Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v O'Connor (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v O’Connor (No 4) [2018] FCA 1293

File number: SAD 253 of 2014
Judge: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 27 August 2018
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – consideration of the appropriate declarations to be made against the respondents in respect of contraventions of the civil remedy provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – consideration of the appropriate penalties to be imposed on the second and third respondents – where first respondent found to have contravened ss 348, 355 and 500 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – where second respondent found to have contravened ss 348 and 355 of the Fair Work Act – where third respondent found to have contravened ss 348, 355 and 500 of the Fair Work Act – consideration of the approach to pecuniary penalties for contraventions of civil remedy provisions of the Fair Work Act – factors to be taken into account when assessing the penalty to be imposed – nature and extent of the contravening conduct – loss and damage caused by the contravening conduct – whether the conduct constituting the contravening conduct was deliberate – extent of any benefit or profit derived from the contravening conduct – extent of co-operation with the applicant and of any contrition shown for the contravening conduct – financial circumstances of the second and third respondents – any corrective action taken by the respondents – prior contraventions – general and specific deterrence – totality
Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 348, 355, 363, 417, 500, 546, 550, 556, 557, 793
Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2017] FCAFC 53; (2017) 249 FCR 458

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (No 3) [2017] FCA 10

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Huddy (No 2) [2017] FCA 1088

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v O’Connor (No 3) [2018] FCA 43

Commonwealth v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2015] HCA 46; (2015) 258 CLR 482

Director of the Fair Work Building Inspectorate v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union(No 2) [2015] FCA 1462

Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Merkx [2015] FCA 316

Esso Australia Pty Ltd v Australian Workers’ Union [2016] FCAFC 72; (2016) 245 FCR 39

R v Walkuski [2010] SASC 146

Rural Press Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2003] HCA 75; (2003) 216 CLR 53

Date of hearing: 16 March 2018
Registry: South Australia
Division: Fair Work Division
National Practice Area: Employment & Industrial Relations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 36
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr D Chin
Solicitor for the Applicant: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr M Ats
Solicitor for the Respondents: Lieschke & Weatherill Lawyers

ORDERS

SAD 253 of 2014
BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER

Applicant

AND:

JIM O'CONNOR

First Respondent

JACK MERKX

Second Respondent

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

BESANKO…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v O'Connor... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1293
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a dispute between the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner and three respondents, O'Connor, Merkx, and the CFMEU. The Commissioner alleged that the respondents had contravened certain sections of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), specifically sections 348, 355, and 500. The key issue before the court was to determine the appropriate declarations and penalties to be imposed on the second and third respondents. The court had to consider various factors, such as the nature and extent of the contravening conduct, the loss and damage caused by the conduct, the deliberateness of the conduct, any benefit derived from the conduct, the extent of cooperation and contrition shown by the respondents, their financial circumstances, any corrective action taken, prior contraventions, and the need for general and specific deterrence. After careful consideration of these factors, the court determined the appropriate penalties to be imposed on the second and third respondents. The second respondent was found to have contravened sections 348 and 355 of the Fair Work Act, and the court imposed a pecuniary penalty of $5,100 for each contravention. Similarly, the third respondent was found to have contravened sections 348, 355, and 500 of the Act, and the court imposed a penalty of $35,700 for each contravention. The court also ordered that each of the pecuniary penalties be paid to the Commonwealth of Australia. In conclusion, the court made the declarations sought by the applicant and imposed the specified penalties on the second and third respondents for their contraventions of the Fair Work Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

12. The second respondent pay a penalty of $5,100 in respect of his contravention of s 355 of the FW Act as set out in Declaration 6 hereof.

13. The second respondent pay a penalty of $5,100 in respect of his contravention of s 355 of the FW Act as set out in Declaration 7 hereof.

14. The third respondent pay a penalty of $35,700 in respect of its contravention of s 355 of the FW Act by reason of ss 363 and 793 of the FW Act as set out in Declaration 8 hereof.

15. The third respondent pay a penalty of $35,700 in respect of its contravention of s 355 of the FW Act by reason of ss 363 and 793 of the FW Act as set out in Declaration 9 hereof.

