Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Egg Corporation Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Egg Corporation Limited [2017] FCAFC 152

Appeal from: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Egg Corporation Limited [2016] FCA 69
File number: SAD 63 of 2016
Judges: BESANKO, FOSTER AND YATES JJ
Date of judgment: 25 September 2017
Catchwords:

COMPETITION – consideration of an appeal by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission against an order of the Federal Court dismissing a proceeding alleging a contravention of s 44ZZRJ of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) by an industry body and others – where the primary judge found evidence established conduct by at least two respondents which could constitute an attempt in the requisite sense – where the primary judge also found that the respondents intended that the attendees at a certain meeting should take action to address and correct an oversupply of eggs – where the primary judge was not persuaded “to the requisite degree of persuasion” that the respondents intended that this action should be pursuant to an agreement or understanding involving reciprocal obligations.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where the Court on appeal is to consider an allegation that the primary judge erred in the inferences he drew or failed to draw from established primary facts – where the primary judge refused to draw an inference going to the intention of the respective respondents – where the ACCC’s case was documentary and did not call any witnesses – where the primary judge did not wholly accept or reject the evidence of any respondent witness – where there were no challenges to the primary judge’s findings as to credibility and reliability – where the matter under challenge is not a matter where there is only one right answer – whether, in the absence of a preponderance of view against that taken by the primary judge, the primary judge’s refusal to draw an inference of intention should be disturbed.

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 2A, 4, 44ZZRD, 44ZZRJ, 76, 84

Egg Industry Services Provision Act 2002 (Cth)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 27, 28

Cases cited:

Apco Service Stations Pty Ltd and Another v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2005) 159 FCR 452

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Egg Corporation Limited [2016] FCA 447

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v CC (NSW) Pty Ltd (and Others) (1999) 92 FCR 375

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Leahy Petroleum Pty Ltd and Others (2007) 160 FCR 321

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v SIP Australia Pty Limited [2001] FCA 824; (2002) ATPR 41‑877

Branir Pty Ltd and Others v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd and Another (2001) 117 FCR 424

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118

Miller & Associates Insurance Broking Pty Ltd v BMW Australia Finance Limited (2010) 241 CLR 357

Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott [2016] HCA 22; (2016) 90 ALJR 679

