Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dunjey

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dunjey [2023] FCA 361

File number: WAD 276 of 2021
Judgment of: FEUTRILL J
Date of judgment: 21 April 2023
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – winding up – unregistered managed investment scheme – scheme – interest in scheme –unlicensed financial services business – financial products – dealing in financial products – business where the second defendant executed 'loan agreements' with investors and pooled loan funds in bank accounts – where second defendant represented loan funds would be used for 'investments' – liquidator of company and scheme appointed – winding up corporate trustee – receivers and managers of trust assets appointed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – implied undertaking – purpose of freezing order disclosure affidavit – release from implied undertaking refused

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – declaratory relief – potential criminal prosecution – proper contradictor – Court's disapproval of contravening conduct – declaratory relief granted

Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) ss 33, 76(1), 76(2), 77(b), 78

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 1101B(1)(a)(i), 601EB, 601ED, 601EE(1), 601EE(2), 761E, 763A(1)(a), 763B, 766A, 911A, 911A(1), 1311, 1317E

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 59, 60-64, 66A-75, 81-84, 87, 88, 135, 136

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 23, 57

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 7.32, 7.33

Cases cited:

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission [1992] HCA 10; (1992) 175 CLR 564

Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australian & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (1995) 57 FCR 360

Aussie Airlines Pty Ltd v Australian Airlines (1996) 68 FCR 406

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2017] FCAFC 113; (2017) 254 FCR 68

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 56; (2012) 201 FCR 378

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Renegade Gas Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1135

Australian Securities Commission v AS Nominees Ltd (1995) 62 FCR 504

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Chase Capital Management Pty Ltd [2001] WASC 27

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Emu Brewery Mezzanine Ltd [2004] WASC 241; (2004) 187 FLR 270

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v HLP Financial Planning (Aust) Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 1868; (2007) 164 FCR 487

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hutchings [2001] NSWSC 522; (2001) 38 ACSR 387

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kreicichwost [2007] NSWSC 948; (2007) 64 ACSR 411

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Marco (No 6) [2020] FCA 1781

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Marco (No 13) [2023] FCA 83

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Monarch FX Group Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1387; (2014) 103 ACSR 453

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Munro [2016] QSC 9

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v MyWealth Manager Financial Services Pty Ltd (No 3) [2020] FCA 1035; (2020) 146 ACSR 270

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Ostrava Equities Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 1064

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Pegasus Leveraged Options Group Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dunjey and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 361
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dunjey, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) brought proceedings against Ascent and Mr. Dunjey, alleging contraventions of the Corporations Act and seeking relief for the winding up of an unregistered managed investment scheme operated by Ascent. The court was tasked with determining whether Ascent and the scheme should be wound up, whether ASIC's requested declarations and orders were appropriate, and if any other relief should be granted. The court found that Ascent had contravened the relevant sections of the Corporations Act and that it was appropriate to wind up the scheme and the company, appoint liquidators, and make various orders for asset preservation, freezing, and disclosure.

The court reasoned that the evidence provided by ASIC, although documentary and hearsay, was sufficient to establish the contraventions by Ascent. The court found that the winding up of Ascent and the scheme was necessary and that the appointment of liquidators was appropriate to manage the process. The court also considered the interests of various stakeholders, including beneficiaries of the trust, creditors of Ascent, and contributors to the scheme, in determining the appropriate orders for remuneration, costs, and expenses. The court decided to appoint joint and several liquidators and receivers and managers, and to reserve the question of remuneration and costs for further hearing. The court made orders for winding up Ascent and the scheme, appointing liquidators and receivers, and varying freezing orders. It also made interim non-publication orders pending further submissions on the matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The second defendant's interlocutory application dated 25 May 2022 for an order that the second defendant be wound up pursuant to s 461(1)(a) of the Corporations Act is dismissed with no order as to the costs of that application.

2. Pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act, the second defendant is wound up on just and equitable grounds.

3. Pursuant to s 472(1) of the Corporations Act, Mr Matthew James Donnelly and Mr Sean Holmes of Deloitte Financial Advisory Pty Ltd, are appointed joint and several liquidators to the second defendant (Liquidators).

4. Pursuant to s 601EE(2) of the Corporations Act, the Scheme is to be wound up.

5. The Liquidators are to be responsible for the winding up of the Scheme.

6. The second defendant is to pay the plaintiff's cost of the proceedings and such costs as taxed or agreed be reimbursed out of the property of the second defendant, in accordance with s 466(2) of the Corporations Act.

