Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Qteq Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Qteq Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 371

File number: NSD 1060 of 2022
Judgment of: BROMWICH J
Date of judgment: 17 April 2025
Catchwords:

COMPETITION – alleged attempts to enter into contracts, arrangements or understandings with companies in the coal seam gas industry that would be contraventions of s 44ZZRJ/45AJ of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) – alleged attempts to induce entry into the same contracts, arrangements or understandings – cartel provisions to allocate customers, limit bids and prevent, restrict or limit the supply of services in competition with the first respondent – whether subjects of the attempts were or were likely to be in competition with the first respondent at the relevant times – whether conduct unilateral or amounted to an attempt to arrive at an understanding or induce arrival at an understanding – HELD: five of six attempts alleged by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission established, with respect to both the first and second respondents

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – s 45AC of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) – scope of deeming provisions – whether broader definition of “party” in s 45AC applied to attempt or attempt to induce cases

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 4D (repealed), 4F(1)(a), 44ZZRB (now s 45AB), 44ZZRC (now s 45AC), 44ZZRD (now s 45AD), 44ZZRJ (now 45AJ), 44ZZRP (now s 45AP), 45(5), 45AB, 45AC, 45AD, 45AD, 45AD(1), 45AD(3), 45AD(4), 45AJ, 45AP, 45AR, 45AR(1), 45AR(3), 47, 47(2), 47(4), 47(10), 76(1), 84(1), 84(2), 84(3), 84(4), 88, 93, 155(1)(c), Pt IV, Div 1 of Pt IV, Pt VI

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 44, 60, 136

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Air New Zealand Ltd [2014] FCA 1157; 319 ALR 388

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Egg Corporation Ltd [2017] FCAFC 152; 254 FCR 311

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v BlueScope Steel Ltd (No 5) [2022] FCA 1475

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cascade Coal Pty Ltd [2019] FCAFC 154; 374 ALR 90

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Delta Building Automation Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 880

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v J Hutchinson Pty Ltd [2015] HCA 10

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Olex [2017] FCA 222; ATPR 42-540

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pacific National Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 77; 277 FCR 49

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v SIP Australia Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 824; ATPR 41-877

Commissioner of Taxation v Comber [1986] FCA 92; 10 FCR 88

Doney v The Queen [1990] HCA 51; 171 CLR 207

Ellison v Sandini Pty Ltd [2018] FCAFC 44; 263 FCR 460

Heating Centre Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission [1986 FCA 72; 9 FCR 153

Holdsworth v Commissioner of Police (NSW) [2020] NSWSC 228

J Hutchinson Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2024] FCAFC 18; 302 FCR 79

Jenks v Dickinson [1997] STC 853 (Ch D)

Jones…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Qteq Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 371
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Qteq Pty Ltd and its managing director, Mr Ashton, alleging contraventions of the cartel provisions under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). Specifically, the ACCC alleged that both Qteq and Mr Ashton had engaged in attempts to enter into contracts, arrangements, or understandings with companies in the coal seam gas industry that would contravene the cartel provisions. The allegations involved six separate attempts, three involving Pro-Test, two involving Eastern Well No 2, and one involving Firetail.

The court was required to determine whether the alleged conduct of Qteq and Mr Ashton contravened the cartel provisions. This involved examining the nature of the alleged agreements, whether they were unilateral or concerted attempts, and whether the parties were or were likely to be in competition at the relevant times. Additionally, the court needed to interpret the scope of the deeming provisions in section 45AC of the Competition and Consumer Act to determine if the broader definition of “party” applied to the attempt or attempt to induce cases.

The court found that five out of the six attempts alleged by the ACCC were established, with respect to both Qteq and Mr Ashton. Specifically, the court found that the three attempts involving Pro-Test and the two attempts involving Eastern Well No 2 were proven, while the attempt involving Firetail was not established as the competition condition was not met. The court held that the competition condition required proving that the subjects of the attempts were or were likely to be in competition with Qteq at the relevant times. The court found that the ACCC had established this condition for the Pro-Test and Eastern Well No 2 attempts but not for the Firetail attempt.

The court ordered that the parties confer and provide by email to the chambers of Justice Bromwich an agreed draft or competing drafts of the terms of the declarations of contravention, an order extending the commencement of the time within which any appeal proceeding is required to be filed, and procedural orders for the preparation and hearing of the relief phase of the proceeding. The court also listed the proceeding for any necessary case management hearing at a time to be fixed in consultation with the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties confer and by 7 May 2025, or such further time as may be allowed, provide by email to the chambers of Justice Bromwich an agreed draft or competing drafts of:

(a) the terms of the declarations of contravention to be made in accordance with the reasons for judgment;

(b) an order extending the commencement of the time within which any appeal proceeding is required to be filed in this proceeding to the end of the next business day after the judgment on relief is delivered; and

(c) procedural orders for the preparation and hearing of the relief phase of this proceeding, including as to evidence, submissions and a joint list of authorities with pinpoint references.

