Axicom Inbuilding Solutions Pty Ltd v Australian Communications and Media Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Axicom Inbuilding Solutions Pty Ltd v Australian Communications and Media Authority [2023] FCA 1069

File number(s): NSD 1171 of 2021
Judgment of: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 8 September 2023
Catchwords:

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – judicial review of assessment of a “participating person’s eligible revenue for an eligible revenue period” under the Telecommunications Act and Telecommunications (Eligible Revenue) Determination (ER Determination) – where assessment of eligible revenue of the participating person included revenue of related entity – question as to whether “decisions” made at different stages in the process of decision-making are separate “decisions” as defined in s 3(1) of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act – construction of revenue “earned from an activity outside the telecommunications industry” under s 9(1) of the ER Determination – consideration of ordinary meaning and statutory meaning in the Telecommunications Act of the term “telecommunications industry” – construction of term “facility” – whether revenue earned from providing infrastructure to carriers for the deployment of communications services throughout Australia is revenue earned from an activity outside the telecommunications industry – whether purpose-built wireless communication sites are a facility for the purposes of the Telecommunications Act

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – where no statutory requirement to give reasons – whether it should be inferred from the failure to refer to a consideration in reasons given in correspondence that the consideration was not considered

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – exercise of discretion under s 9(2) of the Determination – principles concerning implied limitations on statutory discretions – whether decision-maker had adopted a policy that was inconsistent with the statute – whether tax avoidance is a mandatory relevant consideration in the exercise of the discretion – where purpose of discretion in s 9(2) is to clarify ambiguous legal terms – no error in reasoning

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – exercise of broad discretion under s 33 of the Determination – whether implied relevant considerations condition the exercise of discretion – where respondent expressly considered, but gave no weight to, submissions put by applicant – whether decision-maker could make reference to applicant’s competitors – where there was no requirement to give reasons

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AA

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 3, 5, 6

Australia Communications and Media Authority Act 2005 (Cth)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

Legislation Act 2003 (Cth) s 13(1)

Telecommunications (Consumer Protection and Service Standards) Act (1999) (Cth) ss 4, 5, 8, 43–45, 47–51

Telecommunications (Industry Levy) Act 2012 (Cth) s 4C

Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) ss 7, 16, 56, 110, 113

Telecommunications Universal Service Management Agency Act 2012 (Cth) ss 91, 93

Telecommunications (Eligible Revenue) Determination 2015 (Cth) ss 5, 9, 14–34, 37

Telecommunications (Participating Persons) Determination 2015 (Cth) s 4(3)

Telecommunications Universal Service Management Agency (Eligible Revenue) Determination 2013 (Cth)

Telecommunications Universal Service Obligation (Eligible Revenue) Regulations 1998 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond [1990] HCA 33; (1990) 170 CLR 321 at 337

Berenguel v Minister for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Axicom Inbuilding Solutions Pty Ltd v Australian Communicati... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1069
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Axicom Inbuilding Solutions Pty Ltd (Axicom Land) sought judicial review of the Australian Communications and Media Authority's (ACMA) assessment of Axicom Land's eligible revenue under the Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) and the Telecommunications (Eligible Revenue) Determination 2019 (ER Determination). Axicom Land, which holds a carrier licence, argued that the ACMA incorrectly included revenue earned by its related entity, Axicom Pty Ltd (APL), in its eligible revenue assessment for the period 2019-2020. Axicom Land contended that APL's revenue did not constitute telecommunications sales revenue and thus should not have been included in the assessment. The court was tasked with determining whether the ACMA correctly interpreted and applied the relevant provisions of the ER Determination, including the definitions of "telecommunications industry" and "facility", and whether the ACMA's exercise of discretion under the ER Determination was lawful.

The court held that the ACMA's assessment of Axicom Land's eligible revenue did not disclose any reviewable error of law or jurisdictional error. The court found that the ACMA correctly interpreted the statutory terms and exercised its discretion in accordance with the statutory provisions. Regarding the term "telecommunications industry", the court concluded that the ordinary meaning of the term, supported by the statutory context, included revenue earned from providing infrastructure to carriers for deploying communications services. Therefore, the court found that the revenue earned by APL was properly included in Axicom Land's eligible revenue assessment. The court also found that the ACMA's exercise of discretion under the ER Determination was lawful, as the ACMA had considered relevant factors and did not take into account irrelevant considerations or fail to consider relevant ones.

The application for judicial review was dismissed, and Axicom Land was ordered to pay the ACMA's costs of the application. The court's decision affirmed the ACMA's assessment of Axicom Land's eligible revenue and upheld the statutory scheme for imposing the telecommunications infrastructure levy.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for judicial review is dismissed.

