Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Caddick (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Caddick (No 2) [2023] FCA 1196

File number: NSD 1220 of 2020
Judgment of: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 5 June 2023
Date of publication of reasons: 9 October 2023
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – application made by receivers appointed pursuant to s 1101B(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – application for directions pursuant to the Court’s inherent jurisdiction; whether the receivers would be justified in making certain distributions – directions as to the method of distribution – whether the receivers would be justified in distributing to out-of-pocket investors on a pari passu basis – directions in relation to the proposed treatment of a loan secured by mortgage over receivership property –consideration of the position of interested persons – application granted

CORPORATIONS – application made by liquidators seeking directions pursuant to s 90-15 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations), being Sch 2 to the Corporations Act – directions that the liquidators are justified in providing certain releases – directions that the liquidators are justified in not further investigating, assigning or commencing claims that the company may have in relation to distribution of assets realised in the liquidation – application granted

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to extend suppression order – whether order necessary to prevent prejudice to proper administration of justice – application granted

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 424(1), 601EE subs (1) and (2), 1101B subs (1) and subs (8)
Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations), being Sch 2 to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 90-15
Trustee Act 1925 (NSW) s 63
Trustee Act 1963 (NSW) s 63
Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Caddick (2021) 395 ALR 481; [2021] FCA 1443

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Commercial Nominees of Australia Ltd (2002) 42 ACSR 240; [2002] NSWSC

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Letten (No 7) (2010) 190 FCR 59

Dean-Willcocks v Soluble Solution Hydroponics Pty Ltd (1997) 42 NSWLR 209

Glazier Holdings Pty Ltd v Australian Men’s Health (unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Young J, 30 April 1998)

Kelly (Liquidator), Halifax Investment Services Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Loo (2021) 390 ALR 669; [2021] FCA 531

Mariconte v Batiste (2000) 48 NSWLR 724

Re Anglican Development Fund Diocese of Bathurst (Recs and Mgrs Apptd) [2015] NSWSC 440

Re BBY Ltd (recs and mgrs apptd) (in liq) (No 2) (2008) 363 ALR; [2018] NSWSC 346

Re GB Nathan & Co Pty Ltd (in liq) (1991) 24 NSWLR 674

Re Tayeh and Another (as joint liqs of The Black Stump Enterprises Pty Ltd and Others) (2005) 53 ACSR 684; [2005] NSWSC 475

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 100
Date of hearing: 31 May 2023; 5 June 2023
Counsel for Bruce Gleeson and Daniel Robert Soire in their capacity as joint and several receivers of the property of Melissa Louise Caddick: Ms V…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Caddick (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1196
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves an application made by receivers and liquidators, appointed in relation to Ms Caddick, for various directions concerning the distribution of assets. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The legal issues that the court had to decide included whether the receivers would be justified in making certain distributions, whether the receivers would be justified in distributing to out-of-pocket investors on a pari passu basis, and whether the liquidators would be justified in providing certain releases and not further investigating, assigning or commencing claims that the company may have.

The court found that the receivers would be justified in making an interim distribution of up to $3,000,000 of the Receivership Property to the Out-of-Pocket Investors on a pari passu basis, and in making a payment of $950,000 to Edward and Barbara Grimley upon them providing vacant possession of the Edgecliff Property. The court also found that the liquidators would be justified in providing certain releases and in not further investigating, assigning or commencing claims that the company may have. The court granted the orders sought by the Receivers, the Liquidators and Investor A in their respective applications.

The ratio of this case is that silence coupled with surrounding circumstances may be tantamount to assent, but in this case, creditors were not informed of the basis on which the court might make a pooling order or the considerations that might influence its decision making. The court found that in the circumstances of this case, the receivers and liquidators were justified in making certain distributions and providing certain releases. The court also found that Investor A was justified in stepping forward to take on a more active role as a representative defendant on behalf of the group of Out-of-Pocket Investors.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 37AF(1)(a) and s 37AG(1) and (c) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), the publication and disclosure of the names of the investors and account details included in Annexure MDV-2 to the affidavit of Martin Duc Vu sworn 2 June 2023 is prohibited other than to the parties to this proceeding, each of their legal representatives, and the Court until the later of the discharge of the Receivers or the deregistration of Maliver Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (Company).

