Seekers Australia Pty Ltd v Seal Trademarks Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Seekers Australia Pty Ltd to applications under section 92 of the Act by Seal Trademarks Pty Ltd to remove trade mark number 668745(25) - ELEMENTS - in the name of Seekers Australia Pty Ltd

Delegate: Nicole Worth
Representation: Opponent: Angela Dahlke of Cullens Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys.
Applicant: Kelvin Lord of Lord and Company Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys.
Decision: 2012 ATMO 54
Section 96: s92(4)(a) and s92(4)(b) – no use in non-use period – no evidence of circumstances which were an obstacle to use – exercise of Registrar’s discretion – registration partially removed from the Register – no award of costs.

Background

  1. Seekers Australia Pty Ltd (‘the Opponent’) is the registered owner of trade mark registration number 668745, relevant details of which are as follows:

    Trade Mark No:     668745

    Trade Mark:           ELEMENTS

    Registered from:     4 August 1995

    Goods:Class 25: Clothing, footwear and headgear in this class, including beachwear and swimwear.

  2. On 17 November 2009 Seal Trademarks Pty Ltd (‘the Removal Applicant’) filed an application under subsections 92(4)(a) and 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) seeking removal of the trade mark from the Register in respect of all of the goods for which it is registered.

  3. The parties duly served and filed their evidence. In the lead up to the hearing the Opponent filed an application for permission to serve further evidence, to which the Removal Applicant responded. The Opponent subsequently withdrew the application and I therefore advised both parties I would be taking neither the Opponent’s further evidence nor the Removal Applicant’s response into account when deciding this matter.

  4. I heard the matter as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks in Canberra on 22 March 2012. The Opponent was represented by Kelvin Lord of Lord and Company Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys who attended by telephone conference. The Removal Applicant was represented by Angela Dahlke of Cullens Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys who also attended by telephone conference.

    Evidence

  5. The evidence served and filed in respect of this matter is as follows:

Declarant

Position

Date

Exhibits

Evidence in support

Warren McKinney

‘McKinney 1’

Director, Seekers Australia Pty Ltd

27/8/10

WM-1 to WM-13

Evidence in answer

Nicole Louise Murdoch

Attorney with Cullens Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys

30/12/10

NLM-1

Evidence in reply

Warren McKinney

‘McKinney 2’

Director, Seekers Australia Pty Ltd

27/5/11

n/a

  1. A brief history, as described in the evidence, is as follows.

  2. The Opponent commenced trading in swimwear under the trade mark ELEMENTS in 1995, and continued to do so until 2004. It appears to have enjoyed reasonable success, due in part to its business model of selling separate tops and bottoms of two piece swim suits (thereby allowing variations in size and style in the one suit).

  3. During this time (in 2002), in response to another action concerning the subject trade mark registration, Sunseeker Beachwear Pty Ltd (formerly Seekers Nominees Pty Ltd)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Seekers Australia Pty Ltd v Seal Trademarks Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] ATMO 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Nicole Worth, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, concerning an application to remove the trade mark ELEMENTS (registration number 668745) from the Register. The opponent, Seekers Australia Pty Ltd, sought to maintain the registration, while the removal applicant contended that the trade mark had not been used and that there were no circumstances preventing its use during the relevant non-use period.

The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether the trade mark ELEMENTS had been used in Australia in relation to the goods for which it was registered, or if there were circumstances that constituted an obstacle to its use, during the period of non-use. Section 101 of the relevant Act provided the framework for the Registrar's decision to remove a trade mark from the Register if satisfied that the grounds for removal had been established.

The delegate considered the evidence presented, including the opponent's prior trading history with the ELEMENTS trade mark in swimwear from 1995 to 2004. However, the delegate was not satisfied that the trade mark had been used in relation to "clothing, footwear and headgear including beachwear" or the reduced scope of "beachwear." While a project plan mentioned beachwear items generally, the introduction catalogue sent to the market only referred to swimwear. Consequently, the delegate found that there had been no use of the ELEMENTS trade mark within the non-use period for these broader categories of goods, nor any circumstances that constituted an obstacle to such use.