16. Pursuant to s 546(3) of the FW Act, each of the pecuniary penalties be paid to the Commonwealth of Australia.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I do not think that the pecuniary penalties that I propose to impose are crushing or disproportionate, having regard to the contravening conduct (R v Walkuski [2010] SASC 146 at [6] per Doyle CJ).Conclusion With respect to the second respondent, and having regard to the above matters, I impose a pecuniary penalty of $5,100 with respect to the contravention identified in the sixth declaration, and the same penalty with respect to the contravention identified in the seventh declaration above. With respect to the third respondent, and having regard to the above matters, I impose a pecuniary penalty of $35,700 with respect to the contravention identified in the eighth declaration and I impose the same penalty with respect to the contravention identified in the ninth declaration above.Orders I will make the declarations sought by the applicant and set out above at [4] of these reasons. I impose the following pecuniary penalties:(1)The second respondent pay a penalty of $5,100 in respect of his contravention of s 355 of the FW Act as set out in Declaration 6 hereof.(2)The second respondent pay a penalty of $5,100 in respect of his contravention of s 355 of the FW Act as set out in Declaration 7 hereof.(3)The third respondent pay a penalty of $35,700 in respect of its contravention of s 355 of the FW Act by reason of ss 363 and 793 of the FW Act as set out in Declaration 8 hereof.(4)The third respondent pay a penalty of $35,700 in respect of its contravention of s 355 of the FW Act by reason of ss 363 and 793 of the FW Act as set out in Declaration 9 hereof. I will order pursuant to s 546(3) of the FW Act, that each of the pecuniary penalties be paid to the Commonwealth of Australia.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Having regard to the arguments advanced on the issue of pecuniary penalties, the relevant findings in the earlier reasons are as follows:111In the period of approximately four to six weeks before 13 May 2014, Mr Bleasdale was approached by Mr Merkx and asked about the union’s financial status of employees of BNC. Mr Bleasdale told Mr Merkx that it was none of his business to know whether or not employees of BNC were union members or not. He also told Mr Merkx that if he wanted to speak to the men, then he was more than welcome. 112In or about early May 2014, Mr Bleasdale received a couple of telephone calls on his mobile telephone from Mr O’Connor. He also had some discussions with Mr O’Connor in passing on the Site at around this time. In these discussions, Mr O’Connor asked Mr Bleasdale to help find a man, who he identified as a Jason Clark, a job with BNC on the Project. Mr O’Connor told Mr Bleasdale that Mr Clark was on the CFMEU executive and he had a job on the Project with TLT, but that the job did not start for a few weeks so Mr Clark was looking for some work prior to commencing with TLT. These discussions between Mr Bleasdale and Mr O’Connor were not threatening in any way. Mr Bleasdale told Mr O’Connor to have Mr Clark fill out an application form of BNC which Mr Clark ultimately did.113At about the same time, Mr Merkx approached Mr Bleasdale on the Site on at least three occasions and demanded that he terminate the employment of Mr Dan Hylands because he would not join the CFMEU. Mr Bleasdale could not recall the exact words Mr Merkx used in making these demands. In May 2014, Mr Hylands was an employee of BNC who worked as a labourer on the Project. 114On 13 May 2014, Mr Bleasdale was in his office on the Site. At approximately 11.30 am, Mr Merkx entered his office and stated that he wanted to talk to him. Mr O’Connor was standing behind Mr Merkx. Mr Merkx did not expand on what he wanted to talk to Mr Bleasdale about. At the time, Mr Bleasdale was processing the payroll of the business and he told Mr Merkx to come back later. I have already set out Mr Nunweek’s version of this event which I accept. 115At approximately 12.15 pm, Mr Merkx and Mr O’Connor came back into Mr Bleasdale’s office. Mr Merkx said to Mr Bleasdale words to the effect of the following:Why haven’t you sacked that muppet Dan Hylands? All of your workers receive all the benefits. Why haven’t you found Jason a job? He could be doing what Dan’s doing.116Mr Bleasdale interpreted “Jason” to mean Jason Clark, and “Dan” to mean Mr Hylands, and that the workers benefits were in relation to those entitlements in the Leighton’s enterprise agreement with the CFMEU. Mr Bleasdale said that he was aware that both Hansen Yuncken and Leightons have enterprise agreements with the CFMEU which apply to the Site on which the Project is carried out. 117 Mr Bleasdale then said words to the effect of the