Australians for Sustainable Development Inc v Barangaroo Delivery Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

Administrative Decisions Tribunal


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Australians for Sustainable Development Inc v Barangaroo Delivery Authority [2013] NSWADT 252
Hearing dates:12 February 20134, 5 and 6 March 2013
Decision date: 07 November 2013
Jurisdiction:General Division
Before: S Higgins, Deputy President
Decision:

Application File No 123123

1. The decision of BDA is set aside and in substitution thereof a decision to grant ASD access to the information deleted from the 2009 Valuation and the 2010 and 2011 Updated Valuations.

Application File No 123124

2. The decision of BDA in regard to:

(a) the deletions on pages 67 and 107 of BDA's Final Phase RFD - Addendum No. 2,

(b) the deletions on pages of 124 to 126 (para 3.1.1) of BDA's Final Phase Proponent Brief to BM,

(c) the deletions on pages 140 and 147-149 (para 3.1.1) of BDA's Final Phase Proponent Brief to LL,

(d) the deleted fixed payment dollar amounts in para 1(b), para 2(a) and 2(c), on pages 3, 4, 37 and 38, in LL's (Stage 1 RFDP) - Final Phase - Schedule 3,

(e) the deletions in paragraph 2(e)(2), under the heading 'Fixed Payments', and the last sentence in 2(a), under the heading 'Value Payments', in LL's (Stage 1 RFDP) - Final Phase - Schedule 3, and

(f) the deletions in the Minutes of the BDA Evaluation Panel and Executive Review Panel

is set aside and in substitution thereof a decision that ASD be granted access to these deletions.

3. The decision of BDA in regard to the remaining information in dispute, the subject of this application (including the deletions in BM-Final Phase-Returnable Schedule 3), is affirmed.

Application File No 123125

4. The decision of BDA in regard to the information in the KPMG Report is affirmed.

Catchwords: Government information - access application - information contained in tender documents - whether public interest considerations against disclosure out weight the public interest considerations in favour of disclosure - prejudice the supply of confidential information that facilitates the effective exercise of an agency's functions - disclosure of information provided in confidence - reveal commercial-in-confidence provision in a government contract - diminish the competitive commercial value of any information to any person- prejudice any person's legitimate business, commercial and financial interests
Legislation Cited: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 Barangaroo Delivery Authority Act 2009 Contaminated Lands Management Act 1997 Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) Freedom of Information Act 1989 (NSW repealed)
Cases Cited: Attorney-General's Department v Cockcroft (1986) 10 FCR180 Cannon and Australian Quality Egg Farms Ltd (1994) QIC 94 Commissioner of Police, NSW Police Force v Camilleri (GD) [2012] NSWADTAP 19 Hurst v Wagga Wagga City Council [2011] NSWADT 307 Mangan and the Treasury [2005] AATA 898 McLennan v University of New England [2013] NSWADT 113 McKinnon v Secretary, Department of Treasury [2006] HCA 45 McKinnon v Blacktown City Council [2012] NSWADT 44 Nature Conservation Council v Department of Trade and Investment, Regional Infrastructure and Services (NSW)
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australians for Sustainable Development Inc v Barangaroo Del... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWADT 252
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Australians for Sustainable Development Inc sought access to certain documents under the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (NSW) (GIPA Act). The Barangaroo Delivery Authority (BDA) refused to provide the documents, claiming that disclosure would prejudice the supply of confidential information that facilitates the effective exercise of its functions. The applicants took the matter to the Information and Privacy Commission of New South Wales (the Commission), which found in favour of the BDA and dismissed the applications. The applicants sought judicial review of the Commission's decision in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales. The court had to determine whether the BDA was correct in its refusal to disclose the documents under cl 1(d) and (e) of the table in s 14(2) of the GIPA Act. The first issue was whether the BDA was correct in refusing to disclose the documents under cl 1(d). The court found that the BDA was not correct in its refusal to disclose the documents under cl 1(d). The court held that the public interest consideration against disclosure must be assessed in the context of the information in dispute. The weight to be given to the public interest in favour of disclosure will differ depending on the information in question. The second issue was whether the BDA was correct in refusing to disclose the documents under cl 1(e). The court found that the BDA was correct in its refusal to disclose the documents under cl 1(e). The court held that there was a connection between the particular opinion, advice, or recommendation and the relevant deliberative process of the agency. The final orders of the court were that the decision of the BDA in regard to the information in the KPMG Report be affirmed, the decision of the BDA in regard to certain deletions in the documents be set aside, and the decision of the BDA in regard to the remaining information in dispute be affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application File No 123123

1. The decision of BDA is set aside and in substitution thereof a decision to grant ASD access to the information deleted from the 2009 Valuation and the 2010 and 2011 Updated Valuations.

Application File No 123124

2. The decision of BDA in regard to:

(a) the deletions on pages 67 and 107 of BDA's Final Phase RFD - Addendum No. 2,

(b) the deletions on pages of 124 to 126 (para 3.1.1) of BDA's Final Phase Proponent Brief to BM,

(c) the deletions on pages 140 and 147-149 (para 3.1.1) of BDA's Final Phase Proponent Brief to LL,

(d) the deleted fixed payment dollar amounts in para 1(b), para 2(a) and 2(c), on pages 3, 4, 37 and 38, in LL's (Stage 1 RFDP) - Final Phase - Schedule 3,

(e) the deletions in paragraph 2(e)(2), under the heading 'Fixed Payments', and the last sentence in 2(a), under the heading 'Value Payments', in LL's (Stage 1 RFDP) - Final Phase - Schedule 3, and

(f) the deletions in the Minutes of the BDA Evaluation Panel and Executive Review Panel

is set aside and in substitution thereof a decision that ASD be granted access to these deletions.

