| DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL | |
| CITATION: | AAI Limited t/as GIO v Skaf [2024] NSWPICMP 392 |
| CLAIMANT: | Antoin Skaf |
| INSURER: | AAI Limited trading as GIO |
| REVIEW PANEL | |
| MEMBER: | Elizabeth Medland |
| MEDICAL ASSESSOR: | Shane Moloney |
| MEDICAL ASSESSOR: | Geoffrey Stubbs |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 20 June 2024 |
| CATCHWORDS: | MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999; treatment and care dispute; claimant alleges injury to right shoulder, amongst other injures; Held – Panel not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the claimant sustained an injury to the right shoulder; lack of contemporaneous medical evidence of any complaint; examination in weeks/months following accident showed normal range of motion which is contrary to the assertion the accident caused a tear of the shoulder; treatment determined to not be related to an injury caused by the motor accident and not reasonable and necessary. |
| DETERMINATIONS MADE: | CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION The Review Panel 1. Revokes the certificate issued by Medical Assessor Dixon dated 21 June 2023 and finds: 2. The following treatment: (a) MRI Investigation of the right shoulder, as proposed by Dr Vijay Maniam; (b) right shoulder arthroscopy and rotator cuff repair performed in May 2021 (recommended by Dr Bigges); (c) proposed excision lateral end of clavicle for osteolysis distal end right clavicle (Dr Maniam); (d) proposed subacromial decompression for subacromial bursitis in the right shoulder (Dr Maniam); (e) proposed post-operative physiotherapy (Dr Bigges and Dr Maniam); (f) proposed post-operative shoulder abduction brace (Dr Maniam), and (g) three Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) injections to the right shoulder (Dr Maniam). DOES NOT RELATE TO THE INJURY caused by the motor accident. 3. The following treatment: (a) MRI Investigation of the right shoulder, as proposed by Dr Vijay Maniam; (b) right shoulder arthroscopy and rotator cuff repair performed in May 2021 (recommended by Dr Bigges); (c) proposed excision lateral end of clavicle for osteolysis distal end right clavicle (Dr Maniam); (d) proposed subacromial decompression for subacromial bursitis in the right shoulder (Dr Maniam); (e) proposed post-operative physiotherapy (Dr Bigges and Dr Maniam); (f) proposed post-operative shoulder abduction brace (Dr Maniam), and (g) three PRP injections to the right shoulder (Dr Maniam) IS NOT REASONABLE AND NECESSARY in the circumstances. |
STATEMENT OF REASONS
INTRODUCTION
Mr Antoin Skaf (the claimant) has made a claim for damages under the Motor Accident Compensation Act 1999 (MAC Act) following a motor vehicle accident occurring on 28 October 2017.
The claimant alleges injury as result of him being the driver of a stationary vehicle that was hit from behind by another vehicle. This caused his vehicle to be pushed forward and collide with a truck in front.
A dispute has arisen between the claimant and the insurer of the vehicle considered at fault (the insurer) in respect of a number of treatment requests made by the claimant. The treatment in dispute is as follows:
(a) MRI Investigation of the right shoulder, as proposed by Dr Vijay Maniam;
(b) right shoulder arthroscopy and rotator cuff repair performed…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read AAI Limited t/as GIO v Skaf and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWPICMP 392
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to assess the credibility of Mr Skaf's claims and the evidence presented to support them. Specifically, the court needed to decide whether Mr Skaf had sustained an injury to his right shoulder, as alleged, and if the treatment provided was related to that injury and reasonable and necessary. The evidence presented included medical records, witness statements, and expert opinions.
The panel found that there was insufficient evidence to conclude that Mr Skaf sustained an injury to his right shoulder as a result of the motor accident. The lack of contemporaneous medical evidence of any complaint and the examination results, which showed a normal range of motion, contradicted Mr Skaf's assertions. Furthermore, the treatment provided was not determined to be related to an injury caused by the motor accident, nor was it deemed reasonable and necessary. Consequently, the panel ruled in favour of AAI Limited, trading as GIO.
The court ordered that Mr Skaf's claims for treatment and care related to the alleged right shoulder injury be dismissed, and that AAI Limited, trading as GIO, was not liable for the costs associated with the treatment in question. The decision was based on the evidence presented and the legal framework provided by the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999.