Babscay Pty Ltd v Pitcher Partners (a Firm)

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Babscay Pty Ltd v Pitcher Partners (a firm) [2019] FCA 480

File numbers: VID 1188 of 2017
VID 918 of 2018
Judge: MIDDLETON J
Date of judgment: 15 March 2019
Date of publication of reasons: 8 April 2019
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – consideration of application by second and fourth to eight cross-respondents for summary dismissal or permanent stay of cross-claims – where cross-claims said to be futile or hopeless – where apportionment of liability regime applies – where application requires consideration of complex questions of law and application to the facts – application dismissed with costs reserved
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 1041L, 1041N, 1041P

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 31A, 37M

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), r 26

Cases cited:

ABN AMRO Bank NV v Bathurst Regional Council (2014) 224 FCR 1

BrisConnections Finance Pty Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed) v Arup Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1077

Brown v Forest Hill Shopping Centre Pty Ltd (unreported, Ryan, Heerey and Sackville JJ, 25 March 1996)

Bryan v Maloney (1995) 182 CLR 609

Digi-Tech (Australia) Ltd v Brand (2004) 62 IPR 184

Dymocks Book Arcade Pty Ltd v Capral Ltd [2010] NSWSC 195

Hunt & Hunt Lawyers v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd (2013) 247 CLR 613

Jefferson Ford Pty Ltd v Ford Motor Co of Australia Ltd [2008] FCAFC 60

Latteria Holdings Pty Ltd v Corcoran Parker Pty Ltd (2014) 224 FCR 519

Nichol v Discovery Africa Ltd [2016] FCAFC 182

Podrebersek v Australian Iron and Steel Pty Ltd (1985) 59 ALJR 492

Pow v Davis (1861) 1 B & S 220; 121 ER 697

Power Infrastructure Pty Lt v Downer EDI Engineering Power Pty Ltd (No 4) [2012] FCA 143

Reinhold v New South Wales Lotteries Corporation (No 2) (2008) 82 NSWLR 762

Shrimp v Landmark Operations Ltd (2007) 163 FCR 510

St George Bank Ltd v Quinerts Pty Ltd (2009) 25 VR 666

Taylor v Saloniklis [2013] FCA 679

Trade Practices Commission v CC (New South Wales) Pty Ltd (No 4) (1995) 58 FCR 426

United Salvage Pty Ltd v Louis Dreyfus Armateurs SNC [2006] FCA 116

Date of hearing: 13 February 2019 and 15 March 2019
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 102
Counsel for the Applicant in VID 1188 of 2017: Mr R G Craig with Mr K A Loxley
Solicitor for the Applicant in VID 1188 of 2017: Johnson Winter & Slattery
Counsel for the Respondent in VID 1188 of 2017 and VID 918 of 2018: Mr N J Young QC and Mr M S Osborne QC, with Mr J P Tomlinson and Mr J A Davaris
Solicitor for the Respondent in VID 1188 of 2017 and VID 918 of 2018: SBA Law
Counsel for the Applicant in VID 918 of 2018: Mr W A D Edwards with Mr D J Fahey
Solicitor for the Applicant in VID 918 of 2018:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Babscay Pty Ltd v Pitcher Partners (a Firm) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 480
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Babscay Pty Ltd v Pitcher Partners (a Firm), the parties involved were Babscay Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, and Pitcher Partners, the defendant, along with several other cross-respondents. The primary dispute revolved around claims that Pitcher Partners, an accounting firm, engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct which led to the issuance of erroneous financial statements by S&G, a company. This conduct allegedly caused Babscay and a group of associated parties to acquire S&G shares at inflated prices. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The legal issues at the core of this case included the interpretation and application of the apportionment of liability regime under various Australian statutes and the assessment of whether the cross-claims brought by the cross-respondents were futile or hopeless. The court had to determine if the cross-claims could proceed given the complex interplay between the apportionment of liability provisions and the nature of the claims presented.

The court dismissed the applications for summary dismissal or permanent stay of the cross-claims. The reasoning involved a detailed examination of the apportionment of liability provisions and their applicability to the facts of the case. The court concluded that the cross-claims required a thorough consideration of complex legal questions and their application to the specific circumstances, thus they were not futile or hopeless. Consequently, the applications for summary determination were rejected, and costs were reserved for future determination.

No additional orders were made apart from those mentioned, which were either made by consent or related to case management matters. The Federal Court Rules 2011 were referenced in relation to the entry of orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Cross Respondents’ Applications for Summary Determination of the Cross-Claims

3. The Second and Fourth to Eighth Cross Respondents’ 26 November 2018 applications to summarily determine the Cross Claimant’s cross claims are dismissed with costs reserved.