Accordingly, the delegate directed that registration number 668745 be removed from the Register of Trade Marks for all goods for which it was registered, except for "swimwear." The delegate also declined to make an order as to costs, determining that each party should bear its own costs, as neither party had been entirely successful.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I heard the matter as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks in Canberra on 22 March 2012. The Opponent was represented by Kelvin Lord of Lord and Company Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys who attended by telephone conference. The Removal Applicant was represented by Angela Dahlke of Cullens Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys who also attended by telephone conference.Evidence The evidence served and filed in respect of this matter is as follows: A brief history, as described in the evidence, is as follows. The Opponent commenced trading in swimwear under the trade mark ELEMENTS in 1995, and continued to do so until 2004. It appears to have enjoyed reasonable success, due in part to its business model of selling separate tops and bottoms of two piece swim suits (thereby allowing variations in size and style in the one suit). During this time (in 2002), in response to another action concerning the subject trade mark registration, Sunseeker Beachwear Pty Ltd (formerly Seekers Nominees Pty Ltd) an entity with the same director as the Opponent, and an entity in the same corporate group as the Removal Applicant (Rocket Trademarks Pty Ltd) entered into a Deed of Settlement[1]. A condition of the deed was that neither party would pursue the other for infringement of their respective trade mark registrations[2] ‘or any related rights’. (The Opponent submits that given the Removal Applicant and Rocket Trademarks Pty Ltd belong to the same corporate group, the deed applies here. I am not satisfied this is the case given (a) the deed is made in the context of infringement and (b) the parties are different and the precise nature of their relationship is not explained).[1] Exhibit WM-13 of McKinney 1. [2] The trade mark registrations being: number 668745 for the trade mark ELEMENTS in class 25 now in the name of Seekers Australia Pty Ltd, and number 830377 for the trade mark ELEMENT in classes 25 and 28 in the name of Rocket Trademarks Pty Ltd. In 2004 Mr. McKinney and his wife (‘the McKinneys’) entered into an agreement with another party, Skye Group Pty Ltd[3]. Skye Group Pty Ltd agreed to purchase certain trade marks (not including the ELEMENTS trade mark) and stock of the McKinneys’ companies and the McKinneys agreed not to engage in swimwear design, manufacture or sale in Australia and New Zealand for a period of three years (with the exception of a swimwear range called ‘Sea Siren’ which Mrs. McKinney was permitted to continue trading under). The restraint of trade in the McKinneys’ business took effect from 31 December 2004 and remained in place until 31 December 2007.[3] The relationship between Skye Group Pty Ltd and the Removal Applicant is not clear. However I note that the Removal Applicant’s evidence exhibits a declaration made by John Zylstra, Joint Managing Director of Skye Group Pty Ltd, which was made in relation to a concurrent non-use action filed in the name of Janine Zylstra. At some point during 2006, and again in September 2007, the Opponent’s directors and Skye Group Pty Ltd held discussions regarding the possibility of licensing the ELEMENTS trade mark. It appears that nothing came of these discussions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conversely I do not consider that the Opponent’s registration should be maintained in respect of the broad description “clothing, footwear and headgear including beachwear”, nor the reduced scope “beachwear”. I am not satisfied that the circumstances described above apply to those goods. The ‘project plan’ developed in August 2009 includes information about popular beachwear items generally, and under its ‘product strategy’ identifies the need for ‘one mesh solid sarong’. However that appears to be the extent of the Opponent’s considerations with regard to beachwear. The ‘introduction catalogue’ eventually sent out to the market made no mention of beachwear, nor any goods other than swimwear.Decision Section 101 of the Act relevantly provides:(1) Subject to subsection (3) and to section 102, if:(a) the proceedings relating to an opposed application have not been discontinued or dismissed; and(b) the Registrar is satisfied that the grounds on which the application was made have been established;the Registrar may decide to remove the trade mark from the Register in respect of any or all of the goods and/or services to which the application relates. I am satisfied that there has been no use of the Opponent’s ELEMENTS trade mark within the non-use period and no circumstances that constituted an obstacle to us of the trade mark. As such the removal application has been made out. Having regard to the relevant circumstances and upon exercising the discretion under Section 101(3) of the Act, I direct that one month from the date of this decision registration 668745 be removed from the Register of Trade Marks for all of the goods for which it is registered except “swimwear”. If the Registrar has been served with a notice (or notices) of appeal before that time the disposition of the registration should be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction.Costs Each of the parties has requested costs. As neither party has been entirely successful I decline to make an order as to costs in favour of any party. I consider that the appropriate course on this occasion is that each party should be responsible for meeting its own costs.Nicole WorthHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings13 June 2012

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.