Australian Executor Trustees Limited v Propell National Valuers (WA) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Executor Trustees Limited v Propell National Valuers (WA) Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 522

Citation: Australian Executor Trustees Limited v Propell National Valuers (WA) Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 522
Parties: AUSTRALIAN EXECUTOR TRUSTEES LIMITED (ACN 007 869 794) and SEIZA MORTGAGE COMPANY PTY LTD (ACN 114 436 412) v PROPELL NATIONAL VALUERS (WA) PTY LTD (ACN 009 455 056) and TRAVIS COLEMAN
File number: NSD 974 of 2010
Judge: BARKER J
Date of judgment: 18 May 2011
Catchwords: TRADE PRACTICES – whether representations contained within a valuation of property provided by the respondents for the purpose of ascertaining whether property represented acceptable security for mortgage purposes were misleading or deceptive or were likely to mislead or deceive contrary to s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) –– whether valuation fell within accepted range of values that a competent valuer might ascribe to the value of the subject property valued – whether appropriate for expert witnesses to take into account sales subsequent to the date of valuation for the purposes of the proceedings – whether second respondent involved in the contravention within the meaning of s 75B of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

TRADE PRACTICES – whether applicants relied upon the representations in the valuation – where evidence of reliance of the applicants upon the valuation limited - reliance on valuation by applicants made out on the balance of probabilities and by proper inference drawn from the evidence

NEGLIGENCE - whether second respondent owed a duty of care for the purposes of the law of negligence to the applicants – where second respondent is a licensed valuer employed by first respondent, and who prepared and signed the valuation - whether second respondent assumed personal responsibility towards the applicants – where second respondent knew the valuation would be relied upon by applicants for mortgage security purposes 
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 51A
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 52, s 53A, s 75B, 82, s 87
Cases cited: Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 95
Daandine Pastoral Company Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Land Tax of the Commonwealth of Australia (High Court of Australia, Williams J, 26th August 1943, unreported)
Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Peat Marwick Hungerfords [1997] HCA 8; (1997) 188 CLR 241
Fitzgerald Enterprises (WA) Pty Ltd v Bob Slight’s Boat School Pty Ltd [2009] WADC 50
Frewin v Emmdale Sports Club Inc [2003] NSWSC 108
Genworth Financial Mortgage Insurance Pty Ltd v Hodder Rook & Associates Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 1043
Great Wall Resources Pty Ltd v O’Sullivan [2009] NSWCA 119
Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465
Hill v Van Erp (1997) 188 CLR 159
HTW Valuers (Central Qld) Pty Ltd v Astonland Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 54
Interchase Corporation Ltd v ACN 010 087 573 Pty Ltd [2003] 1 Qd R 26
Kestrel Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN 009 590 265) v APF Properties Pty Ltd (ACN…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Executor Trustees Limited v Propell National Valu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 522
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Australian Executor Trustees Limited v Propell National Valuers (WA) Pty Ltd, the plaintiffs sought damages for alleged misleading or deceptive conduct by the defendants under section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and for breach of a duty of care. The plaintiffs, Australian Executor Trustees Limited and Seiza Mortgage Company Pty Ltd, claimed that the defendants, Propell National Valuers (WA) Pty Ltd and Travis Coleman, provided a misleading valuation of property at 95 Curtin Avenue, Cottesloe, Western Australia, which was intended to be security for a mortgage. The plaintiffs alleged that the valuation overstated the value of the property and that they relied on this valuation when making lending decisions.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the valuation provided by the defendants contained misleading or deceptive representations in contravention of section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), whether the valuation fell within the accepted range of values a competent valuer might ascribe, and whether Coleman, as a licensed valuer, owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs. Additionally, the court had to consider whether subsequent sales could be taken into account in assessing the value of the property for the purposes of the proceedings. The plaintiffs also sought damages under section 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and for breach of duty of care at common law.

The court held that the valuation provided by the defendants was misleading and deceptive, and that the plaintiffs relied on this valuation for the purpose of assessing the property as security for a mortgage. The court found that Coleman owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs in preparing the valuation, and that the valuation did not fall within the accepted range of values a competent valuer might ascribe. The court rejected the argument that subsequent sales could be taken into account for the purposes of the proceedings, finding that to do so would be to ascribe a value with the benefit of hindsight, which was not available to a competent valuer at the relevant date. Consequently, the court concluded that the defendants had contravened section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and breached their duty of care.

