Austin, Nichols & Co Inc v Lodestar Anstalt

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Austin, Nichols & Co Inc v Lodestar Anstalt [2011] FCA 39

Citation: Austin, Nichols & Co Inc v Lodestar Anstalt [2011] FCA 39
Parties: AUSTIN, NICHOLS & CO INC and RARE BREED DISTILLING LLC v LODESTAR ANSTALT
File number: NSD 518 of 2009
Judge: COWDROY J
Date of judgment: 4 February 2011
Catchwords:

TRADE MARKS – Appeal from decision of a delegate of Registrar of Trades Marks – Application for removal of trade mark on grounds of non-use – Whether Applicants have standing as a person aggrieved for purposes of s 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – Whether Applicants in same trade as owner of contested trade mark – First Applicant and owner of contested trade mark both producers of whiskey – Whether Applicants have standing as a ‘person aggrieved’ in relation to non-alcoholic goods in Class 32 – Held – Applicants trade rivals of owner of contested trade mark – Applicants have standing as a ‘person aggrieved’ pursuant to s 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth).

TRADE MARKS – Appeal from decision of a delegate of Registrar of Trades Marks – Application for removal of trade mark on grounds of non-use – Non-use in relevant three year period conceded by Respondent – Whether any obstacles to use existed such that s 100(3)(c) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) has effect – Respondent engaged in multiple jurisdiction trade mark litigation – Respondent denied permission to exhibit product a Cannes trade fair – Respondent experienced delays in production – Held – Respondent adopted deliberate strategy to market product in other jurisdictions in priority to Australia – Litigation proved no bar to use of trade mark and promotion of product in other jurisdictions – Delays in production had been rectified before the completion of the relevant non-use period – No causal connection demonstrated between failure to use the mark and denial of exhibition space in Cannes – Respondent’s claims not sufficient to constitute obstacles for the purposes of s 100(3)(c) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth).

TRADE MARKS – Appeal from decision of a delegate of Registrar of Trades Marks – Application for removal of trade mark on grounds of non-use – Respondent’s non-use of contested trade mark established – Whether Court should exercise discretion under s 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) to retain trade mark on the Register of Trade Marks – Scope of discretion under s 101(3) – Whether any public confusion would be caused by removal of the trade mark – Held – Respondent has developed limited international and domestic reputation – Possibility of public confusion should mark be removed – No apparent prejudice would result should the mark be maintained – Circumstances warrant the exercise of the Court’s discretion to retain the trade mark on the register.

Legislation: Federal Court Rules (Cth) O 58 r 5a
Trade Marks Act 1938 (UK) s 26(3)
Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) s 23(4)
Trade Marks Act 1995
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Austin, Nichols & Co Inc v Lodestar Anstalt and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants Austin, Nichols & Co Inc and Rare Breed Distilling LLC, who are involved in the production and sale of bourbon whiskey, sought the removal of the trade mark WILD GEESE from the Register of Trade Marks on the basis of non-use. The respondent, Lodestar Anstalt, an Anstalt incorporated in Liechtenstein, is associated with Stichting Lodestar, a company registered in the Netherlands, and is the proprietor of the trade mark WILD GEESE in respect of certain goods. The applicants appealed against the Registrar’s delegate’s decision to refuse the removal of the trade mark WILD GEESE. The key issues were whether the applicants had standing as a ‘person aggrieved’ for the purposes of section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), whether there were obstacles preventing the respondent's use of the trade mark, and whether the Court should exercise its discretion under section 101(3) of the Act to retain the trade mark on the register.

The Court found that the applicants had standing as a ‘person aggrieved’ as they were trade rivals of the respondent, and this was sufficient to confer standing. The Court concluded that the respondent had not established any valid obstacles to the use of the trade mark within the meaning of section 100(3)(c) of the Trade Marks Act. The respondent's litigation and delays in production did not constitute valid obstacles to the use of the trade mark. Finally, the Court exercised its discretion under section 101(3) to retain the trade mark on the register due to the potential for public confusion and the limited prejudice that would result from its removal.

The Court dismissed the application for the removal of the trade mark WILD GEESE from the register and reserved costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Application be dismissed.