2. The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs of the application as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 5 of the Participating Persons Determination provides that “[i]f a person is a non-participating person for an eligible revenue period, the person is exempt from section 44 of the [TCPSS] Act [ie. the provision pertaining to participating persons] for that eligible revenue period”. Section 4(3) of the Participating Persons Determination in turn provides that a person is a “non-participating person for an eligible revenue period” if (relevantly) the person’s initial sales revenue, gross telecommunications sales revenue, or eligible revenue for the period is less than $25 million. This calculation is subject to s 4(4) of the Participating Persons Determination, which is not presently relevant. 3. FACTUAL BACKGROUND 3.1 Axicom Land’s statutory declaration on 30 October 2020 of its eligible revenue On 30 October 2020, and following communication with the ACMA, Stefan Kennedy, General Counsel and Company Secretary of Axicon Land, provided a statutory declaration declaring that, for the purposes of s 4(3)(b)(i) of the ER Determination, the eligible revenue for Axicom Land was less than AUD$25 million for the eligible revenue period. Shortly thereafter, on 2 November 2020, Axicom Land sent an email to the ACMA confirming it had submitted Axicom Land’s eligible revenue return on 30 October 2020 with eligible revenue of zero. The email stated that Axicom Land had earned zero revenue since receiving its carrier licence in July 2019 as “[t]he carrier licence was sought in anticipation of Axicom Land engaging in the supply, installation and provision of fibre optic cable, and this has not yet commenced”. The email further claimed that Axicom Land’s consolidated related parties, including APL, did not earn any telecommunications revenue. This was because, in Axicom Land’s view, APL’s revenue did not constitute telecommunications sales revenue, and therefore it did not need to be declared as part of Axicom Land’s eligible revenue return, for the following reasons:Axicom Pty Ltd’s business is leasing and licensing access to passive infrastructure, land and buildings in common with power, land access and other similar inputs, and as such, is not properly considered to be part of the telecommunications industry. We believe that the inclusion of such revenue in the calculation of Axicom Land’s eligible revenue would be inconsistent with both the letter and the intention of the TIL and the [ER] Determination.…Axicom Pty Ltd does not require a carrier licence to own or provide access to its facilities, and neither is Axicom deemed to be a carriage service provider. Only carriers and (in some circumstances) carriage service providers can be required to contribute to the TIL. Accordingly it would be a perverse outcome if the revenue of an entity which is neither a carrier nor a carriage service provider were to be included in the TIL.…We understand from the Determination’s Explanatory Statement that the concept of “consolidated related party” and “declared related party” was included to “discourage, and ultimately deal with, persons trying to minimise their revenue, and thus levy payments, by diverting revenue to associates that are not participating persons.” Axicom Land is not attempting to avoid paying the TIL by diverting funds to Axicom Pty Ltd.Firstly, Axicom Land has not earned any revenue since it received its carrier licence last July, so has no funds to divert.Secondly, Axicom Pty Ltd has been engaged in the business of providing access to passive infrastructure since 2000 and this business is not related to the operation of the business sought to be established by Axicom Land. Axicom Land is a separate and distinct business from the passive infrastructure business owned and operated by Axicom Pty Ltd. Axicom Land is designed to invest in the development of new fibre telecommunications infrastructure which will be made available to carriers on an open-access, wholesale-only basis.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 13 October 2021, the ACMA made the Eligible Revenue Assessment 2019-20 pursuant to s 47 of the TCPSS Act with respect to the eligible revenue period for all participating persons, including Axicom Land (the Eligible Revenue Decision). Axicom Land was advised of the Eligible Revenue Decision by letter from the ACMA dated 14 October 2021 that its eligible revenue had been assessed in the sum of $200,576,000.00. This assessment was used as the basis for calculating Axicom Land’s 2020-21 Levy for which Axicom Land was subsequently invoiced in the amount of $1,860,019.95. Axicom Land seeks judicial review of the Eligible Revenue Decision pursuant to s 5 of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) (ADJR Act) and s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). Axicom Land contends that the calculation of its eligible revenue was in error on three grounds. These grounds focus on the inclusion of revenue earned by APL, which did not hold a carrier licence, in the assessment of Axicom Land’s eligible revenue. Specifically, Axicom Land contends that the ACMA erred in the following respects:(1)the ACMA failed to characterise APL’s sales revenue for the eligible revenue period as “non-telecommunications sales revenue” for the purposes of s 9 of the ER Determination and to deduct such revenue from Axicom Land’s initial sales revenue pursuant to s 16 of the ER Determination (Ground 1);(2)in declining to exercise its discretion in s 9(2) of the ER Determination to declare that the entirety of APL’s sales revenue is “non-telecommunications sales revenue”, the ACMA erred in construing the scope of its statutory discretion, took into account irrelevant considerations, and failed to take into account relevant considerations (Ground 2); and(3)in declining to exercise its discretion in s 33 of the ER Determination to declare that the entirety of APL’s telecommunications sales revenue be deducted from Axicom Land’s initial sales revenue, the ACMA erred in construing the scope of its statutory discretion, took into account irrelevant considerations, and failed to take into account relevant considerations (Ground 3). Accordingly, Axicom Land seeks an order either quashing or setting aside the Eligible Revenue Decision, or declaring that the Eligible Revenue Decision is void and of no effect and/or was made unlawfully. The ACMA accepts that if the applicant succeeded on any of the three grounds, a declaration that the Eligible Revenue Decision is of no effect would be appropriate. For the reasons that follow, the Eligible Revenue Decision discloses no reviewable error of law or jurisdictional error, and the application for judicial review is therefore dismissed with costs. Ultimately, with respect, Axicom Land’s complaint reduces to strong disagreement with the statutory scheme and with the merits of the ACMA’s decision, neither of which are reviewable by the Court. 2. THE LEGISLATIVE AND REGULATORY SCHEME The judicial review application principally concerns the construction of certain provisions within the ER Determination. As the ER Determination is made under the TCPSS Act, it is helpful first to set out the relevant legislative scheme under the TCPSS Act before turning to the salient provisions of the ER Determination. 2.1 The legislative scheme established by Part 2 of the TCPSS Act for imposing a levy on carriers2.1.1Purpose of the scheme

