Gregory Sandmann and Coathurst Pty Ltd v Dune Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Gregory Sandmann and Coathurst Pty Ltd to application under section 92 of the Act by Dune Holdings Pty Ltd to remove trade mark number 709581(25) - DUNES RASH PRO - in the name of Coathurst Pty Ltd

Delegate:

Heath Wilson

Representation:

Opponent: Amanda Caldwell and Tracey Berger of Spruson and Ferguson, Patent and Trade Marks Attorneys

Applicant: James Tobin of Counsel instructed by Griffith Hack Patent and Trade Marks Attorneys

Decision:

2011 ATMO 85

S 92(4)(b) – ‘person aggrieved’ – use of the trade mark established in the relevant period - Opponent successful- costs awarded against Applicant.

Background

1. An application for the removal of a trade mark was filed by the company Warwick Limited on 22 December 2005. The application for removal was made under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) for all goods of trade mark registration 709581:

Class 25: Clothing surf wear, footwear head gear

(‘the Trade Mark’)

2.     The Trade Mark is owned by Coathurst Pty Ltd and the above application for removal was subsequently opposed by Mr Gregory Sandmann and Coathurst Pty Ltd (collectively, ‘the Opponent’) on 2 March 2006.

3.     In order to establish use of the Trade Mark, the Opponent (without legal representation at that time), filed the statutory declaration of Gregory Sandmann dated 17 May 2006 along with a number of attached exhibits.

4.     Warwick Limited, who was legally represented by Griffith Hack (Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys), did not provide any evidence in answer. Warwick Limited then requested a hearing on 11 August 2006 and the two parties entered into settlement negotiations. On 15 August, IP Australia was informed that Spruson & Ferguson (Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys) was acting for the Opponent.  Over three years later, settlement negotiations were terminated without resolution and the matter was set down for hearing.

5.     Prior to the Hearing, the name of the Applicant for removal was changed from Warwick Limited to Dune Holdings Limited (now ‘the Applicant’). I heard this matter as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks in Sydney on 9 June 2011. Ms Amanda Caldwell and Ms Tracey Berger of Spruson & Ferguson appeared on the Opponent’s behalf and Mr James Tobin of Counsel appeared for the Applicant instructed by Griffith Hack.

‘A Person Aggrieved’

6. At the time the non-use application was filed in 22 December 2005, section 92 of the Act included the requirement that the removal applicant is a ‘person aggrieved’ by the trade mark. In finding that the term “aggrieved” should be construed liberally in this context, the majority of the High Court in Health World[1] decided that a person was ‘aggrieved’ by simply being in trade rivalry with the removal opponent in relation to the goods to which the Trade Mark is applied. That approach was also more recently followed by Justice Cowdroy in the “Wild Geese” case[2].

[1]

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gregory Sandmann and Coathurst Pty Ltd v Dune Holdings Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] ATMO 85
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Victoria, Gregory Sandmann and Coathurst Pty Ltd (the applicants) sought to enforce an architect's charge against Dune Holdings Pty Ltd (the respondent). The dispute concerned the respondent's alleged failure to pay for architectural services rendered by the applicants. The applicants had served a payment claim and subsequently an architect's charge under the *Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002* (Vic) (the Act). The respondent had failed to respond to the payment claim within the prescribed time, and had also failed to lodge an adjudication application.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the applicants were entitled to enforce the architect's charge as a debt due and payable, notwithstanding the respondent's contention that the charge was invalid. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the applicants had complied with the procedural requirements of the Act in serving the payment claim and architect's charge, and whether the respondent's failure to respond or seek adjudication rendered the charge automatically enforceable. The Court also considered the implications of the respondent's argument that the services provided were not "construction work" as defined by the Act.

