SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Munro & Anor [2016] QSC 9
PARTIES:
AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
(applicant)
v
ROGER GARETH MUNRO(first respondent)
KATHLEEN SUSAN MUNRO
(second respondent)FILE NO:
Supreme Court No 7253 of 2015
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Originating Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court of Queensland
DELIVERED ON:
3 February 2016
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATES:
5, 12, 13 November 2015; 2 December 2015.
Further submissions received 16 November 2015 (respondents); 18 November 2015 (applicant); 1 December 2015 (respondents) and 2 December 2015 (applicant)
Respondents afforded opportunity to provide further submissions prior to 4.00 pm, 17 December 2015. No further submissions were provided.
JUDGE:
Flanagan J
ORDERS:
1. The Court declares that between 1 January 2011 and 7 August 2015, the first respondent, by seeking, accepting, obtaining and/or receiving financial investments from persons ordinarily domiciled in Australia, including Robyn Cannon, Norma Swanepoel and Francis Armstrong, each of whom intended their financial investment to generate a financial return or benefit, contravened section 911A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“the Act”), by carrying on a financial services business in this jurisdiction (Australia) without holding an Australian Financial Services Licence covering the provision of the financial services.
2. The first respondent, either by himself, his servants and/or agents, is permanently restrained from carrying on a financial services business in this jurisdiction, without holding an Australian Financial Services Licence, including by:
(a) dealing in a financial product;
(b) dealing with, using or applying, Investor Funds, or authorising the dealing, use or application of Investor Funds, held in or by any of the following financial institutions or brokerage accounts:
(i) Interactive Brokers;
(ii) J.P. Schultz;
(iii) TradeStation Securities Inc;
(iv) TradeStation Futures;
(v) Bank of Montreal;
(vi) Royal Bank of Canada;
(vii) PNC Bank;
(viii) Any other financial institution or brokerage account in which Investor Funds are held or located, whether in Australia or elsewhere;
except to the extent necessary to return Investor Funds to investors.
(c) receiving or obtaining money or money’s worth (contribution) from another person ordinarily domiciled in this jurisdiction if the other person intends that the contribution will be used to generate a financial return or other benefit;
(d) engaging in conduct that is intended to induce persons in this jurisdiction to use the financial services the first respondent provides, or which is likely to have that effect; or
(e) holding a financial product (within the meaning of the Act, including a contribution intended to be used to generate a financial return or other benefit) or a beneficial interest in a financial product in trust for or on behalf of, any other person ordinarily domiciled in this jurisdiction.
3. Nothing in Order 2 prevents the first respondent from returning to any Investor any Investor Funds provided to him in relation to any financial services business carried on by him prior to the making of this order.
4. For the purposes of Order 2, Order 3, Order 5 and Order 6:
“
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Munro and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] QSC 9
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the first respondent carried on a financial services business by dealing in financial products and whether the second respondent provided a custodial or depository service. Additionally, the court had to determine if the second respondent aided and abetted the first respondent in carrying on a financial services business without the relevant licence. The court also needed to consider whether section 79 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) permits the making of a declaration against a party for aiding and abetting another party in contravening a section of the Act that does not, in itself, impose liability on the person involved in the contravention. Furthermore, the court had to determine if an injunction could be granted against a party who had not previously contravened the Act, to restrain them from contravening the Act in the future.
The court found that the first respondent carried on a financial services business by dealing in financial products, and the second respondent provided a custodial or depository service. The second respondent also aided and abetted the first respondent in carrying on a financial services business without the relevant licence. The court concluded that section 79 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) permitted the making of a declaration against the second respondent for aiding and abetting the first respondent in contravening a section of the Act that did not, in itself, impose liability on the person involved in the contravention. Finally, the court found that an injunction could be granted against a party who had not previously contravened the Act, to restrain them from contravening the Act in the future. The court provided declaratory and injunctive relief against the first and second respondents as a consequence of their alleged contraventions of section 911A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
The final orders included a declaration that the first respondent contravened section 911A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by carrying on a financial services business in Australia without holding an Australian Financial Services Licence. The first respondent was permanently restrained from carrying on a financial services business in Australia without holding the required licence, and the second respondent was permanently restrained from permitting or authorising the first respondent to use any bank or brokerage accounts in her name for the purposes of carrying on a financial services business in Australia. The first and second respondents were ordered to pay the applicant's costs of the proceeding.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The Court declares that between 1 January 2011 and 7 August 2015, the first respondent, by seeking, accepting, obtaining and/or receiving financial investments from persons ordinarily domiciled in Australia, including Robyn Cannon, Norma Swanepoel and Francis Armstrong, each of whom intended their financial investment to generate a financial return or benefit, contravened section 911A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“the Act”), by carrying on a financial services business in this jurisdiction (Australia) without holding an Australian Financial Services Licence covering the provision of the financial services.
