Australian Capital Territory v Munday

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Capital Territory v Munday [2000] FCA 653

RESTRAINT OF TRADE – common law restraint – grant by occupier of land of exclusive licence to carry on particular trade on land – other persons permitted to enter on terms prohibiting the carrying on of that trade – whether doctrine of restraint of trade applies – whether “pre-existing freedom” or “structure of trading society” test

North Western Salt Company Limited v Electrolytic Alkali Company Limited [1914] AC 461 mentioned
Esso Petroleum Co Ltd v Harper’s Garage (Stourport) Ltd [1968] AC 269 applied

Amoco Australia Pty Ltd v Rocca Bros Motor Engineering Co Pty Ltd (1973) 133 CLR 288 discussed
Queensland Co-operative Milling Association v Pamag Pty Ltd (1973) 133 CLR 260 discussed

Quadramain Pty Ltd v Sevastapol Investments Pty Ltd (1976) 133 CLR 390 discussed

Thompson v Harvey (1689) Comb 121 at 122 mentioned
Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Dickson [1970] AC 403 at 431 mentioned
Bartsch v Avtex Air Services Pty Ltd (Full Court of the Federal Court, unreported, 27 August 1993) mentioned
Greenhalgh v Composite Buyers Limited (Full Court of the Federal Court, unreported, 31 May 1995) mentioned
Peters (WA) Ltd v Petersville Ltd [1999] ATPR 41-714 discussed
McGuigan Investments Pty Ltd v Dalwood VineyardsPty Ltd [1970] 1 NSWR 686 at 693 mentioned
Fisher v GRC Services Pty Ltd (1998) ATPR (Digest) 46-180 mentioned
Aloha Shangri-La Atlas Cruises Pty Ltd v Gavan [1970] Qd R 438 at 445 mentioned
ICT Pty Ltd v Sea Containers Ltd (1995) 39 NSWLR 7640 at 673 mentioned
Hollywood Premier Sales v Faberge Australia (Pty) Ltd (1976) 11 ALR 18 at 22 mentioned
Adamson v NSW Rugby League (1991) 31 FCR 242 mentioned
Robinson v Golden Chips (Wholesale) Ltd [1971] NZLR 257 mentioned
Thomas Borthwick & Sons (Australasia) Ltd v South Otago Freezing Co Ltd [1978] 1 NZLR 538 at 550 mentioned
Stephens v Gulf Oil Canada Ltd (1975) 25 CPR 2d 64 mentioned
Woolworth v Hudsons Bay Company (1985) 61 NBR (2d) 403 mentioned
Cleveland Petroleum Co Ltd v Dunstone Ltd [1969] 1 WLR 116 mentioned
Panayiotou v Sony Music Entertainment (UK) Ltd (1994) 13 Tr L 532 at 548 mentioned
Instone v A Schroeder Music Publishing Co Ltd [1974] 1 All ER 171 mentioned
Donovan v Pennsylvania Company 199 US 279 (1905) discussed
Alec Lobb (Garages) Ltd v Total Oil Great Britain Ltd [1985] 1 All ER 303 mentioned
Heatley v Tasmanian Racing and Gaming Commission (1977) 137 CLR 487 at 507,511 mentioned
Buckley v Tutty (1971) 125 CLR 353 mentioned
Forbes v New South Wales Trotting Club Ltd (1979) 143 CLR 242 discussed
Nagle v Feilden [1966] 2 QB 633 mentioned
United States v Addyston Pipe & Steel Co 86 F 291 (1898) mentioned

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY v LEONARD GEORGE MUNDAY

A 20 of 2000

MILES, O’CONNOR AND HEEREY JJ
19 MAY 2000
MELBOURNE (HEARD IN CANBERRA)


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

DISTRICT REGISTRY

A 20 of 2000

On appeal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Capital Territory v Munday and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 653
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Australian Capital Territory v Munday involved a challenge by the respondent, Munday, against the appellant, the Australian Capital Territory, over certain terms of entry to the Tip, a landfill site in the Australian Capital Territory. Munday, who had been scavenging and reselling discarded goods from the Tip, sought an injunction against the appellant's officers to prevent them from interfering with his activities. The Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory had previously ruled that specific terms of entry to the Tip, which restricted trading, bargaining, and soliciting for materials, goods, or waste within the Tip, contravened the common law doctrine of restraint of trade and were void. The appellant appealed this decision to the higher court.

The central legal issue in the appeal was whether the terms of entry to the Tip, which imposed restrictions on the respondent's activities, were valid under the common law doctrine of restraint of trade. The court had to determine whether these terms constituted an unreasonable restraint on trade. Additionally, the court considered whether the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (TPA) applied to the appellant's actions in granting exclusive rights to salvage materials from the Tip to a particular company.

The court found that the doctrine of restraint of trade did apply to the terms of entry, as these terms indeed imposed a restraint on the respondent's pre-existing freedom to trade in goods found at the Tip. The court held that while the appellant was not prohibited by the TPA from granting exclusive rights to salvage materials, the terms of entry to the Tip constituted an unreasonable restraint of trade under common law. The court concluded that the restrictions placed on the respondent's activities, which substantially lessened competition for goods that were about to be or had been abandoned at the Tip, were not justified. Therefore, the terms of entry were void and of no effect.

Following the court's reasoning, the appeal was allowed, and the previous judgment of the Supreme Court was set aside. In lieu of the earlier order, the respondent's motion for an injunction was dismissed, effectively upholding the appellant's right to set terms of entry to the Tip, subject to the limitations imposed by the common law doctrine of restraint of trade.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The order of 23 February 1999 is set aside.