7. Paragraph 5 of the orders made on 13 December 2021 is varied by inserting the following paragraph before existing sub-paragraph 5(a):

(aa) Mr John Gervase Shanahan (Trustee), in his capacity as the Trustee in Bankruptcy of the estate of the first defendant, from preserving any property (as defined in the Corporations Act) of the first defendant and:

(i) realising any such property in accordance with the applicable powers under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth); and

(ii) paying from the proceeds of sale of any such property:

(A) any valid and subsisting secured claims against such property; and

(B) the Trustee's reasonable remuneration, costs and expenses relating to the preservation and realisation of such property,

with any remaining proceeds of sale, following the payments referred to above at paragraphs 5(a)(ii)(A) and 5(a)(ii)(B), to be paid into an interest bearing bank account held jointly by the Liquidators and the Trustee requiring the dual authorisation of the Trustee and any one of the Liquidators to effect a withdrawal of any funds,

(iii) exercising the rights attached to any share held by the first defendant for the purpose of appointing Mr Donnelly and Mr Holmes of Deloitte as liquidators of the company in which that share is held.

8. Pursuant to s 57 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), Mr Donnelly and Mr Holmes are appointed, jointly and severally, as receivers and managers (Receivers) over the property, assets and undertakings of the Ascent Trust (formerly the Dunjey Family Trust) (Trust).

9. The need for the Receivers to file a guarantee under rr 14.21 and 14.22 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) is dispensed with.

10. The Receivers are authorised to take possession of, preserve, maintain and sell all property, assets and undertakings of the Trust (Trust Assets).

11. The Receivers are to have the power:

(a) to do all things (including, but not limited to, the signing of any documents) for the realisation of the Trust Assets;

(b) provided by s 420 of the Corporations Act as if the reference therein to 'the corporation' were to 'the Trust' together with the powers that a liquidator has in respect of property of a company (in its role as legal owner and trustee) pursuant to s 477(2) of the Corporations Act;

(c) without limiting the powers granted pursuant to paragraphs 11(a) and (b), necessary to attend to the following identified tasks:

(i) the identification of the Trust Assets and the trust liabilities;

(ii) the identification of Trust creditors and distinguishing them from non-Trust creditors (if any);

(iii) the ascertaining of the state of the accounts between the beneficiaries and the trustee;

(iv) the recovering of, or attempting to recover, the Trust Assets, including debts due to the Trust;

(v) the taking of possession of, collecting and protecting the Trust Assets;

(vi) the carrying on of any business of the Trust;

(vii) the realisation, or attempted realisation, of the Trust Assets;

(viii) the distribution of any proceeds of realisation to meet the claims of the creditors or persons whose debts were incurred in relation of the Trust; and

(ix) any matter in the administration of the Trust which is ancillary to the above to the extent to which it had to be undertaken for the purposes of the identified tasks.

12. The Receivers are justified and would be acting properly in not distributing any Trust Assets, or any part of them, to or for the benefit of any of the beneficiaries of the Trust until further direction or order of the Court.

13. The question of payment of the remuneration, costs and expenses of the Liquidators and Receivers and of the Trustee for assisting them in the discharge if their duties is reserved and is to be the subject of further order of the Court and, in the meantime:

(a) the remuneration, costs and expenses incurred by the Receivers are to be paid from the Trust Assets;

(b) the remuneration, costs and expenses of the Liquidators as liquidators of the Scheme are to be paid out of the assets of the Scheme; and

(c) the remuneration, costs and expenses of the Liquidators as liquidators of the second defendant are to be paid out of the assets of the second defendant.

14. Pursuant to section 37AI of the Federal Court Act, until 4:15pm on the date fixed for the hearing referred to in paragraph 19 of these orders or any other date to which that hearing may be adjourned, or further or other order, paragraphs A – I of the notes to these orders, paragraphs 1 and 2 of the declarations made under these orders and the reasons for decision in respect of these orders are not to be published to anyone other than to the Court, the parties to these proceedings and the Liquidators and Receivers, the Trustee, Westpac Banking Corporation, Seaflower Pty Ltd and GD Project Living Pty Ltd (collectively, interested non-parties) and the parties' and interested non-parties' legal representatives

15. By 5 May 2023, the first defendant is to file and serve on the other parties to the proceedings and the interested non-parties an outline of submissions in support of his application for a suppression and non-publication order together with a minute of the proposed order and any affidavit(s) in support of that application.

16. By 12 May 2023, any interested news publisher which wishes to appear and be heard on the first defendant's application is to file a notice to that effect and serve that notice on each party and each interested non-party.

17. By 19 May 2023, the plaintiff, second defendant, interested non-parties and any interested news publisher are to file and serve on each party, each interested non-party and any interested news publisher any submissions and any affidavit(s) in support of those submissions.

18. By 19 May 2023, the parties and the interested non-parties are to file and serve on each party and each interested non-party any minute of agreed proposed orders, or competing minute of proposed orders, addressing the matters the subject of paragraphs 167 to 171 of the reasons for decision together with any submissions and affidavit(s) in support of the relevant minute of proposed orders.