2. The first respondent, either by himself, his servants and/or agents, is permanently restrained from carrying on a financial services business in this jurisdiction, without holding an Australian Financial Services Licence, including by:
(a) dealing in a financial product;
(b) dealing with, using or applying, Investor Funds, or authorising the dealing, use or application of Investor Funds, held in or by any of the following financial institutions or brokerage accounts:
(i) Interactive Brokers;
(ii) J.P. Schultz;
(iii) TradeStation Securities Inc;
(iv) TradeStation Futures;
(v) Bank of Montreal;
(vi) Royal Bank of Canada;
(vii) PNC Bank;
(viii) Any other financial institution or brokerage account in which Investor Funds are held or located, whether in Australia or elsewhere;
except to the extent necessary to return Investor Funds to investors.
(c) receiving or obtaining money or money’s worth (contribution) from another person ordinarily domiciled in this jurisdiction if the other person intends that the contribution will be used to generate a financial return or other benefit;
(d) engaging in conduct that is intended to induce persons in this jurisdiction to use the financial services the first respondent provides, or which is likely to have that effect; or
(e) holding a financial product (within the meaning of the Act, including a contribution intended to be used to generate a financial return or other benefit) or a beneficial interest in a financial product in trust for or on behalf of, any other person ordinarily domiciled in this jurisdiction.
3. Nothing in Order 2 prevents the first respondent from returning to any Investor any Investor Funds provided to him in relation to any financial services business carried on by him prior to the making of this order.
4. For the purposes of Order 2, Order 3, Order 5 and Order 6:
“financial services business” includes any activity concerning the trading (whether inside or outside this jurisdiction), of commodities, currencies, securities or derivatives (including futures), for or on behalf of persons who are ordinarily domiciled in this jurisdiction.
“in this jurisdiction” means in Australia.
“Investor” includes any of the persons or entities known by the following names:
(a) Robyn Cannon, also known as Robyn Grundy;
(b) Fast Forward Charters Pty Ltd as trustee for the Jackpot Superannuation Fund;
(c) Greg Von Harten;
(d) Norma Swanepoel;
(e) Catherine Heyer, also known as Anna Turner;
(f) Frank Armstrong;
(g) Anne Gale;
(h) Teagarden or the Tea Garden Family Trust;
(i) Narelle Wearne;
(j) Brooke Hobbs;
(k) Anthony Hobbs;
(l) Bob Terrill;
(m) Jean Florence Munro;
(n) Hannah Munro; and
(o) Helen Munro.
“Investor Funds” means any monies provided by any Investor to the first respondent, his servants and/or agents, since 1 January 2011 (including any interest, profit or dividend on those monies), in relation to any financial services business carried on by him.
5. The second respondent be permanently restrained from permitting or authorising the first respondent from using any bank or brokerage accounts in the second respondent’s name for the purposes of the first respondent carrying on a financial services business within this jurisdiction (Australia).
6. Nothing in Order 5 prevents the second respondent from permitting or authorising the first respondent from using any bank or brokerage accounts in the second respondent’s name in order to return to any Investor any Investor Funds provided to the first respondent in relation to any financial services business carried on by the first respondent prior to the making of this order.