2. Costs be reserved.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The Court notes at the outset that for the purposes of this judgment, consistent with popular usage, ‘whiskey’ produced in the United States and Ireland shall be spelt with an ‘e’ while the corresponding product produced in Scotland shall be spelt ‘whisky’.THE FACTS The respondent Lodestar Anstalt (‘Lodestar’) is an Anstalt incorporated in Liechtenstein. Although the precise status and characteristics of an ‘Anstalt’ were not disclosed at the hearing, for the purposes of this judgment it is sufficient to say that an Anstalt is a corporate form peculiar to Liechtenstein which has legal personality. Lodestar is associated with Stichting Lodestar, a company which has its registered office in the Netherlands. Trade Mark Registration No. 839740 in respect of the words WILD GEESE (‘the WG trade mark’) was registered under the Trade Marks Act in the name of Lodestar on 21 June 2000 in respect of the following goods:Class 32: Beers; mineral and aerated waters and other non-alcoholic drinks; fruit drinks and fruit juices; syrups and other preparations for making beveragesClass 33: Alcoholic beverages (except beers) Wild Geese Wines Pty Ltd (‘WG Wines’) is an Australian Proprietary Company registered 27 September 2009. Such company produces and sells wines, principally in South Australia. On 30 January 2001 WG Wines applied to register a graphical mark containing the word ‘WILD GEESE WINES’. Such application was rejected. The first named applicant Austin, Nichols & Co Inc (‘Austin Nichols’) was at all relevant times a subsidiary of a Pernod Ricard Group. Austin Nichols carried on the business of making and selling bourbon whiskey under various trade marks including the trade mark ‘WILD TURKEY’. On 27 June 2005 Austin Nichols filed an application for removal of the WG trade mark pursuant to s 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act (‘the first removal application’) on the grounds of non-use. Section 92 of the Trade Marks Act then extant relevantly stated:Application for removal of trade mark from Register etc. (1)A person aggrieved by the fact that a trade mark is or may be registered may, subject to subsection (3), apply to the Registrar for the trade mark to be removed from the Register.(2)The application:(a)must be in accordance with the regulations; and(b)may be made in respect of any or all of the goods and/or services in respect of which the trade mark may be, or is, registered.…(4)An application under subsection (1) of (3) (non-use application) may be made on either or both of the following grounds, and on no other grounds:…(b)That the trade mark has remained registered for a continuous period of 3 years ending one month before the day on which the non-use application is filed, an, at no time during that period, the person who was then the registered owner:(i)used the trade mark in Australia; or(ii)used the trade mark in good faith in Australia;in relation to the goods and/or services to which the application relates.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Both the applicants and Lodestar agree that there are three issues for determination in this appeal, namely:1.Whether the applicants have established standing as a ‘person aggrieved’ in respect of all of the goods of registration at the date of the application, being 27 June 2005 or 6 September 2005.2.Whether Lodestar has established that there were obstacles preventing its use of the WG trademark within the meaning of s 100(3)(c) of the Trade Marks Act in the relevant non-use period. 3.Whether the Court should exercise its discretion under s 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act to refuse to remove the WG trade mark.THE EVIDENCE Mr Andre Levy of Dublin Ireland provided evidence on behalf of Lodestar. As will be referred to later, this company acquired its trade mark rights to WILD GEESE by licence from Stichting Lodestar, via a group of companies known as the Avalon Group Inc, of the British Virgin Islands. Lodestar is described by Mr Levy as a closed company, incorporated in Liechtenstein. There are no details of the shareholders or directors of Lodestar available to the Court, nor of any details of its incorporation. Mr Levy is effectively the owner and Chief Executive Officer of ARL Communications Ltd and Protégé International Limited (‘Protégé’) both companies being apparently incorporated in the United Kingdom. Protégé is a wholly owned subsidiary of ARL Communications Ltd. Both ARL Communications Ltd and Protégé provide design and marketing consultant services to their clients. Protégé is the exclusive marketing consultant for Lodestar with regard to creation, marketing and securing distributors for Lodestar’s whiskey product known as Wild Geese Rare Irish Whiskey (‘Wild Geese Whiskey’). Protégé has provided such services since approximately 2000. Over the past nine years Mr Levy has supervised trade mark litigation involving the WILD GEESE trade mark instigated by Austin Nichols against Lodestar in several countries around the world.Background to the Production of Wild Geese Whiskey by Lodestar In late 1999 Mr Levy was approached by a group of investors (‘the investors’) seeking to become involved in the spirit industry and who wished to produce a new whiskey product. Mr Levy stated that due to the competitiveness of the Scotch Whisky market, he in co-operation with the investors decided to create a new Irish whiskey product. Mr Levy stated that prior to the development of the Wild Geese Whiskey product, he was aware of the story of the ‘Wild Geese’, the name given to Irish soldiers of fortune who left Ireland for Europe as far back as the 13th century in organised military units. According to Mr Levy’s evidence, in approximately 1691 more than 11,000 Wild Geese soldiers left Ireland for France where they joined the French Army and were known as the Irish Brigade. Such brigade assisted France in fighting every major conflict from the days of Louis XIV of France to World War II. The Wild Geese name is also said to embrace the totality of the Irish Diaspora rather than merely soldiers of fortune. Mr Levy determined that the incorporation of the name ‘Wild Geese’ into the name of a new Irish whiskey product would allow the creation of a very memorable marketing campaign and branding of a new Irish whiskey