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Importantly, for reasons which I later explain, it is apparent the purpose of this letter was to request that the ACMA consider exercising one of the relevant statutory discretions and that the ACMA give a statement of reasons outlining the basis of its decision on the exercise of those powers. Apart from that request, Axicom Land merely sought, by the letter, to reserve its position with respect to the question of whether APL’s sales revenue constituted non‑telecommunications sales revenue.3.5 The ACMA’s “decision” not to make a declaration on 23 September 2021 and provision of “reasons” in its letter dated 8 October 2021 (October letter) On 23 September 2021, officers of the ACMA prepared a detailed submission to the ACMA with respect to Axicom Land’s request to make a declaration under (relevantly) ss 9(2) or 33 of the ER Determination, the effect of which would exempt Axicom Land from having to contribute to the Levy. The submission attached (among other things) the correspondence from Axicom Land dated 9 December 2020, the ACMA 30 July letter, and the letter from Axicom Land’s solicitors to the ACMA’s delegate dated 16 August 2021. The submission recommended that the ACMA agree not to make a declaration. With respect to the application of s 9(2) of the ER Determination, the submission advised that (at [42]–[43]):A telecommunications tower is the physical structure that hosts the antennas and other equipment necessary for the supply of mobile and other wireless services. Tower infrastructure is mainly used for mobile telecommunications, television broadcasting and wireless radio transmission. Access to tower infrastructure is usually required in areas where it is uneconomical to duplicate tower infrastructure, particularly regional areas. In Australia, tower infrastructure has largely been established by the Mobile Network Operators (MNOs), who have built a large number of their own towers and have co-location arrangements on other MNOs’ towers and shared infrastructure assets (for example, land or roof-tops sites).There are around 12,000 macro towers in Australia and [a]round 75 per cent are owned by vertically integrated operators. In its application for a carrier licence, Axicom (formerly known as Crown Towers) identified itself as the largest non-carrier telecommunications tower infrastructure operator with 20% ownership of the market and over 1700 sites, most of which were acquired from MNOs since 2000. After referring to its view that the revenue earned from APL can properly be characterised as telecommunications sales revenue (referring to s 7(f)(ii) of the Telecommunications Act), the recommendation set out a number of arguments against making a declaration for Axicom Land:(1)Axicom Land was advised of its obligations and conditions of holding a carrier licence when it applied for the licence, including the liability to contribute to the levy;(2)taking out the carrier licence was a strategic commercial decision made by Axicom Land;(3)the conditions and powers gained from owning a carrier licence immediately provided Axicom Land with commercial value as an entity planning to expand its telecommunications infrastructure business, and may have afforded it a reputational advantage; and(4)making a declaration for Axicom Land:(a)was likely to be considered inequitable by other carriers, as the sources of revenue used to determine the eligible revenue for Axicom Land are the same as those for other participating persons. In particular, it may be considered unfair for carriers with similar revenue streams that have included all telecommunications sales revenue in their eligible revenue returns;(b)would have a direct impact on Uniti and Vodafone who would no longer be permitted to claim an inter-person-input payment deduction under s 29 of the ER Determination, thereby increasing the amount the Levy they were required to contribute (as acknowledged by Axicom Land in its submission to the ACMA on 9 December 2020); and(c)may lead to further requests for deductions in relation to revenue that had traditionally been caught in the ACMA’s assessment of the Levy.