7. Orders 2 and 3 made on 7 August 2015 are vacated.
8. The first and second respondents pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as a result of proceedings instituted by ASIC against the first and second respondents. ASIC sought both declaratory and injunctive relief against the respondents for alleged contraventions of s 911A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Prior to the final hearing, ASIC had investigated the first and second respondents and conducted examinations with them pursuant to s 19 of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth). During the examinations, the first and second respondents claimed privilege with respect to a number of answers and did not sign the transcripts of their examinations. The court had to determine the admissibility of the examinations in light of the claims of privilege and the unsigned transcripts.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the first respondent carried on a financial services business by dealing in financial products.
2. Whether the second respondent provided a custodial or depository service.
3. Whether the second respondent carried on a financial services business by providing a custodial or depository service.
4. Whether the second respondent aided and abetted the first respondent in carrying on a financial services business without the relevant licence.
5. Whether s 79 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) operates so as to permit the making of a declaration against a party by virtue of aiding and abetting another party in contravening a section of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) that does not, of itself, impose liability on a person involved in the contravention.
6. Whether an injunction can be granted, pursuant to s 1324(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), so as to restrain a party who has not previously contravened the Act, from contravening the Act in the future.
7. Whether the court should provide declaratory and/or injunctive relief.
8. Whether the examinations conducted pursuant to s 19 of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) were admissible in the application with respect to privileged answers.
9. Whether the examinations were admissible in the application notwithstanding the fact they had not been signed by the first and second respondents.
Held
1. The Court concluded that the first respondent contravened s 911A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by carrying on a financial services business in Australia without holding an Australian Financial Services Licence.
2. The Court held that the second respondent did not provide a custodial or depository service.
3. The Court held that the second respondent did not carry on a financial services business by providing a custodial or depository service.
4. The Court concluded that the second respondent did not aid and abet the first respondent in carrying on a financial services business without the relevant licence.
5. The Court held that s 79 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) does not permit the making of a declaration against a party for aiding and abetting another party in contravening a section of the Act that does not, of itself, impose liability on a person involved in the contravention.
6. The Court held that an injunction can be granted, pursuant to s 1324(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), to restrain a party who has not previously contravened the Act, from contravening the Act in the future.
7. The Court held that declaratory and injunctive relief should be granted against the first respondent.
8. The Court held that the examinations conducted pursuant to s 19 of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) were admissible in the application with respect to privileged answers.
9. The Court held that the examinations were admissible in the application notwithstanding the fact they had not been signed by the first and second respondents.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court found that the first respondent's actions in soliciting, accepting, and pooling funds from Australian residents, and using those funds to conduct trading through an offshore trading platform, constituted carrying on a financial services business in Australia without a required licence. This was despite the first respondent's argument that he was merely a manager operating in a supervisory context. The Court noted the first respondent's control over the pooled funds, his provision of quarterly reports, and his taking of a fee from the profits as evidence of his active involvement in the financial services business.
The Court rejected the argument that the trading was outside the jurisdiction of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission as it occurred offshore by an offshore entity. The Court held that the first respondent's conduct, which involved soliciting and pooling funds within Australia, was sufficient to bring the activity within the jurisdiction of the Act.
Regarding the second respondent, the Court found that she did not provide a custodial or depository service, nor did she carry on a financial services business by providing such a service. The Court held that the second respondent's limited role in writing blank cheques for the first respondent did not amount to providing a custodial or depository service, nor did it amount to carrying on a financial services business.
The Court also held that s 79 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) does not permit the making of a declaration against a party for aiding and abetting another party in contravening a section of the Act that does not, of itself, impose liability on a person involved in the contravention. However, the Court found that an injunction could be granted under s 1324(1) of the Act to restrain a party who has not previously contravened the Act, from contravening the Act in the future.
The Court granted both declaratory and injunctive relief against the first respondent, and injunctive relief against the second respondent, on the basis that the first respondent had contravened s 911A of the Act and that such relief was necessary to prevent future contraventions.
The Court found that the examinations conducted pursuant to s 19 of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) were admissible in the application with respect to privileged answers. The Court held that the privilege did not extend to answers that were not claimed as privileged or that were not subject to a valid claim of privilege. The Court also held that the fact that the examinations had not been signed by the first and second respondents did not render them inadmissible. The Court found that the unsigned nature of the examinations did not affect their admissibility or the validity of the answers provided during the examinations.