IronStar Consulting Pty Ltd v Tully

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

Federal Court of Australia

IronStar Consulting Pty Ltd v Tully [2023] FCA 358

File number:

NSD 59 of 2022

Judgment of:

MARKOVIC J

Date of judgment:

20 April 2023

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – applications for discovery in categories –whether the discovery sought is necessary to facilitate the just resolution of the proceeding – whether the categories of discovery have been sufficiently addressed in the informal discovery process – whether categories of discovery sought are relevant to the issues in the proceeding – whether categories of discovery should be limited – discovery of some categories ordered

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)ss180, 181, 182, 183 and 191

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)rr 1.34, 20.13, 20.15, 20.16 and 20.17

Cases cited:

Fuji Xerox Australia Pty Ltd v Whittaker (No 2) [2021] FCA 696

Joint v Stephens [2008] VSCA 210

Division:

General Division

Registry:

New South Wales

National Practice Area:

Commercial and Corporations

Sub-area:

Corporations and Corporate Insolvency

Number of paragraphs:

59

Date of last submission/s:

25 November 2022 (Applicant)

2 December 2022 (First, Second and Fourth Respondents)

Date of hearing:

Determined on the papers

Solicitor for the Applicant:

Heathfield Grosvenor Lawyers

Solicitor for the First, Second and Fourth Respondents:

McCourts Solicitors

Counsel for the Third Respondent:

The Third Respondent was self-represented

ORDERS

NSD 59 of 2022

BETWEEN:

IRONSTAR CONSULTING PTY LTD ACN 166 792 267

Applicant

AND:

MR MARK TULLY

First Respondent

S.T.A.R. PROCUREMENT PTY LIMITED ACN 651 932 624

Second Respondent

MR KABEL VAFIOPULOUS (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

order made by:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 APril 2023

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

1.For the purposes of Orders 2 and3 belowthe term “Entities” is defined in Annexure A to these Orders.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

2.Pursuant to r 20.13 and r 20.15 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) the first, second and fourth respondents are to give discovery of documents in the following categories:

(a)all communications between the first respondent and/or second respondent and/or third respondent and/or any of the Entities, in the period 1 January 2021 to date;

(b)all quotes, tenders or requests made by the first respondent, second respondent and/or third respondent, to any of the Entities, in the period 1 January 2021 to date;

(c)all contracts, purchase orders or agreements entered into by the first respondent, second respondent and/or third respondent, with any of the Entities, in the period 1 January 2021 to date;

(d)all bank account statements of the first respondent into which funds from any of the Entities were deposited, in the period 1 January 2021 to date;

(e)all invoices issued by the second respondent to any of the Entities, in the period 1 June 2021 to date; and

(f)all financial records of the second respondent, including but not limited to bank account statements, profit and loss…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IronStar Consulting Pty Ltd v Tully and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 358
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

IronStar Consulting Pty Ltd, the applicant, sought an order for discovery of documents from several respondents, including A2B Australia Limited and others, as well as the applicant itself, in proceedings relating to various contracts and payments. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where the central issue was whether the categories of discovery sought by the parties were necessary for the just resolution of the proceeding and whether they were relevant to the issues in the case.

The court had to decide if the categories of discovery sought were necessary for the just resolution of the proceeding and if they were relevant to the issues at hand. Additionally, the court considered whether the categories of discovery should be limited in any way. The applicant argued that the discovery of certain documents was necessary for the just resolution of the proceeding, while the respondents contended that the scope of discovery should be narrowed to only those documents relevant to the issues in the case.

The court found that the discovery sought by the parties was necessary for the just resolution of the proceeding and that the categories of discovery were relevant to the issues in the case. The court also determined that some of the categories of discovery should be limited to ensure that the scope of the discovery was appropriate. As a result, the court ordered the parties to provide discovery of certain categories of documents, as outlined in the orders section.