Orders 1–2 and 4–19 are not addressed in these reasons for judgment as those orders were made by consent or related to case management matters.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before I proceed further, I need to briefly describe the background to the proceedings and the various claims made by the parties.BACKGROUND The scheme of arrangement and Hall proceeding settlement deed The Applicants in each proceeding previously brought shareholder class actions against S&G. Those claims were settled by the entering into of a deed of settlement executed on 21 September 2017 between Mr Hall and S&G and others (‘Settlement Deed’) and a scheme of arrangement between S&G and shareholder claimants (‘Scheme’). The Settlement Deed and the Scheme contain, for present purposes, the same rights and obligations. The Scheme relevantly contains the following definitions, many of which appear in similar terms in the Settlement Deed:“Permitted Claims” means Claims brought against a Third Party other than a Released Person in the Federal Court of Australia arising out of or in connection with a Shareholder Claim and are apportionable Claims by operation of the Proportionate Liability Provisions.“Proportionate Liability Provisions” means(a)Part 2, Division 2, Subdivision GA of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth);(b)Part 7.10, Division 2A of the Corporations Act;(c)Part VIA of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth);(d)Part 4 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW);(e)Part IVAA of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic);(f)Chapter 2, Part 2 of the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld);(g)Part 3, Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Apportionment of Liability) Act 2001 (SA);(h)Part 1F of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (WA);(i)Part 9A of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (Tas);(j)Chapter 7A of the Civil Law (Wrongs) Act 2002 (ACT); and(k)Proportionate Liability Act 2005 (NT).“Released Claim” means any Claim against any Released Person …“Released Person” means:(a)the Company [S&G], its Related Bodies Corporate and their Related Entities; and(b)any present or past Officer, employee, servant or agent of any of the entities referred to in (a) above.“Shareholder Claim” means any Claim against Released Persons arising from or in connection with any fact, matter, circumstance or event occurring at any time in the 6 year period on or before the Proof Lodgement Date and which arises:(a)in a person’s capacity as:(i) a member of the Company (including as a Shareholder); or(ii) a holder or beneficiary (whether directly or indirectly) of any Security or Financial Product in the Company; or (b)from a person buying, acquiring, holding, selling, transferring, converting or otherwise dealing (whether directly or indirectly) in any Shares, Security or other Financial Product in the Company.“Shareholder Claimant” means any person who has a Shareholder Claim …“Third Party” means any person who is not a Released Person. The following aspects of the Settlement Deed and the Scheme should be noted. The Shareholder Claimants released the Released Persons (which includes the Directors) from any Released Claims and released all Third Parties from any Shareholder Claims other than Permitted Claims. Shareholder Claimants could pursue Permitted Claims.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The “causation chain” pleaded by Babscay is that Pitcher Partners’ misleading or deceptive representations caused S&G to publish erroneous financial statements and erroneous revenue guidance to the market, which in turn caused the market price of the S&G shares acquired by Babscay and the group members to be inflated. That is, the causation aspect underpinning the Babscay claim is a combination of indirect reliance and market based causation that Pitcher Partners’ wrongful conduct was relied on by S&G and thereby caused S&G to publish erroneous financial statements and guidance to the market (indirect reliance), which resulted in the market price of S&G shares being inflated and Babscay and group members acquiring their S&G shares at an inflated price (market based causation). There is no allegation that Babscay or any group member relied directly on: (a) Pitcher Partners’ representations; (b) S&G’s financial reports or revenue guidance; or (c) the directors’ reports and directors’ declarations in S&G’s financial statements for the financial years 2012 to 2015 or in S&G’s financial statements for the half-years ending 31 December 2012, 31 December 2013 and 31 December 2014 (the ‘Directors’ Reports and Declarations’). There is also no allegation in Babscay’s statement of claim that any of the Directors’ Reports and Declarations caused the market price of S&G shares to be inflated.Amended defence and cross-claims Pitcher Partners denies the allegations but says that, if it is liable to Babscay under the statement of claim, then each of the claims is an apportionable claim and that (inter alia) the Directors are concurrent wrongdoers and any liability of Pitcher Partners should therefore be limited. The amended defence also raises the independent claim referred to above, and significantly, also raises another matter which is separate and distinct from the apportionment defence, which is relevant to the cross-claims (which I will come to later). Just looking at the apportionment defence, it invokes indirect reliance and market based causation as the basis for the alleged liability of the Directors to Babscay for Babscay’s loss. As the Directors contended, the causation chain relied on is that:(1)two directors signed each of the Directors’ Reports and Declarations, which were misleading;(2)after which (and in reliance on which) Pitcher Partners issued its audit and review reports;(3)which (as alleged by Babscay in its statement of claim) caused S&G to publish erroneous financial statements and erroneous revenue guidance to the market; and (4)which (as also alleged by Babscay in its statement of claim) caused the market price of the S&G shares acquired by Babscay to be inflated. I will return to the amended cross-claims later.The Hall proceedingStatement of claim Mr Hall alleges Pitcher Partners represented to S&G shareholders, and to the market, that it had formed the opinion that S&G’s 2015 financial report gave a true and fair view of S&G’s financial position and performance and complied with the accounting standards, and that its opinion was based on reasonable grounds. Mr Hall alleges that Pitcher Partners’ representations were incorrect and Pitcher Partners thereby engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct.