Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Caddick

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Caddick [2021] FCA 1443

File number: NSD 1220 of 2020
Judgment of: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 22 November 2021
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – application for declarations of contravention by defendants of s 911A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) – where defendants’ contravening conduct established – where utility in making declarations sought – application to appoint interim receivers as receivers of the first defendant’s property pursuant to s 1101B of the Corporations Act – whether Court has power to appoint receivers – extent of powers to be exercisable by receivers – where complexities arise from potential premature administration of first defendant’s estate through receivership process – application to wind up second defendant pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act and appoint provisional liquidators as liquidators – where justifiable lack of confidence in the conduct of the second defendant – where breaches of s ‍911A of the Corporations Act established – where second defendant likely insolvent – identity of liquidators to be appointed – where appointment of provisional liquidators as liquidators appropriate in the interests of efficiency – application granted in part

CORPORATIONS – application by interim receivers for payment of remuneration – where prior orders of the Court capped the interim receivers’ remuneration – where remuneration sought exceeds capped amount – where substantial work had to be undertaken that could not have been reasonably anticipated – where work undertaken by interim receivers reasonably necessary – where work delegated to fee earners at appropriate levels of seniority – where hourly rates applied below prevailing market rates for services of the same type – where costs proportionate to the work undertaken – application granted

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 244

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 20, 436A, 447A, 461, 471B, 761A, 761C, 761E, 762C, 763A, 763B, 764A, 766A, 766B, 766C, 911A, 1101B

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 9.09

Probate and Administration Act 1898 (NSW) ss 44, 61

Cases cited:

Application by Solomons [2013] FCA 1273

Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Activesuper Pty Ltd (2015) 235 FCR 181

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Marco (No 6) [2020] FCA 1781

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Merlin Diamonds Limited [2019] FCA 1546

Bilta v Nazir [2015] UKSC 23

Black v Freedman (1910) 12 CLR 105

Commissioner for Fair Trading v TLC Consulting Services Pty Ltd [2011] QSC 233

Correa v Whittingham (2013) 278 FLR 310

Courtenay House Capital Trading Group Pty Ltd (In Liq) [2018] NSWSC 404; (2018) 125 ACSR 149

DSG Holdings Australia Pty Ltd v Helenic Pty Ltd (2014) 86 NSWLR 293

Hutchins, in the matter of Ardenberg Pty Ltd (in liq) (Administrators Appointed) (No 2) [2020] FCA 1424

In the matter of Bella Fountain Pty Ltd [2017] NSWSC 391

In the matter of Lilibuck Pty Ltd [2016] NSWSC 1950

J&J Richards Super Pty Ltd ATF the J&J Richards Superannuation Fund v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Caddick and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1443
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) filed an application against Ms Caddick and Maliver Pty Ltd (Maliver), seeking various declarations and orders under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act). ASIC sought declarations of contravention of s 911A of the Corporations Act against both Ms Caddick and Maliver, an order to appoint receivers for Maliver's property, and an order to wind up Maliver and appoint provisional liquidators. The court was required to decide whether the defendants had contravened s 911A of the Corporations Act, whether the court had the power to appoint receivers and liquidators, and if so, the extent of their powers. The court also had to consider the application for the payment of remuneration by the interim receivers.

The court found that Ms Caddick and Maliver had contravened s 911A of the Corporations Act, which prohibits carrying on a financial services business without a financial services licence. The court held that it had the power to appoint receivers and liquidators, and granted the application in part. The court appointed Bruce Gleeson and Daniel Robert Soire as joint and several receivers and liquidators of Maliver's property, with specific powers and duties. The court also granted the application for the payment of remuneration by the interim receivers, finding that the work undertaken was reasonably necessary, and the remuneration was proportionate to the work carried out.

The final orders included granting leave to ASIC to file a third further amended originating process, appointing Gleeson and Soire as joint and several receivers and liquidators of Maliver's property, winding up Maliver, and fixing the remuneration, costs, and expenses of the interim receivers. The court also allowed parties to file submissions on outstanding questions of costs within specified timelines.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. Leave be granted to the plaintiff to file and serve a third further amended originating process in the form provided to the Court on 30 June 2021, to be filed electronically by 5.00 pm on 23 November 2021.

3. Leave be granted nunc pro tunc to the plaintiff, pursuant to s 471B of the Corporations Act, to continue this proceeding against the second defendant.

4. Pursuant to s 1101B(1) of the Corporations Act, Bruce Gleeson and Daniel Robert Soire of Jones Partners of Level 13, 189 Kent St, Sydney NSW 2000 be appointed as joint and several receivers (Receivers) of the Receivership Property for the purpose of:

(a) identifying, collecting and securing the Receivership Property;

(b) to the extent necessary, ascertaining the total quantum of Investor Funds and any funds advanced by any interested party to the first defendant and the identity of all investors who, in the Receivers’ view, ought to be included as an Out of Pocket Investor as well as any interested party who may be a creditor of the first defendant;

(c) subject to Order 6 below, taking possession of and realising the Receivership Property;

(d) to the extent necessary, establishing an interest-bearing account with an authorised deposit taking institution nominated by the Receivers for the purposes of holding any net proceeds of realisation of the Receivership Property (Receivers’ Trust Account); and

(e) subject to Order 7 below, seeking directions in relation to the distribution of funds in the Receivers’ Trust Account.

5. The Receivers have the following powers:

(a) the power to do all things reasonably necessary or convenient to be done, in Australia and elsewhere, for or in connection with, or as incidental to the attainment of, the objectives for which the Receivers are appointed;

(b) the powers under s 1101B(8) of the Corporations Act;

(c) the powers set out in s 420 of the Corporations Act save for the powers set out in subs 420(2)(d), (h), (j), (m), (n), (o), (s), (t) and (u) and provided that, wherever in that section the word ‘corporation’ appears, it shall be taken to include reference to the first defendant;

(d) the power to seek directions from the Court regarding any matter relating to the exercise of the Receivers’ powers; and

(e) the power to require, by request in writing, any employee, agent, banker, solicitor, stockbroker, accountant, consultant or other professionally qualified person who has provided services or advice to the first defendant, to provide such reasonable assistance (including access to any documents, books or records to which the first defendant has a right of access or control) to the Receivers as may be required from time to time.

6. Before taking possession of or realising any of the Receivership Property, the Receivers shall:

(a) give notice to any interested party of their intention to do so and inform those parties in writing that they should:

(i) advise the Receivers within 15 business days if they object to the taking possession of or sale of any of the Receivership Property and specify the basis of their objection; and

(ii) provide documentary evidence in support of their objection; and

(b) seek directions from the Court in relation to their intention to do so.

7. Before making any distribution of funds in the Receivers’ Trust Account, the Receivers shall:

(a) give notice to any interested party of their intention to do so and inform the said parties in writing that they should:

(i) advise the Receivers within 15 business days if they object to the distribution of funds in the Receivers’ Trust Account and specify the basis of their objection; and

(ii) provide documentary evidence in support of their objection; and

(b) seek directions from the Court in relation to their intention to do so.

8. The above Orders do not affect the rights of any secured creditor holding a mortgage or other security interest over any of the Receivership Property.

9. For the avoidance of doubt, nothing in these Orders is intended to limit the right of the Receivers to seek directions from the Court.

10. Immediately upon Order 4 above taking effect, the appointment of Bruce Gleeson and Daniel Robert Soire of Jones Partners of Level 13, 189 Kent St, Sydney NSW 2000 as receivers pursuant Order 5 of the Orders made on 15 December 2020 (Interim Receivers) be terminated.

11. Pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act, the second defendant, Maliver Pty Ltd (ACN 164 334 918), be wound up.

12. Bruce Gleeson and Daniel Robert Soire of Jones Partners of Level 13, 189 Kent St, Sydney NSW 2000 be appointed as joint and several liquidators of the second defendant (Liquidators).

13. Order 7 of the Orders made on 10 November 2020 be varied and leave be granted to the plaintiff to provide the Liquidators with unredacted copies of the affidavits filed by the plaintiff in this proceeding.

14. The remuneration, costs and expenses of the Interim Receivers for the period from 15 December 2020 to 22 February 2021 be fixed in the sum of $188,017.84 inclusive of GST.

15. Paragraphs 9E, 9H, 19D and 26 of the plaintiff’s third further amended originating process and paragraphs 2-4 of the Interim Receivers’ interlocutory application filed on 2 March 2021 be stood over to a date to be notified.

16. Any party who wishes to make submissions in relation to the outstanding questions of costs referred to in Order 15 above is to file and serve written submissions, not exceeding four pages in length, by 13 December 2021.

THE COURT NOTES:

17. The redactions made in the copy of the reasons for judgment to be published on 24 November 2021 at 2.15 pm AEDT are made in accordance with the non-publication orders of this Court made in this proceeding.

18. The undertaking proffered by Bruce Gleeson and Daniel Robert Soire of Jones Partners that, if a possibility of conflict in or as between their roles as Receivers and Liquidators arises, they will approach the Court and give notice to the plaintiff and investors of that circumstance.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Table of contents

1 History of the proceeding

[4]

2 Relief sought by ASIC

[11]

3 The evidence

[15]

3.1 Maliver

[16]

3.2 Documents provided to investors by Maliver

[19]

3.2.1 Maliver FSG

[22]

3.2.2 Appointment letter

[24]

3.2.3 Letter of authority

[25]

3.2.4 Fact finder and investor risk profile

[26]

3.2.5 Portfolio Valuations

[30]

3.3 [REDACTED] and [REDACTED]

[32]

3.4 Maliver’s client relationships

[46]

3.4.1 Ms Horn

[49]

3.4.1.1 Establishment of and investment by the [REDACTED]

[55]

3.4.1.2 Ms Horn’s personal investments

[59]

3.4.1.3 Interactions between Ms Horn and Ms Caddick

[64]

3.4.1.4 Summary of funds invested

[65]

3.4.2 Mr Wilson

[66]

3.4.2.1 Mr Wilson’s first meeting with Ms Caddick

[74]

3.4.2.2 Appointment of Maliver as advisor for the Wilson Super Fund

[77]

3.4.2.3 Appointment of Maliver as advisor for Mr Wilson’s personal investments

[79]

3.4.2.4 Moneys invested

[84]

3.4.2.5 Maliver’s management of the investments

[86]

3.4.3 Ms Kraft-Reid

[90]

3.4.3.1 Initial meeting with Ms Caddick

[93]

3.4.3.2 The decision to invest with Maliver

[105]

3.4.3.3 Establishment of the self-managed superannuation fund and associated bank account

[107]

3.4.3.4 Rollover of funds to the Kraft-Reid Super Fund

[111]

3.4.3.5 Ongoing relationship and dealings with Maliver

[117]

3.4.4 Mrs Coetzee

[125]

3.4.4.1 Initial meeting with Ms Caddick

[130]

3.4.4.2 Engagement of Maliver as financial advisor

[135]

3.4.4.3 Ongoing relationship

[141]

3.4.4.4 TC Super Fund ceases its investment with Maliver

[148]

3.4.4.5 TC Super Fund retains Maliver again

[150]

3.5 Evidence given by officers of CommSec

[159]

3.6 Mr Gleeson’s evidence

[169]

3.6.1 The Edgecliff Property

[185]

3.6.2 Other claims raised by Ms Caddick’s parents

[197]

3.7 Ms Caddick’s whereabouts

[201]

4 Consideration

[203]

4.1 Leave to proceed against Maliver

[204]

4.2 A financial services business without an AFSL – s 911A of the Corporations Act

[211]

4.2.1 Legislative framework

[213]

4.2.2 Have Ms Caddick or Maliver contravened s 911A of the Corporations Act?

[227]

4.2.2.1 Maliver’s conduct

[236]

4.2.2.2 Ms Caddick’s conduct

[256]

4.3 Relief

[285]

4.3.1 Declaratory relief

[285]

4.3.2 Appointment of receivers pursuant to s 1101B of the Corporations Act

[288]

4.3.2.1 The Contradictor’s submissions

[296]

4.3.2.2 Ms Caddick’s parents’ submissions

[309]

4.3.2.3 Legislative framework

[315]

4.3.2.4 The power question

[317]

4.3.2.5 Should an order be made under s 1101B(1) of the Corporations Act?

[330]

4.4 The winding up of Maliver

[360]

4.5 Who should be appointed as the Receivers?

[369]

5 Receivers’ Remuneration Application

[381]

5.1 The evidence

[384]

5.2 Legal principles

[396]

5.3 Consideration

[398]

5.4 Conclusion on the Interim Receivers’ interlocutory application

[408]

6 Costs

[409]

7 Conclusion

[411]

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The filing of the third further amended originating process should be allowed. Only Ms Caddick’s parents made submissions in relation to its filing. However, those submissions address the relief sought by the third further amended originating process, rather than the question of leave to file it, and are set out at [309]-[314] below.3. The evidence ASIC relied on a significant volume of evidence which, in broad terms, included evidence given by: ASIC as to documents obtained and findings from its investigations into Maliver and Ms Caddick; the director of the entity that held the Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSL) which Ms Caddick claimed to hold; four investors regarding their dealings with Ms Caddick; officers of CommSec regarding the existence of CommSec Accounts referred to in documents provided by Ms ‍Caddick to investors; and the Interim Receivers and Provisional Liquidators in relation to the work they have undertaken. It is neither possible nor, indeed, desirable to set out that evidence in full. It is summarised below to the extent it is relevant to the issues that arise for resolution.3.1 Maliver Maliver was incorporated on 18 June 2013. Ms Caddick is the sole director, secretary and shareholder of Maliver. ASIC is the authority that regulates the Australian financial services industry and is responsible for the supervision and granting of AFSLs pursuant to Pt 7.6 of the Corporations Act. Details of all AFSL holders and their authorised representatives are maintained by ASIC in registers within databases maintained by it pursuant to s 1274 of the Corporations Act which include the Australian Securities Commission on Time (ASCOT) database and the Seibel database. Based on searches undertaken by ASIC on the ASCOT and Seibel databases, neither Ms Caddick nor Maliver currently hold or have previously held an AFSL, Maliver is not and has never been an authorised representative of an AFSL holder and since 9 October 2009 Ms Caddick has not been and is not presently an authorised representative of an AFSL holder.3.2 Documents provided to investors by Maliver Isabella Lucy Allen is an investigator in ASIC’s financial services enforcement team as part of the Office of Enforcement. Ms Allen has been the case officer in charge of the investigation into Maliver and Ms Caddick since its commencement on 8 September 2020. Ms Allen explains that as part of its investigation ASIC has obtained more than 50,000 documents which relate to Identified Investors, who are the 72 investors listed in the document described as “Updated Annexure I” to Mr Gleeson’s affidavit sworn on 12 May 2021 and which is described at [180] below. Those documents were obtained from the following sources: (1)voluntary production by Identified Investors; (2)14 devices seized under a search warrant issued under s 39D of the ASIC Act at the Caddick Residence;(3)Ms Caddick’s email account; and (4)notices issued under s 30 of the ASIC Act. Based on her review of documents obtained from the sources referred to in the preceding paragraph, Ms Allen has identified that:(1)on and from Maliver’s incorporation, Ms Caddick generally provided the following documents to investors prior to the commencement of their investment: (a)a financial services guide from Maliver (Maliver FSG); (b)an appointment letter; (c)a letter of authority; (d)a document titled “Fact Finder”; and (e)a document titled “Investor Risk Profile”;(2)usually at the end of each month Identified Investors were provided with the following documents that appeared to be a summary of their investment:(a)a document titled “Portfolio Statement” which purported to be a print out from an Identified Investor’s CommSec account listing that investor’s current shareholding; and (b)a document titled “Transaction Summary Statement” which purported to be a print out from an Identified Investor’s CommSec account listing the shares that had been purchased or sold during a specified period through that investor’s CommSec account; (together, Portfolio Valuations); and(3)certain investors were also provided with the following documents:(a)a document titled “Appointment & Implementation of Maliver Pty Ltd as your Adviser”; (b)a document titled “Statement of Advice”; and (c)a document titled “Request for personal information form”.The documents listed at (1) and (2) above are more fully described below.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I will grant leave to any party who wishes to file submissions, not exceeding six pages in length, in relation to these matters or other aspects of costs of the proceeding within 21 days of publication of these reasons. Any party filing submissions should indicate whether an oral hearing is required or whether any outstanding questions of costs can be dealt with on the papers.7. Conclusion I will make declarations and orders giving effect to these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 29 June 2021, the first day of the hearing, I granted leave pursuant to r 2.13 of the Federal ‍Court (Corporations) Rules 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Rules) to Barbara and Edward ‍Grimley, Ms Caddick’s parents, to be heard in the proceeding without becoming a party to it. 2. Relief sought by ASIC By its second further amended originating process ASIC sought:(1)declarations of contravention of s 911A of the Corporations Act against each of Ms Caddick and Maliver;(2)an order pursuant to s 1101B(1) of the Corporations Act appointing Messrs Gleeson and Soire as joint and several receivers (Receivers) of the Receivership Property (as defined) for the purpose of, among other things, identifying, collecting, taking possession of and realising that property and distributing the proceeds of its realisation to Investors (as defined) and any Interested Party (as defined), in accordance with this Court’s directions;(3)an order that before realising any of the Receivership Property the Receivers shall: (a)give notice to any Interested Party of their intention to realise the property and inform the said parties in writing that:(i)Interested Parties should advise the [Receivers] within 10 business days if they object to the sale of any of the property, specify the precise nature of the property and the basis of their objection and provide documentary evidence in support of their objection;(ii)in the case of the Real Property, that they seek the written consent of the occupiers of any such property, which is to be provided by the occupiers within 28 days of the date of the [Receivers] giving such notice, that they will vacate the said property by a date acceptable to the [Receivers];(iii)in the event Interested Parties advise the [Receivers] of any objection to sale, the [Receivers] are required by the Court to re-list the matter and seek further directions from the Court in which case the Interested Party may be susceptible to an adverse order for costs.(b) in the event the [Receivers]:(i)receive no objections to the sale of the property within the notice period referred to in sub-paragraph 9C(a)(i) above; and (ii)in respect of the Real Property, obtain the written consent of the occupiers of the Real Property to vacate the said property in accordance with sub-paragraph 9C(a)(ii);the [Receivers] shall as soon as practicable following the expiry of the notice period referred to in sub-paragraph 9C(a)(i), and the agreed date for vacation of the Real Property, take steps to realise that property;(c)in the event objections are received within the notice period referred to in sub-paragraph 9C(a)(i) above, or in the event the [Receivers] do not procure the written consent of the occupiers of the Real Property to vacate the property within the time period, and as provided for, in subparagraph ‍9C(a)(ii), the [Receivers] shall seek directions from the Court as to whether they are justified in taking all necessary steps to realise the property (in respect of which objections have been received or which the occupants have not agreed to vacate) having regard to the said objections and in doing so join all parties they consider necessary to be joined to any such application. (4)an order pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act that Maliver be wound up and that Messrs Gleeson and Soire be appointed as liquidators; and(5)an order pursuant to s 90-15(1) of the Insolvency Practice Schedule, being Sch 2 to the Corporations Act, that the liquidators not take any steps to pursue any claims through any court proceedings that may be available to Maliver against any person or issue any examination summonses under Part 5.9 Division 1 of the Corporations Act without first seeking the Court’s approval and that they provide no less than 14 days’ written notice to ASIC of any such proposed application.