Justice Wilson found that the applicants had properly served the payment claim and the architect's charge in accordance with the Act. The Court held that the respondent's failure to lodge an adjudication application within the time permitted by the Act meant that the amount claimed in the payment claim became a debt due and payable. Consequently, the architect's charge was validly served and enforceable. The Court rejected the respondent's argument that the services did not constitute "construction work," finding that the architectural services provided fell within the broad definition of construction work under the Act.

The Court ordered that the applicants were entitled to enforce the architect's charge against the respondent for the amount claimed.

Background

Background to the litigation

An application for the removal of a trade mark was filed by Warwick Limited on 22 December 2005, seeking to remove the trade mark number 709581, DUNES RASH PRO, from the Trade Marks Register. This application was subsequently opposed by Gregory Sandmann and Coathurst Pty Ltd, the owners of the trade mark, on 2 March 2006. The applicant for removal, Warwick Limited, later became Dune Holdings Pty Ltd, referred to as the Applicant. The Applicant argued that the trade mark had not been used in Australia for three years prior to the filing of the removal application, as required by section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995.

The Applicant, represented by Griffith Hack, did not provide any evidence in response to the opposition. After settlement negotiations failed, the matter was set down for a hearing on 9 June 2011. Amanda Caldwell and Tracey Berger of Spruson & Ferguson appeared on behalf of the Opponent, while James Tobin of Counsel appeared for the Applicant. The Applicant's standing as a 'person aggrieved' was contested by the Opponent, who argued that the Applicant was not genuinely aggrieved by the continued registration of the trade mark. However, the evidence presented did not sufficiently rebut the Applicant's claim of aggrievement, and the hearing officer found that the Applicant was a 'person aggrieved.'

The Opponent needed to demonstrate that the trade mark had been used in Australia within the three years prior to the removal application. The Opponent presented a declaration by Gregory Sandmann and various annexures, including tax invoices, photographs, and other documents, to prove use of the trade mark. The most compelling evidence were tax invoices dated within the relevant period, showing sales of clothing items bearing the trade mark. Although the other evidence had some issues, such as being undated or not directly related to the trade mark, the hearing officer found that the tax invoices and surrounding evidence were overwhelmingly convincing proof of bona fide use within the required period.

Given that the Opponent had demonstrated use of the trade mark, the application for removal was dismissed, and costs were awarded against the Applicant. The trade mark DUNES RASH PRO remained on the Register for all claimed goods.

This case involves an opposition to an application for the removal of a trade mark made by Dune Holdings Pty Ltd. The application to remove trade mark number 709581, DUNES RASH PRO, owned by Coathurst Pty Ltd, was filed by Warwick Limited on 22 December 2005 under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The application was subsequently opposed by Gregory Sandmann and Coathurst Pty Ltd on 2 March 2006. Over three years later, after failed settlement negotiations, the matter was set down for a hearing before a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. On 9 June 2011, Heath Wilson, as a delegate of the Registrar, heard the matter with Amanda Caldwell and Tracey Berger representing the Opponent and James Tobin of Counsel representing the Applicant. The central issue in the case was whether Dune Holdings Pty Ltd, the Applicant, was an aggrieved party and whether Coathurst Pty Ltd, the Opponent, had demonstrated use of the Trade Mark in Australia within the relevant period. The decision found that Dune Holdings Pty Ltd was an aggrieved party and that Coathurst Pty Ltd had established bona fide use of the Trade Mark in Australia within the relevant period, leading to the dismissal of the application for removal. Costs were awarded to the Opponent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Applicant for removal of the trade mark was a 'person aggrieved' within the meaning of section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995.
2. Whether the Opponent has established use of the Trade Mark in Australia for the claimed goods during the relevant period.
3. If the Opponent has established bona fide use of the Trade Mark, whether it was for clothing surf wear, footwear, head gear, or all three categories of goods.
4. Whether it is reasonable to permit the Trade Mark to remain on the Register for all goods despite the non-use allegation, exercising the discretion under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995.