In summary, the Federal Court of Australia granted the applicant's application for discovery of certain categories of documents from the respondents and the applicant itself. The court found that the discovery sought was necessary for the just resolution of the proceeding and relevant to the issues in the case. The court also limited some of the categories of discovery to ensure that the scope of the discovery was appropriate. The parties were ordered to provide the specified documents by a certain date, and costs and case management arrangements were also addressed in the orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. Pursuant to r 20.13 and r 20.15 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) the first, second and fourth respondents are to give discovery of documents in the following categories:

(a) all communications between the first respondent and/or second respondent and/or third respondent and/or any of the Entities, in the period 1 January 2021 to date;

(b) all quotes, tenders or requests made by the first respondent, second respondent and/or third respondent, to any of the Entities, in the period 1 January 2021 to date;

(c) all contracts, purchase orders or agreements entered into by the first respondent, second respondent and/or third respondent, with any of the Entities, in the period 1 January 2021 to date;

(d) all bank account statements of the first respondent into which funds from any of the Entities were deposited, in the period 1 January 2021 to date;

(e) all invoices issued by the second respondent to any of the Entities, in the period 1 June 2021 to date; and

(f) all financial records of the second respondent, including but not limited to bank account statements, profit and loss sheets, income and balance sheets, financial statements, and BAS reports, recording funds received from any of the Entities, in the period 1 June 2021 to date.

3. Pursuant to r 20.13 and r 20.15 of the Rules the applicant is to give discovery of documents in the following categories:

(a) records relating to any remuneration paid to directors including travelling and other expenses properly incurred in connection with the affairs of the applicant from 1 July 2016 to date;

(b) records of payment by the directors of interim and final dividends from 1 July 2016 to date;

(c) income tax returns of the applicant for the financial years ended 30 June 2017 to 30 June 2021;

(d) financial reports of the applicant including, but not limited to, profit and loss statements and balance sheets, for the financial years ended 30 June 2017 to 30 June 2021;

(e) draft financial reports of the applicant including, but not limited to, profit and loss statements and balance sheets, for the current financial year and the financial year ended 30 June 2022;

(f) records of:

(i) employment contracts in respect of any employee employed by the applicant;

(ii) PAYG or PAYE tax paid by the applicant in respect of any employee employed by the applicant;

(iii) superannuation paid in respect of any employee employed by the applicant;

(iv) workers compensation premiums paid in respect of any employee employed by the applicant;

(v) annual leave, sick leave, long service leave or any other type of leave to which an employee of the applicant was entitled;

from 1 July 2016 to date;

(g) all records and documents including, but not limited to, records and documents described as heads of agreement, co-operation agreement, terms of consultancy, being records and documents relating to binding contractual arrangements between the applicant and any of the Entities; and

(h) all records and documents concerning contact between the applicant (or Mr Jubian or any agent of the applicant) and any of the Entities relating to unpaid monies owing to the applicant pursuant to contractual rights or entitlements to ongoing income from 1 June 2021 to date.

4. Discovery of the documents referred to in Orders 2 and 3 above is to be made electronically by either email or Dropbox link, pursuant to r 20.13(4) and r 20.15(2) of the Rules.

5. Pursuant to r 1.34 of the Rules the requirement in r 20.16 and r 20.17 for the preparation and provision of a list of documents by the applicant or the first, second and fourth respondents is dispensed with.

6. The applicant, on the one hand, and the first, second and fourth respondents, on the other, are to each give discovery by producing the documents to be discovered by the electronic means identified in Order 4 above, by 18 May 2023.

7. Costs of the applicant’s interlocutory application filed on 31 August 2022 and costs of the first, second and fourth respondents’ interlocutory application filed on 21 September 2022 be costs in the cause.

8. If any party wishes to vary the costs orders made in Order 7 above, they are to file and serve their application seeking an alternative order on or before 27 April 2023.

9. The proceeding be listed for case management hearing on 31 May 2023 at 9.30 am AEST.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Annexure A to the Orders

The term “Entities” is defined to mean any of the 129 companies or other entities listed in the schedule to the IronStar Discovery Application and any “related entity” or “related body corporate” thereto as defined in the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

1

5G Network Operations Pty Ltd

2

A2B Australia Limited

3

Abco Products Pty Ltd

4

Ability First

5

AMC Commercial Cleaning Pty Ltd

6

Aptness Pty Ltd

7

ARA Group

8

Aspen Medical Pty Ltd

9

Assetlink Services Pty Ltd

10

Australian Beverage Corporation

11

Australian Financial Planning Group Pty Limited

12

BBC Digital Australia part of the BBC Digital Group. Berwicks (Gold Coast) Pty Ltd ATF The Gorski Family Trust A.B.N. 14 984 516 327 and Berwicks (Sunshine Coast) Pty Ltd ATF Berwicks Sunshine Coast Trust A.B.N. 53 147 233 423

