Court of Appeal
New South Wales
Case Title: Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Cervantes Medium Neutral Citation: [2012] NSWCA 244 Hearing Date(s): 26 July 2012 Decision Date: 08 August 2012 Jurisdiction: Before: McColl JA at [1];
Basten JA at [2];
Macfarlan JA at [50]Decision: (1) Dismiss the appeal from the judgment delivered on 2 November 2011 in the Common Law Division.
(2) Order that the appellant pay the costs of the first respondent of the appeal.
[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - judicial review - failure to take into account relevant considerations - whether failure to refer to particular evidence can constitute failure to take into account relevant consideration - whether applicant entitled to rely on the reasons of the decision maker - whether necessary for applicant to rely on submissions before decision maker - need to identify source of legal obligation to consider mandatory factors - whether decision maker considered evidence - whether evidence is a relevant consideration for the purposes of judicial review
DAMAGES - motor vehicle accident - future economic loss - use of buffer - whether decision to award damages by way of buffer is an evaluative judgment - whether buffer manifestly unreasonable given likely future loss
Legislation Cited: Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s 55
Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW), ss 94, 125, 126, 146
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 69Cases Cited: Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Kerr [2012] NSWCA 13; 60 MVR 194
Pollard v Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 99; 172 IR 453
Craig v South Australia [1995] HCA 58; 184 CLR 163
Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2003] HCA 26; 77 ALJR 1088
The King v Connell; Ex parte The Hetton Bellbird Collieries Ltd [1944] HCA 42; 69 CLR 407
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd [1986] HCA 40; 162 CLR 24
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS [2010] HCA 48; 243 CLR 164
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu [1999] HCA 21; 197 CLR 611
Nominal Defendant v Livaja [2011] NSWCA 121
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex part Miah [2001] HCA 22; 206 CLR 57
Swift v SAS Trustee Corporation [2010] NSWCA 182Texts Cited: Aronson, Dyer and Groves Judicial Review of Administrative Action (2009, 4th ed) at [4.220] Category: Principal judgment Parties: Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd (Appellant)
Rita Cervantes (First Respondent)
Tom Goudkamp (Second Respondent)
Motor Accidents Authority of NSW (Third Respondent)Representation - Counsel: Counsel:
Mr M A Robinson SC/Dr J Lucy (Appellant)
Mr K P Rewell SC/Mr M…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Cervantes and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NSWCA 244
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the decision maker's failure to refer to particular evidence constituted a failure to take into account a relevant consideration for the purposes of judicial review. It also considered whether the applicant was entitled to rely on the reasons of the decision maker and whether it was necessary for the applicant to have made submissions before the decision maker to establish the source of a legal obligation to consider mandatory factors. Furthermore, the Court examined whether the evidence presented was a relevant consideration and whether the decision maker had indeed considered it. Finally, the Court reviewed whether the decision to award damages by way of a buffer for future economic loss was an evaluative judgment and if such a buffer was manifestly unreasonable given the likely future loss.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, upholding the original judgment. The judges applied principles of administrative law concerning judicial review, specifically the requirement for decision makers to consider all relevant considerations. They found that the failure to refer to specific evidence could indeed amount to a failure to consider a relevant consideration. The Court also affirmed that the applicant could rely on the reasons provided by the decision maker and that the obligation to consider mandatory factors did not necessarily require specific submissions from the applicant. Regarding the damages assessment, the Court considered the use of a buffer for future economic loss to be an evaluative judgment within the decision maker's purview, and found it was not manifestly unreasonable in the circumstances.
The appeal was dismissed, and Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd was ordered to pay the costs of Mr. Cervantes for the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Dismiss the appeal from the judgment delivered on 2 November 2011 in the Common Law Division.
(2) Order that the appellant pay the costs of the first respondent of the appeal.
[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]
Background
Background to the litigation
The insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd, conducted its own investigation and assessment of the claim, considering various factors such as Mr Cervantes's age, occupation, and the extent of his injuries. The insurer decided to use a buffer in calculating the future economic loss, a method that involves reducing the total loss amount by a percentage to account for the uncertainty of future events. Mr Cervantes disagreed with this approach and the amount awarded, arguing that the insurer had failed to consider certain evidence and had not adequately justified its decision. He sought judicial review of the insurer's determination, claiming that the decision-making process was flawed and that the damages awarded were insufficient.
The proceedings before the court involved detailed examination of the evidence presented to the insurer, including expert reports, medical records, and submissions from both parties. Mr Cervantes argued that the insurer should have referred to specific evidence in making its decision and that the use of a buffer was inappropriate in the circumstances. Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd defended its decision, asserting that it had considered all relevant factors and that the buffer method was a reasonable and accepted approach in assessing future economic loss. The court was tasked with determining whether the insurer had indeed failed to take into account relevant considerations and whether the use of a buffer was an acceptable evaluative judgment in the context of this case.