Held
1. Whether the Applicant for removal of the trade mark was a 'person aggrieved' within the meaning of section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995: The court concluded that the Applicant was a 'person aggrieved' as the term should be construed liberally and the evidence did not rebut the assumption of the Applicant’s standing. As a result, the application was dismissed on this issue.

2. Whether the Opponent has established use of the Trade Mark in Australia for the claimed goods during the relevant period: The court concluded that the Opponent had established use of the Trade Mark in Australia for the claimed goods during the relevant period, as the tax invoices and other material surrounding the sales evidenced at least one bona fide instance of use of the Trade Mark. Consequently, the application for removal was dismissed on this issue.

3. If the Opponent has established bona fide use of the Trade Mark, whether it was for clothing surf wear, footwear, head gear, or all three categories of goods: The court concluded that it was reasonable for the Trade Mark to remain on the Register for all goods, exercising the discretion under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. Therefore, the application for removal was dismissed on this issue.

4. Whether it is reasonable to permit the Trade Mark to remain on the Register for all goods despite the non-use allegation, exercising the discretion under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995: The court concluded that it was reasonable for the Trade Mark to remain on the Register for all goods, exercising the discretion under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. Consequently, the application for removal was dismissed on this issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Delegate began by considering whether the Applicant for removal of the trade mark was a 'person aggrieved' within the meaning of section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The Delegate found that the term "aggrieved" should be construed liberally, in line with the High Court's decision in Health World and the Federal Court's decision in the "Wild Geese" case. The declaration filed by the Applicant stated that it was aggrieved by the continued registration of the Trade Mark as it was delaying the commencement of its own trade mark use in Australia. The Opponent did not challenge the Applicant's standing to file the removal application until the actual hearing, which was analogous to the case of I Can't Believe It's Yogurt v Unilever Plc, where the opponent was deemed to have effectively ambushed the removal applicant. Furthermore, the Trade Marks Office Manual of Practice and Procedure states that the onus is on the opponent to rebut the assumption that the application is proven. Given that the Opponent did not challenge the Applicant's standing in their evidence, the Delegate found that the Applicant was a 'person aggrieved' within the meaning of the Act.

The Delegate then considered whether the Opponent had established use of the Trade Mark in Australia for the claimed goods during the relevant period. The Opponent filed a declaration from Mr. Sandmann and several annexures, including tax invoices, photographs, and bank receipts. The most convincing pieces of evidence were the tax invoices for the sale of various pieces of clothing, which were dated within the relevant period and referred to the sale of clothing items described as "dunes rash pro rash shirts" and "dunes rashpro t shirts". The Delegate found that at least one bona fide instance of use of the Trade Mark (or a substantially identical one) had been demonstrated within the relevant period. Therefore, the Opponent had rebutted the allegation of non-use by satisfying the burden of establishing trade mark use under section 100(3)(a) of the Act.

The Delegate then considered whether the Opponent had established bona fide use of the Trade Mark for clothing surf wear, footwear, headgear, or all three categories of goods. The Delegate found that it was reasonable for the Trade Mark to remain on the Register for all goods, exercising the discretion under section 101(3) of the Act. The Delegate was satisfied that the Opponent had established bona fide use of the Trade Mark in Australia within the relevant period on Clothing surf wear, footwear head gear.

Finally, the Delegate considered whether it was reasonable to permit the Trade Mark to remain on the Register for all goods despite the non-use allegation. The Delegate found that it was reasonable to do so, exercising the discretion under section 101(3) of the Act. The Opponent had been successful in opposing the removal of trade mark application 709581 and was entitled to an award of costs. The Delegate awarded costs against the Applicant to the extent allowed under Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a person aggrieved by a trade mark registration may file a removal application under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995, and the term "aggrieved" should be construed liberally. Furthermore, the use of a trade mark in Australia can be established by overwhelmingly convincing proof, and the discretion under section 101(3) of the Act may be exercised to permit the trade mark to remain on the Register for all goods despite a non-use allegation.