2. Evidence filed and relied on in this proceeding by Messrs Gleeson and Soire in their capacity as Receivers of the property of Melissa Louise Caddick in support of their amended interlocutory application lodged with the Court on 12 May 2023 shall be evidence in the interlocutory application filed by Messrs Gleeson and Soire as liquidators of the Company on 2 June 2023.

Receivership

Edgecliff Loan

3. The direction to the Receivers given in Order 6(e) of the Orders made on 25 July 2022 is vacated insofar as it relates to the Edgecliff Property.

4. The Receivers would be justified in placing monies into an offset account held with the National Australia Bank (NAB) and linked to debts payable to NAB by the first defendant secured over the Edgecliff Property, on the terms proposed by NAB in its letter to the Receivers dated 16 March 2023.

Interim distribution to Out-of-Pocket Investors

5. The Receivers would be justified in making an interim distribution of up to $3,000,000 of the Receivership Property to the Out-of-Pocket Investors, on a pari passu basis.

Payment to Mr and Mrs Grimlev

6. The Receivers would be justified in making a payment from the Receivers’ Trust Account to Edward and Barbara Grimley (Grimleys) in the amount of $950,000 (Settlement Sum) upon the Grimleys providing vacant possession of the Edgecliff Property on the basis that:

(a) the Grimleys will provide vacant possession of the Edgecliff Property to the Receivers within six weeks of the date of these Orders;

(b) upon payment of the Settlement Sum:

(i) the Grimleys will cause to be removed from the title of the Edgecliff Property caveats AQ 623920, AQ664219, AQ786558;

(ii) the Receivers, the Liquidators and the Company release the Grimleys in respect of all matters relating to the Receivership Property, the Company, their dealings with Melissa Caddick and the proceeding;

(iii) the Grimleys release the Receivers, the Liquidators and the Company in respect of all matters relating to the Receivership Property, the Company, their dealings with Melissa Caddick and the proceeding.

7. The Receivers would be justified in providing the release to the Grimleys referred to in Order 6(b)(ii) above.

Sale of the Edgecliff Property

8. Subject to completion of those matters specified in Order 6 above, the Receivers would be justified in taking possession of the Edgecliff Property, and:

(a) preparing the Edgecliff Property for sale including, but not limited to, removing items from the Edgecliff Property, undertaking maintenance and repairs that they consider appropriate and arranging for the styling of the Edgecliff Property;

(b) undertaking a selection process with a view to appointing a real estate agent or agents to commence marketing the Edgecliff Property for sale;

(c) appointing a real estate agent or agents to market the sale of the Edgecliff Property;

(d) obtaining updated valuation(s) of the Edgecliff Property;

(e) insuring the Edgecliff Property;

(f) preparing a contract for sale;

(g) marketing the sale of the Edgecliff Property; and

(h) incurring expenses in the process of implementing (a) to (g) above, which expenses may be paid from the Receivers’ Trust Account.

9. The Receivers would be justified in realising the Edgecliff Property by conducting a sales and marketing campaign of the Edgecliff Property as recommended by the real estate agent appointed by the Receivers.

10. The Receivers would be justified in applying the proceeds of such sale as follows:

(a) first, any necessary property adjustments in order to sell the property including applicable council, water, strata and utility rates;

(b) second, the sales and marketing expenses of any real estate agent appointed by the Receivers;

(c) third, costs in relation to conveyancing costs of the solicitor for the Receivers;

(d) fourth, any taxes including but not limited to capital gains tax, land tax and goods and services tax;

(e) fifth, the debts secured over the Edgecliff Property including mortgage debts pursuant to the registered mortgages to the NAB;

(f) sixth, costs of attending to remove, securing, dealing with and storing any Receivership Property located at the Edgecliff Property; and

(g) thereafter by deposit into the Receivers’ Trust Account established in accordance with Order 4(d) of the Orders made on 22 November 2021.