3. The decision of BDA in regard to the remaining information in dispute, the subject of this application (including the deletions in BM-Final Phase-Returnable Schedule 3), is affirmed.

Application File No 123125

4. The decision of BDA in regard to the information in the KPMG Report is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

KPMG's evidence In his evidence, Mr Brooke explained he is the partner in charge of KPMG's Infrastructure & Projects Group. He said he has been a specialist in the commercial and financial aspects of infrastructure projects for 21 years and he supervised the KPMG team that undertook, at the request of BDA, the financial evaluation of the Barangaroo Project Stage 1. Mr Brooke explained that on or about March 2009, KPMG, under his supervision, prepared a detailed proposal to provide financial advisory services, to SHFA, with respect to Barangaroo. He said KPMG was appointed to provide such services in late March 2009 and in doing so gave a confidentiality undertaking in regard to the information it prepared and was provided by SHFA and then BDA. Mr Brooke went on to explain the measures taken by KPMG in ensuring that the information remained confidential, including ensuring that no one other than those allocated to work on this task within KPMG had access to the information provided by the SHFA and BDA, or the work undertaken by the KPMG team on behalf of SHFA and BDA. Mr Brooke explained that the KPMG Infrastructure and Projects Group provide its services in a competitive market. He said, to his knowledge, KPMG's Infrastructure and Projects Group is unique within Australia in that it combines finance, infrastructure and property experts in a single team. He said the knowledge, experience and expertise of this group, in the context of specific projects, has significant commercial value to KPMG. Mr Brooke said the Barangaroo development was an unusual type of government infrastructure project as it largely involved property development, which extended over a long period of time and during which there will be an ongoing relationship between Government and the developer. He said due to the unusual nature of the Barangaroo development and the differences between the proponents' proposals there were no pre-existing or commonly used approach or template for evaluating these proposals. Hence, he and Mr Miller (also of KPMG) developed what they considered to be the most appropriate methodologies for addressing the issue. This, he said, was based on their respective experience, expertise and judgment. These methodologies, he said, were disclosed within the Report. A disclosure of the Report to a competitor firm, he said, could enable the competitor firm to ascertain the methodologies developed by KPMG and then utilise these to their own advantage in future projects and thereby diminish or destroy the commercial value of them to KPMG. Mr Brooke listed a number of other ways in which a disclosure of the information in the Report could prejudice the commercial value of the methodologies developed by KPMG for the Barangaroo Project and KPMG's approach more generally. However, in my view, these prejudices were essentially another form of saying the same thing. Although the public interest consideration in favour of disclosure must be considered in the context of the information in dispute, in these applications, given the nature of the documents containing the disputed information, the public interest consideration in favour of disclosure is common to almost all the information in dispute. The weight to be given to that public interest will of course differ depending on the information in question.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The public interest considerations against disclosure - generally The abovementioned remarks of Bowen CJ and Beaumont J, in Cockcroft (supra), have been widely accepted. However, it is instructive to repeat their observations in full: In the same decision, at p 196, Sheppard J made the following remark: Although Cockcroft (supra), concerned the meaning of the term in the context of s 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Commonwealth Freedom of Information Act 1982, (FOI Act (Cth)), as I have indicated above, it has been accepted that the term, as used in other exemptions in that Act, the exemptions in Schedule 1 of the former NSW Freedom of Information Act 1989 (FOI Act (repealed)) and in the table to subs 14(2) of the GIPA Act, have the same meaning. Cockcroft's (supra) case was considered and applied in Searle Australia Pty Ltd v Public Interest Advocacy Centre (1992) 36 FCR 111, 108 ALR 163. At 176, after reciting the abovementioned paragraphs from the decision in Cockcroft, the Court (per Davies, Wilcox and Einfeld JJ) said: In my view, the approach adopted by their Honours above, remains the correct approach in determining whether the disclosure of information 'could reasonably be expected to' have one or more of the effects as prescribed in the clauses in the table to subs 14(2) of the GIPA Act. That is, the inquiry is not whether the occurrence of the prescribed effect is likely, possible or probable. The inquiry is whether the expectation of the claimed effect is reasonably based (cf the approach in Nature Conservation Council (supra), at [179]). The public interest considerations in favour of disclosure examples in subs 12(2), I note, are also predicated with the words 'could reasonably be expected' to 'promote', 'enhance', inform' and 'insure' public discussion, Government accountability etc. The term 'could reasonably be expected' in this context must have the same meaning. Clause 1(d) prejudice supply of confidential information As outlined above, for the cl 1(d) public interest consideration to apply, the information in issue must not only be 'confidential information', it must also be information that facilitates the effective exercise of that agency's functions. The Tribunal has accepted that the word 'prejudice', in the context of the public interest considerations against disclosure, is to be given its ordinary meaning, namely: 'to cause detriment or disadvantage': see Hurst (supra) at [60], McLennan v University of New England [2013] NSWADT 113 at [38] and Sobh v Victoria Police (1993) 1 VR 41. Clause 1(e) reveal an opinion, advice, or recommendation so as to prejudice a deliberative process of government or an agency In order for this public interest consideration against disclosure to apply, it is necessary to establish a connection between the particular opinion, advice or recommendation and the relevant deliberative process of the agency: see Van der Wall v University of Sydney [2008] NSWADT 213 at [36] and Re Waterford and Department of the Treasury (No 2) (1984) 5 ALD 588 at [58] to [61].