2. The proceeding be listed for any necessary case management hearing at a time to be fixed in consultation with the parties.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

A. INTRODUCTION

[1]

B. THE ALLEGATIONS

[8]

Overview of the ACCC’s case

[8]

Attempt #1 (Pro-Test 2017 Customer Allocation Understanding: 27 June–October 2017)

[14]

Attempt #2 (Pro-Test 2017 QGC Tender Understanding: 27 October–10 November 2017)

[16]

Attempt #3 (Pro-Test 2019 Market Sharing Understanding: 24 June 2019)

[18]

Attempt #4 (Easternwell 2017 Non-Compete Agreement: 6–17 November 2017)

[20]

Attempt #5 (Easternwell 2018-2019 Non-Compete Agreement: 7 December 2018–11 February 2019)

[22]

Attempt #6 (Firetail Understanding: 19–20 September 2017)

[24]

Timeline overview

[25]

The trial evidence

[27]

C. APPLICABLE LEGAL PRINCIPLES

[31]

Case law

[32]

Conduct

[34]

Intention

[38]

Arrangements and understandings

[43]

Cartel provisions

[46]

Purpose condition

[49]

Competition condition

[51]

Defences and exceptions

[55]

D. THE COAL SEAM GAS INDUSTRY

[57]

Key entities and people

[58]

Qteq

[58]

Pro-Test

[61]

Easternwell

[65]

Firetail

[69]

QGC

[70]

GeoPSI

[72]

Welldog

[75]

Farley Riggs

[78]

Key terms

[80]

E. THE PRO-TEST UNDERSTANDINGS (ATTEMPTS #1, #2 AND #3)

[81]

Introduction

[81]

The pleading issue

[87]

Witness testimony

[106]

Mr Ashton and Mr Meldrum

[107]

Mr Dabrowski

[115]

Motivation for reporting Qteq to the ACCC

[116]

Relationship with Mr Ashton and Qteq

[130]

Alleged inconsistencies in Mr Dabrowski’s account

[133]

Business dealings

[139]

Lack of contemporaneous records

[140]

Conclusion on Mr Dabrowski’s credibility

[141]

Mr McDonald

[142]

Attempt #1: The Pro-Test 2017 Customer Allocation Understanding

[143]

Background

[146]

The QGC tender package release – 23 and 24 October 2017

[146]

Relationship between Pro-Test, Santos and Origin

[161]

Conduct

[162]

Discussions between Mr Ashton and Mr Dabrowski – June to October 2017

[162]

Kingsley’s dinner – 26 October 2017

[165]

Respondents’ further submissions on the alleged conduct

[173]

Conclusion on Attempt #1

[186]

Attempt #2: The Pro-Test 2017 QGC Tender Understanding

[193]

Conduct

[199]

Conversations between Mr Ashton and Mr Dabrowski after the release of the QGC tenders

[199]

Meeting at Qteq’s offices – 2 November 2017

[208]

Qteq provides pricing for GeoPSI to Pro-Test – 10 November 2017

[217]

Consideration

[230]

Mr Dabrowski’s evidence

[230]

Corroborating evidence

[231]

The respondents’ arguments

[233]

Conclusion on Attempt #2

[249]

Attempt #3: The Pro-Test 2019 Market Sharing Understanding

[255]

Conduct

[258]

The Fantauzzo Hotel dinner – 24 June 2019

[258]

Conclusion on Attempt #3

[266]

Competition condition as to completions and DST for Attempts #1, #2 and #3

[272]

Must the ACCC prove that Qteq was in competition with Pro-Test in relation to drill stem testing?

[273]

Was Qteq in competition with Pro-Test in relation to DST services?

[281]

Testimony and statements of Mr Meldrum, Mr Ashton and Mr Dabrowski

[284]

Qteq’s DST work in Mongolia

[288]

Consideration

[290]

Must the ACCC prove that Qteq was in competition with Pro-Test in relation to completions?

[294]

Conclusion on the competition condition

[297]

Qteq and Mr Ashton’s liability for the Pro-Test Attempts

[298]

F. THE EASTERNWELL NON-COMPETE AGREEMENTS (ATTEMPTS #4 AND #5)

[305]

Introduction

[305]

Application of s 45AC to the attempts

[315]

Attempt #4: The Easternwell 2017 Non-Compete Agreement

[325]

The second Easternwell allegation is that, during the period from approximately 6 to 17 November 2017, Qteq, through Messrs Ashton and Meldrum, engaged in an attempt to make, or induce, a contract with Eastern Well No 2 containing cartel provisions. Those cartel provisions would have prevented Eastern Well No 2 and its related bodies corporate from, other than in concert with Qteq, pursuing or performing gauge installation services work for QGC or any other CSG operators. The ACCC also alleges that Mr Ashton attempted to induce Eastern Well No 2 to enter into such an agreement.