Further distributions

11. The Receivers shall seek directions from the Court prior to any further or final distribution.

12. Any further interim or final distribution to Out-of-Pocket Investors will be made on a pari passu basis.

Other matters

13. The Receivers’ legal costs and expenses of the Amended Interlocutory Application filed by the Receivers on 15 May 2023 are to be paid out of the Receivership Property.

14. Without limiting Order 5 made on 8 March 2023, pursuant to s 43 of the Federal Court Act and r 2.13(5) of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth), the legal costs and expenses reasonably incurred by Investor A in this proceeding be paid out of the Receivership Property and on an indemnity basis.

Liquidation

15. Pursuant to s 90-15 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule (IPS) being Schedule 2 to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) the Liquidators would be justified in providing the release to the Grimleys referred to in Order 6(b)(ii) above.

16. Pursuant to s 90-15 of the IPS the Liquidators would be justified in not further investigating, assigning, commencing or seeking to enforce or compromise any claim that the Company may have against the first defendant (or her deceased estate or trustee in bankruptcy) including:

(a) in respect of Receivership Property; or

(b) which, if made out, would be payable from the Receivership Property.

17. Pursuant to s 90-15 of the IPS so long as the total admitted amounts for admitted creditors of the Company (other than any Out-of-Pocket Investors) is not more than $11,000, the Liquidators would be justified in making any distribution of assets realised in the liquidation in accordance with s 556 of the Corporations Act but, in respect of any amounts payable to any Out-of-Pocket Investors or any admitted creditors of the Company:

(a) first, pari passu amongst any admitted creditors of the Company other than any Out-of-Pocket Investors; and

(b) then, pari passu amongst all Out-of-Pocket Investors.

Suppression orders

18. Except as provided in Order 19 below, the following orders made pursuant to ss 37AF(1)(a) and (b), 37AG(1)(a) and (c) and 37AI of the Federal Court Act be extended until the later of the discharge of the Receivers or the deregistration of the Company:

(a) Order 7 made on 10 November 2020;

(b) Order 1 made on 10 December 2020;

(c) Order 18 made on 15 December 2020;

(d) Order 8 made on 17 December 2020;

(e) Orders 2 and 3 made on 22 February 2021;

(f) Order 1 made on 9 March 2021;

(g) Order 2 made on 24 May 2021;

(h) Order 2 made on 15 June 2021;

(i) Orders 5 and 6 made on 29 June 2021;

(j) Order 3 made on 23 August 2021;

(k) Order 2 made on 26 November 2021;

(l) Orders 5, 6 and 7 made on 4 March 2022 at 11.00 am;

(m) Order 1 made on 4 March 2022 at 2.00 pm;

(n) Order 1 made on 22 March 2022;

(o) Order 2 made on 25 July 2022;

(p) Order 1 made on 31 October 2022;

(q) Order 10 made on 8 March 2023; and

(r) Order 3 made on 31 May 2023.

19. Pursuant to s 37AF(1)(a) and (b) and s 37AG(1)(a) and (c) of the Federal Court Act, the publication or disclosure of:

(a) the Grimleys’ bank account details be prohibited until the passing of Barbara Anne Grimley or Edward Grimley, whichever occurs later; and

(b) the name of the son of the first defendant be prohibited until 30 June 2024, other than to the parties to this proceeding and each of their legal representatives and the Court.

20. Pursuant to s 37AF(1)(a) and (b) and s 37AG(1)(a) and (c) of the Federal Court Act, Order 1 made on 8 March 2023 and extended on 28 April 2023, 5 May 2023 and 31 May 2023, be extended until the date that is six months after the later of the discharge of the Receivers or the deregistration of the Company.