19. The question of the Receivers' and Liquidators' costs and the first defendant's application for a suppression and non-publication order is listed for hearing on a date to be fixed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the end, notwithstanding that the evidence upon which ASIC relies is documentary and (or) hearsay, I am satisfied to the degree required for the serious nature of the allegations made against Ascent, that it has contravened ss 601ED(5) and 911A of the Corporations Act. I am also satisfied that Ascent and the unregistered managed investment scheme it operated should be wound up and the provisional liquidators appointed as liquidators for that purpose. As there may be some complexity identifying and getting in property of each of the scheme and the company, I will hear the parties further on an appropriate mechanism for so doing including, if appropriate, the appointment of the receivers to get in all property of the scheme and the company in respect of which the liquidators may then request directions as to the division and distribution of that property at some later point in time. Although I am also satisfied that the Court should grant the declaratory relief requested as a mark of the Court's disapproval of the contravening conduct, I will hear the parties on the extent to which it would be appropriate to make a non-publication order regarding those declarations, parts of the orders made and these reasons. In the meantime, there will be an interim non-publication order pending the hearing and determination of that issue.Background On 13 December 2021, ASIC commenced proceedings against Ascent and Mr Dunjey (collectively referred to in these reasons as the defendants). At the time of commencement, the proceedings were originally made under s 1323 of the Corporations Act and s 23 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). Interim relief was sought for asset preservation orders against the defendants, for orders restraining the first defendant from leaving Australia and for other orders (freezing orders). On 13 December 2021, freezing orders were made against the defendants after an ex-parte hearing that day. These orders restrained the defendants from removing any property of the defendants from Australia and prevented Mr Dunjey from leaving Australia. Disclosure orders were also made against Mr Dunjey in his own capacity, and on behalf of Ascent. These orders required Mr Dunjey to disclose details about bank accounts, debts, assets and liabilities, as well as property and income of the defendants. The initial freezing orders were varied, by consent, on 15 December 2021, 20 December 2021 and 4 March 2022. There was not an inter-partes hearing and, subject to further variations made by orders of 2 June 2022 and 9 December 2022, the freezing orders remain in place. On 20 January 2022, Seaflower was ordered to file a notice of appearance on the basis that it remained necessary for it to seek leave to be heard. Seaflower was granted leave to appear, by its director, from time-to-time at various case management hearings. Seaflower had an interest as a person which had provided funds to Ascent and, therefore, may have been affected by the freezing order and the final relief ASIC requested in the Application.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 27 March 2023, the parties and interested non-parties were invited to make further written submissions on three questions arising from ASIC's request that the Court make declaratory relief against Ascent. On 4 April 2023, ASIC filed written submissions in response to that invitation. On 5 April 2023, the Court received email correspondence from the director of Seaflower in which submissions or comments were made with respect to ASIC's submissions regarding declaratory relief. On 6 April 2023, the Court invited all interested non-parties who (which) had participated in the proceedings at any time to make any further submissions on the question of declaratory relief. On 11 April 2023, the Court received further correspondence from Seaflower in which further submissions were made in response to the Court's letter of 27 March 2023. On 13 April 2023, Mr Dunjey filed submissions in response to the Court's request in which he made submissions, for the first time, opposing the declaratory relief requested against Ascent. On 14 April 2023, the Court received email correspondence from ASIC in which it made submissions, in effect, in response to Mr Dunjey's submissions. No further submissions were received from any of the other parties or interested non-parties.Evidence ASIC read and relied on the following affidavits.(a)Paragraphs [1]-[6], [12], [13], [16]-[18], [21(d)], [21(e)], [23]-[25], [28]-[43], [50]-[55], [61]-[73], [77]-[90], [92]-[95] of the affidavit of Mr Jamie Macchiusi affirmed 10 December 2021 and exhibit JM-1 to that affidavit. The affidavit was received on the hearing of the originating application as Ex 1.1.(b)Paragraphs [1]-[7], [10]-[12], [17], [17(a)-(c)], [18], [22], [23], [25(d)], [27]-[29], [42], [46], [48], [50] and [54] of the affidavit of Mr Macchiusi affirmed 1 March 2022 and exhibit JM-2 to that affidavit. The affidavit was received in the hearing as Ex 1.2, but the documents at tabs 4, 5 and 6 of JM-2 were provisionally received in the hearing as part of the exhibit and subject to rulings on Mr Dunjey's objections to the receipt of those documents.(c)Paragraphs [1]-[6], [11]-[15] and [18] of the affidavit of Mr Macchiusi affirmed 12 April 2022 and exhibit JM-3 to that affidavit. The affidavit was received as Ex 1.3 in the hearing.