Decision

Reasons for decision

The business and assets of Austin Nichols was thereafter sold and transferred to the second named applicant, Rare Breed Distilling LLC (‘Rare Breed’), which is itself a subsidiary of a major international group, namely Davide Campari-Milano S.p.A., an Italian corporation. As part of that transaction the applications for the WG Wines trade marks originally made by WG Wines on 26 July 2005 were assigned from Austin Nichols to Rare Breed as was Austin Nichols’ interest in the first and second removal application. Hereafter for convenience, the applicants will be collectively referred to as ‘Austin Nichols’ or ‘the applicants’.Decision of the Registrar’s Delegate The Registrar’s delegate refused the first removal application. The Registrar’s delegate concluded that Austin Nichols had not demonstrated that there was ‘the necessary element of deceptive similarity about the trade marks’ (Austin Nichols’ trade mark being that of WILD TURKEY) and that accordingly Austin Nichols was not, when the first removal application was filed, ‘a person aggrieved’ within the meaning of s 92 of the Trade Marks Act. As to the second removal application, the Registrar’s delegate considered that WG Wines was a person aggrieved within s 92. The Registrar’s delegate ordered the removal of the WG trade mark in respect of Class 33 goods, namely wine, fortified wine, and wine-based spirits, namely brandy, grappa and cognac, after Lodestar had apparently consented to such removal. In consequence of such decision the WG Wines trade marks were accordingly accepted for registration in the name of the applicants on 20 May 2009. As a result of the above, Lodestar’s WG trade mark specification remained to include the following:Class 32: drinks and fruit juices; syrups and other preparations for making beverages.Class 33: Alcoholic beverages (except beers) but excluding wine, fortified wine and wine-based spirits, namely brandy, grappa and cognac.Issues for Determination The applicants appeal from the delegate’s decision, seek an order that such decision be set aside and request that the WG trade mark be removed from the Trade Mark register. Both the applicants and Lodestar agree that there are three issues for determination in this appeal, namely:1.Whether the applicants have established standing as a ‘person aggrieved’ in respect of all of the goods of registration at the date of the application, being 27 June 2005 or 6 September 2005.2.Whether Lodestar has established that there were obstacles preventing its use of the WG trademark within the meaning of s 100(3)(c) of the Trade Marks Act in the relevant non-use period. 3.Whether the Court should exercise its discretion under s 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act to refuse to remove the WG trade mark.THE EVIDENCE Mr Andre Levy of Dublin Ireland provided evidence on behalf of Lodestar. As will be referred to later, this company acquired its trade mark rights to WILD GEESE by licence from Stichting Lodestar, via a group of companies known as the Avalon Group Inc, of the British Virgin Islands.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the above reasons Lodestar submits that the applicants do not have standing in respect of non-alcoholic Class 32 goods and that accordingly the first removal application in respect of those products should fail from the outset.CONSIDERATION The delegate’s decision in respect of the first removal application found that there was no deceptive similarity between the trade marks of Austin Nichols and of Lodestar and accordingly found that Austin Nichols was not a person aggrieved. However the subsequent decision of the High Court of Australia in Health World has clarified the requirements for determining whether a person is a ‘person aggrieved’ within s 92(1) of the Trade Marks Act. At [30] of the majority judgment, French CJ, Gummow, Heydon, and Bell JJ held that a liberal test is to be applied to the meaning of ‘person aggrieved’, adopting the observations of Lord Pearce in “Daiquiri Rum” Trade Mark [1969] RPC 600 at 615. In reference to Lord Pearce’s test, the majority said at [43]:All that mattered was that they were rivals in relation to the goods to which the mark applied. It did not matter whether or not they intended to use the mark on those goods. In applying Lord Pearce’s observations to the facts before them, the majority of the High Court said at [44]-[45]:Shin-Sun submitted that the test required the applicant to establish a reasonable possibility that the trade mark proprietor in maintaining registration was having an adverse impact on the applicant. The test does not require that, beyond proof of trade rivalry.With respect, then, Lord Pearce correctly stated one test, among others, for ascertaining whether a person is “aggrieved”. It is satisfied here, for Health World and Shin-Sun are rivals in selling the health products in question. They are in the same trade, and they each trade in the class of goods in respect of which the challenged mark is registered. Accordingly the mere fact of being engaged in the same trade, trading in the same class of goods was regarded by the majority as sufficient to warrant a claimant being constituted a ‘person aggrieved’ for the purpose of standing. The majority of the Court also did not identify any requirement that there be a likelihood of confusion between any mark currently used by the apparently aggrieved person and the mark under attack. Significantly, the High Court held that it was immaterial that an applicant seeking removal had not established an intent to actually use the trade mark. At [38] the majority said:Hence a possibility of use of the mark unsupported by evidence suffices, even where there is no evidence of an actual desire or intention on the applicant’s part to use the mark. In arriving at such conclusion the majority made reference to the findings of Lord Watson in William Powell (trading as Goodall, Backhouse & Co) and The Birmingham Vinegar Brewery Company, Limited [1894] AC 8 at 12 where his Lordship said:Whatever benefit is gained by registration must entail a corresponding disadvantage upon a trader who might possibly have had occasion to use the mark in the course of his business. It is implied, of course, that the person aggrieved must manufacture or deal in the same class of goods to which the registered mark applies, and that there shall be a reasonable possibility of his finding occasion to use it. But the fact that the trader deals in the same class of goods and could use it, is prima facie sufficient evidence of his being aggrieved, which can only be displaced by the person who registered the mark, upon whom the onus lies, shewing that there is no reasonable probability that the objector would have used it, although he were free to do so.