21. To the extent necessary, the hearing of this matter listed on 4 and 7 August 2023 is vacated.

22. Mr and Mrs Grimley and Investor A, each of whom are named as interested persons in this proceeding, are excused from further attendance.

23. Liberty to apply on two days’ notice.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

These are my reasons for making the orders. BACKGROUNDOrders made on 22 November 2021 The Receivers were appointed pursuant to s 1101B(1) of the Corporations Act by Orders made on 22 November 2021 (22 November 2021 Orders) over the Receivership Property which was defined as all property, as defined in s 9 of the Corporations Act, of Ms Caddick. By those Orders Messrs Gleeson and Soire were also appointed as liquidators of Maliver: see Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Caddick (2021) 395 ALR 481; [2021] FCA 1443 (ASIC v Caddick). It is convenient to set out some of the findings made in ASIC v Caddick. Mr Gleeson gave evidence in the proceeding, both in his capacity, at the time, as joint receiver and provisional liquidator. Relevantly:(1)I noted that Mr Gleeson was of the opinion that subject to the claim by Mr and Mrs Grimley in relation to the Edgecliff Property, assets held by Maliver or Ms Caddick that were purchased after October 2012 were purchased using investor funds or from proceeds from property acquired with investor funds: see ASIC v Caddick at [177];(2)I referred to Mr Gleeson’s investigations which demonstrated the extent of the intermingling of funds and thus supported his view that it was difficult to determine for what particular amounts advanced by investors were ultimately used. The intermingling of funds supported the conclusions in the interim receivers’ and provisional liquidators’ reports dated 15 February 2021 that Ms Caddick treated the financial affairs of Maliver and her personal affairs as one: see ASIC v Caddick at [178];(3)the investigations revealed that: (a)when investor funds were paid either into a Citibank account in the name of Ms Caddick’s brother, Adam Grimley, or the bank accounts of Maliver or Ms Caddick, they were used to pay for living expenses, meet mortgage payments for the Edgecliff Property and Ms Caddick’s residence or to purchase property in the name of Maliver or Ms Caddick; and (b)investor funds were also transferred to other bank accounts controlled by Ms Caddick and that frequent transfers between accounts meant that investor funds had been intermingled with a number of accounts making it difficult to determine for what particular amounts advanced by investors were ultimately used,see ASIC v Caddick at [178]; (4)I noted that Mr Gleeson’s investigations confirmed that investor funds which were advanced to Ms Caddick and, following its incorporation, Maliver were used to meet Ms Caddick’s personal expenses and to purchase assets in her name: see ASIC v Caddick at [179]; (5)I referred to a document prepared by the receivers and provisional liquidators, titled “Updated Annexure I”, which set out the investors who contributed funds for investment with Ms Caddick or Maliver, whether they invested as individuals, companies or through a self-managed superannuation fund, for each investor details of amounts paid, the date and purpose of payment and bank accounts into which the payments were made and any amounts returned to investors by Ms Caddick or Maliver. Mr Gleeson’s evidence about Updated Annexure I included:(a)the total funds advanced, including of management fees, and received by investors including the amount of profit received by investors who were repaid;(b)the total amount owed to the remaining investors after taking account of those investors who had been repaid, referred to as Out-Of-Pocket Investors, being $23,554,921; and(c)that he had undertaken a tracing exercise. He explained his analysis of the sources of funds received by Maliver and the uses to which those funds were put which underpin his conclusion that the assets held by Ms Caddick and Maliver were acquired with investor funds,see ASIC v Caddick at [180]-[184];(6)I set out Mr Gleeson’s evidence in relation to the tracing exercise he undertook insofar as it dealt with the Edgecliff Property and the dispute that had arisen with Mr and Mrs Grimley who had made a claim in relation to that property: see ASIC v Caddick at [185]-[196]; and(7)I referred to a “secondary claim” made by Mr and Mrs Grimley and an alternate claim in relation to the Edgecliff Property: see ASIC v Caddick at [197]-[200].