications required for him to drive independently. The Tribunal also considered submissions regarding the financial sustainability of the NDIS and the risk of inequity if private vehicles were funded for some participants but not others, accepting that funding regular daily living expenses could pose such risks.

Consequently, the Tribunal was not satisfied that providing funding for a private motor vehicle for Mr McPherson met the criteria of a "reasonable and necessary support." The decision under review, which affirmed the NDIA's refusal to fund the vehicle, was therefore affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There is substantial evidence before the Tribunal in relation to Mr McPherson’s requirements for a private motor vehicle/transport to access the community, and his requirements in relation to his electric-powered wheelchair. The evidence set out below relates solely to the issue of funding a private motor vehicle for Mr McPherson.Mr McPherson’s evidence Mr McPherson currently lives at home with his mother who provides him full-time care. This care includes transferring Mr McPherson between his bed and electric-powered wheelchair using a hoist, assisting him with toileting and bathing, and preparing his meals. Mr McPherson said he is reasonably independent in his mobility once he is sitting in his electric-powered wheelchair. Mr McPherson’s NDIS plan includes funding of $74,460 for core supports, which may be used to pay for carers or attendants. Both Mr McPherson and the NDIA told the Tribunal he has accessed only a small amount of this core supports funding as he does not use (or uses in a very limited way) a carer or attendant. In oral evidence to the Tribunal, Mr McPherson indicated there were two reasons for not using a carer; firstly, his mother’s care currently meets his needs, and secondly, he has not been able to access a suitable carer. In his oral and written evidence to the Tribunal, Mr McPherson strongly emphasised his desire for independence. He told the Tribunal at the hearing that a private motor vehicle would allow him to leave his home, meet with friends, travel alone to medical appointments, undertake study and participate in employment, attend family functions and sporting events, build and maintain his personal relationships, shop for groceries and go to cafes. Mr McPherson acknowledged that he needs assistance from other people due to his muscular dystrophy and anxiety but – understandably – he asserted his desire to live his life as independently as possible. Mr McPherson stated his goal to independently access the community would be achieved if he owned a private motor vehicle that was modified to enable him to drive it. He provided a quote from Freedom Motors Australia dated 10 April 2018, which priced a current KIA Carnival YP S model including road costs as $41,843.50 (price subject to change) and additional costs associated with modifying the vehicle for wheelchair use. Mr McPherson explained that a vehicle could be modified using a “space drive system” that would enable him to access and drive the vehicle without the assistance of another person. Mr McPherson held a full driver’s license prior to 2013. He currently does not hold a driver’s license and, at the date of the Tribunal hearing, he had not undertaken a medical assessment, driving assessment by an occupational therapist (OT) or an OT driving test, which are some of the procedures he is required to complete before he can acquire a driver’s license. Mr McPherson stated that his financial situation precludes him from saving the money required to purchase a private motor vehicle. In his written statement dated 5 September 2018, he noted:Why I need the NDIS to fund me a motor vehicle and modificationMy only form of income support I have is from my mother/sole carer, she is on a carer’s pension. So the unrealistic expectation for me to fund my own vehicle with less than 100,000km and under three years old is unrealistic as that pretty much means a brand-new car which is more than two years the amount I get paid annually. If I were not disabled I could buy a $2000 car and be fine, however because of my disability I cannot go out and buy a $2000 car. And then we get to second hand vehicles, for a reliable engine vehicle with a modification already installed it costs upwards of $20,000. And then every modification is fitted to the disabled occupant so someone’s needs might be met but not mine and keeping the high price tag of $20,000 this is unachievable for me.[3][3] Exhibit ST-ST8, p 219.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons set out above, I am not satisfied that providing funding for a private motor vehicle for Mr McPherson is a “reasonable and necessary support” as defined in subsection 34(1) of the Act.DECISION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Despite my request, the Actuary did not appear at the Tribunal hearing to provide oral evidence and so it was not possible to examine any assumptions that may underlie the Actuary’s calculations and the Actuary’s concerns about the “ripple effect” as contended in their report. Nonetheless, I accept the Actuary’s submissions that there would be risks to the financial sustainability of the NDIS if the Scheme were to pay “regular daily living expenses that are an ordinary cost of life for all Australians”, and there could be “risks of inequity between various cohorts of participants” if funding for private vehicles is provided for one group of participants and not another group.[10][10] Exhibit ST-ST9, p 233.CONSIDERATION Based on the evidence before the Tribunal, I make the following findings of fact:·Mr McPherson is seeking funding for a private motor vehicle that is fully modified for him to drive so that he is able to access the community independently.·The cost of this private motor vehicle is approximately $41,843.50 (plus additional costs associated with modifying the vehicle to enable Mr McPherson to drive it independently).·Mr McPherson does not have a current driver’s licence.·Due to his combined conditions of muscular dystrophy and anxiety/depression, Mr McPherson finds it extremely difficult to use public transport or accessible taxis to access the community.·Mr McPherson currently owns a motor vehicle that has been modified to transport a person in a wheelchair and may be driven by an adult with a driver’s licence.·In his NDIS plan that commenced on 4 June 2018, Mr McPherson has funding in the amount of $74,460 for core supports, which includes support to pay for a carer to drive his motor vehicle. Mr McPherson has only used a small amount of this funding to date. It is clear from these findings that the issue before the Tribunal – to decide whether funding a private motor vehicle for Mr McPherson is a reasonable and necessary support in accordance with the Act – is speculative. This is because Mr McPherson does not currently hold a driver’s licence. Further, there is no evidence before the Tribunal from medical practitioners, an OT or the NSW Department of Roads and Maritime Services about Mr McPherson’s potential to obtain a driver’s licence in view of his conditions of muscular dystrophy and anxiety/depression. The issue is also speculative because there is no clear and objective documentation before the Tribunal (or the NDIA) about the sort of vehicle modifications that would be required for Mr McPherson to be able to drive independently. Rather, the only information is Mr McPherson’s oral evidence and a brief statement in Ms Spencer’s OT report, which is based on information they obtained from a visit to Problem Management Engineering (a company that undertakes vehicle modifications). I also note that changes in technology, including developments such as self-driving vehicles, may assist Mr McPherson in his goal to drive a vehicle independently. However, again there is no expert evidence before the Tribunal.