13

BIC Services Pty Ltd

14

Britannia Metal Industries

15

Broadlex Services Pty Ltd

16

Bunzl Australia & New Zealand part of part of Bunzl Australasia

17

Cabcharge Australia Limited

18

Cairns Airport

19

Calvary Health is part of the Little Company of Mary, Calvary is a charitable, not-for- profit of the Catholic health care organisation

20

CDK Stone Pty Ltd

21

Central Cleaning Supplies

22

Challenger Services Group

23

Cirka Pty Ltd

24

City Tattersall’s Club

25

Cleaner Future

26

Cleaner Future Australia Pty Ltd

27

Collective Maintenance Services Pty ltd

28

Consolidated Property Services (Australia) Pty Ltd

29

Cricket Australia

30

Crown Property Services Pty Ltd

31

CSR Limited

32

CUB Private Business Club

33

Deelron - Ventia Limited group

34

Design Group (Design Sheetmetal Pty Ltd ATF Design Group)

35

Dexus Limited

36

Diamond Globe Pty Ltd

37

Dimeo Cleaning Services Pty Ltd

38

Doltone House Pty Ltd

39

Ecolab Australia Pty Ltd (Ecolab Inc.)

40

Ezko Property Services (Aust) Pty Ltd

41

Facilities First Australia

42

Flick Anticimex Pty Ltd

43

FMH Group

44

Fox Studios Australia

45

Frucor Beverages (Australia) Pty Limited

46

Gelatissimo Pty Ltd

47

George Weston Foods

48

Glad Group

49

Glascott Landscape & Civil

50

Globe Williams International

51

Golf NSW

52

Good Price Pharmacy

53

Hasspa Group

54

Healthia Limited

55

Hoyts Group, Hessel Group Hoyts

56

Hudor Integrated Services Pty Ltd

57

Hungry Jack's

58

Huxtaburger. Huxtaburger.com.au

59

IKON Services Australia Pty Ltd

60

Independent Living Villages Ltd

61

John Lyns Group

62

JS Hayes

63

Keyts Cleaning Services Pty

64

Larrakia Nation Aboriginal Corporation

65

Livingchoice

66

MA Services Group

67

Mad Mex

68

Menzies Group

69

Microguard

70

Millennium Services Group Limited

71

Modus Projects Pty Ltd

72

Montrose Therapy & Respite Services

73

Motto Motto Japanese

74

NorthCott

75

Novita

76

Oban Group

77

OCS Group Limited

78

Ozland Group Solutions

79

Pack & Send Systems Pty Ltd Pty

80

Palm Oasis Ventures Pty Ltd for Baskin-Robbin® Australia

81

PAYCE Consolidated Pty Ltd

82

Pickwick Group

83

Pirtek Fluid Systems

84

Pitchers Partners

85

Precise Air Group

86

Premier Packaging

87

PrompCorp

88

Quad Services

89

Quay Clean

90

ResMed

91

Roberts Co

92

Roll'd

93

Rowing Australia

94

Royal Wolf

95

San Churro

96

Schnitz

97

SCIS Property Group

98

Scope

99

Sheet Metal

100

Solotel

101

Sonic Healthcare

102

Southern Cross Group

103

Sparke Helmore Lawyers

104

Sportsbet

105

SSP, SSP Accounting

106

St Giles Society

107

Sumo Slad

108

SuperCars, V8 SuperCars

109

Surf Lakes

110

The myHomecare Group Australia T

111

Tiger Electrical Solutions Pty Ltd

112

TLC Health Care

113

TOGA Group

114

Total Ventilation & Hygiene Services Pty Ltd

115

Trident Services Australia

116

Tristar Medical

117

Umbrella Health

118

United Cinemas

119

Unity Waster

120

Ventia Pty

121

Vet Partners Australia Pty Ltd

122

Vibrant Security Services

123

Vivid Services

124

Wasteflex

125

Web central Group

126

Wests Tigers

127

Winc

128

Wycombe Services Pty Ltd / Cornerstone Health

129

Zippy Cleaning

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.