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In particular it was both necessary and of assistance to the Court and the resolution of the proceeding for the Out-of-Pocket Investors to be represented in the proceeding, given its nature; Investor A came forward and was prepared to take on that representative role; and in doing so Investor A made submissions in the interests of the larger group of Out-of-Pocket Investors. As a member of the group of Out-of-Pocket Investors referred to in the evidence in this proceeding, Investor A has had the benefit of an order suppressing her name. It would be curious if, because she stepped forward to take on a more active role as a representative defendant on behalf of that class, she would lose that benefit. This is particularly so in a case such as this where competing claims to a finite pool of assets are to be considered, making the participation of each claimant group critical to a resolution of the proceeding. As Investor A submitted, if the Court is not willing, in circumstances such as these, to extend the Order, there is a real risk that people would not be willing to step forward and take on those critical roles.CONCLUSION For those reasons I made the orders sought by the Receivers, the Liquidators and Investor A in their respective applications.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Re Tayeh and Another (as joint liqs of The Black Stump Enterprises Pty Ltd and Others) (2005) 53 ACSR 684; [2005] NSWSC 475 Barrett J explored the circumstances in which creditors may be deemed to have provided their assent in relation to the liquidators’ proposed scheme for the assets of associated companies to be pooled and for dividends to creditors to be paid from a single pool of assets. His Honour noted (at [24]) that “[t]here may be circumstances in which silence, coupled with surrounding circumstances is tantamount to assent”, citing Re Bailey Hay & Co Ltd [1971] 3 All ER 693 as an example. Justice Barrett declined to make the directions sought by the liquidators in that case. In doing so at [25] his Honour noted that: … In the present case, creditors were told that the liquidators proposed to ask the court to make “a pooling order”. They were not informed of the basis on which the court might make “a pooling order” or the considerations that might influence its decision, apart from the intermingling of the companies’ financial affairs. In particular, they were not told that any evaluation of the existence or non-existence of creditors’ unanimous approval of what was proposed might play a part in the court’s decision making. Having received the messages they received, the creditors would have had the impression that the court would, in some undefined way, look after matters on its own and without regard for their wishes or attitudes.CONSIDERATIONThe Edgecliff Property and the offer made by Mr and Mrs Grimley The Receivers submitted that they were cognisant of their obligations to act in the best interests of creditors as a whole and act impartially between them. They noted that they do not themselves have the power to accept Mr and Mrs Grimley’s offer or to compromise claims that other creditors may have against the Receivership Property. In those circumstances they sought the directions in their amended interlocutory application. It was apparent from the evidence before me that a distribution to Mr and Mrs Grimley on the basis of their offer was likely to result in an earlier and more certain outcome for the Out-of-Pocket Investors than the alternative, namely a hearing of the dispute between Mr and Mrs Grimley and the Out-of-Pocket Investors as to whether Mr and Mrs Grimley have the interest they assert in the Edgecliff Property. That that was so was evident from:(1)the nature of the dispute between Mr and Mrs Grimley and the Out-of-Pocket Investors and the issues it raises; and(2)the modelling undertaken by the Receivers in relation to the likely cost of the litigation and the time it would take. As to the modelling I note that, on close examination, it was relatively conservative in that it did not take into account both the cost and time for any appeals that might lie from a decision at first instance. Further, as submitted by the Receivers the modelling carried out by them indicated that, even if the Out-of-Pocket Investors were wholly successful in the proceeding with Mr and Mrs Grimley and all contingencies as to the costs of the proceeding were to favour them, at best distributions may only be marginally higher than if they accepted Mr and Mrs Grimley’s offer. Of course in the event that any of the variables in the modelling proved to be inaccurate and, in particular too conservative, the distributions could be lower. Critically, Mr and Mrs Grimley’s offer provided the Out-of-Pocket Investors with certainty about an outcome which seemed to be similar to the best outcome that could in any event be expected following a complex and possibly protracted proceeding.