The Heating Centre Pty Ltd…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCAFC 152
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Egg Corporation Ltd, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) appealed against an order of the Federal Court which dismissed a proceeding alleging a contravention of section 44ZZRJ of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 by an industry body and others. The primary judge had found that the evidence established conduct by at least two respondents which could constitute an attempt in the requisite sense, and that the respondents intended that the attendees at a certain meeting should take action to address and correct an oversupply of eggs. However, the primary judge was not persuaded "to the requisite degree of persuasion" that the respondents intended that this action should be pursuant to an agreement or understanding involving reciprocal obligations. The appeal was primarily concerned with the inferences which the primary judge drew, or did not draw from the primary facts. The primary judge refused to draw an inference of intention, which was central to the ACCC’s case. The Court on appeal considered whether, in the absence of a preponderance of view against that taken by the primary judge, the primary judge’s refusal to draw an inference of intention should be disturbed. The appeal was dismissed, and the ACCC was ordered to pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the primary judge erred in the inferences he drew or failed to draw from established primary facts, particularly in relation to the intention of the respondents to induce an arrangement involving reciprocal obligations. The Court found that the primary judge’s refusal to draw an inference of intention should not be disturbed in the absence of a preponderance of view against that taken by the primary judge. The Court held that the conduct of Mr Lendich and Mr Ironside could not be attributed to Farm Pride and IMS respectively, as they attended the Board meeting and the Summit on behalf of AECL and their respective companies, not as representatives of their companies. The Court concluded that the appeal must be dismissed and the ACCC must pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondents’ costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Ironside also filed a Notice of Contention. He raised similar contentions to those raised by Farm Pride in its first and second contentions. In addition, he contended that the primary judge erred in failing to find that he made a certain statement at the Summit. IMS filed a Notice of Contention relying on the contentions raised by Mr Ironside and raising a similar contention to that raised by Farm Pride in its third contention.THE FACTS Most of the primary facts were not in dispute on the appeal and the ACCC’s appeal relates to the inferences which the primary judge drew, or did not draw from those primary facts. In this section of these reasons, we will set out the key events in chronological order, none of which are in dispute. We will then summarise the primary judge’s approach to the various witnesses who gave evidence at the trial. We will then summarise how his Honour resolved the key factual issues before him.The Key Events On 26 November 2010, AECL in its fortnightly email update entitled “EggCorp EggsPress” advised readers that:According to CIE [the Centre for International Economics], the egg industry can only advert a catastrophic result by culling birds 14 days earlier than their expected disposal date out to April 2011. Throughout 2011, the information provided to the Board of AECL indicated that the supply of eggs was exceeding, and was likely to continue to exceed, demand. A recurrent theme at Board meetings was a consideration of the oversupply of eggs. Throughout 2011 and in early 2012, there was a standing item on the agenda for Board meetings for “Egg Industry KPIs” and under that item, reports were provided of egg production, egg consumption and national inventory levels. The minutes of the Board meeting of AECL held on 23 March 2011 record the following:… further discussed the need for the education of egg producers on how to manage their production levels and agreed that a meeting should be convened prior to the 15th AECL Forum at which Derek Quirke be invited to speak. AECL monitors both egg production and the demand for eggs in Australia. Since 2003, it has engaged International Economics Pty Ltd, trading as The Centre for International Economics (CIE) to provide it with reports about matters such as levels of egg production, analysis of egg production and distribution markets in Australia, and forecasts of the demand for, and the supply of, eggs in Australia. Mr Quirke was the principal person within CIE providing the reports, analysis and forecasts to AECL. On 5 April 2011, EggCorp EggsPress contained a statement that egg inventory stocks had increased significantly beyond levels recorded in April 2010 and that “[i]t is now crunch time where inventory levels must be carefully managed so as not to oversupply the market”. AECL held two industry forums in 2011 and at the forum in Melbourne on 26 May 2011, Mr Quirke, in the course of his presentation, reported on an 8.3% increase in egg production in 2011 as well as presenting a projection of the impact this would have on prices “without continued action by industry”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The final contention is made by Farm Pride and IMS and it is that the conduct of Mr Lendich and Mr Ironside cannot be attributed to Farm Pride and IMS respectively. Mr Lendich and Mr Ironside attended the Board meeting on 19 January 2012 as directors of AECL and not as representatives of Farm Pride and IMS respectively. They both attended the Summit on behalf of AECL and their respective companies. We think that their conduct at the Summit can be attributed to AECL, but the fact that they were representatives of their companies at the Summit does not mean that their conduct can be attributed to their respective companies. There are two contextual matters of importance and they are that, assuming there was an attempt by Mr Lendich and Mr Ironside which commenced at the Board meeting on 19 January 2012, that was in their capacity as directors of AECL and, at least in the case of Mr Ironside, there was no further positive conduct at the Summit. In the case of the one matter which Mr Ironside was alleged to have said at the Summit, the primary judge found that he did not make the statement (at [228]). Had it been necessary to decide this contention of Farm Pride and IMS finally, we would have been disposed to accept it.CONCLUSION For these reasons, the appeal must be dismissed. The appellant must pay the respondents’ costs of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The ACCC did not challenge any of the findings set out above. It made clear that it did not challenge any finding made prior to the primary judge’s consideration of the circumstantial case which is dealt with in the next section of these reasons.THE PRIMARY JUDGE’S CONSIDERATION OF THE ACCC’S CIRCUMSTANTIAL CASE The primary judge said that each of the elements of the ACCC’s circumstantial case had to be considered collectively. He said that the ACCC’s case had “some force”. There was conduct which, looked at generally, could be characterised as a form of affirmative action directed towards the inducement the ACCC alleged. However, his Honour said that the evidence did not establish that the respondents had the intention of inducing a proscribed arrangement or that any respondent conveyed to the attendees at the Summit the potential for such an arrangement or understanding. The primary judge drew a distinction between two situations and the distinction played an important part in his reasoning. The first situation was where industry participants are brought to an appreciation that it is in their interests, independently of what others are doing, to act in a particular way. Such conduct did not involve a contravention of the Act. By contrast, the second situation involved conduct where industry participants are invited to agree to act in a particular way in the expectation of reciprocal conduct by others and that does involve a contravention of the Act. The primary judge agreed with a characterisation of the evidence advanced by counsel for AECL and Mr Kellaway. It was consistent with an outcome of “We want everybody to think harder about their own circumstances and what they can do to solve the problem which is, in part, theirs and, in part, the industry’s”. The primary judge noted that it needed to be added that suggestions and recommendations as to particular conduct which producers could take were also made (at [382]). In an important paragraph in his analysis, the primary judge said (at [383]):The evidence warrants a finding that the means by which egg production could be reduced (removing one hen from each cage and bringing forward the disposal of hens by 6-8 weeks) were canvassed at the Summit, but there is insufficient evidence to warrant the conclusion that these options were propounded as a form of collective action involving reciprocal obligations or understandings by the egg producers. It is one thing to conclude that suggestions, even firmly expressed suggestions, were made that removing a hen from a cage and bringing forward hen disposal were forms of action which producers, making independent judgments about their own commercial interests, could (or even should) adopt: it is another thing to conclude that the respondents were proposing that producers agree that each would pursue either or both of these options on the understanding that their competitors would do likewise. There is no persuasive evidence that a proposal to that effect was articulated.