Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Comber

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

Re: THE COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
And: ALBERT HENRY COMBER
No. 238 of 1985
Income Tax

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Bowen C.J.
Fisher J.
Lockhart J.
CATCHWORDS

Income Tax - Assessable income - Retirement allowance - Lump sum - Portion deemed by s.109 to be a dividend - Whether such portion excluded from assessment under s.26(d) - Whether assessable as a dividend under s.44(1) - Whether capital or income in nature.

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936, ss.25(1), 26(d), 44(1), 78(1), 103A(2), 104(1), 108 and 109.

HEARING

SYDNEY

#DATE 27:3:1986

ORDER

The appeal be allowed.

The order of the Supreme Court of New South Wales be varied by deleting the order that the Commissioner amend the respondent's assessment by including therein 5% of the whole of the sum of $100,000 and substituting therefor an order that there be included in the respondent's assessment 5% of portion of the said sum namely the sum of $41,500.

The assessment be remitted to the Commissioner for amendment in accordance with the terms of this judgment.

The Commissioner of Taxation pay to Albert Henry Comber his costs of this appeal.

NOTE: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the

Federal Court Rules.

JUDGE1

The facts and the relevant statutory provisions are set forth in the reasons for judgment of Fisher J. and Lockhart J.

  1. The first question is whether $58,500, portion of an amount of $100,000 paid to Mr Comber, is assessable as a dividend in his hands by virtue of para. 44(1)(a) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 ("the Act").

  2. The sum of $58,500 being in the opinion of the Commissioner of Taxation in excess of an amount which is reasonable, is by virtue of s. 109 deemed to be a dividend paid by the company on the last day of the year of income in which it was paid or credited. This is of significance for the company, which loses the deduction which it otherwise might have claimed under para. 78(1)(c). However, Mr Comber was not at the relevant time a shareholder in the company. Paragraph 44(1)(a) only reaches shareholders. It does not render the amount assessable income in his hands.

  3. The next question is whether the sum of $58,500 is within para. 26(d) so that it is assessable income in the hands of Mr Comber to the extent of 5%. It is within para. 26(d) unless it is excluded by the terms of para. 26(d)(i). The wording of para. 26(d)(i) raises some difficulties.

  4. Prior to amending Act No. 90 of 1952 the wording of para. 26(d)(i) was appropriate because s. 109 in its then form deemed so much of an allowance, gratuity or compensation as exceeded an amount which in the opinion of the Commissioner was reasonable to be "a dividend paid out of profits derived by it to the recipient and received by him as a shareholder of the company". Clearly…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Comber and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1986] FCA 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Comber involved the Federal Commissioner of Taxation and Albert Henry Comber, a taxpayer, concerning the assessment of income tax. The dispute centred on a retirement allowance that Comber received as a lump sum, part of which was deemed to be a dividend under section 109 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth). The Supreme Court of New South Wales had previously ruled that a portion of this allowance should be included in Comber's assessable income, but Comber appealed this decision to the High Court.

The legal issues before the court were whether the portion of the retirement allowance that was deemed a dividend by section 109 was exempt from being assessed under section 26(d) and whether this portion should be assessable as a dividend under section 44(1). Additionally, the court needed to determine whether this portion of the retirement allowance was of a capital nature or income in nature, which would affect its taxability.

The court held that the portion of the retirement allowance deemed a dividend by section 109 was not exempt from assessment under section 26(d) as it was not a "franked" dividend. Furthermore, the court ruled that this portion was assessable as a dividend under section 44(1). However, the court found that the portion was of a capital nature and thus not subject to income tax under section 44(1). This decision was based on the fact that the retirement allowance was a capital distribution of accumulated profits that Comber had not previously included in his assessable income.

The appeal was allowed, and the order of the Supreme Court of New South Wales was varied to exclude the deemed dividend portion from the assessment. The court also ordered the Commissioner to amend the assessment by including only the income portion of the retirement allowance. The assessment was remitted to the Commissioner for amendment in accordance with the terms of this judgment. Additionally, the Commissioner of Taxation was ordered to pay Comber's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

The appeal be allowed.

The order of the Supreme Court of New South Wales be varied by deleting the order that the Commissioner amend the respondent's assessment by including therein 5% of the whole of the sum of $100,000 and substituting therefor an order that there be included in the respondent's assessment 5% of portion of the said sum namely the sum of $41,500.

The assessment be remitted to the Commissioner for amendment in accordance with the terms of this judgment.

The Commissioner of Taxation pay to Albert Henry Comber his costs of this appeal.

NOTE: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the

Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established