Background: The QGC gauge and rig tenders

[326]

Conduct

[329]

Discussions between Easternwell and Qteq begin

[329]

The First Qteq NDA

[343]

The First Qteq NDA is rejected by Easternwell

[346]

Mr Ashton contacts Easternwell about the First Qteq NDA

[349]

Epilogue

[358]

Conclusions on conduct

[360]

The purpose condition

[361]

Plain language of cl 8

[364]

Admissions as to purpose by Messrs Ashton, Meldrum and Morgan

[366]

Additional surrounding evidence

[373]

The respondents’ arguments

[374]

Conclusion on purpose condition

[383]

Competition condition

[384]

Evidence of Qteq’s perception of Easternwell as a competitive threat

[385]

Structure of the QGC tenders

[389]

Cartel provision conclusion

[397]

Exclusive dealing exception

[398]

Conclusion on Attempt #4

[415]

Attempt #5: The Easternwell 2018-2019 Non-Compete Agreement

[417]

Background: Easternwell wins the QGC rig tender and Qteq wins the QGC gauge tender

[420]

Conduct

[424]

The Second Qteq NDA

[424]

The revised Second Qteq NDA

[438]

Epilogue

[451]

Conclusion on conduct

[457]

Purpose condition

[459]

Language of cls 4(B) and 4(e)

[462]

Evidence of Qteq’s perception of Easternwell as a competitive threat

[472]

The respondents’ arguments

[475]

Conclusion

[478]

Competition condition

[479]

Cartel provision conclusion

[480]

Exclusive dealing exception

[481]

Conclusion on Attempt #5

[483]

Qteq and Mr Ashton’s liability for the Easternwell Attempts

[484]

G. ATTEMPT #6: THE FIRETAIL UNDERSTANDING

[490]

Overview

[490]

Conduct issue and purpose condition

[498]

Construction of the 19 September 2017 email chain

[507]

Construction of the 20 September 2017 email chain

[527]

Conclusion on conduct and the purpose condition

[550]

The competition condition

[553]

Framing the debate by reference to the statutory test and the parties’ competing cases

[553]

Incorporation and intentions

[560]

QGC gauge tender

[567]

Firetail’s access to equipment

[574]

The gauges

[592]

Discussions with and quote from GeoPSI

[593]

Discussions with Bridgeport

[602]

Conclusion on access to gauges

[604]

Firetail customer communications

[605]

Financial difficulty

[622]

Qteq’s knowledge of Firetail’s activities

[625]

Conclusion on the competition condition

[638]

Joint Venture

[639]

Conclusion on Attempt #6

[640]

H. TENDENCY EVIDENCE

[640]

I. OVERALL CONCLUSION

[641]

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For completeness, I should record that the ACCC sought to adduce tendency evidence to the effect that Mr Ashton had a tendency to seek to persuade those that he perceived to be, or likely to be, competitors of Qteq to not compete with Qteq in relation to its supply of downhole gauges and related services. This was advanced as being probative of the allegations in respect of Firetail and Pro-Test. In substance it was an application for the use of evidence already adduced in that way. The application was opposed. I have not found it necessary to determine the application because the Pro-Test Attempts were plainly established without the need to rely upon such reasoning, and the Firetail Attempt failed only on the competition condition. I. OVERALL CONCLUSION For the reasons above, I have concluded:(a)the three attempt contraventions involving Pro-Test (Attempts #1, #2 and #3), as alleged by the ACCC, have been proven with respect to both Mr Ashton and Qteq;(b)the two attempt contraventions involving Eastern Well No 2 (Attempts #4 and #5), as alleged by the ACCC, have been proven with respect to both Mr Ashton and Qteq, and the respondents’ reliance on the exclusive dealing exception has failed;(c)the attempt contravention involving Firetail (Attempt #6) has not been proven, because the competition condition has not been established. Rather than defer making declarations of contravention so that the relief phase can be heard and determined before any time limit for an appeal against liability runs, I propose to make such declarations, but to extend the start time for commencing any appeal proceeding to the end of the next business day after the relief judgment is delivered. The parties are therefore to confer and by 7 May 2025, or such further time as may be allowed, provide by email to my chambers an agreed draft, or competing drafts, of: (a)the terms of the declarations of contravention to be made in accordance with the reasons for judgment;(b)an order extending the commencement of the time within which any appeal proceeding is required to be filed in this proceeding to the end of the next business day after a judgment on relief is delivered; and(c)procedural orders for the preparation and hearing of the relief phase of this proceeding, including as to evidence, submissions and a joint list of authorities with pinpoint references.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.