The court ordered that the defendants pay damages to the plaintiff Australian Executor Trustees Limited in the sum of $405,682.15 plus pre-judgment interest, and that the plaintiffs would also be entitled to their costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This proceeding was conducted under the Court’s Fast Track practice note (CM 8). While damages under s 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (TP Act), compensation under s 87 of the TP Act and damages for breach of duty of care at common law were claimed by both the first applicant, Australian Executors Trustees Ltd (AET) and the second applicant, Seiza Mortgage Company Pty Ltd (Seiza Mortgage Co) in the Fast Track application, at trial senior counsel for the applicants opened the case on the basis that only the first applicant, AET, sought relief and that relief was only for damages under s 82 of the TP Act and damages at common law. FACTS At all material times, the first respondent, Propell National Valuers (WA) Pty Limited (Propell) carried on business as a valuer, and the second respondent, Travis Coleman (Mr Coleman) was employed by Propell as a licensed valuer within the State of Western Australia. As explained in more detail below, on or about 20 April 2007, Seiza Mortgage Co received a loan application from a Mr Michael Paul Pell, the stated purpose of which was, in part, to refinance an existing mortgage with another entity, Mortgage Ezy Pty Ltd, over property located at 95 Curtin Avenue, Cottesloe, Western Australia (the subject property), in the sum of $1,200,000. Mr Pell’s loan application included a copy of a valuation for the subject property dated 3 April 2007, addressed to Mortgage Ezy Pty Ltd, which had been issued by Propell and signed by Mr Coleman. An officer of Seiza Mortgage Co, who appears to have been a Mr Dean Italia, recommended approval of a four year “Lo-Doc Cash Flow” loan with a loan-to-value ratio (LVR) of 75%, subject to receipt of a valuation report. Seiza Mortgage Co seems to have operated to that point on the basis that the valuation attached to the loan application was indicative of the true value of the subject property. By a “pre-approval” letter dated 26 April 2007, AET (on the face of it by its agent, “Mortgage Ezy Pty Ltd – Qld”) notified Mr Pell that, among other things, a valuation report was required. Propell were then re‑instructed by Mr Pell or his agent (which also appear to have been Mortgage Ezy Pty Ltd – Qld or its principal, a Mr McLeod) to prepare a new valuation. Mr Coleman completed the task after visiting the subject property and satisfying himself that it appeared to be in same condition as it was when he completed the 3 April valuation for Mortgage Ezy. He then signed a new valuation which was provided to Seiza Mortgage Co on 7 May 2007. The valuation issued by Propell and signed by Mr Coleman and given to Seiza Mortgage Co on 7 May stated that the report could be relied on by, amongst others, AET and Seiza Mortgage Co. Mr Coleman accepted, in the course of evidence, that the valuation so issued was issued with the intention or expectation that the appellants could rely on it for the purposes of assessing and approving the subject property as security for a loan. The valuation issued by Propell and given to Seiza Mortgage Co contained a representation that the market value of the subject property as at 3 April 2007 was $1,600,000.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the recovery process may be said to have been drawn out, I find that the applicants took reasonable steps to mitigate their loss in all the circumstances.CONCLUSION AND ORDERS For the reasons given above, I consider the representations as to value of the subject property contained in the valuation of the respondents dated 7 May 2007, were misleading and deceptive in contravention of s 52 of the TP Act, and also in breach of the duty of care the respondents owed to the applicants to prepare the valuation with due care and skill. I find the applicants relied on those representations and that AET has suffered loss. I will invite counsel to bring forward a minute reflecting the findings and damages I have assessed in the sum of $405,682.15 plus pre‑judgment interest. The applicants will also be entitled to their costs of the proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to sales evidence analysis methodology, Mr Kish considered sales evidence on the basis of gross price and weighted same by overall comparison to the subject property. Mr Hughes, by contrast, stated that he considered the sales evidence in accordance with the systematic procedure set out in the International Valuation Guidance Note 1 (ANZ VGN1) entitled “Real Property Valuation” and analyses based on relevant units of comparison or price per square metre. The valuers disagreed on the approach to analysis of sales evidence. In the opinion of Mr Hughes, sales evidence used by Mr Kish was not reported and adequately analysed in accordance with the requirements of the Australian Property Institute guidelines. Mr Kish disagreed.CONSIDERATION Subsequent sales: Mr Kish’s valuation depends on a number of sales that occurred after the date upon which Mr Coleman valued the subject property on 3 April 2007. They have been identified above. The primary question, which the two valuers, Mr Hughes and Mr Kish dispute is whether it is permissible, for present purposes, for a valuer to have regard to such subsequent sales in expressing an opinion as to what the value of the subject property was as at 3 April 2007. As a matter of broad principle, one would have thought that to take account of subsequent sales in present circumstances is to ascribe a value with the benefit of hindsight, something obviously not available to a competent valuer at the relevant valuation date. That suggests, unless the exercise in a particular case is to state what, with the benefit of hindsight, the value was at an earlier date, that such an approach is impermissible. Another way of expressing that, perhaps, is to ask whether the object of the valuation exercise is to be able to say whether a price paid at some earlier point seems to have been a fair price. In my view, as a matter of principle, Mr Hughes is correct when he asserts that in providing for the purposes of these proceedings a valuation of the subject property as at 3 April 2007, it is inappropriate to take account of subsequent sales. This is because the task before the Court is to assess whether, upon the sales evidence available as of 3 April 2007, a competent valuer could have, using the comparable sales methodology, ascribed a value of $1,600,000, or thereabouts to the subject property. The respondents challenge this in principle approach by reference to what Williams J said in Daandine. Daandine came before Williams J in the High Court of Australia, Queensland Registry, as Appeal Number 2 of 1942, pursuant to The Lands Tax Assessment Act 1910‑1940 (Cth) (LTA Act) against the assessment of the Deputy Commissioner of Taxes for the financial year 1939‑1940. Daandine Station was purchased by the appellant in 1926. For the financial years ending 30 June 1939, 1940 and 1941, in respect of 36,737 acres of freehold land used for grazing and fattening cattle, the Commissioner assessed the appellant upon an unimproved value of £38,574 or in round figures, 21 shillings per acre. The appellant contended that the value was excessive and that the true unimproved value was in round figures, 15 shillings per acre.