3. In lieu thereof it is ordered that the respondent’s motion by notice dated 23 September 1998 is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant appeals from a judgment of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory which declared that those parts of the terms of entry to the Tip which (a)prohibit entrants from trading, bargaining for or soliciting for materials, goods or waste within the Tip;(b)require entrants only to approach the Tip face to dump items and then to depart forthwith or immediately; and(c)require entrants not to loiter within the Tip areacontravene the common law doctrine of restraint of trade and are accordingly void and of no effect. Background The Tip is open to the public during designated hours to enable them to approach an area designated for the dumping of domestic waste and other unwanted materials. This area is referred to as the Tip face. During 1994 the appellant introduced fees for entry to the Tip face. In August 1996 the appellant sought expressions of interest for the exclusive right to salvage recyclable materials from ACT landfill sites, including the Tip. The respondent and others formed a consortium which put in a bid but a company called Revolve Limited was successful. Revolve had already been operating recycling operations at the Tip for about two years. The appellant and Revolve entered into an agreement in writing dated 26 February 1997. The agreement extends for a period of three years from 1 January 1997 subject to extension for a further two years at the option of the appellant. By the agreement Revolve is given a non-exclusive right to enter and use the Tip (cl 3.1) and an exclusive right to salvage materials from the Tip face (cl 5.1). Revolve has established a depot and recycling area in part of the Tip. Entrance to this area remains free. Prior to the commencement of litigation between the respondent and the appellant signs erected at the entrance to the Tip stated:“All material deposited at this landfill is the property of the Territory.Domestic and commercial customers whose Tip fees are not up-to-date will not be permitted to enter or dump at this landfill.Revolve has exclusive rights to salvage material from the Tip face. Anyone found removing material from the Tip may be prosecuted.” The respondent has for a number of years engaged in scavenging at the Tip face. He has collected discarded goods and either kept them for his own use or resold them at trash and treasure markets held at various sites in the Canberra region. Proceedings in the Supreme Court On 13 May 1998 the respondent commenced a proceeding in the Supreme Court seeking an injunction to restrain officers of the appellant’s Department of Urban Services (“the Department”) from interfering with his scavenging activities. In a judgment given on 8 July 1998 his Honour concluded that the appellant may, as against persons licensed to enter the Tip face area, assert control over goods abandoned there for the benefit of Revolve. However his Honour construed the terms of the contractual licence for entry to the Tip contained in the signs as not prohibiting licensees from dealing with one another so as to transfer items of property whilst at the Tip, although the terms did prohibit the scavenging of goods already abandoned.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

A further hearing took place before his Honour on 20 November 1998 and he delivered judgment on 23 February 1999.Judgment of the primary Judge His Honour set out the background already referred to. He then related evidence of an incident at the Tip on 20 September 1998. The respondent asked a person throwing away plastic bottles at the Tip if he could have them. When the person agreed and gave the respondent about twelve of the bottles, a Tip attendant told the respondent that if he put the bottles in his car that was soliciting and the police would arrest him. Police were called. Apparently the respondent kept the bottles. Some remaining bottles abandoned by the other person had already been bulldozed into the ground. His Honour noted that the appellant was not free to impose whatever conditions it chose for entry to the Tip. The conditions had to be lawful. The appellant was, in licensing persons to have access to the Tip on payment of a fee, engaging in trade or commerce. His Honour found that on the evidence there was a market for goods which were about to be or which had been abandoned at the Tip. To permit only one of the competitors for such materials to have access to them substantially lessened competition for such goods. However his Honour noted that the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“TPA”) does not prohibit conduct or agreements merely because the effect thereof is to lessen competition, even if it does so to the extent of conferring a monopoly. There was nothing in the TPA which prevented the appellant from granting exclusive rights to persons to salvage at the Tip. His Honour then went on to consider the applicability of s 47(1) and (9) of the TPA which prohibit exclusive dealing. However his Honour considered there was no evidence on which he could find that restriction of competition was “substantial”, although he did find that it was arguable that the terms imposed on entrants to the Tip restricted or reduced competition for goods which otherwise would be dumped at the Tip, that competition being between Revolve and persons such as the respondent. His Honour then discussed whether the terms of the licence were invalid as being an unreasonable restraint of trade at common law. The first issue dealt with by his Honour was whether the doctrine of restraint of trade applied at all. As will be discussed more fully subsequently, one of the suggested criteria for excluding the doctrine is that the impugned restraint is not a restraint on a pre-existing freedom to trade. His Honour held that even if it was essential that a restraint be of such a character before the doctrine applied, that requirement would be satisfied on the evidence before him. His Honour said (at pars 76-78):“76. It was common ground that, prior to the grant of sole scavenging rights to Revolve, persons, including the plaintiff, would scavenge over the Tip area and take and sometimes resell items they found there. They would bargain between themselves, and with persons seeking to abandon goods, for the right to have them. That freedom has been curtailed by the actions of the Territory in imposing restrictions on the activities of persons entering upon the Tip. It is unrealistic, in my view, to look at each licence as if it bore no relationship to any other. Restraint of trade is, as the authorities disclose, to be viewed broadly.77.Further, a consideration of the terms of a licence to be upon land is quite a different matter from the transfer of an enduring interest in it. The right of entry onto the Tip area is, as Mr Erskine [counsel for the appellant] conceded, little different to permitting patrons to enter and view a sporting event. It would, no doubt, be reasonable for a sporting promoter of that event to licence, say, food and drink vendors and lend value to such licences by limiting unauthorised competition. However, that does not mean that the test of reasonableness has no application. Rather it will readily be perceived to have been passed by such an arrangement.78.It does not seem to me that the arrangement between the Territory, Revolve and persons entering the Tip area to dump unwanted items, is so much part of the structure of a trading society as to be exempt from, or to automatically satisfy, the doctrine of restraint of trade.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.