(d)Paragraphs [1]-[7], [9]-[15], [16]-[21], [22], [24]-[26], [28]-[52] of the affidavit of Ms Hollie Ponton affirmed 1 March 2022 and exhibit HEPP-1 to that affidavit. The affidavit was received as Ex 2.1 in the hearing.(e)The affidavit of Ms Ponton affirmed 9 March 2022 and annexures HEPP-1 to HEPP-5 of that affidavit. The affidavit was received as Ex 2.2 in the hearing.(f)Paragraphs [1] and [5] of an affidavit of Mr Dunjey sworn 23 May 2023. The affidavit was received as Ex 3 in the hearing.(g)Paragraphs [2]-[14] and [15(a)] of the affidavit or Mr Donnelly affirmed 22 June 2022 and annexures MD1 to MD11 to that affidavit. The affidavit was received as Ex 4 in the hearing. MD10 of that affidavit was report of the provisional liquidators (Provisional Liquidators' Report).(h)Paragraphs [1]-[3] of the affidavit of Mr Sean Holmes affirmed 22 June 2022. The affidavit was received as Ex 5 in the hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Paragraph [18] of the second part of the minute requests the Court to make orders to the effect that Mr Shanahan is entitled to reasonable remuneration, costs and expenses for assistance in the identification, care, preservation of assets of the scheme and to be paid for such remuneration, costs and expenses out of the assets of the scheme. On the basis of the information available, I am not prepared to make an order in such terms. This is not to say that an order to the effect that the Liquidators, as liquidators of the scheme, would be acting properly and would be justified in paying of such reasonable remuneration, costs and expenses of Mr Shanahan out of the assets of the scheme would not be appropriate if the Liquidators were to request such a direction and provide proper and sufficient justification for such a direction to be made in due course. Conclusion Orders will be made substantially in terms of the minute of proposed orders dated 21 July 2022. I will hear the parties on the final form of the orders to be made with respect to the remuneration, costs and expenses of Mr Donnelly and Mr Holmes as Receivers and Liquidators and of Mr Shanahan for assisting Mr Donnelly and Mr Holmes in the performance of their duties. There will be an interim non-publication order made in respect of the declarations, part of the orders and these reasons. Provision will be made for the parties and interested non-parties to make further submissions as to whether there should be any continuation of that non-publication order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Paragraphs [7] and [8] of the second part of the minute request further variations to the freezing orders made on 13 December 2021. The order requested in para [7(a)] will be made by consent. The order requested in para [7(b)] was made on 9 December 2022. The order requested in para [8] is unnecessary because the freezing orders already make provision for the parties to have liberty to apply.Remuneration, costs and expenses Paragraphs [14] to [17] of the second part of the minute request the Court to make orders that would, in effect, permit the remuneration, costs and expenses incurred by Mr Donnelly and Mr Holmes as liquidators of Ascent, as liquidators of the scheme and as receivers and managers of the Ascent Trust to be paid out of the assets of the Ascent Trust, the assets of the scheme and the assets of the company as if all these assets were a single combined pool of assets for the purposes of the costs and expenses of the receivership and liquidations of Ascent and the scheme. I am not prepared to make orders of the requested nature without a further hearing. In short, I would need to be persuaded that it is appropriate to make such an order in the circumstances of this case. For example, it seems to me that the beneficiaries of the Ascent Trust, the creditors of Ascent and the contributors of the scheme may have different or conflicting interests in an order of the kind that is requested. Nonetheless, I consider that Mr Donnelly and Mr Holmes should not be hindered in the task of identifying, getting in and realising the property, assets and undertaking of the Ascent Trust, scheme and Ascent in the most efficient and cost effective manner and should be able to do so knowing that their costs and expenses will be paid out of such property, assets and undertaking. It seems to me that a possible solution is to appoint Mr Donnelly and Mr Holmes as joint and several receivers and managers of all property, assets and undertaking of Ascent, Ascent as trustee and the scheme (Property) and make provision for them to identify what part of the Property is trust property of the Ascent Trust, property of Ascent in its own right, and property of the scheme and for them to deliver those parts of the Property, in due course, to the trustee of the Ascent Trust, the liquidators of Ascent and the liquidators of the scheme. It would be appropriate for their costs and expenses of undertaking the work of that receivership to be paid out of the Property, as a whole. Orders of a similar nature were made in Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Marco (No 6) [2020] FCA 1781. I will hear the parties as to whether it would be appropriate to make orders of a similar nature in this case. In the meantime, orders will be made for payment of remuneration, costs and expenses out of the assets of the Ascent Trust for the Receivers, out of the assets of the scheme, for the Liquidators as liquidators of the scheme and out of the assets of Ascent for the Liquidators as liquidators of Ascent.