The matter before the court is an appeal against the judgment delivered on 2 November 2011 in the Common Law Division of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal pertains to a dispute arising from a motor vehicle accident, focusing on the assessment of future economic loss and the application of a buffer in the damages awarded. The appellant, Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd, challenges the original decision on the basis of alleged procedural errors by the primary judge. The appellant contends that the primary judge failed to take into account relevant considerations and made an evaluative judgment in awarding damages by way of a buffer, which was manifestly unreasonable given the likely future loss. The first instance proceedings involved a detailed assessment of the evidence presented, including expert testimonies and submissions from both parties. The primary judge's decision was grounded on a comprehensive review of the evidence and the applicable legal principles. The appellant's appeal followed, raising specific grounds related to the judicial review of the decision-making process. The court's consideration of the appeal is informed by the procedural framework established under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, including the specific provisions for setting aside and varying judgments and orders.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the failure to refer to particular evidence can constitute a failure to take into account relevant considerations in the context of judicial review.
2. Whether the applicant is entitled to rely on the reasons of the decision maker, or is it necessary to rely on submissions before the decision maker.
3. Whether it is necessary to identify the source of the legal obligation to consider mandatory factors in the decision-making process.
4. Whether the decision maker actually considered the evidence in question.
5. Whether the evidence in question is a relevant consideration for the purposes of judicial review.
6. Whether the decision to award damages by way of a buffer is an evaluative judgment.
7. Whether the use of a buffer to award damages for future economic loss is manifestly unreasonable given the likely future loss.
Held
1. The court held that the failure to refer to particular evidence can constitute a failure to take into account relevant considerations in the context of judicial review.
2. The court concluded that the applicant is not necessarily required to rely on the reasons of the decision maker, and it is possible to rely on submissions before the decision maker.
3. The court held that it is necessary to identify the source of the legal obligation to consider mandatory factors in the decision-making process.
4. The court concluded that the decision maker did not actually consider the evidence in question.
5. The court held that the evidence in question is a relevant consideration for the purposes of judicial review.
6. The court concluded that the decision to award damages by way of a buffer is an evaluative judgment.
7. The court held that the use of a buffer to award damages for future economic loss is not manifestly unreasonable given the likely future loss.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Cervantes, the court addressed several significant issues regarding the application of judicial review principles, particularly focusing on whether a failure to refer to particular evidence could constitute a failure to take into account relevant considerations. The case revolved around an application for judicial review of a decision made in the context of a motor vehicle accident involving future economic loss. The court found that the failure to refer to particular evidence could indeed be considered a failure to take into account relevant considerations, particularly when the evidence was pertinent to the decision-making process. The court emphasized that a decision-maker must consider all relevant evidence and properly weigh it, as mandated by statutory provisions.
The court examined the principle that the applicant in a judicial review case can rely on the reasons provided by the decision-maker to demonstrate the failure to take into account relevant considerations. It distinguished between relying on the reasons of the decision-maker and the submissions made before the decision-maker. The court concluded that it was not necessary for the applicant to reiterate submissions made before the decision-maker, as the focus should be on whether the decision-maker's reasons adequately addressed the relevant considerations. This approach aligns with the broader principle that the merits of the decision are not revisited in judicial review unless there is a procedural flaw.
Furthermore, the court addressed the necessity of identifying the source of the legal obligation to consider mandatory factors in the decision-making process. The court noted that it is crucial to identify the specific legal obligation that requires the consideration of certain factors, as this informs the scope of judicial review. The identification of such legal obligations ensures that the court can properly assess whether the decision-maker complied with the requisite legal standards.
The court then scrutinized whether the decision-maker had actually considered the evidence in question. This involved a detailed analysis of the decision-maker's reasoning process and whether it sufficiently engaged with the evidence. The court found that the decision-maker had failed to adequately consider certain evidence, which was a critical part of the decision-making process. This failure was deemed to be a procedural error that warranted judicial review.
In assessing whether the evidence in question was a relevant consideration for the purposes of judicial review, the court emphasized that the relevance of evidence must be determined based on its connection to the decision-maker's obligations and the statutory framework governing the decision. The court held that the evidence in question was indeed relevant, as it directly impacted the assessment of future economic loss.
The court also explored whether the decision to award damages by way of a buffer constituted an evaluative judgment. It determined that the use of a buffer in calculating damages for future economic loss involved an evaluative judgment, as it required balancing various factors to arrive at an appropriate amount. However, the court found that the decision to use a buffer in this context was not manifestly unreasonable given the likely future loss.
Finally, the court considered whether the use of a buffer to award damages for future economic loss was manifestly unreasonable. It concluded that the decision was not manifestly unreasonable, as it was within the bounds of reasonable evaluative judgment. The court found that the decision-maker had appropriately exercised discretion in determining the buffer, considering the nature of the evidence and the statutory guidelines. This decision reflects a cautious approach to overturning evaluative judgments made by decision-makers, unless there is a clear procedural misstep or manifest unreasonableness.