Australasian United Steam Navigation Co Ltd v The Shipping Control Board

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read
71 CLR 508

AUSTRALASIAN UNITED STEAM NAVIGA-

TION COMPANY LIMITED

THE SHIPPING CONTROL BOARD AND Constitutional Law (Cth.)-" Acquisition of property "____" Just terms "-National

security-Regulations-Validity-Requisition of ship-RequisitionStandard time charter party-Whether charter party passes property or possession-Loss of MELBOURNE,

shipCompensation-The Constitution (63 &64 Vict. c. 12), S. 51 (xxxi.)- Oct. 11, 12;

National Security (Shipping Control) Regulations (S.R. 1941 No. 20), reg. 11 National Security (Shipping Requisition) Regulations (S.R. 1941 No. 230).

Where a ship is requisitioned by the Commonwealth under the National Security (Shipping Control) Regulations and becomes subject to the standard time charter party contained in the schedule to the National Security (Shipping Requisition) Regulations, the owner retains within his control the management, navigation and handling of the ship and therefore neither property nor posses- sion in the ship is acquired by the Commonwealth, SO that no question of com- pensation for the acquisition of property by the Commonwealth arises within the meaning of S. 51 (xxxi.) of the Constitution.

So held by the whole Court. DEMURRER.

The plaintiff company brought an action in the High Court against the Shipping Control Board and the Commonwealth, in which the statement of claim was substantially as follows:-

2. The defendant The Shipping Control Board is a body constituted under the National Security (Shipping Control) Regulations.

3. At all material times on and prior to 14th July 1941 the plaintiff was the owner and in possession of the steamship Macumba, a vessel registered at Melbourne.

71 CLR 509

4. By an order made by the Minister of State for Commerce of the Commonwealth of Australia on 14th July 1941 and expressed to be made under the National Security (Shipping Control) Regulations the ship was requisitioned by the Commonwealth of Australia as from the date when the voyage upon which it was then engaged should be completed.

5. The voyage upon which the ship was on 14th July 1941 engaged was completed on 6th August 1941 whereupon the Shipping Control Board on behalf of the Commonwealth of Australia took possession and control of the ship pursuant to the order referred to in par. 4 hereof and retained such possession until 6th August 1943 when the ship was lost by enemy action.

6. By reason of the matters alleged in pars. 4 and 5 hereof the defendant the Commonwealth of Australia on 6th August 1941 acquired property of the plaintiff.

7. Following upon such requisition the ship was used by the defendants on voyages as directed by the defendant Shipping Control Board on behalf of the defendant Commonwealth including the voyage on which she was lost. The voyages involved the use of the ship in waters in which the ship was subject to attack by enemy ships of war and/or aircraft. On 6th August 1943, whilst under such requisition and whilst being used on a voyage in such waters, the ship was attacked by enemy aircraft and was sunk by a bomb or bombs or torpedo or torpedoes dropped or fired from such…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australasian United Steam Navigation Co Ltd v The Shipping C... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1945] HCA 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australasian United Steam Navigation Co Ltd (the plaintiff) brought an action against the Shipping Control Board and the Commonwealth of Australia (the defendants) concerning the requisition of the plaintiff's steamship, the Macumba. The plaintiff alleged that the Commonwealth acquired property in the ship through the requisition and sought compensation for the ship's loss by enemy action, as well as for loss of profits and business disturbance. The defendants contended that the requisition was lawful and that the terms of compensation were governed by the National Security (Shipping Requisition) Regulations and a standard time charter party, which they argued provided just terms. The plaintiff demurred to parts of the defence, arguing that the relevant regulations and charter party provisions were invalid as they did not provide for just terms for the acquisition of property, as required by section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the requisition of the steamship Macumba by the Commonwealth under the National Security (Shipping Control) Regulations constituted an acquisition of property within the meaning of section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution. This question hinged on whether the standard time charter party, which governed the terms of the requisition, resulted in the Commonwealth acquiring either property in or possession of the vessel. If an acquisition of property had occurred, the court would then need to determine if the terms of compensation provided by the regulations and charter party were "just terms" as mandated by the Constitution.

The Court held that the requisition of the ship did not amount to an acquisition of property by the Commonwealth. Applying the principles of charter parties, the Court found that under the standard time charter party, the owner retained control over the management, navigation, and handling of the ship. Consequently, neither property nor possession in the ship was acquired by the Commonwealth. As there was no acquisition of property, the constitutional requirement for compensation on "just terms" under section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution did not arise. The plaintiff's demurrer was therefore disallowed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established