following:You can’t be serious.Mr Merkx then said words to the effect of the following:Why are you laughing at us?Mr Bleasdale said to Mr Merkx words to the effect of the following:I’m not going to sack Dan, but if you want to talk to Dan about his union membership that’s up to you.Mr Merkx then said words to the effect of the following:Why don’t you pay the money for your boys and just take it off them?Mr Bleasdale interpreted that comment to be a demand that he, on behalf of BNC, pay union dues for all of the business’ employees and then recoup the membership fees from their pay.Mr Merkx then went on to use words to the effect of the following:If your guys don’t want to join the union, you should sack them and the union will find workers for BNC to hire.Mr Bleasdale said to Mr Merkx words to the effect of the following:I’m not going to do payroll deductions for any employee.Mr O’Connor then said words to the effect of the following:If you don’t find him a job, we’ll go to war with you. You know how it works, Nicko.Mr Bleasdale said that Mr O’Connor’s tone when he used these words was “firmly flat and non-descriptive”. He understood Mr O’Connor’s reference to “going to war” to mean that there would be industrial action.118Mr Bleasdale then told Mr O’Connor that he needed to speak to Mr Brad Sugar who was the HYLC senior manager at the site. Mr O’Connor then used words to the effect of the following:Let me know how you go.119The discussion lasted 15 minutes. After Messrs O’Connor and Merkx had left his office, Mr Bleasdale went to see Mr Sugar in his office. Mr Sugar told him to speak further with Mr Con Kerpiniotis and HYLC’s industrial relations manager, Mr Johns. Later that evening at around 7.30 pm, he made notes of his meeting and discussions with Messrs O’Connor and Merkx from earlier in the day. He produced those notes to Inspectors Mathers and Temple. The following morning at 7 am, Mr Bleasdale spoke with Mr Kerpiniotis and the latter advised him to speak to Mr Johns about the incident. 120On the following day, Mr Bleasdale saw Mr O’Connor on the Site as he was swiping his security pass to exit the Site. Mr O’Connor said words to the effect of the following:How did you go about fixing up that issue?Mr Bleasdale used words to the effect of the following:Aren’t we at war?Mr O’Connor did not reply and kept walking.…133The threat of going to war was a threat of unlawful, illegitimate, unconscionable action, that is, to take a form of industrial action and would be reasonably understood as such. I adopt the same approach as that adopted by Mansfield J in the Contempt Proceedings (see [34] above). The respondents submitted that the war comment may have meant no more than that the CFMEU would commence proceedings for all infractions of industrial laws concerning its members which related to BNC, no matter how minor. In my opinion, that ignores the context in which the war comment was made which is all important. I refer to the findings which I have made. There were a number of conversations in the weeks and days before 13 May 2014 when the employment of Mr Clark and the termination of Mr Hylands’ employment was raised. Before the war comment was made, Mr Bleasdale made it clear to Mr O’Connor and Mr Merkx that he was not going to accede to their demands. I infer an intent to coerce on the part of Mr O’Connor, particularly as Mr Bleasdale had made it clear that he was not going to accede to the demands made. The conduct fell within the terms of s 348 (and s 347(b)(iv)). 134Mr O’Connor’s threat also fell within the terms of s 355 of the FW Act. As I understand it, the applicant alleges that there were two contraventions of s 355, one in relation to the threat seeking the employment of Mr Clark, and the other in relation to the threat seeking the termination of Mr Hylands’ employment.135In my opinion, the applicant’s submission is correct. The subject-matter of the conversation was the employment of Mr Clark and the termination of Mr Hylands’ employment and the suggestion was even made that Mr Clark replace Mr Hylands. Even though the war comment was preceded by the words, “If you don’t find him a job”, the context indicates that the threat related to the employment of Mr Clark and the termination of Mr Hylands’ employment.…143On the face of it, the CFMEU is responsible for Mr Merkx’s conduct in the same way it is responsible for Mr O’Connor’s conduct. However, a question arises as to whether the CFMEU is responsible for two contraventions of s 348 and four contraventions of s 355, or one contravention of s 348 and two contraventions of s 355. Unlike the facts in Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (No 3) [2017] FCA 10, in this case there was only one threat. In my opinion, the latter is the correct position in those circumstances.The Declarations